Off side

Dazzler21

Lol. Ok then

randy andy

[cite]Posted By: holyjo[/cite]BBC Website

Deon Burton drew the Addicks level with a header after keeper Kelvin Davis failed to deal with a cross from the lively Jonjo Shelvey.

Charlton had the ball in the net twice more but both efforts were correctly ruled out for offside, while Kelly Youga struck the post with a low strike.

But the Addicks, who have now fielded the same starting XI for all seven League One fixtures, could not find a winning goal and now lead the table on goal difference from Leeds United.

I wonder who rights the BBC website report then. as they clearly disagree with the BBC commentator on the TV who thought it was clearly onside. Nice consistency there beeb.

The Red Robin

[cite]Posted By: Kap10[/cite]Concensus seems to be that the first was offside the second was not and we should have had a penalty -mind you I thought they should have had a pen at the end too, so it should have been 3-2 to us.

Spot on

dabos

[cite]Posted By: The Red Robin[/cite]

[cite]Posted By: Kap10[/cite]Concensus seems to be that the first was offside the second was not and we should have had a penalty -mind you I thought they should have had a pen at the end too, so it should have been 3-2 to us.

Spot on

Elliot would've saved their pen, 3-1 to us

Elthamaddick

[cite]Posted By: Stone[/cite]

[cite]Posted By: Elthamaddick[/cite]both teams should've had a pen, us on Sam and Saints near the end.....first disallowed goal looked correct, Burton flicked it and it looked like it was going in to me, if Jonjo had left it I think it would've counted, but unfortunately he touched it in - not blaming him as I'd had done the same.

2nd one was laughable, even from my seat in the North Upper I didn't need a slow motion replay to tell me that Burton was a clear 3 or 4 yards onside !!, shocking decision.

re The first disallowed goal: Burton's flick was definately going wide. We were right in line with it. (Block N North Upper)

I stand corrected, cheers, Block H North Upper !!!