Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Ipswich v Charlton (closes Wednesday teatime)

24

Comments

  • PhilFor54
    PhilFor54 Posts: 184

    KAMINSKI:8 much better tonight after looking a bit shaky recently

    RAMSAY: 8 

    JONES: 8.5 usual

    GILLESPHEY: 9 had a fantastic game, mom. Cut out so many of their attacks. And another goal.

    BREE: 6.5

    COVENTRY: 7.5

    CAREY: 8.5 great game again. Love him. Given a shooting opportunity he shoots early rather than take an extra touch, just like Matty

    DOCHERTY: 7.5

    BELL: 8

    KELMAN: 7.5

    OLAOFE: 7.5

    Referee 8 no problems with the ref tonight

    Subs: LEABURN: 8

    CAMPBELL: 8 Maybe coming on for the last 30 minutes suits him. Dunno, a dilemma, but he did well.

  • gringo
    gringo Posts: 600

    KAMINSKI:     9  1 point deducted for poor pass first half

    RAMSAY:       9

    JONES:         10  Is there a better defender in our league

    GILLESPHEY:  9 I think many thought he would struggle in championship- not so far!

    BREE:            7  fairly quiet

    COVENTRY:  7 

    CAREY:         10

    DOCHERTY:  9

    BELL:            9

    KELMAN:      7

    OLAOFE:       7

    Referee      8

    Subs: LEABURN:     8

    CAMPBELL:             9

    KNIBBS: n/a

    J R-C: n/a

    BURKE: n/a


  • KAMINSKI: 8

    RAMSAY: 8.5

    JONES: 9

    GILLESPHEY: 9

    BREE: 8.5

    COVENTRY: 8

    CAREY: 9

    DOCHERTY: 8

    BELL: 8.5

    KELMAN: 7

    OLAOFE: 7

    Referee 8

    Subs: LEABURN: 8

    CAMPBELL: 8

    KNIBBS: n/a

    J R-C: n/a

    BURKE: n/a

  • Bailey
    Bailey Posts: 3,276

    KAMINSKI: 10 

    RAMSAY: 10

    JONES:10

    GILLESPHEY:10

    BREE: 10

    COVENTRY:10

    CAREY:10

    DOCHERTY:10

    BELL:10

    KELMAN: 10

    OLAOFE: 10

    Referee Yes you can have 10 too 

    Subs: LEABURN: 10

    CAMPBELL:10

    KNIBBS: n/a

    J R-C: n/a

    BURKE: n/a

  • jose
    jose Posts: 643

    KAMINSKI: 7.5

    RAMSAY: 7.5

    JONES: 7.5

    GILLESPHEY: 8

    BREE: 7

    COVENTRY: 7

    CAREY: 8

    DOCHERTY: 7

    BELL: 7.5

    KELMAN: 6

    OLAOFE: 6

    LEABURN: 7.5

    CAMPBELL:7.5

    Referee 7


  • CafcSteve
    CafcSteve Posts: 759

    KAMINSKI: 8.5

    RAMSAY: 8.5

    JONES: 9.5

    GILLESPHEY: 9

    BREE: 8

    COVENTRY: 8

    CAREY: 9.5

    DOCHERTY: 8

    BELL: 9

    KELMAN: 7.5

    OLAOFE: 7.5

    Referee: 8

    LEABURN: 8.5

    CAMPBELL: 8.5

  • KAMINSKI: 9

    RAMSAY: 9

    JONES: 9.5

    GILLESPHEY: 9

    BREE: 8.5

    COVENTRY: 8.5

    CAREY: 9

    DOCHERTY: 8.5

    BELL: 8.5

    KELMAN: 8

    OLAOFE: 7.5

    Referee 7.5

    Subs: LEABURN: 8.5

    CAMPBELL: 8.5

  • KAMINSKI: 7.5

    RAMSAY: 7.5

    JONES: 8.5

    GILLESPHEY: 8.5

    BREE: 7

    COVENTRY: 7.5

    CAREY: 9

    DOCHERTY: 7.5

    BELL: 8

    KELMAN: 7.5

    OLAOFE: 7.5

    Referee 7.5

    Subs: LEABURN: 7.5

    CAMPBELL: 7.5

  • soapboxsam
    soapboxsam Posts: 23,232

    marks 0.5 to 10.0 please

    KAMINSKI: 8 vital save when Ipswich were so on top 1st half

    RAMSAY:8.5 Kayne is back.

    JONES: 8 strong performance.

    GILLESPHEY: 8.5 bounced back from a poor miss to get the vital 2nd goal by being in the right place yet again.

    BREE: 8 steady game from an experience player.

    COVENTRY: 8.5The normal hard working shift from Conor.

    CAREY:9.5 sublime goal and the under the radar signing is a revelation.

    DOCHERTY:8 a nuisance to the opposition even if he doesn't look smooth. Took a booking for the team just before HT.

    BELL:8.5looks class on the ball and is doing well as Edwards' cover after shifting from LCB.

    KELMAN: 7.5 improving with each match and it was tough for Charlie and Olaofe in the 1st half when we took so long to strong a few passes together.

    OLAOFE:7.5 lovely turn but couldn't finish. He and Kelman put in a good 60 minute shift 

    Referee 8 One of the best in this division and if Kaminski took 8 seconds then giving a corner is fair as long as all refs do it.

    Subs: LEABURN: 8 Miles did great and got involved straight away with his headed goal and all round play.

    CAMPBELL: 8 needed to be on the bench but great impact running at tired defenders and we have so many options now. Great assist TC.


  • bristoladdick
    bristoladdick Posts: 1,149

    KAMINSKI: 7.5

    RAMSAY: 8

    JONES: 8

    GILLESPHEY: 8.5

    BREE: 7.5

    COVENTRY: 8

    CAREY: 9

    DOCHERTY: 8

    BELL: 8.5

    KELMAN: 7.5

    OLAOFE: 7

    Referee 7

    Subs: LEABURN: 8

    CAMPBELL: 8.5




  • Sponsored links:



  • Rob
    Rob Posts: 11,823

    KAMINSKI: 8

    RAMSAY: 8

    JONES: 8

    GILLESPHEY: 8

    BREE: 7.5

    COVENTRY: 8

    CAREY: 9

    DOCHERTY: 8

    BELL: 8

    KELMAN: 7

    OLAOFE: 7

    Referee 7

    Subs: LEABURN: 8

    CAMPBELL: 8

  • KAMINSKI: 9

    RAMSAY: 8.5

    JONES: 8.5

    GILLESPHEY: 9

    BREE: 9 - he’s so good. 

    COVENTRY: 10 - had to take on a ridiculous amount of the defensive work after Doherty’s booking. 

    CAREY: 9.5

    DOCHERTY: 7 

    BELL: 8.5

    KELMAN: 8.5

    OLAOFE: 7.5 - snatched at his 1v1

    Referee 7 - not too bad. 

    Subs: LEABURN: 8.5 (chuks like impact)

    CAMPBELL: 8.5 - I prefer him coming off the bench. 

  • mendonca
    mendonca Posts: 9,415
    KAMINSKI: 8

    RAMSAY: 9
    JONES: 9
    GILLESPHEY: 9
    BREE: 7
    COVENTRY: 8
    CAREY: 9
    DOCHERTY: 8
    BELL: 9
    KELMAN: 8
    OLAOFE: 7
    Referee 7
    Subs: LEABURN: 8
    CAMPBELL: 9
  • Mckforester
    Mckforester Posts: 851

    KAMINSKI: 8

    RAMSAY: 8.5

    JONES: 9

    GILLESPHEY: 9

    BREE: 8

    COVENTRY: 8

    CAREY: 8.5

    DOCHERTY: 8

    BELL: 8

    KELMAN: 8

    OLAOFE: 8

    Referee 8

    Subs: LEABURN: 8.5

    CAMPBELL: 8.5

    The Gaffer: 10


  • RugbyAddick
    RugbyAddick Posts: 2,083

    KAMINSKI: 9.5 that early save was class

    RAMSAY: 9.5 Kaynes back! That tackle was just brilliant 

    JONES: 9.5 just solid  won everything 

    GILLESPHEY: 9.5 immense again. Got his goal. Should have had 2. But just so good

    BREE: 9.5 defensively so good. Calm on the ball. Set pieces dangerous once again.

    COVENTRY: 9 feel harsh only giving a nine. Protected the defence. Carried the ball well. Blocked everything

    CAREY: 9.5 goal and set one up. Dangerous going forward. I thought he look shattered end of the first half, and wouldn’t blame him if he was. Absolute steal getting him for free.

    DOCHERTY: 9 same as Cov. Gave it away a couple of times but first 25 minutes Ipswich were very good.

    BELL: 9.5 part of THAT defence. Carries the ball well.

    KELMAN: 8.5 not in the game first 20 mins and that’s not his fault. Put himself about. Held it up well again. So unlucky not to score and knackered out their defence which set up our subs nicely to cause carnage

    OLAOFE: 8.5 same as Kelman. Should have done better with the first half chance. Almost had too much time to think about it

    Referee 6 I actually think he done well. Their goal was offside. Made a mistake with our third… looks like it was out of play, but I couldn’t give a shite!

    Subs: LEABURN: 9 put himself about. Got a goal. Linked up with TC very well. Really scared them. Arguably the best he’s played in about 18 months. 

    CAMPBELL: 9.5 I have criticised him a fair bit this season, but remain adamant that it will all click into place with him. That performance from the bench was unbelievable. He scared them. Set up the third. Unlucky with his attempts but that’s a performance he… and we, can be proud of

    KNIBBS: n/a needed them fresh legs

    J R-C: n/a

    BURKE: n/a 


    That’s a performance the fans can be proud of. Every single player today played out of their skin both in defence and attack. Said to my brother at half time that I’d take 0-0 all day. Wow

  • vff
    vff Posts: 6,888

    marks 0.5 to 10.0 please

    KAMINSKI:9 - Great performance and key save earlier on that set the tone for the match

    RAMSAY:9 - What a great defensive tackle and quality throughout

    JONES:9 - Great leadership and heart of defence, even helped build up to 3rd goal

    GILLESPHEY:9 - goal line clearance, goal and stout defending alongside Jones

    BREE:8 - Worked hard and great play

    COVENTRY:8 - back to form in centre of the park, managed quick midfielders well

    CAREY:9 - Brilliant goal, and assist for the 2nd, work so hard. 

    DOCHERTY:8 - authoritative performance

    BELL:9 - Quality player and excellent peformance throughout

    KELMAN:- 7.5 - worked hard, good shot 2nd - that goal is cominng

    OLAOFE: 7.5 - lead the line, worked hard, missed the one on one

    Referee 9 - best referee of the season so far by country mile

    Subs: LEABURN: 8 .5

    CAMPBELL:8.5 -assist and looked really dangerous with lots of end product

    KNIBBS: n/a

    J R-C: n/a

    BURKE: n/a



  • Redrobo
    Redrobo Posts: 11,333

    KAMINSKI: 9

    RAMSAY: 10

    JONES: 10

    GILLESPHEY: 10

    BREE: 9

    COVENTRY: 9

    CAREY: 10

    DOCHERTY: 9

    BELL: 9

    KELMAN: 9

    OLAOFE: 9

    Referee

    Subs: LEABURN: 9

    CAMPBELL: 9

  • Bridgeboy
    Bridgeboy Posts: 123

    KAMINSKI: 7.5

    RAMSAY: 8

    JONES: 8

    GILLESPHEY: 8.5

    BREE: 8

    COVENTRY: 9

    CAREY: 8.5

    DOCHERTY: 7.5

    BELL: 8

    KELMAN: 8

    OLAOFE: 8

    Referee

    Subs: LEABURN: 8

    CAMPBELL: 8

  • KAMINSKI: 8.5

    RAMSAY:9

    JONES:9

    GILLESPHEY:9

    BREE:8

    COVENTRY:7.5

    CAREY:9.5

    DOCHERTY:8

    BELL:9

    KELMAN:8

    OLAOFE:8

    Referee9

    Subs: LEABURN:8.5

    CAMPBELL:8.5
  • 93Addick
    93Addick Posts: 138

    KAMINSKI: 8

    RAMSAY: 8.5

    JONES: 9

    GILLESPHEY: 9

    BREE: 8

    COVENTRY: 8

    CAREY: 9

    DOCHERTY: 8

    BELL: 9

    KELMAN: 7.5

    OLAOFE: 7.5

    Referee: 9

    Subs: LEABURN: 8

    CAMPBELL: 8


  • Sponsored links:



  • thewolfboy
    thewolfboy Posts: 2,930
    Telly!

    KAMINSKI: 8

    RAMSAY: 9

    JONES: 9

    GILLESPHEY: 9

    BREE: 9

    COVENTRY: 9

    CAREY: 9.5

    DOCHERTY: 8

    BELL: 9

    KELMAN: 8

    OLAOFE: 8

    Referee 9

    Subs: LEABURN: 9

    CAMPBELL: 9

  • KAMINSKI: 8

    RAMSAY: 8

    JONES: 8

    GILLESPHEY: 8

    BREE: 8

    COVENTRY: 8

    CAREY: 9

    DOCHERTY: 8

    BELL: 8

    KELMAN: 8

    OLAOFE: 8

    Referee

    Subs: LEABURN: 8

    CAMPBELL: 8


  • DyerConsequences
    DyerConsequences Posts: 2,635
    edited October 21
    KAMINSKI: 8
    RAMSAY: 8.5
    JONES: 8.5
    GILLESPHEY: 9
    BREE: 8
    COVENTRY: 8
    CAREY: 9
    DOCHERTY: 8
    BELL: 9
    KELMAN: 8
    OLAOFE: 7.5
    Subs: LEABURN: 8
    CAMPBELL: 8

    Referee: 5


  • KAMINSKI: 7

    RAMSAY: 7

    JONES: 9

    GILLESPHEY: 9

    BREE: 7

    COVENTRY: 8

    CAREY: 9

    DOCHERTY: 8

    BELL: 9

    KELMAN: 7

    OLAOFE: 7

    Referee 7

    Subs: LEABURN: 6

    CAMPBELL: 6


  • KAMINSKI: 8

    RAMSAY: 8.5

    JONES: 9

    GILLESPHEY: 9

    BREE: 7

    COVENTRY: 8

    CAREY: 8.5

    DOCHERTY: 8

    BELL: 8

    KELMAN: 7.5

    OLAOFE: 7

    Referee 4

    Subs: LEABURN: 7.5

    CAMPBELL: 8

  • Nicholas
    Nicholas Posts: 7,634
    edited October 22

    KAMINSKI: 8.5

    RAMSAY: 9

    JONES: 8.5

    GILLESPHEY: 8.5

    BREE: 8

    COVENTRY: 8

    CAREY: 8.5

    DOCHERTY: 8

    BELL: 9.5

    KELMAN: 7

    OLAOFE: 7.5

    Referee

    Subs: LEABURN: 8

    CAMPBELL: 8


  • Addictedoldgit
    Addictedoldgit Posts: 1,828
    From a TV at @Addicktedtothereds bar-Spain

    KAMINSKI:    8

    RAMSAY:       8

    JONES:           8

    GILLESPHEY: 8

    BREE:               7.5

    COVENTRY:     7.5

    CAREY:              8

    DOCHERTY:      8

    BELL:                  7.5

    KELMAN:            7

    OLAOFE:              6    disappointing 

    Referee  7

    Subs: LEABURN: 7.5

    CAMPBELL:         8.5

    KNIBBS: n/a

    J R-C: n/a

    BURKE: n/a


  • swords_alive
    swords_alive Posts: 4,280
    edited October 21

    KAMINSKI: 7

    RAMSAY: 7.5

    JONES: 7.5

    GILLESPHEY: 7.5

    BREE: 7

    COVENTRY: 7

    CAREY: 8

    DOCHERTY: 7.5

    BELL: 7.5

    KELMAN: 7.5

    OLAOFE: 7

    Referee: 7.5

    Subs: LEABURN: 7

    CAMPBELL: 7

  • KAMINSKI: 8

    RAMSAY: 9

    JONES: 9

    GILLESPHEY: 9

    BREE: 8

    COVENTRY: 8.5

    CAREY: 9

    DOCHERTY: 8.5

    BELL: 9

    KELMAN: 7.5

    OLAOFE: 7.5

    Referee: 7

    Subs: 

    LEABURN: 8

    CAMPBELL: 7.5

  • Steven81
    Steven81 Posts: 1,016
    edited October 22
    10 for all of them Idgaf