If you were unlucky enough to see this game at the Valley or on TV please give your marks between 0-10, half marks allowed and please state if you were at the match or watched on TV. Cut & paste the names below and give your marks:
Elliot
Francis
Dailly
Fortune
Jackson
Martin
McCormack
Semedo
Racon
Reid
Benson
Wagstaff
Abbott
n/a Sodje
0
Comments
How many goals were Daillys - TWO
Yet Francis gets a zero and Dailly a 5
It's getting boring now
Francis 0 - shocking, the main culprit of hoofing the ball onto Benson hopelessly
Dailly 4 - shocking mistake with the second goal
Fortune 6 - made a lot of clearances, would have conceded a few more without him
Jackson 7 - scored the first goal, tried to create something
Martin 4 - looked good in the first 10 minutes, then kind of burned out
McCormack 3 - very average appearance, invisible most of the game
Semedo 5.5 - was alright
Racon 5 - Very average
Reid 5 - Struggled today
Benson 6 - the guy's done nothing wrong, it's the sh*t delivery that's to blame, he wasn't played one good pass all day
Wagstaff - 5
Abbott - 6 - the only good pass he got he used for a very good goal, still a mediocre player
n/a Sodje - haven't seen him touch the ball really
Francis 1
Dailly 1
Fortune 3
Jackson 5
Martin 1
McCormack 1
Semedo 6
Racon 2
Reid 1
Benson 1
Wagstaff 2
Abbott 4
n/a Sodje
Francis 4
Dailly 4
Fortune 6
Jackson 7
Martin 5
McCormack 5
Semedo 5
Racon 5
Reid 4
Benson 4
Wagstaff 5
Abbott 6
Francis .5
Dailly 2
Fortune 2
Jackson 6
Martin 2
McCormack .5
Semedo 4
Racon 3
Reid 2
Benson 2
Wagstaff 3
Abbott 5
n/a Sodje
Elliot 6
Francis 5 - a predictable scapegoat but certainly not worse than many others.
Daillly 3 - cost us two goals
Fortune 4
Jackson 6
Martin 4 - can stepover but can't make a simple pass
McCormack 3
Semedo 7 - our only footballer
Racon 5 - shows some skills then repeatedly passes to the opposition or out of play. so frustrating
Reid 4
Benson 4
Wagstaff 5
Abbott 3 - scored yet showed what a poor footballer he is with every other touch
n/a Sodje
Parky - 0 - Wrong formation & wrong team selection. Too slow to change it and then they just hoofed it up the middle. Awful route 1 football and badly executed at that. Shocking performance.
Due to his continued effort, almost got the Swindon defender to score an OG of the season.
Elliot - 6 - pehaps to blame sightly for their equaliser and a couple of poor kicks
Francis - 3 - just poor
Dailly - 3 - to blame for their 2nd and seemed not to play well alongside forch
Fortune - 6 - did ok while he was on got a few crucial touches when called upon
Jackson - 7 - my charlton player of the match
Martin - 4 - deceived to flatter - one trick pony?
McCormack - 3 - didn't even notice him
Semedo - 5 - ok
Racon - 5.5 - slightly better than Smedo
Reid - 5.5 - did okish in first half....second was poor
Benson - 5 - no service and when he did get it did little with it, lucky he gt away with the and-ball in build up to Jacko's goal
Wagstaff - 5 - not on long enough to have any effect imo
Abbott - 5 - just for the goal, which i didnt see as the stream wet bloody down!
n/a Sodje - 3 - did he touch the ball when he came on?
Parky - 2 - inept tactics which, according to the sky commentators, they were only practising on the pitch 3 hours before the game started!! No plan B, no motivation on touchline.
This is only the second time I have seen them this season (admitedly on a stream again), but I have to say that it was just embarrasing. As you know I listen to most matches on CAFC player and provide match updates on here....but watching that was just horrfic!!!
Exactly.
Many are posting just emotional kneejerk stuff and little to do with actual individual player performance.
Elliot - 5
Francis - 1 no better than ryman league standard. a disgrace that this man earns what he does.
Dailly - 3 shocking mistake for goal
Fortune - 3 been watching his mate francis for too long. hoof.
Jackson - 6 decent
Martin - 1 send him back
McCormack - 2 dont think he knew where he was supposed to be playing
Semedo - 4 not great but not the worst
Racon - 5 first half ok....altho he should be fined for the attempt at tracking back AFTER 35 MINUTES!!!
Reid - 5 couple of decent crosses first half but was marked out the game
Benson - 5 if i was him id be asking serious questions of what PP expects of him with the service he gets
Wagstaff - 4 crap
Abbott - 3 embarrasing apart from the goal.
n/a Sodje
lol kneejerk, we say it every week. he is shit.....lets look at the all round performance. daily got punished for some very slack defending but francis is slack for 90 minutes. the man is soooo bad its insulting.
Francis 3 Dont know what this guys strengths are
Dailly 3 Way of the pace,,,,,,,he can afford to have one bad game
Fortune 2 No time for sentiment, time to let him go
Jackson 6 Atleast this guy tries
Martin 3 Lame
McCormack 4 An average player in this poor league
Semedo 5 Below Par
Racon 4 Lose the roll neck
Reid 2 Was he playing
Benson 4 Didnt do alot
Wagstaff 2 Not enough time to make an impression
Abbott 5 Good finish but slow, and doesnt do alot for a big man
n/a Sodje
Francis-2 Shyte REPLACEMENT PLEASE
Dailly-5 Did ok but screwed up for their 2nd
Fortune-6 One of his better performances since his return
Jackson-5.5 Got lucky with the goal but isnt really a left back
Martin-6 Effort is there but not much end product.
McCormack-3 Not sure what he did...
Semedo-6 OK nothing special
Racon-5.75 Started ok fizzled out towards the end
Reid-6.5 Tried to play, caused a few problems but was marked by at least 2 players most of the time
Benson-4 Went missing
Wagstaff-5 Ok
Abbott- 6.5 took his goal well
n/a Sodje
Elliot 5.5
Francis 2
Dailly 3
Fortune 4.5
Jackson 6
Martin 5
McCormack 2
Semedo 4
Racon 4.5
Reid 3
Benson 2
Wagstaff 3
Abbott 1.5
n/a Sodje 1
Francis 4
Dailly 5
Fortune 6
Jackson 6
Martin 5.5
McCormack 5
Semedo 6
Racon 6.5
Reid 5
Benson 5.5
Wagstaff 4.5
Abbott 5
n/a Sodje
that wasnt benson T it was lee martin who chased their defender down .
Who aimlessly spanked the ball forwards? Anyway, this is a thread for discussion, it's for people to give their own take on each players performace.
Watched on TV.
Elliot 4
Francis 2
Dailly 2
Fortune 4.5
Jackson 6
Martin 5.5
McCormack 5
Semedo 5.5
Racon 5.5
Reid 5
Benson 6
Wagstaff 4.5
Abbott 5
Elliot 5
Francis 3.5
Dailly 3
Fortune 4
Jackson 4
Martin 3.5
McCormack 3.5
Semedo 3.5
Racon 3.5
Reid 3.5
Benson 5 - not his fault not his type of game
Wagstaff 3
Abbott 4 good goal
Elliot 5 Let in 4 so can't mark higher but didn't stand a chance with any to be fair
Francis 0 Awful
Dailly 3.5 Terrible blunder for their 2nd. At least he ran the ball out of defence.
Fortune 3.5 Not interested
Jackson 6 Scored
Martin 0 Needn't have bothered turning up, not the sort of player we need in this division (or ever)
McCormack 0 Kick and run football you play on a Sunday (when still pissed)
Semedo 3.5 Sideways, sideways, sideways.
Racon 3.5 For his first half performance which was ok
Reid 1 Prob should have been sent off First Half - didn't touch the ball second half
Benson 2 Forgot he was playing (not really his fault as was given no service at all)
Wagstaff 1 At least he tries
Abbott 2 At least he scored
n/a Sodje
Elliot 4
Francis 4
Dailley 4
Fortune 4
Jackson 5.5
Semedo 5
Martin 2
Racon 4
Mcormack 5
Reid 5
Benson 4.5
Wagstaff 4
Abbott 4
Elliot 6
Francis 5.5
Dailly 5
Fortune 5.5
Jackson 6
Martin 5
McCormack 5
Semedo 5
Racon 5
Reid 5
Benson 6
Wagstaff 5
Abbott 6
n/a Sodje
Noone particularly good and noone particularly bad - just no cohesion as a team.
Francis 4
Dailly 4 Loses mark for stoopid error
Fortune 5 Certainly missed him when he went off.
Jackson 5 Lucky goal, handball and an offside.
Martin 5 Nearly scored when he chased down the defender. Usual disappointment.
McCormack 4 Never in the game apart from one storming run.
Semedo 5
Racon 5 Disappointing
Reid 5 Pleased he didn't give the ball away.
Benson 5 Think he is in the wrong team. Would probably have scored for Swindon.
Wagstaff 5
Abbott 4 Walked out at 1 - 4 so missed his goal.
n/a Sodje
Francis 4
Dailly 2
Fortune 3
Jackson 5
Martin 2
McCormack 3
Semedo 6
Racon 3
Reid 3
Benson 4
Wagstaff 3
Abbott 4 - But only because of his goal
n/a Sodje
Francis 6
Dailly 4
Fortune 5.5
Jackson 7
Martin 4
McCormack 4
Semedo 5
Racon 5
Reid 6
Benson 6
Wagstaff 5.5
Abbott 5
n/a Sodje 7
Elliot 4
Francis 3
Dailly 3
Fortune 4
Jackson 4
Martin 2
McCormack 4
Semedo 5
Racon 5
Reid3 Forgot he was playing again 2nd half
Benson2
Wagstaff 2
Abbott 5
n/a Sodje Must be wondering just how crap our forwards have to get before he gets a chance
Parkinson 0 Utter gash
Francis - 4 - Didn't hide but confidence looks shot.
Dailly - 2 - Hopefull his one shocker for the season out of the way.
Fortune - 2 - Release him now. His legs are shot and he makes the same mistakes over an over again.
Jackson - 5 - Scored and didn't disgrace himself. Wasted at left back.
Martin - 1 - Pony. No football brain. No end product. Must be better loan options out there. Andros Townsend?.
McCormack - 1 - Injured in the warm up. Shouldn't have bothered coming back out. He didn't have a clue where he was playing.
Semedo - 4
Racon - 5 - Ok first half. Vanished 2nd.
Reid - 1 - Unbalances the side when he plays. Offered nothing but rolling around on the floor. Did he touch the ball 2nd half?
Benson - 5 - Game. But no striker in the world could play with that service.
Wagstaff - 2
Abbott - 2 - Didn't see the goal as I left at 4-1. But everything else was woeful.
Francis 2
Dailly 2
Fortune 4
Jackson 6
Martin 2
McCormack 2
Semedo 4
Racon 2
Reid 3
Benson 6
On that performance only Jackson and Benson were Div 1 standard.
To single out a couple who annoyed the life outta me; McCormack and Francis are very very flawed players and are just not good enough for this league.
If there is a club in for Racon I'd also get rid. The way he plays and his attiude/desire aren't g oing to get us outta this league.
Semedo is all over the shop and we appear to have a different player in Reid to the one that was tearing teams apart earlier this season, ditto Martin.
Staggeringly bad performance and a lot didn't deserve a red shirt tonight, let alone a wage.
Elliot 6
Francis 2
Dailly 3
Fortune 5
Jackson 6
Martin 3
McCormack 1
Semedo 5
Racon 4
Reid 3
Benson 2
Wagstaff 1
Abbott .5 (for the goal), got be the worse charlton striker i have ever seen
n/a Sodje 2