Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Which players out of current crop would you keep for 11/12?

chapperschappers
edited March 2011 in General Charlton
and you can't say none of them !!!

For me its definites
Worner
Jackson
BWP
Solly
Harriott (never seen play, but only a kid)
Jenkinson


Maybe's
Elliot
Llera (looking better at moment)
Semedo
Wagstaff (not sure f his best position coz he ain't a winger!)
Benson (every striker needs serivce!)
Dailly

Out's
Francis
Youga
Racon
Reid
Doherty
Mambo
McCormack
Fortune
«1

Comments

  • cafcdan18cafcdan18
    edited March 2011
    Keep:

    Elliot
    Jackson
    Semedo
    Racon- but as a squad player
    BWP
    Jenkinson
    Solly
    Wagstaff
    Youga
    Benson- as a squad player
    Dailly- maybe
  • hudson-son-sonhudson-son-son
    edited March 2011
    Definite:

    Semedo - Don't care about recent form, he's our best player still
    Racon - He is actually good at football
    Jackson - To play left midfield only
    BWP - Obvious
    Jenkinson
    Solly
    Wagstaff
    Anyinsah - Injuries are a bit of a worry I suppose but he's more than capable.

    Probably

    Llera - Doesn't have to be a starter but he's fairly cheap and a committed League One level centre half who is a goal threat, no reason to not have him in the squad
    Benson - Looks capable of scoring at this level with better service
  • December_The_5THDecember_The_5TH
    worner
    jenkinson
    jackson
    bwp
  • Kap10Kap10
    Elliot as back up
    Jackson
    Solly
    Jenkinson

    The rest can go to hell
  • covered_end_juniorcovered_end_junior
    To keep for 1st 11: Jenkinson, Jackson, BWP (possibly Semedo)
    To keep for squad players: Dailly, Llera, Solly, Waggy, Reid, (possibly Benson)
    To go: Elliot, Worner, Francis, Doherty, McCormack, Racon, Anyinsah(always injured), Stav, Tuna, Fortune,
  • MortimerwasgodMortimerwasgod
    Elliott
    Francis
    Solly
    Jenkinson
    Jackson
    Doherty (need at least one old head)
    Racon
    Semedo
    BWP
    Anyinsah
    Wagstaff

    And thats the lot, which is why Powell had a massive job this summer.
  • ISawLeaburnScoreISawLeaburnScore
    [cite]Posted By: Mortimerwasgod[/cite]Doherty (need at least one old head)

    I love gallows humour
  • December_The_5THDecember_The_5TH
    edited March 2011
    [cite]Posted By: covered end junior[/cite]To keep for 1st 11: Jenkinson, Jackson, BWP (possibly Semedo)
    To keep for squad players: Dailly, Llera, Solly, Waggy, Reid, (possibly Benson)
    To go: Elliot, Worner, Francis, Doherty, McCormack, Racon, Anyinsah(always injured), Stav, Tuna, Fortune,


    What has reid done this season comes on with 20mins to go and other than mk dons at home in the league what games has he played well
    il give you a chance name 1 other in the league he has played well
  • Mendonca In AsdasMendonca In Asdas
    Surely we've got to keep McCormack , he is our engine midfield powerhouse.
  • MortimerwasgodMortimerwasgod
    [quote][cite]Posted By: Mendonca In Asdas[/cite]Surely we've got to keep McCormack , he is our engine midfield powerhouse.[/quote]

    Genuine LOL!! At least we're keeping our sense of humour!
  • Sponsored links:


  • ISawLeaburnScoreISawLeaburnScore
    Based on a combination of ability, contract situation, likelihood to stay, injury concerns, age etc.

    DEFINITELY KEEP (or try to)

    BWP
    Jackson
    Semedo
    Llera
    Solly & Jenkinson (if it is worth keeping both, it may be decided that it isn't)
    Wagstaff (for the squad unless he improves his consistency tenfold)
    The promising kids, e.g. Harriott, Cousins

    MAYBE

    Elliot
    Worner
    Reid

    NOT BOTHERED (GOODBYE)

    Everyone else
  • No.1 in South LondonNo.1 in South London
    If we want to build a team capable of promotion ...............

    Jackson
    BWP

    Plus the following squad players ...........
    Solly
    Jenkinson
    Wagstaff
    Llera
  • Athletico CharltonAthletico Charlton
    edited March 2011
    I would keep:

    Jenkinson
    BWP
    Semedo
    Jackson

    Squad players:
    Solly
    poss Llera as a cheap No4 defender
    Poss Youga subject to fitness
    Doherty (No 3 CB though)
    Elliott (No2 though)


    All the others can go....so 4 frst teamers....there is a massive summer ahead of us. Just pray we are still in League1 next season as i am starting to get nervous.
  • Se12AddickSe12Addick
    Semedo
    Jackson
    BWP
    Solly
    Jenkinson
    Wagstaff, but he would need to start scoring goals again to justify it.

    Would like to keep Anyinsah if he could stay fit, and Racon if he could find some consistency - but in both cases thats looking unlikely.
  • SageSage
    edited March 2011
    Keep:
    Worner, Jenkinson, Solly, Llera, Mambo, Cousins, Youga, Bessone, Waggy, Semedo, Racon, Jackson, Stavrinou, Harriott (Very young but has been included in a matchday squad several times), Reid (When confident he is capable of being brilliant), Anyinsah (Must keep him fit, we're better with Joe), BWP, Benson

    To go:
    Elliott (I would keep him if we had a better defence next season), Francis, Dailly (His last season for me), Doherty (Could keep but will need a pacey player next to him), Fortune, McCormack, Tuna, Perkins

    - Must get in a couple of younger, quicker centre backs. A right winger, someone like Danny Green. Another one or two strikers and a couple of loans from the Premier League to give us a boost and quality. I wouldn't mind having Eccleston back here again last season as well as Zak Ansah from Arsenal.

    - Tuna and Perkins are just not good enough for us, I have a friend who I have known most of my life and he is much better than Tuna. My friend used to play for Gillingham reserves and now plays for Bromley.

    - The players I have selected to keep for next season, many of them are young and are very good prospects for the future. We need experience along with them and for the strikers we need players from midfield who is going to give them service, this is why I mentioned Danny Green who has scored and assisted loads of goals this year in a competitive but struggling Dagenham & Redbridge side.
  • addickted_to_cafcaddickted_to_cafc
    Jenkinson
    Solly
    BWP
    Llera(squad player)

    The rest, apart from the youth players, goodbye and goodluck
  • mid_life_crisismid_life_crisis
    In order, starting with the must-keeps:

    BWP
    Jackson
    Jenkinson
    Youga (if he regains full fitness)
    Bessone (granted his is a loanee)
    Semedo
    Elliot
    Solly
    Wagstaff
    Racon
    Llera
    Worner
    Reid

    p.s. don't know re Stavrinou and obviously not including the likes of Cousins.
    p.p.s. I see the above as forming maybe 4 of next years starting XI
  • covered_end_juniorcovered_end_junior
    December_The_5TH 2
    My reason for keeping Reid is simply that we know what he is capable of when he is confident, this is clearly something he is lacking at the moment.
  • redmanredman
    Part of the answer is how much money is available - but assuming there is some but not a lot

    Keep
    Elliot (still young and continuing to improve)
    Jenkinson
    Solly
    Dailly
    Semedo (although he is frustraing me like hell!)
    Jackson
    Wagstaff
    BWP
    Benson
    Asinwa

    plus of course Cosins, Mambo, prob Stav but not Tuna

    Some of these will be suad players rather than regulars tho
  • Athletico CharltonAthletico Charlton
    If we release Waggy in the summer he will not get another club in the top 3 divisions IMO. I love the blokes enthusiam and effort and wish our other players had that as we would be a lot higher and going a lot better but ultimately he is just not good enough. Hope he proves me wrong, as if anyone deserves it out of our bunch it is him but I just don't see it.
  • Sponsored links:


  • swords_aliveswords_alive
    Out -
    BWP

    Anyone really think his heart is in it?
  • Greenie JuniorGreenie Junior
    Keep:
    BWP
    Jackson
    Jenks
    Solly
    Wagstaff
    Racon (don't know why everyone hates him seems to be the only person who tries to attack)
    Llera
    Semedo

    The rest can go
  • golfaddickgolfaddick
    Keep

    Elliot
    Worner
    Daily
    Solly
    Jenkinson
    LLera
    Waggy
    Semedo
    Racon
    BWP
    Anyinsah
    Jackson
    Bessone (if loan can be made pemenant)
    Fry (ditto)
  • BedsaddickBedsaddick
    [cite]Posted By: addickted_to_cafc[/cite]Jenkinson
    Solly
    BWP
    Llera(squad player)

    The rest, apart from the youth players, goodbye and goodluck

    I would agree with that except i would keep Worner,Jackso & Youga also.
  • cafc18cafc18
    Keep As First Team: Youga(fitness dependant), Wagstaff, Racon, Jackson, Wright-Phillips, Anyinsah(fitness dependant)
    Keep As Squad Players/Subs: Worner, Jenkinson, Solly, Llera, Semedo, Reid, Benson
    OUT: Elliott, Francis, Dailly, Doherty, McCormack, Fortune.
    Youngsters To Keep: Cousins, Mambo, Tuna, Harriott

    AIM FOR A FIRST TEAM LIKE:
    Goalkeeper
    RB CB CB Jackson/Youga
    RM/Wagstaff Racon CM LM
    BWP Anyinsah
  • BlackForestRedsBlackForestReds
    Keep:
    Elliot, Worner, Solly, Bessone, Jenkinson, Reid, Wagstaff, Jackson, Semedo, Racon, Anyinsah, Racon, BWP, Benson.

    Dailly I'd like to keep, perhaps more as a reserve CB and senior pro-type. i presume he's going to or is taking his coaching badges and keeping him on could have some long term benefits.

    So we'd need a left-back, Bessone would be first choice, but seems to be injury prone, but Jenkinson could play there. I'd be inclined to see if Solly or Jenkinson could nail down the RB spot, then we need at least two if not three CBs. Assuming JJ/Reid play on the left and Waggy on the right then we'd need a central midfielder and a striker to take his turn alongside Benson, Anyinsah and BWP.
  • Nozza2310Nozza2310
    KEEP: Elliott, Worner, Bessone, Jenks, Solly, Llera, Semedo, Racon, Jackson, Waggy, Youga, BWP, Anyinsah.
  • ISawLeaburnScoreISawLeaburnScore
    [cite]Posted By: BlackForestReds[/cite]Keep:
    Elliot, Worner, Solly, Bessone, Jenkinson, Reid, Wagstaff, Jackson, Semedo, Racon, Anyinsah, Racon, BWP, Benson.

    Racon... so good you'd keep him twice?

    Wouldn't even consider keeping him once!
  • Jon_CAFCJon_CAFC
    Keep:

    For starting 11: Jackson, BWP, Semedo, Wagstaff, Anyinsah (injury dependant), Jenkinson

    For back up: Racon, Reid, Benson, Daily (If he is still fit), Llera

    The rest can get lost
  • MuttleyCAFCMuttleyCAFC
    edited March 2011
    I think you need to exclude the youngsters who havent established themselves in the team from this list - those are decisions for better informed.

    As for the current first teamers there a 4 categories IMO. 1) keep potential first choice 2) Keep but possibly as back up 3) Not sure- some thinking to do 4) Goodbye

    For me Cat 1 are: Elliot, Jenkinson, Semedo,JJ, Anyinsah (on ability - injuries a different matter), BWP Cat 2 are: Francis, Doc, Llera, Waggy, Reid, Benson, Worner, Cat 3 is Racon (possibly Anyinsah due to injuries) and the rest are cat 4 for various reasons. Of course players in Cat 2 and 3 could be cat 1 if the right players are playing with them but would seem there might be a lot of work to do.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!