Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Charlton v Tranmere - Player ratings

edited February 2010 in General Charlton
Not looking forward to this, but away you go......

Copy and paste the list below (the reason i always say this is because it is much easier me typing out the scores when they are in the same order). Half marks allowed

Elliot -
Richardson -
Dailly -
Sodje -
Basey -
Sam -
Semedo -
Bailey -
Reid -
Burton -
Mooney -
Randolph -

Wagstaff -
McKenzie -
«1

Comments

  • Elliot - 5
    Richardson - 6
    Dailly - 6
    Sodje - 7
    Basey - 5
    Sam - 4
    Semedo - 4.5
    Bailey - 6
    Reid - 6.5
    Burton - 5.5
    Mooney - 4
    Randolph - 6

    Wagstaff - 6
    McKenzie - 5.5
  • Elliot - 6 no real errors before he was forced off
    Richardson - 5 a few dashing runs all ended in surrendering possession. Some defensive frailties too, apparently can't judge the bounce. If Omo turned in this kind of performance they'd be baying for blood.
    Dailly - 5.5 Looking tired.
    Sodje - 6 Part soccer genius, part buffoon. Crazy own goal, but added pace to the defence.
    Basey - 6 Pretty solid and decent dead balls, but often mired in his own half.
    Sam - 5.5 Off the pace, and not tracking back as much as usual.
    Semedo - 5.5 Didn't offer much, but screened well.
    Bailey - 6.5 Busy goal grabbing performance, but needs to learn he can't do it all.
    Reid - 7 A few fumbles, but generally encouraging start. A left winger on the left, what a great idea, Parky knows his stuff.
    Burton - 6.5 Good assist, and hard working. Could do with getting onside sharper.
    Mooney - 5 Lightweight and limited threat
    Randolph - 5.5 Looked shaky (maybe understandable given the manager's attitude). Not at fault for the goal, at all.

    Wagstaff - 6.5 one decent cross, maybe worth a start.
    McKenzie - 6 One decent chance, worth a start.

    Parky - 5 More fail
  • Elliot - 6
    Richardson - 5
    Dailly - 5
    Sodje - 6
    Basey - 5.5
    Sam - 5.5
    Semedo - 5.5
    Bailey - 6.5
    Reid - 7
    Burton - 5.5
    Mooney - 4.5
    Randolph - 6

    Wagstaff - 6.5
    McKenzie - 6
  • Elliot - 6
    Richardson - 6
    Dailly - 5.5
    Sodje - 6.5
    Basey - 6
    Sam - 5
    Semedo - 5.5
    Bailey - 5.5
    Reid - 7
    Burton - 6
    Mooney - 4
    Randolph - 6

    Wagstaff - 6
    McKenzie - 6
  • Elliot - 6
    Richardson - 6.5
    Dailly - 6
    Sodje - 7
    Basey - 5.5
    Sam - 6
    Semedo - 5
    Bailey - 6.5
    Reid - 7.5
    Burton - 6.5
    Mooney - 4.5
    Randolph - 6

    Wagstaff - 7
    McKenzie - 6
  • Elliot - 6
    Richardson - 6
    Dailly - 6
    Sodje - 6
    Basey - 5
    Sam - 5
    Semedo - 4
    Bailey - 3
    Reid - 7
    Burton - 6
    Mooney - 3
    Randolph - 6

    Wagstaff - 7
    McKenzie - 6
  • Elliot - 6.5
    Richardson - 6.5
    Dailly - 6.5
    Sodje - 6.5
    Basey - 6
    Sam - 7
    Semedo - 7
    Bailey - 6.5
    Reid - 7
    Burton - 6.5
    Mooney - 5
    Randolph - 6.5

    Wagstaff - 7.5
    McKenzie - 7
  • Elliot - 6
    Richardson - 5.5
    Dailly - 5.5
    Sodje - 5.5
    Basey - 6.5
    Sam - 5.5
    Semedo - 5
    Bailey - 6
    Reid - 7.5
    Burton - 6
    Mooney - 4.5
    Randolph - 5.5

    Wagstaff – 6.5
    McKenzie - 6
  • Elliot - 6
    Richardson - 6
    Dailly - 6
    Sodje - 6
    Basey - 6
    Sam - 5.5
    Semedo - 5.5
    Bailey - 6
    Reid - 7
    Burton - 6.5
    Mooney - 5.5
    Randolph - 6.5

    Wagstaff - 6
    McKenzie - 6
  • Elliot - 6
    Richardson - 6
    Dailly - 5
    Sodje - 6
    Basey - 6
    Sam - 3
    Semedo - 5
    Bailey - 5
    Reid - 7
    Burton - 6
    Mooney - 3
    Randolph - 5

    Wagstaff - 6
    McKenzie - 6
  • Sponsored links:


  • Elliot - 6 not much to do
    Richardson -6.5 good bombing on. Caught out of position a couple of times though
    Dailly - 6 quiet day
    Sodje - 7 dominant in the air and very unlucky for the own goal
    Basey - 7 great delivery for the goal - couple of other superb crosses from his wand of a left foot.
    60 minute Sam - 5.5 soooooo frustrating. Why is he unable to last the whole game!
    Semedo - 6 doesn't excel in a 442 as too defensive. Really think we need 451 for a while
    Bailey - 5.5 sat too deep which is Semedo's job and passing was generally pants. Another goal though
    Reid - 7.5 MOM a real bright spark for me. Pacy and direct - some superb deliveries and intelligent play. Considering he is not match fit I thought that was a great start. Shame he went off
    Burton - 6 looks to be struggling a bit
    Mooney - 5 very poor day at the office. Parky needs to accept that "his boy" had a mare and should have come off.
    Randolph - 7 looked a bit shaky - to be expected as it's been a while since he played. Great save late on

    Wagstaff - 7 Good cameo again - direct and pacy
    McKenzie - 6.5 won a few headers
  • Elliot - 6
    Richardson - 7
    Dailly - 6.5
    Sodje - 6
    Basey - 6
    Sam - 6
    Semedo - 6
    Bailey - 5.5
    Reid - 6.5
    Burton - 6
    Mooney - 5.5
    Randolph - 6

    Wagstaff - 5.5
    McKenzie - 6
  • Elliot - 6
    Richardson - 7
    Dailly - 6
    Sodje - 5
    Basey - 5
    Sam - 5
    Semedo - 5
    Bailey - 5
    Reid - 7
    Burton - 6
    Mooney - 5
    Randolph - 5

    Wagstaff - 6
    McKenzie - 6
  • Elliot - 6
    Richardson - 7
    Dailly - 6
    Sodje -6
    Basey - 5
    Sam - 5
    Semedo - 5
    Bailey - 5
    Reid - 7.5
    Burton -6
    Mooney - 4
    Randolph - 6

    Wagstaff - 6.5
    McKenzie - 6.5
  • Elliott-6.5
    Richardson-6
    Dailly-6
    Sodje-6
    Basey-5.5
    Sam-4
    Semedo-5.5
    Bailey-6
    Reid-7.5
    Burton-6.5
    Mooney-6
    Randolph-6.5

    Wagstaff-7
    Mckenzie-6.5
    Llera -10 cos he didnt f--k anything up
  • Elliot - 6
    Richardson - 6
    Dailly - 6
    Sodje - 6
    Basey - 6
    Sam - 6
    Semedo - 6
    Bailey - 6
    Reid - 7
    Burton - 6
    Mooney - 6
    Randolph - 6

    Wagstaff - 6
    McKenzie - 6

    Ball-boys - 7.5 improvement from last monday
  • Elliot - 6
    Richardson - 6
    Dailly - 6.5
    Sodje - 5.5
    Basey - 6
    Sam - 5
    Semedo - 6
    Bailey - 5.5
    Reid - 7.5
    Burton - 7
    Mooney - 4.5
    Randolph - 6

    Wagstaff - 6
    McKenzie - 6.5
  • Elliot - 6
    Richardson - 6
    Dailly - 6
    Sodje - 6.5
    Basey - 6
    Sam - 6
    Semedo - 5 Too negative this time and passing poor
    Bailey - 6.5 Agree it wasn't his best but even off colour we'd be lost without his sheer drive
    Reid - 7 good positive debut. Always looked to go forward and sent over several crosses from the byline. Sounds simple but hasn't happened much lately
    Burton - 6.5 Useful target but rendered ineffective by lack of presence alongside
    Mooney - 4 Made v little impression. Needs to do a lot more when he's not scoring. Please let's at least see what Leon can do in these games
    Randolph - 5.5 Want him to do well but why punch a straight-forward cross when you've jumped well above everyone?
  • Elliot - 6.5 one poor kick two or more good throws. Seemed more decisive to me hence the injury!
    Richardson - 6 usual solid performance
    Dailly - 6 a few good blocks
    Sodje - 6.5 would have been higher but for the own goal. Tried to get involved and make things happen
    Basey - 7 one of his better games. Didn't seem to get exposed like he has done previously
    Sam - 6.5 He tried. Got a few balls in but we didn't use them. Unfairly maligned by some
    Semedo - 6 Started well winning the second balls but faded. The midfield parted like the Red Sea at times in the second half
    Bailey - 6 Anonymous in the first half but came into it more towards the end. One of our few goal threats.
    Reid - 6 That first burst I thought Run Forrest Run but got better
    Burton - 7 Usual intelligent play just wish he could finish!
    Mooney - 6 Not great but didn't hide and deserves credit for that
    Randolph - 6 looked shaky poor distribution at times but a couple of good saves

    Wagstaff - 6.5 had some impact. Still not convinced he should start.
    McKenzie - 6 Nothing particularly good or bad
  • Elliot - 6.5
    Richardson - 6.5
    Dailly - 6
    Sodje - 6
    Basey - 6.5
    Sam - 6
    Semedo - 7
    Bailey - 6
    Reid - 7
    Burton - 5.5
    Mooney - 5.5
    Randolph - 6.5

    Wagstaff - 6
    McKenzie - 6.5
  • Sponsored links:


  • Elliot - 6.5 - Did OK whilst he was there.
    Richardson - 6.5 - Still some good runs (out wide) needs to cross or run inside a bit more.
    Dailly - 6 - Steady - got forward a bit more.
    Sodje - 7 - Rock solid and a more consistent than Llera.
    Basey - 6 - Not really doing it - better when he gets forward. Need Youga back.
    Sam - 6 - Still most creative - but starting to remind me of Rommedahl(!). All flair and little final product.
    Semedo - 7 - Solid. Not quite as good as he was - but we'd miss him badly if he wasn't there.
    Bailey - 7 - Some wayward passes (but a few good ones too) and over hit a few. Shows he cares.
    Reid - 7 - Great start. Lots of pace - I'm sure he will only get better.
    Burton - 5 - Poor passing. Sure he works but so did Varney. Misplaced balls and gives up when he loses the ball.
    Mooney - 6 - Some great runs (not always spotted). Midfield (what midfield?) not giving him the service. Played with his back to goal a lot (bit like Burton....).
    Randolph - 6 - Flapped a bit and a wild punch....did OK.

    Wagstaff - 6.5 - Need to see more of the ball.
    McKenzie - 6 - Should get a start with Mooney (rest Burton) - his pace could make a difference.
  • edited February 2010
    Elliot - 6
    Richardson - 5
    Dailly - 5
    Sodje - 6
    Basey - 5
    Sam - 6
    Semedo - 4
    Bailey - 5
    Reid - 6
    Burton - 6.5
    Mooney - 4
    Randolph - 4.5

    Wagstaff - 6
    McKenzie - 5
  • Here are my marks.....1 is pants 5 is average and 10 is exceptional....

    Elliot -5
    Richardson -6
    Dailly - 5
    Sodje -4
    Basey -4
    Sam -4
    Semedo -5
    Bailey -4
    Reid -7
    Burton -4
    Mooney -3 (Although he was pants)
    Randolph -5

    Wagstaff - 6
    McKenzie 5
  • edited February 2010
    Elliot - 6 Basically had nothing of note to do until he went off apart from one great throw out to Sam.
    Richardson - 6 Added some verve down the right but with no real end product, misjudged a few high balls.
    Dailly - 6 Not as assured as he was earlier in the season.
    Sodje - 6.5 tried to make a few things happen and got stuck in as ever, looked unlucky with the OG
    Basey - 6 Lacks that pace to get up the pitch, especially when we're starting so deep but set piece delivery and crossing makes him a threat.
    Sam - 5.5 hardly anything came off for the lad but he didn't hide, despite the crowd baying for blood. Not as dilligent as he can be tracking back
    Semedo - 6 Did his job of screening the defence, but a bit of a spare part when the opposition park the bus.
    Bailey - 5 Nearly rescued the game for us late on but was poor up to there. Got lucky with goal, but so often made a bad call when on the ball and was very wasteful with possesion. Probably more a by-product of trying too hard to force the issue than not trying but the end result is much the same. Was dissappointed to see him berating Basey for virtaully the whole of the last 10 minutes - not great captaincy imo. Extra point for the goal, but a point off for the Basey thing.
    Reid - 6.5 Took a while to get going but looked a threat when he did. Left me wanting to see more of him.
    Burton - 6 One of the only players who seemed to have his brain in gear, but nothing came off for him - was unlucky to find the keeper in fine form when he had two good chances.
    Mooney - 5 Struggled to make much impact. I still felt he was trying to do a lot of the right things but our tactics on the day were never going to suit him or Burton.
    Randolph - 6 Looked nervouse when he came (Parky's decision re Ikeme coming home to roost imo). He seems to be a bit of a scatter brain but got better as he settled in and made one fine save late on to help save the point.

    Wagstaff 7 - best I've seen him play and added some good crosses to the hustle and bustle. Still needs to learn when to go chasing people and when to hold his position but he's getting close to a start ahead of Sam, although it'll be tougher for him against a fresh left back.
    McKenzie 6 - I'd still like to see him a Burton through the middle together as I suspect Leon is still our best hope of more goals between now and the end of the season.
  • Good points on Wagstaff and McKenzie exiled, agree about Bailey as well. Was trying to get things going probably a
    bit too hard. Didn't notice him shouting at Basey, what was that about? Giving the ball away?
  • Elliot - 6
    Richardson - 6
    Dailly - 6
    Sodje - 6
    Basey - 5
    Sam - 6
    Semedo -6
    Bailey -5
    Reid -7
    Burton -6
    Mooney -5
    Randolph -6

    Wagstaff - 5
    McKenzie -6
  • Elliot - 6
    Richardson - 6
    Dailly - 6
    Sodje - 6
    Basey - 6
    Sam - 6
    Semedo - 6
    Bailey - 7
    Reid - 7.5
    Burton - 6
    Mooney - 6
    Randolph - 6

    Wagstaff - 7
    McKenzie - 6
  • Elliot - 6 Ok.
    Richardson - 6 Not at his best. Didn't get forward effectively but was ok otherwise.
    Dailly - 7 Did fine.
    Sodje - 7 Good in the air. Should get better too as he's been off for a month.
    Basey - 6 Like Richardson, didn't offer enough going forward. Good at dead balls though.
    Sam - 5.5 Marked out of it by left back. Maybe have him on bench at Walsall.
    Semedo - 5.5 Tried but was again ponderous in possession. If we hadn't had to use Randolph, reckon Semedo would've been subbed for Spring.
    Bailey - 6 Goal gets him a half mark. He wasn't too good...until the last couple of minutes. If he doesn't score, we don't.
    Reid - 7.5 Very impressed. Worked hard and was a threat. Only ever going to play 70 minutes. May find it hard at Walsall so soon after Sat.
    Burton - 6 Just can't score. Late header was a great chance. Still worked hard without looking at his best. Big assist for the goal.
    Mooney - 5 Tried but his inexperience isn't helping him cope with the dip in form or the crowd barracking. Good dummy to set up Burton's first half shot. Needs a rest.
    Randolph - 6 He did ok considering lack of match practice.

    Wagstaff - 7.5 Excellent contribution. Two superb runs and crosses that were begging for someone to fling themselves head first at! Give him a start on the right at Walsall.
    McKenzie - 6 Not really a left winger so guess he did ok. Needs a goal.

    Parky 6 - Shouldn't be moaned at for Reid substitution as he needed to keep him fit for Tuesday. Reckon he might be keeping Shelvey fresh for a bit of 4-5-1 at Walsall and he was hamstrung by having to use Randolph as one of his subs. Probably needs to make some changes on Tuesday (Sam, Mooney and possibly Semedo out....Wagstaff, Shelvey (or Akpo) and Spring in.
  • edited February 2010
    Elliot -7
    Richardson - 6.5
    Dailly - 7
    Sodje - 7
    Basey - 6.5
    Sam - 6.5
    Semedo - 6.5
    Bailey - 6.5
    Reid - 8 MoM
    Burton - 7
    Mooney - 7
    Randolph - 7

    Wagstaff - 7
    McKenzie - 7

    Back of J block - 3 booing and slating was not required IMO and when they stopped whinging and actually sung, it was good and loud.
  • Elliot - 6
    Richardson - 6
    Dailly - 6
    Sodje - 6
    Basey - 6
    Sam - 6
    Semedo - 6
    Bailey - 6
    Reid - 6.5
    Burton - 6
    Mooney - 5
    Randolph - 6

    Wagstaff - 7
    McKenzie - 6
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!