Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
FA Cup Final
Comments
-
There's a 40K stadium that Palace should move to 🤔
It's in Liverpool and it's available after today.
They can share the ground with Everton Women.
If their genuine fans, they can either drive and chance still having tyres as the locals work faster than Kwik Fit or get the early morning train or relocate and live in Skelmersdale.
Time to move on and up Palace.
0 -
Who knows what will happen in the future. Wigan beat City in the FA cup final not so long ago didn't they?
What I do keep reflecting on is the past.
The season they went up, I have a recollection they were generally lucky, and we lost both games but could so easily have been different. Home game we had a perfectly good goal ruled out before they scored and then hit the bar and one cleared off the line at the death.
Selhurst I remember us being all over them 1st half, went 1-0 up could have been 2, then did Hamer make a mistake and they got 2 goals about a minute or two apart?
Had we got 4 points from those games, we would have made play-offs at their expense.
I do often feel we are living an ongoing hell for what happened in 2005. For one, I'm sure it is part of the reason Murray lost his mind.0 -
You’d think they’d look at sites beyond the M25, even in West Sussex where apparently seagulls and eagles have massive airborn fights.Woodwork said:
That keeps hitting issues though. As it is an awful site to try and develop.Chris_from_Sidcup said:
I think they've decided to just expand Selhurst (to 34k) which will be a lot lot cheaper than building a new stadium.Woodwork said:The way English football is now, any London club could fill a 40,000 capacity stadium.
If Bromley were plonked into the PL and given a 40,000 stadium and had reasonable ticket prices, they’d sell-out most games with floating Arsenal, Chelsea etc fans, tourists, locals wanting to watch live PL football.I am surprised Palace aren’t looking to build a new stadium tbh. Selhurst Park is hardly a historic & charismatic old ground. It’s holding them back. If they built a new 45,000 capacity stadium somewhere else, they’d fill it. Maybe only a lack of suitable sites stopping them?If I was them, I would look at building a 45-50k stadium near M25.0 -
Chris_from_Sidcup said:
As we've seen in the last couple of years though, newly promoted sides struggle to even get to 30 points now, so Palace would require a serious meltdown to end up in any relegation trouble.ElfsborgAddick said:Hopefully the European games will get in their way and harm their league position.This is true.I have always maintained that the key to the pricks staying up, and never being in danger, is that they have appointed very good managers for their needs.We have to hope that they start a season badly and get in a bad run.0 -
Woodwork said:The way English football is now, any London club could fill a 40,000 capacity stadium.
If Bromley were plonked into the PL and given a 40,000 stadium and had reasonable ticket prices, they’d sell-out most games with floating Arsenal, Chelsea etc fans, tourists, locals wanting to watch live PL football.I am surprised Palace aren’t looking to build a new stadium tbh. Selhurst Park is hardly a historic & charismatic old ground. It’s holding them back. If they built a new 45,000 capacity stadium somewhere else, they’d fill it. Maybe only a lack of suitable sites stopping them?
Where is there land for them to do it?
0 -
We will just have to get back up there and relegate them again. I've come to the conclusion it's the only way1
-
Chris_from_Sidcup said:
I think they've decided to just expand Selhurst (to 34k) which will be a lot lot cheaper than building a new stadium.Woodwork said:The way English football is now, any London club could fill a 40,000 capacity stadium.
If Bromley were plonked into the PL and given a 40,000 stadium and had reasonable ticket prices, they’d sell-out most games with floating Arsenal, Chelsea etc fans, tourists, locals wanting to watch live PL football.I am surprised Palace aren’t looking to build a new stadium tbh. Selhurst Park is hardly a historic & charismatic old ground. It’s holding them back. If they built a new 45,000 capacity stadium somewhere else, they’d fill it. Maybe only a lack of suitable sites stopping them?
I saw 100 million mentioned for the cost.
0 -
What's that phrase about polishing a turd?ElfsborgAddick said:Chris_from_Sidcup said:
I think they've decided to just expand Selhurst (to 34k) which will be a lot lot cheaper than building a new stadium.Woodwork said:The way English football is now, any London club could fill a 40,000 capacity stadium.
If Bromley were plonked into the PL and given a 40,000 stadium and had reasonable ticket prices, they’d sell-out most games with floating Arsenal, Chelsea etc fans, tourists, locals wanting to watch live PL football.I am surprised Palace aren’t looking to build a new stadium tbh. Selhurst Park is hardly a historic & charismatic old ground. It’s holding them back. If they built a new 45,000 capacity stadium somewhere else, they’d fill it. Maybe only a lack of suitable sites stopping them?
I saw 100 million mentioned for the cost.1 -
iaitch said:
What's that phrase about polishing a turd?ElfsborgAddick said:Chris_from_Sidcup said:
I think they've decided to just expand Selhurst (to 34k) which will be a lot lot cheaper than building a new stadium.Woodwork said:The way English football is now, any London club could fill a 40,000 capacity stadium.
If Bromley were plonked into the PL and given a 40,000 stadium and had reasonable ticket prices, they’d sell-out most games with floating Arsenal, Chelsea etc fans, tourists, locals wanting to watch live PL football.I am surprised Palace aren’t looking to build a new stadium tbh. Selhurst Park is hardly a historic & charismatic old ground. It’s holding them back. If they built a new 45,000 capacity stadium somewhere else, they’d fill it. Maybe only a lack of suitable sites stopping them?
I saw 100 million mentioned for the cost.As much as I despise this mob, I have never disliked the ground.Getting to the place has never been a problem using public transport, but I realise getting there by motor is a massive pain in the backside.0 -
Jesus Nigel Christ is his full name I thinkNorth Lower Neil said:
Didn't know Jesus had favourite football teams.Callumcafc said:
1 -
Sponsored links:
-
God help me.
Me mum can't believe I didn't watch the game and I should be happy for the rest of the family.
Been summoned by the wife to go to the inlaws.
Mother in law Palace season ticket holder.
Won't go down well if I say with a bit of luck you'll be relegated next season.2 -
3rd round at The Valley, we knock them out as the current holders, live on the beeb.....Dave2l said:How does Charlton resurrect this rather shit situation.
We get promoted.
Instantly drawn into the fa cup 3rd round.
We cause an upset, maybe even knock palace out....then we surprisingly reach the QF, bit of luck on our side. Next thing we know, we are in the cup final and we bloody win it in 2026
Shrug our shoulders and casually say yeh we won the FA cup, I know palace did last season but so what - we did it.
Then the likes of Susana Reid has a casual sexy angry devastated look on her face the following morning when presenting Good morning Britain!
....Gonna take my meds now!1 -
no i will not be backing palace in europe, quite the oppositeGribbo said:Question for the people who always back English teams in Europe; will you be backing the Nigels?
For me, they've just joined Arsenal as the only two teams, who I'll back foreign opposition.0 -
Just been for a roast in New Cross and the beer garden was full of Palace fans, still in their shirts, singing their songs. Ruined my meal.
0 -
ok, good try but no, you are the only team south of the river without a major trophy (apparently wimbledon no longer count as they are a new club now) - if its simpler, lets say you are the only club without a major trophy in south east london - palace are in se25, like it or not. Apart from your lack of top division appearances, that makes you the least successful by some distance. I appreciate palace are catching us up, but you lot will just have to rely on your tales of when you were hard as that seems to be some consolation to most of you. It has to be i guess.Woodwork said:
You not counting the Football League Trophy, mate? They won it when top flight teams entered, so Rothman’s count it as a ‘major’ trophy 🙃😘DOUCHER said:As i said previously, palace doing well is of miniscule importance compared to millwall doing well as palace is not something that happens in my world - they are over there and only became of real relevance when we had to ground share. The silver lining to us losing our status as the only major trophy winners south of the river is that millwall now become the only team not to have won a major trophy and puts them firmly into the loser bin. It's better how it was but its something and something i'm happy to remind millwall about
Also… if we are talking ‘south’ London as a whole, Clapham, Chelsea and the old Wimbledon have all won it too tbf.If you only count SE London, Charlton Athletic are still the only SE London club to win it. 1 -
spot on - palace may have some proper strange fans and although i know a lot of good millwall fans, the plastic gangster, once a year hoolie makes me cringe more - millwall bingo bermugees who we have to put up with out here in the suburbsOff_it said:
And your lot have thousands upon thousands who associate themselves with the club purely because of the historic reputation and have either never been to a game in their lives or else only turn up for the big games or when there's a chance it will go off.MillwallFan said:
I had a customer from the Bromley area who was an Arsenal fan, as were his sons. For years though he had a season ticket for him and his three sons at the Valley during your PL days. He just got them so he could watch cheap live PL football on a regular basis. I don’t think he’s been back since you got relegated.soapboxsam said:JamesSeed said:
Sam, it’s not just about tribalism. I have friends who decided to become palace fans two or three years ago. They’ve always been very patronising about Charlton, and pretend to not even know which league we’re in.soapboxsam said:The great thing about Charlton fans are they are so level headed as demonstrated on CL ?
They have 7 chips on one shoulder about Palace and 7 chips on the other shoulder about Millwall.
A week before a 50/50 match in getting Charlton Athletic back to their home land of the Championship and the 2nd tier, they are focused on Palace who left Charlton behind long ago. The League cup game when we lost 4-1 with our 1st team against their reserves was when we waved goodbye in their tatty old stadium. The last close game was the 2-1 lost when Glenn Murray scored twice after Ben Hamer's slip.
I took that loss badly as 1-0 up at HT and JJ should have buried his header to go 2 up 🤦🏻♂️
Palace have a hybrid fan base with more ethnic groups than I see at Charlton. I'm not talking about ground hoppers or Football tourists. Many of their supporters live in Surrey but Thornton heath is very diverse as well as West Croydon where English isn't spoken very often.
Because of my Bermondsey roots I suffered more if we lost to Millwall because in many of those games we were higher in the table FFS.
Tribal rivalry is an ancient feral state and Charlton should probably focus on Millwall our nearest rival, IF and when we reached the promised land of the 2nd tier as opposed to a Premier team, with an FA cup win and European football next season.
Jealousy eats you up as I know with my hatred of Chelsea ! 😤The one thing I’ve had to counter their jibes was the fact that we’d actually won a major trophy and they hadn’t. Of course It should be water off a duck’s back, I know, but it does rile me up. They have no understanding of the history of the game. To them it’s all about the Premier League. I guarantee if palace were relegated they’d soon lose interest.
When Charlton reached the Premier League, we had new fans as well. Staying with my parents one weekend in Canterbury I got the coach up from the Victoria Pub. One 'fan' was a recently retired weather man on Meridian; he knew all the current players TBF.
Despite his age I knew he was a newbie as when I compared a player to John Humphrey's he didn't know who I was talking about ! Johnny H !
It would be like a fan not knowing about the late great Jimmy Seed.
If Palace were ever relegated they would lose 'fans' like we did and the odious Chelsea did back in the day.
Not all 'fans' are "Charlton until I die"
That's show business.1 -
When we played there I was living in Sydenham so with games ending at 4.50 could get a train around 5.00 and be back home around 5.10 but it wasn't our ground.ElfsborgAddick said:iaitch said:
What's that phrase about polishing a turd?ElfsborgAddick said:Chris_from_Sidcup said:
I think they've decided to just expand Selhurst (to 34k) which will be a lot lot cheaper than building a new stadium.Woodwork said:The way English football is now, any London club could fill a 40,000 capacity stadium.
If Bromley were plonked into the PL and given a 40,000 stadium and had reasonable ticket prices, they’d sell-out most games with floating Arsenal, Chelsea etc fans, tourists, locals wanting to watch live PL football.I am surprised Palace aren’t looking to build a new stadium tbh. Selhurst Park is hardly a historic & charismatic old ground. It’s holding them back. If they built a new 45,000 capacity stadium somewhere else, they’d fill it. Maybe only a lack of suitable sites stopping them?
I saw 100 million mentioned for the cost.As much as I despise this mob, I have never disliked the ground.Getting to the place has never been a problem using public transport, but I realise getting there by motor is a massive pain in the backside.1 -
i thought i read somewhere that for one of your recent play offs at wembley you only sold 28k?Woodwork said:The way English football is now, any London club could fill a 40,000 capacity stadium.
If Bromley were plonked into the PL and given a 40,000 stadium and had reasonable ticket prices, they’d sell-out most games with floating Arsenal, Chelsea etc fans, tourists, locals wanting to watch live PL football.I am surprised Palace aren’t looking to build a new stadium tbh. Selhurst Park is hardly a historic & charismatic old ground. It’s holding them back. If they built a new 45,000 capacity stadium somewhere else, they’d fill it. Maybe only a lack of suitable sites stopping them?0 -
Really?? What pub? I have a lot of connections to New Cross. A lot of family from there and spent a lot of time there, as a kid and as an adult, drinking in the pubs tgere. And I have never seen a palace fan there… ever. Even when we’ve played them at home.se9addick said:Just been for a roast in New Cross and the beer garden was full of Palace fans, still in their shirts, singing their songs. Ruined my meal.4 -
Sponsored links:
-
The Rose opposite New Cross Gate.MillwallFan said:
Really?? What pub? I have a lot of connections to New Cross. A lot of family from there and spent a lot of time there, as a kid and as an adult, drinking in the pubs tgere. And I have never seen a palace fan there… ever. Even when we’ve played them at home.se9addick said:Just been for a roast in New Cross and the beer garden was full of Palace fans, still in their shirts, singing their songs. Ruined my meal.0 -
Strange location for them. No where near their area. Right outside the station though so maybe on route somewhere.se9addick said:
The Rose opposite New Cross Gate.MillwallFan said:
Really?? What pub? I have a lot of connections to New Cross. A lot of family from there and spent a lot of time there, as a kid and as an adult, drinking in the pubs tgere. And I have never seen a palace fan there… ever. Even when we’ve played them at home.se9addick said:Just been for a roast in New Cross and the beer garden was full of Palace fans, still in their shirts, singing their songs. Ruined my meal.0 -
they're taking over millwallfan - south london is their's remember3
-
If you appreciated football history more, you’d at least recognise Millwall have a fair bit of football history to their.DOUCHER said:
ok, good try but no, you are the only team south of the river without a major trophy (apparently wimbledon no longer count as they are a new club now) - if its simpler, lets say you are the only club without a major trophy in south east london - palace are in se25, like it or not. Apart from your lack of top division appearances, that makes you the least successful by some distance. I appreciate palace are catching us up, but you lot will just have to rely on your tales of when you were hard as that seems to be some consolation to most of you. It has to be i guess.Woodwork said:
You not counting the Football League Trophy, mate? They won it when top flight teams entered, so Rothman’s count it as a ‘major’ trophy 🙃😘DOUCHER said:As i said previously, palace doing well is of miniscule importance compared to millwall doing well as palace is not something that happens in my world - they are over there and only became of real relevance when we had to ground share. The silver lining to us losing our status as the only major trophy winners south of the river is that millwall now become the only team not to have won a major trophy and puts them firmly into the loser bin. It's better how it was but its something and something i'm happy to remind millwall about
Also… if we are talking ‘south’ London as a whole, Clapham, Chelsea and the old Wimbledon have all won it too tbf.If you only count SE London, Charlton Athletic are still the only SE London club to win it. Eg pioneers of professional football in London and the south, allowing them to be the first working man’s southern team to give the top professional northern & midland’s teams from the Football League a bloody nose. Their victories over Preston NE, Derby County, Everton & the great Aston Villa side of the late Victorian meaning they’re the only club in England to be bestowed a nickname for sporting prowess! The ‘Dockers’ being christened the ‘Lions of the South’ by the national sporting press.Indeed, the Millwall Athletic team, as they were then known, that reached two FA Cup semi-final (1900, 1903) no doubt inspired others in London to start their own clubs. Palace & Chelsea were both formed in 1905.1 -
Haha. Just so long as there’s no Millwall fans about 😉DOUCHER said:they're taking over millwallfan - south london is their's remember0 -
Again, to be a Millwall apologist, yes… for their 5th visit in 8 years & with ticket sales restricted to two per members.DOUCHER said:
i thought i read somewhere that for one of your recent play offs at wembley you only sold 28k?Woodwork said:The way English football is now, any London club could fill a 40,000 capacity stadium.
If Bromley were plonked into the PL and given a 40,000 stadium and had reasonable ticket prices, they’d sell-out most games with floating Arsenal, Chelsea etc fans, tourists, locals wanting to watch live PL football.I am surprised Palace aren’t looking to build a new stadium tbh. Selhurst Park is hardly a historic & charismatic old ground. It’s holding them back. If they built a new 45,000 capacity stadium somewhere else, they’d fill it. Maybe only a lack of suitable sites stopping them?That’s still pretty impressive tbf. Especially as it was a L1 play-off following a L1 play-off defeat the year before. I think we (Charlton 🙄) would do well to shift that many in same circumstances. Don’t you?0 -
Exactly. That is why I wrote the last bit.ElfsborgAddick said:Woodwork said:The way English football is now, any London club could fill a 40,000 capacity stadium.
If Bromley were plonked into the PL and given a 40,000 stadium and had reasonable ticket prices, they’d sell-out most games with floating Arsenal, Chelsea etc fans, tourists, locals wanting to watch live PL football.I am surprised Palace aren’t looking to build a new stadium tbh. Selhurst Park is hardly a historic & charismatic old ground. It’s holding them back. If they built a new 45,000 capacity stadium somewhere else, they’d fill it. Maybe only a lack of suitable sites stopping them?
Where is there land for them to do it?0 -
i do appreciate football history and acknowledge millwall have been around longer than us but doesn't stop me pointing out they've never won anything so yesterday was probably a bigger blow to you than us - in my opinion, of course !!!Woodwork said:
If you appreciated football history more, you’d at least recognise Millwall have a fair bit of football history to their.DOUCHER said:
ok, good try but no, you are the only team south of the river without a major trophy (apparently wimbledon no longer count as they are a new club now) - if its simpler, lets say you are the only club without a major trophy in south east london - palace are in se25, like it or not. Apart from your lack of top division appearances, that makes you the least successful by some distance. I appreciate palace are catching us up, but you lot will just have to rely on your tales of when you were hard as that seems to be some consolation to most of you. It has to be i guess.Woodwork said:
You not counting the Football League Trophy, mate? They won it when top flight teams entered, so Rothman’s count it as a ‘major’ trophy 🙃😘DOUCHER said:As i said previously, palace doing well is of miniscule importance compared to millwall doing well as palace is not something that happens in my world - they are over there and only became of real relevance when we had to ground share. The silver lining to us losing our status as the only major trophy winners south of the river is that millwall now become the only team not to have won a major trophy and puts them firmly into the loser bin. It's better how it was but its something and something i'm happy to remind millwall about
Also… if we are talking ‘south’ London as a whole, Clapham, Chelsea and the old Wimbledon have all won it too tbf.If you only count SE London, Charlton Athletic are still the only SE London club to win it. Eg pioneers of professional football in London and the south, allowing them to be the first working man’s southern team to give the top professional northern & midland’s teams from the Football League a bloody nose. Their victories over Preston NE, Derby County, Everton & the great Aston Villa side of the late Victorian meaning they’re the only club in England to be bestowed a nickname for sporting prowess! The ‘Dockers’ being christened the ‘Lions of the South’ by the national sporting press.Indeed, the Millwall Athletic team, as they were then known, that reached two FA Cup semi-final (1900, 1903) no doubt inspired others in London to start their own clubs. Palace & Chelsea were both formed in 1905.0 -
noWoodwork said:
Again, to be a Millwall apologist, yes… for their 5th visit in 8 years & with ticket sales restricted to two per members.DOUCHER said:
i thought i read somewhere that for one of your recent play offs at wembley you only sold 28k?Woodwork said:The way English football is now, any London club could fill a 40,000 capacity stadium.
If Bromley were plonked into the PL and given a 40,000 stadium and had reasonable ticket prices, they’d sell-out most games with floating Arsenal, Chelsea etc fans, tourists, locals wanting to watch live PL football.I am surprised Palace aren’t looking to build a new stadium tbh. Selhurst Park is hardly a historic & charismatic old ground. It’s holding them back. If they built a new 45,000 capacity stadium somewhere else, they’d fill it. Maybe only a lack of suitable sites stopping them?That’s still pretty impressive tbf. Especially as it was a L1 play-off following a L1 play-off defeat the year before. I think we (Charlton 🙄) would do well to shift that many in same circumstances. Don’t you?0
