Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Player Marks: Charlton 1-3 Carlisle

For those of you at the match last night marks between 0-10. halves allowed, please cut and paste the list below:

Elliott
Francis
Dailly
Doherty
Jenkinson
Reid
Semedo
Racon
Wagstaff
Eccleston
Wright Phillips

Fortune
n/a Benson
«1

Comments

  • Elliott - 5.5
    Francis - 5
    Dailly - 6
    Doherty 5.5
    Jenkinson - 6.5 MOM
    Reid - 6
    Semedo - 6
    Racon - 5.5
    Wagstaff - 5.5
    Eccleston - 5.5
    Wright Phillips - 6

    Fortune - 5.5
    n/a Benson
  • Elliott - 5
    Francis - 4
    Dailly - 5
    Doherty - 5.5
    Jenkinson - 6
    Reid - 4
    Semedo - 5
    Racon - 4
    Wagstaff - 6
    Eccleston - 5
    Wright Phillips - 6

    Fortune - 4
  • edited March 2011
    I never usually bother with this but last night I could not wait to get on here and do this;

    Elliott 5 (not a great couple of games for the local boy)
    Francis 6 (shows more effort and energy than most of the team put together)
    Dailly 6
    Doherty 6 (his injury saved us from his usual mistakes)
    Jenkinson 6 (out of position but still looks like he will be a star)
    Reid 5 (where has the other Reid gone?)
    Semedo 6 (worked hard but could do little)
    Racon 3 (his touch and passing were terrible last night, how many times did he play a team mate into trouble. A shock considering his recent form)
    Wagstaff 5 (Effort but no impact)
    Eccleston 6 (set up the goal but although he got a fair bit of the ball created little)
    Wright Phillips 6 (scored, had one blocked and headed over)

    Fortune 4 (Made Doc look quick when he came on, I just feel sad for the guy)
    n/a Benson
  • [cite]Posted By: lancashire lad[/cite]For those of you at the match last night marks between 0-10. halves allowed, please cut and paste the list below:

    Elliott 4
    Francis 7
    Dailly 5
    Doherty 5
    Jenkinson 6.5
    Reid 4.5
    Semedo 5
    Racon 4
    Wagstaff 4
    Eccleston 4
    Wright Phillips 4.5

    Fortune 4.5
    n/a Benson
  • Elliot - 5 (Felt sorry for him to be fair, there is an obvious ask of him to deliver out through the back four or through the wide players, but time and time again people had there backs to him and never showed for the ball, but the last goal is basic )

    Francis - 6 (Distribution at times leaves a lot to be desired but fair play the guy never hides and is useful going forward)

    Jenkinson 6.5 (Not a left back, keeps having to check in on his right foot which caused him problems, but full of effort, eye for a pass and isnt afraid to have a go)

    Daily 5 (Looked shaky all night, right out of sorts! At times when things are going pair shaped and everyone starts firing passes all over the shop, i really question how strong his leadership qualities to calm things down and keep the shape)

    Doherty 6 (I think he looked fairly solid, anything in the air, or ball played up to him he's as solid as they get, play the ball behind him or give him too much time and he's struggling)

    Eccelstone 6(In and out for me, gilmpses of ability, needs to release the ball quicker)

    Reid - 4 (Frustrating ......... he carries the ball to long, he's look's a shadow of last season in terms of confidence, summed up by his break away which he took about 10 touches and near enough ran the ball of the pitch, similar to the same break at Southend last year of which he finished)

    Racon 5- (Poor, needless fouls, wayward passing, summarises our squad, inconistant)

    Semedo 6- (Actually showed some good forward passing, but failed to make a huge impact on the game)

    Wagstaff 5 (Headless Chicken for the large part, struggles to keep the ball under control)

    Wright-Phillips 6.5 (MOM - The only one in the front 6 who seems to be able to keep hold of the ball, and the utlilise correctly, great finish)

    Fortune 4 - (What an earth has happened to him? I would take his name of the shirt and just call him Johnno, because he's not the Fortune I remember)
  • WSSWSS
    edited March 2011
    Elliott - 5
    Francis - 6
    Dailly - 5.5
    Doherty - 5.5
    Jenkinson - 6.5
    Reid - 5.5
    Semedo - 6
    Racon - 4
    Wagstaff - 5.5
    Eccleston - 5
    Wright Phillips - 6.5

    Fortune - 4
  • Elliott 3; he needs to be rested, at fault in all three goals last night. Also lack of understanding with back 4.
    Francis 3, out of posistion to often, and could no pass to a charlton player, he must be colour blind.
    Dailly 4 seemed hesitant
    Doherty 4 seemed uncertain what to do with the ball whenhe had it at feet.
    Jenkinson 5 ok that is about it
    Reid 4 went into to many blind alleys
    Semedo 5 had ok game
    Racon 6 At leats he can pass the ball, also tackled more than usual
    Wagstaff 4 same as Reid
    Eccleston 5 tried to do to much onhis own but did get the cross in for our goal
    Wright Phillips 5 because he scored

    Fortune 3 just not fit enough to play football
    n/a Benson
  • Elliott-4
    Francis-5
    Dailly-5
    Docherty-4
    Jenkinson-7 played out of position and looks like he is gonna be a key player for us in the future.
    Reid-5.5
    Semedo -4 used to like him but he seems to be labouring about doesnt give any impetus to the team anymore
    Racon-4 gone back to his f---king about with the ball again
    Wagstaff-5
    Eccleston-5
    Wright Phillips-6

    Fortune-4 could be time for him to hang up his boots which would be a shame he just doesnt look up for it anymore.
  • Elliott 5
    Francis 5
    Dailly 4.5
    Doherty 5
    Jenkinson 6.5
    Reid 5
    Semedo 4.5
    Racon 4.5
    Wagstaff 5
    Eccleston 5
    Wright Phillips 6

    Fortune 4.5
  • Elliott 4 - very very shaky at the moment.
    Francis 6.5
    Dailly 6
    Doherty 6.5 - He actually looked better tonight until he went off injured.
    Jenkinson 8 - best player on the pitch by a mile. Would love to see him played in his proper position and also be allowed to take free kicks and corners....or even penalties if BWP ever steps near one again!
    Reid 5.5 - whats gone wrong?
    Semedo - 7 - the usual
    Racon 6.5
    Wagstaff 5.5 - needs to play right wing
    Eccleston 5 - needs to play up front
    Wright Phillips 6

    Fortune 6
    n/a Benson 6 - looked lively.
  • Sponsored links:


  • edited March 2011
    As much as i try , i cant give the players any more than these scores.
    A diabolical performance that they should be thoroughly ashamed of.

    Elliott - 2
    Francis - 4
    Dailly - 3
    Doherty - 3
    Jenkinson - 4
    Reid - 3
    Semedo - 3
    Racon - 2
    Wagstaff - 2
    Eccleston- 1
    Wright Phillips - 2

    Fortune - 1
    n/a Benson
  • [cite]Posted By: The Red Robin[/cite]Reid 5.5 - whats gone wrong?

    he's been charltonised
    [cite]Posted By: The Red Robin[/cite]Jenkinson 8 - best player on the pitch by a mile. Would love to see him played in his proper position and also be allowed to take free kicks and corners....or even penalties if BWP ever steps near one again!.

    jenkinson said he offered to take a penalty in the brentford shoot out , fairplay to the lad
  • Wright Phillips - 2
    Wright-Phillips 6.5 (MOM)

    Here we go again!!!!!!!!
  • edited March 2011
    Elliott - 5
    Francis - 5
    Dailly - 6
    Doherty - 5.5
    Jenkinson - 7
    Reid - 5.5Semedo - 5.5
    Racon - 5
    Wagstaff - 5.5
    Eccleston - 5
    Wright Phillips 6.5
    Fortune - 4
  • Elliott 5 Looked off colour
    Francis 6 Always available and got more crosses over than anyone else
    Dailly 6 Solid as usual
    Doherty 6 As above
    Jenkinson 6 Looks settled now
    Reid 4 Woeful
    Semedo 5 Got outnumbered in the middle
    Racon 6 Occasional flashes but got crowded out
    Wagstaff 6 Good first half
    Eccleston 5 Can't last 90 mins, looked jiggered
    Wright Phillips 6 well taken goal does what it says on the tin

    Fortune 5 Looked plump
    n/a Benson
  • Elliott - 5.5 - nice to see he was at least looking to distribute well even if some players didnt want it - at fault for the final goal
    Francis - 6 - actaully thought he had a decent game tonight and has improved from his early season tosh
    Dailly - 6.5
    Doherty 5 - slow, poor distribution would be being kind
    Jenkinson - 6.5 MOM - good all round player with the best vision in the club by a mile and a great attitude. I hope we get to see more of him than we did Jonjo!
    Reid - 6 - tried hard and should certainly be given another game
    Semedo - 5.5 - we will never play decent football with him as our pivot - he is good defensively but hides when we have the ball
    Racon - 5 - yet again poor -
    Wagstaff - 6 - our biggest threat and dint seem the ref was giving him any protection - shame we couldnt make any use of the free kicks he earnt let alone the ones we weren't given
    Eccleston - 4.5 - a few good flashes of skill but frequently made the wrong choice and has poor vision. Will certainly never make it at Liverpool
    Wright Phillips - 5.5 - mark boosted by the goal but rarely made himself available

    Fortune - 4.5 - sorry Jon but time for the pasture
    Benson - tried hard but wasn't on long enough to make an impact
  • edited March 2011
    Elliott 4 - Terrible, no presence, looks nervous - at fault in all three goals last night. Cannot catch the ball and hold it!
    Francis 3 - Awful - 1 cross in 10 good the rest overhit or to opponent - just dump.
    Dailly 6 - Still solid. Few minor mistakes. Doesn't seem to have much influence as captain...
    Doherty 5 - OK. Still quite a few errors - but better.
    Jenkinson 6 - Shows great promise and just needs more game time.
    Reid 5 - Exciting - doesn't knowweh nto pass and when to shoot!
    Semedo 5 - Ok game. Still thinks he's one of our best.
    Racon 6 - Passes well and really works hard - bit frustrating sometimes
    Wagstaff 5- Plenty of endeavour - no end result...
    Eccleston 5 - Touch of class - needs more game time
    Wright Phillips 6 - Scored and seemed to be more involved last night

    Fortune 4 - Not fit - an embarrassment

    n/a Benson
  • Elliott 5 - very poor kicking and throws, he seems completely unsure as to what to do when he has to move the ball upfield
    Francis 5 - nowhere near as strong as he has been recently (pre-injury), we missed his incisive crosses
    Dailly 6 - he still wants to win but, understandably, not as quick as used to be
    Doherty 5 - very disappointing, again
    Jenkinson 7.5 - a real live-wire, he is going places ... and I hope it's with us
    Reid 5.5 - should start again as he tried hard but too many errors
    Semedo 5 - far from his usual standard
    Racon 5 - something not right here, he does not seem to want to be there anymore
    Wagstaff 6 - please stand up and stop staying on the floor when you are knocked over, toughen up ... but keep the enthusiasm
    Eccleston 5 - hardly got in the game, not being played in the right position
    Wright Phillips 6.5 - if all he does is score, then fine ... however he needs to be stronger

    Fortune 3 - I have never scored a player thislow ... but to be honest even zero would not have been wrong ... he did nothing and put us in danger
  • For those criticising Wagstaff for falling over, it should be noted that we won most of our freekicks in dangerous areas this way. The fouls were committed mostly due to his speed and trickery. The disappointment was the shocking inability to create a goal scoring opportunity from set pieces.
    Francis was always willing to recieve the ball and yes, some of his crosses were poor but he didn't give up until the 93rd minute and if you compare his efforts to that of Wagstaff and Reid (whose jobs it is to cross) he did OK.
  • edited March 2011
    Elliott 4 (Time for Worner)
    Francis 5 (Better going forward, try him in midfield maybe, Solly behind)
    Dailly 4 (Getting worse every week, not Captaining whatsoever)
    Doherty 5.5 (Makes the odd mistake, but nowhere near as many as Dailly right now)
    Jenkinson 6.5 (promising, never gives up)
    Reid 4 (lost it big time: all fur coat - no knickers.
    Semedo 5 (Tackles,harrasses, but what else?)
    Racon 4 (Non!)
    Wagstaff 5 (Missing again)
    Eccleston 5
    Wright Phillips 6 (Does his job; Gets the goals, can't really argue with that)

    Fortune 3 (Unfit, lazy, dissinterested and totally a waste of a place on our bench. How the flip can Llera be as bad as that? No way! Get rid)
    n/a Benson 4
  • Sponsored links:


  • Elliott 5
    Francis 5
    Dailly 6
    Doherty 6
    Jenkinson 7
    Reid 4
    Semedo 6
    Racon 4
    Wagstaff 5
    Eccleston 5
    Wright Phillips 6

    Fortune 3
  • Elliott 5
    Francis 4.5
    Dailly 6
    Doherty 5.5
    Jenkinson 6.5 MOM
    Reid 6
    Semedo 5
    Racon 5
    Wagstaff 5.5
    Eccleston 6
    Wright Phillips 6

    Fortune 4.5
    Benson 5.5
  • Elliott 5 good distribution at times one excellent save at the Covered end but at fault for at least one of the goals
    Francis 5 usual mix of sublime and incompetent
    Dailly 6 unlucky with the deflection. Got to admire the commitment from a man of his age but not as assured as usual
    Doherty 6 ok until his injury
    Jenkinson 7 hope we can keep him. The one ray of light MOM
    Reid 5 What happened to the guy who tore Bournemouth to shreds in the first game of the season?
    Semedo 5 Carlisle won all the second balls after about 20 minutes which is partly down to him
    Racon 5 see Semedo
    Wagstaff 5.5 Ran around a lot trying to take up good positions and exert pressure but little impact no service
    Eccleston 5 Disappointing. Little impact but in fairness where was the service from midfield
    Wright Phillips 6 Gets that for a class finish. Did little else.

    Fortune 4 Sad to see the decline of a loyal club servant
  • Elliott 5
    Francis 5
    Dailly 5
    Doherty 5
    Jenkinson 6
    Reid 6
    Semedo 4
    Racon 4
    Wagstaff 5
    Eccleston 5
    Wright Phillips 6

    Fortune 5
    n/a Benson
  • Elliott - 4 Poor game: time to give Ross a run
    Francis - 3 Dreadful even by his standards.
    Dailly - 6 Didn't do much wrong.
    Doherty - 4 His injury saved him from further trauma. A real liability who urgently needs replacing
    Jenkinson - 7 Considering he was being played out of position he had a good game.
    Reid - 3 Anonymous until the last ten minutes.
    Semedo- 4 Part of the non-existent midfield
    Racon - 3 Traps the ball further than I can kick it*
    Wagstaff - 5 Not much end product. Huge work rate and chases the ball everywhere - but then you could say the same for a spaniel.
    Eccleston - 4 Doesn't look a happy bunny
    Wright Phillips - 6 Mainly for the goal

    Fortune - 2 A dreadful night. Did nothing right. I'm truly sorry for him he was such a good player but it's time to hang up the boots.
    n/a Benson - Not marked because he wasn't on long enough but why was the substitiution not made earlier?

    The whole team - 3 - passed off the park by Carlisle for heavens sake!
    * With apologies to Gary Edwards, a Leeds Utd fan, whose comment about Carlton Palmer from the book Paint It White I have just plagiarised.
  • Elliott - 4
    Francis - 5
    Dailly - 5
    Doherty - 4.5
    Jenkinson - 6.5
    Reid - 5
    Semedo - 5
    Racon - 5
    Wagstaff - 5
    Eccleston - 5
    Wright Phillips - 6.5

    Fortune - 4.5
  • Elliott - 4..made 1 decent save in 2nd half,,,disappointing again
    Francis - 4..below average although fair play never hides
    Dailly - 5 - worst period since he arrived
    Doherty - 5 - can head the ball and that's about it!
    Jenkinson - 7 - MOM - Impressive for a young 'un playing out of position
    Reid - 3 - awful, never got past the full back once
    Semedo - 4 - see Dailly
    Racon - 5 - caught out twice leading to goals
    Wagstaff - 5 - tries, won free kicks.........and thats it!
    Eccleston - 5 - bright start...faded badly
    Wright Phillips - 6 - scored, had another blocked. Decent game considering no service

    Fortune - 3 - Oh dear!
    n/a Benson
  • Elliott 3
    Francis 4
    Dailly 4
    Doherty 4
    Jenkinson 5 - out of position
    Reid 4
    Semedo 5
    Racon 1
    Wagstaff 0
    Eccleston 1
    Wright Phillips 5

    Fortune 3
    Not sure if I was watching the same game as some people. Racon is my favourite player, so no bias. Wagstaff is the one I don't get, so bias..... MOM, my dad for staying home to watch Man U.
  • I'm sorry but Wagstaff gets a an average of about 5.5ish from everyone else yet is marked ZERO by someone.
  • [cite]Posted By: masicat[/cite]Elliott 3
    Francis 4
    Dailly 4
    Doherty 4
    Jenkinson 5 - out of position
    Reid 4
    Semedo 5
    Racon 1
    Wagstaff 0
    Eccleston 1
    Wright Phillips 5

    Fortune 3
    Not sure if I was watching the same game as some people. Racon is my favourite player, so no bias. Wagstaff is the one I don't get, so bias..... MOM, my dad for staying home to watch Man U.

    Your choice ... but how does a player get zero when another player who actually did zero (Fortune) gets 3?
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!