Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Charlton vs. Notts County - Players Ratings

2

Comments

  • How many times do you need to see Benson and Abbott to realise they are not very good?
  • Elliot - 8.5 - penalty saved top off a man of the match display
    Francis - 6.5 - would still prefer solly
    Fry - 8 - impressive
    Doherty - 7
    Jackson - 7
    Martin - 7
    McCormack - 6.5 - him and semedo seem to spend most of the time doing the same job
    Semedo - 7
    Reid - 7
    Abbott - 7
    Benson - 7

    Racon - 7
    Sodje - 7.5 - changed the game in my opinion
    Anyinsah - 7
  • Elliot - 9 - Top stuff from Rob today
    Francis - 6. Best game so far, still alot to prove
    Fry - 7 Dominated in the air, apart from the Pen didnt put a foot wrong, feel much more confident with him (Then Lera)
    Doherty - 7 . Got the Job done
    Jackson - 5.5 Yet to see the best of him, his not a LB so hard to rate him
    Martin - 7 Martin usual stuff in a charlton shirt, Running his heart out for 90 mins some nice touches,turns
    McCormack - 4.5 Just didnt get started for me, good sub by parky
    Semedo - 6. Semedo is Semedo, Got the job done
    Reid - 6. Normal Trickery stuff on the wing
    Abbott - 5.5 No Real service didnt get up to much
    Benson - 5.5 Again no real service, gets into good spots though

    Racon - 6. Came on looks to have a better understanding with Semedo.
    Sodje - 6. Came on Worked hard, chased the ball down well
    Anyinsah - 6.5 came on and got the job done, nice little finnish
  • Elliot - 9
    Francis - 6.5
    Fry - 7.5
    Doherty - 7
    Jackson - 6.5
    Martin - 7
    McCormack - 5
    Semedo - 7
    Reid - 7
    Abbott - 5.5
    Benson - 5.5

    Racon - 6.5
    Sodje - 6.5
    Anyinsah - 7
  • Elliot - 8
    Francis - 6
    Fry - 7
    Doherty - 6
    Jackson - 6
    Martin - 6
    McCormack - 5
    Semedo - 6
    Reid - 7
    Abbott - 5
    Benson - 6

    Racon - 7
    Sodje - 7
    Anyinsah - 7
  • [cite]Posted By: MuttleyCAFC[/cite]Cant see how Doc should have got a 4 and Francis a 2!!!!! If you don't like /rate the players, posting ridiculous scores hardly enhances your argument.

    I'll post what I fecking like they were shite
  • Elliot - 9
    Francis - 7
    Fry - 8
    Doherty - 7
    Jackson - 6
    Martin - 7
    McCormack - 5
    Semedo - 6
    Reid - 7
    Abbott - 6
    Benson - 6

    Racon - 6
    Sodje - 6
    Anyinsah - 7
  • Elliot - 9
    Francis - 6
    Fry - 8
    Doherty -7.5
    Jackson - 6
    Martin - 7
    McCormack - 5
    Semedo - 6
    Reid - 6
    Abbott - 5
    Benson - 6

    Racon - 7
    Sodje - 7
    Anyinsah - 7


    cant believe that i have been so generous if the 1st half wouldve been the better half of the 2 then scores wouldve been lower, only because 2nd half was better that the scores have creeped up
  • Elliot - 9.5 Faultless. Only the fact that he wasn't called on to make more saves, stops him getting a 10.
    Francis - 6 Not great but defended the box ok.
    Fry - 7 Was never too far away from where he should have been. Hopefully he'll learn from his penalty error. Promising.
    Doherty - 7 Will be annoyed about his missed chance in the 1st minute. Caught out once but I'll settle for that.
    Jackson - 6 Got better as the game went on but looks like a midfielder playing at the back.
    Martin - 7 Tried to spark things and nearly scored with a far post header. Stupid booking but picked his pass superbly for the winner. He'll only get better too.
    McCormack - 3 Oh dear. Had to come off and it should probably have happened after about 25 minutes.
    Semedo - 7.5 Had to do the work of two men in the 1st half. Never lets anyone down.
    Reid - 7 Heavily marked but still created a couple of good openings. Composure at both ends of the field would see him playing at a higher level. It may come with experience.
    Abbott - 5 Not a lot went right for him. Tried but looked short of confidence. Needs a goal but may be a sub for a few games now.
    Benson - 6 Moved well and had one useful header. Have a feeling he will be ok once the team gels.

    Racon - 7 Has probably secured the other CM spot for a few games now. I think he'll do ok and will even get a few goals (he popped up in the box late on yesterday).
    Sodje - 7 Did well. Unselfish and brave. Might well get the nod instead of Abbott for a while.
    Anyinsah - 7 Well struck goal. Too early to make predictions about him but what a good start.

    Parky 7.5 - Had the bottle to remove McCormack who was really struggling. Yes, he probably should have picked Racon in the first place. I wouldn't have taken Benson off but he did and it won us the game. Was brave enough to go with Fry ahead of Fortune and Llera. This team might not gel until 2nd half of season but the spirit is definitely there.
  • Elliot - 7
    Francis - 5.5
    Fry - 6.5
    Doherty - 6.5
    Jackson - 6.5
    Martin - 7
    McCormack - 5
    Semedo - 6.5
    Reid - 6.5
    Abbott - 5
    Benson - 6

    Racon - 6.5
    Sodje - 6
    Anyinsah - 8
  • Sponsored links:


  • Elliot - 9
    Francis - 7.5
    Fry - 8
    Doherty - 6
    Jackson - 6
    Martin - 7
    McCormack - 5.5
    Semedo - 7
    Reid - 7
    Abbott - 6
    Benson - 6

    Racon - 7
    Sodje - 7
    Anyinsah - 7.5
  • Elliot - 8
    Francis - 5 - Would prefer Solly (when fit)
    Fry - 7 - Like him, Parky will have a decision to make when Daily comes back
    Doherty - 6
    Jackson - 5 - Doesn't look the same player he was last season
    Martin - 6.5 - Not his best game, but is one of the players we have who can make something happen
    McCormack - 5 - I've not been impressed so far - must come out for Racon next week
    Semedo - 6 - Can't believe anyone who's seen this guy reguarly would call him "over rated" - best player in our squad for me, just not his best game today
    Reid - 6 - Same as Jackson
    Abbott - 3 - Does nothing. I feel really depressed seeing a player like this in a Charlton shirt
    Benson - 5 - Needs to get his goal scoring boots on quick, for both his and Parky's sake

    Racon - 8 - is playing alot better in the chances he's getting this season, hope he starts next week
    Sodje - 7.5 - I'm not a fan, but he really changed things and was a threat when he came on. Maybe better as a sub than a starter ?
    Anyinsah - 8 - Does anyone know how to pronounce his name correctly ? Who cares, not sure how long It's been since we saw a striker finish so instinctively in Charlton colours. If we can create chances for him more often than not he could be a great bargin.
  • edited September 2010
    Elliot - 9 What more can he do. Great distrubution, won the battle in the air, dealt with Hughes' fouls and blocks and saved a pen. Well done to Oah Aah for giving credit when it was due
    Francis - 5.5 short passes leaving team mates in trouble and too many other errors. Got forward well a few times but only once put in a good ball. fell over for a comedy gold moment near the end. Lack of confidence or lack of talent? or both?
    Fry - 7.5 Other than when exposed for the pen did well against a good forward.
    Doherty - 5.5 Let more than one ball get passed him over the top. Fry and Dailly please until Fortune is fit
    Jackson - 6.5 hard days work for him but stuck to it. Little quality going forward
    Martin - 6.5 Would have been less but for the assist. Lots of skill and hard work but not so much end product.
    McCormack - 5.5 rightly subbed off. Pulled out of a challenge most likely as had already been booked but was also poor
    Semedo - 6.5 Got better in 2nd half when he imposed himself more
    Reid - 6.5 Didn't hurt them enough
    Abbott - 5.5 Slow and didn't show for the wingers
    Benson - 5.5 Got his head on the end of a couple of crosses but did little on the deck. Still not convinced.

    Racon - 6.5 Not great but gave us a foothold back into the midfield
    Sodje - 7 real impact and showed what we had lacked. Bullied their defence into errors and set up the move for the goal
    Anyinsah - 7.5 Have to give him a high mark for a well taken goal on his debut as well as a good work effort.

    Notts Co. - 6 Good side but nothing special, obviously played together as a team a lot more than us and it showed. Unlucky? No, they were not. They didn't take their chances and that is nothing to do with luck. That is good goalkeeping and poor finishing. Both about skill not luck.

    The Ref - 4 Lost control early on, let far to much shirt pulling go and should have booked the County player who handled in the wall for deliberate handball. Was it Hughes who had already been booked.

    Parky - 6.5 picked a too defensive team in the middle and a too slow attack. Means we rely too much on Reid and Martin to add all the pace and creativity. Showed the courage to drop Llera for Fry and to sub three of his summer signings. And all three subs had a positive impact so tactically he changed the game to get the win.

    We were poor, we got away with it and we weren't punished as we could and should have been for defensive lapses and with the pen but I'll say it again, that is not "luck". That is poor play by County.
  • Elliot - 8 Penalty save and other saves kept us in it
    Francis -6.5 Best I've seen him play
    Fry - 6 Gave away a penalty
    Doherty -6 Did okay
    Jackson -6 Nothing amazing
    Martin - 7.5 Ran his socks off
    McCormack - 4.5 Was awful, maybe he was out Friday night but he seemed a yard off the pace
    Semedo - 6.5 Did better in the 2nd half not his best game
    Reid - 6 Was wasteful with the final ball
    Abbott - 5 Poor, still no league goal would drop him for Sodje next game
    Benson - 5 Non exsistant

    Racon - 6.5 Got involved alot more than McCormack
    Sodje - 7 Put himself about worth a start now
    Anyinsah 7 Great debut hopefully he'll get more goals now
  • Elliot - 7.5
    Francis - 6
    Fry - 7
    Doherty - 6
    Jackson - 5
    Martin - 7
    McCormack - 4
    Semedo - 6
    Reid - 6
    Abbott - 5
    Benson - 5

    Racon - 6
    Sodje - 6.5
    Anyinsah - 6.5
  • Elliot - 7
    Francis - 3
    Fry - 8
    Doherty -6
    Jackson - 4
    Martin - 7
    McCormack -4
    Semedo - 5
    Reid - 5
    Abbott -4
    Benson - 5

    Racon - 7
    Sodje - 7
    Anyinsah 6

    Miss firing all over the shop.....The coaching has always been a bit suspect and Im sad to say that its all gotten worse.
  • elliott 9 man of match
    francis 7
    jackson 7
    semedo 6
    doc 7
    fry 8 (did brilliantly again hughes, apart from penalty was fine display)
    martin 8
    mccormack 4( i shouted get him off get racon on, i dont formally like racon but he deserves a chance again)
    reid 7
    abbott 6 (ok this first touch could be better, but i like him)
    benson 6 (ike abbott needs the service and we are not doing that enough)

    racon 7
    akpo 7
    anyinsah 8 ( just for the great finish) id be worried if i was abbott or benson!!
  • Elliot - 10 - what more could he have done?
    Francis - 6 - steady
    Fry - 7 - looked good in first game I have seen him play
    Doherty - 6 - let ball over his head for Hughes to be through on goal and very slow
    Jackson - 6 - steady
    Martin - 8 - always willing
    McCormack - 3 - forgot he was playing
    Semedo - 6 - has played a lot better
    Reid - 7 - sometimes looks great, often looks average
    Abbott - 3 - non entity
    Benson - 6 - tried hard

    Racon - 6 - better than McCormack (does not say much)
    Sodje - 7 - only on for a short time but put in a great stint and looked very keen to have his place back
    Anyinsah - 7.5 - played 15mins, scored a goal, won the game, did nothing else of note
  • Elliot - 8
    Francis - 6
    Fry - 7
    Doherty - 6
    Jackson - 6
    Martin - 7.5
    McCormack - 5
    Semedo - 6
    Reid - 6.5
    Abbott - 5
    Benson - 5

    Racon - 6.5
    Sodje - 7
    Anyinsah - 7
  • Elliot - 9
    Francis - 6.5
    Fry - 7
    Doherty - 7.5
    Jackson - 6.5
    Martin - 7
    McCormack - 6
    Semedo - 6.5
    Reid - 5.5
    Abbott - 5
    Benson - 5

    Racon -6
    Sodje - 6.5
    Anyinsah - 7
  • Sponsored links:


  • Elliot - 8 - Couple of good save and the pen of course
    Francis - 6 - Give Solly a chance when fit!
    Fry - 7.5 - Better with him in the centre - gives us missing pace
    Doherty - 7
    Jackson - 6
    Martin - 8 - Everywhere, creative, looks keen, exciting
    McCormack - 6
    Semedo - 6
    Reid - 7 - Too selfish at times
    Abbott - 6
    Benson - 5 - Poor home debut

    Racon - 7 - Should partner Semedo again
    Sodje - 6.5
    Anyinsah - 7.5
  • edited September 2010
    [cite]Posted By: se9addick[/cite]Elliot - 8

    Anyinsah - 8 - Does anyone know how to pronounce his name correctly ? Who cares, not sure how long It's been since we saw a striker finish so instinctively in Charlton colours. If we can create chances for him more often than not he could be a great bargin.



    An - Yin - Sa
  • Elliot - 8.5 - vital penalty save
    Francis - 6 - Probably his best game so far, but still got a lot to prove
    Fry - 7 - Did quite well, would like to see more of him.
    Doherty - 6.5 - Decent
    Jackson - 6.5 - Again decent without standing out
    Martin - 6.5 - Some great moments but want to see more end product. Think he set up the goal but then he had plenty of time and space
    McCormack - 5.5 - Didn't notice him for most of the half. Him and Semedo are too similar, it's not helping either of them or the team
    Semedo - 6 - Has played a lot better but was ok
    Reid - 6 - A threat but teams seem to deal with it, and when they don't he can make something happen. Today was one of those games he wasn't making the right decisions when he did get those chances
    Abbott - 5 - Not impressed, barely won a header or held up the ball. Not as good as Burton but then we couldn't afford Burton's wages
    Benson - 6 - Can see why he scored goals, does get into some decent positions. Will look poor if we don't create the right chances for him though.

    Racon - 6 - Did ok. Didn't stand out but just that bit different from McCormack
    Sodje - 6 - Again ok, can't remember loads he did but can be a nuisance
    Anyinsah - 7 - Took his goal well, think he'll offer something very different to our other strikers which is a good thing. And as he can play out wide, gives the other wingers more competition .


    Yes I've copied & pasted Scoham as I agree with every score & word.
  • Elliot - 8.5
    Francis - 6.5
    Fry - 8
    Doherty -6.5
    Jackson - 6.5
    Martin - 6.5
    McCormack -6
    Semedo - 6.5
    Reid - 7
    Abbott -6
    Benson - 6.5

    Racon - 7
    Sodje - 7
    Anyinsah -7.5
  • Elliot - 9
    Francis - 6
    Fry - 7
    Doherty - 6.5
    Jackson - 6
    Martin - 7
    McCormack - 5.5
    Semedo - 6.5
    Reid - 7
    Abbott - 6
    Benson - 6

    Racon - 7.5
    Sodje - 7
    Anyinsah - 8
  • Elliot - 9
    Francis - 6
    Fry - 8
    Doherty - 7
    Jackson - 7
    Martin - 8.5
    McCormack - 6
    Semedo - 6
    Reid - 7
    Abbott - 6
    Benson - 6

    Racon - 6.5
    Sodje - 7
    Anyinsah - 8
  • Elliot - 8 excellent saves, great distribution
    Francis - 7 Best game so far
    Fry - 8 95% spot on, 5% penalty!
    Doherty - 7 Quiet efficiency
    Jackson - 6 Slow, is he injured still
    Martin - 7 Assist, otherwise a 6
    McCormack - 4 totally off the pace and did the one thing i thought he wouldnt do, bottle tackles
    Semedo - 8 Powerhouse and has a presence
    Reid - 6 More in and out than flares
    Abbott - 6 Seemed laboured, strange compared to previous efforts
    Benson - 6 No service, bit of a passenger. Seemed to be annoying Martin, needs training ground work.

    Racon - 7 Composed presence
    Sodje - 7 Had an effect unlike the starting strikers
    Anyinsah - 8 On top of goal seems to be a bubbly player with a smile on his face, so will hopefully cheer up some of the stone faced ones
  • Elliot - 8
    Francis - 5
    Fry - 7
    Doherty - 7
    Jackson - 6.5
    Martin - 7
    McCormack - 4
    Semedo - 5.5
    Reid - 7
    Abbott - 4.5
    Benson - 4.5

    Racon - 7
    Sodje - 7
    Anyinsah - 6.5
  • Elliot - 8
    Francis - 4
    Fry - 6
    Doherty - 6
    Jackson - 5
    Martin - 6
    McCormack - 4
    Semedo - 6
    Reid - 7
    Abbott - 5
    Benson - 4

    Racon - 6
    Sodje - 6
    Anyinsah - 6
  • Elliot - 8.5
    Francis - 5.5
    Fry - 6.5
    Doherty - 5
    Jackson - 6
    Martin - 7
    McCormack - 4
    Semedo - 6.5
    Reid - 7
    Abbott - 5.5
    Benson - 6

    Racon - 6.5
    Sodje - 7
    Anyinsah - 7
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!