POST-MATCH THREAD: Mansfield Town v Charlton Athletic: Tuesday 1st April 2025: KO 19:45
Comments
-
TellyTubby said:bobmunro said:TellyTubby said:bobmunro said:killerandflash said:RC_CAFC said:How many times did that Sky commentator say they had a goal disallowed 😂. It wasn’t allowed because it never went in!
I was very surprised that the ref didn't have the net checked - Sunday park game perhaps, but that should not happen in a professional game.
Neither went in the goal, both were outside. We had an excellent view from right behind that side of the goal.I KNOW THEY WERE NOT GIVEN!That's not my point - clearly the side netting was compromised. Why do you think linos check the nets before the game? The integrity of the netting should have been checked and repaired.6 -
Briston_Addick said:bromleyjohn said:I think we can forget automatics but we can focus on coming third just like under Bowyer The main thing is to be the in-form team.
Wycombe dropping points.
Charlton still winning ... and still have to play the Ws (albeit away from home).
Automatics anything but forgotten as far as I'm concerned.
Don't settle for play-offs, don't coast ... run through the tape and you never know who you may pip on the line.
We've been relegated in the final minute of the season, we've moved up the play-off positions in the final minute of the season, and we've been promoted in the final minute of the season (play off finals) ... this one's not over yet!4 -
Very good away performance considering we were without arguably our most important player through injury.I thought McIntyre did really well, especially considering how few minutes he’s played.
Mansfield knocked the ball about quite well,but were always looking for free kicks and hassling the ref (who was one of the best we’ve seen this season.) Their Vickers was always a threat. Worth keeping tabs on him I’d say.
Tupac gets better and better. On this trajectory, we might lose him even if we do get promoted. Another great finish from him - set up by Aneke who almost scored the goal of the season. Great technique when striking the ball.Nathan Jones has done a sensational job turning it round from the disappointing start to the season and some of the awful results we had along the way, turning us into the seriously competitive and physically robust side that we can actually be proud if.Having sat through the sterile Arsenal v Chelsea at the Emirates, and the sometimes comically bad Brighton v Forest cup tie on TV, I genuinely think some of our recent games have been way more entertaining.Two points gained over Wrexham and Wycombe. Long may it continue.5 -
A great battling performance. Mansfield pressed us & didn’t allow us to play. I thought some of their challenges were over robust to say the least. Ref wasn’t the worst we’ve had but a couple of ‘challenges’ on both Anderson & Campbell were more like assaults & nothing given ! I always felt comfortable that we would get the win even when they had a little spell of putting us under pressure. We seem to find a way in most games now. In Jones we trust ! You can bet he hasn’t given up automatic promotion & he won’t let these players either . The pressure will be on both Wycombe & Wrexham to the last. As somebody once said, it’s squeaky bum time for them & that can create some funny old results !0
-
Thataddick said:They completely deserved to lose. They spent more time diving than playing, especially their No. 8 who, in my opinion, was seriously dodgy, and his hair was stuck in the 70s.
0 -
RC_CAFC said:How many times did that Sky commentator say they had a goal disallowed 😂. It wasn’t allowed because it never went in!
Otherwise next time could have serious consequences.0 -
golfaddick said:Kap10 said:Wycombe next two games Hudds and reading away, both could be tough gigs for them, before they get us at their place.
But they play Stockport last game of the season. Tasty.0 -
Bailey said:ButtleJR said:Superb result. Great atmosphere. Out of interest do readings results get removed if they don't find a buyer? I don't wish that on any club but could it benefit us?
West Ham cheated be playing Tevez & Mascereno and got a slap on the wrist instead of a points deduction.
Rules are rules. I think the deadline is the end of this week. If Reading are not sold by the weekend then they should be kicked out.
But sadly the EFL are pussies & wont do anything until the end of the regular season.
0 -
Praise the Lord!1
-
killerandflash said:TellyTubby said:bobmunro said:TellyTubby said:bobmunro said:killerandflash said:RC_CAFC said:How many times did that Sky commentator say they had a goal disallowed 😂. It wasn’t allowed because it never went in!
I was very surprised that the ref didn't have the net checked - Sunday park game perhaps, but that should not happen in a professional game.
Neither went in the goal, both were outside. We had an excellent view from right behind that side of the goal.I KNOW THEY WERE NOT GIVEN!That's not my point - clearly the side netting was compromised. Why do you think linos check the nets before the game? The integrity of the netting should have been checked and repaired.
@golfaddick the Mansfield 'disallowed' goal absolutely didn't go through the net.2 - Sponsored links:
-
golfaddick said:RC_CAFC said:How many times did that Sky commentator say they had a goal disallowed 😂. It wasn’t allowed because it never went in!
Otherwise next time could have serious consequences.Freddie Sears v Bristol City, 15th August 2009
When Freddie Sears found the back of the net past Bristol City ‘keeper Dean Gerken, he naturally wheeled away to join his teammates celebrating Palace’s opening goal of a controversial summer afternoon, oblivious to the ball which sailed back over his head towards the penalty spot.
It wasn’t until he’d turned around to see referee Rob Shoebridge deliberating with his linesman that Sears realised something wasn’t quite right.
His goal, which followed a considerable punt upfield from Julian Speroni, cannoned in and out of the net in the flash of an eye and seemed to evade Shoebridge, who awarded a goal kick instead.
Despite enjoying the better of the two teams' performance, Palace would go on to lose the clash 1-0 as Nicky Maynard stole a point from the Eagles in the 90th minute.
2 -
golfaddick said:Bailey said:ButtleJR said:Superb result. Great atmosphere. Out of interest do readings results get removed if they don't find a buyer? I don't wish that on any club but could it benefit us?
West Ham cheated be playing Tevez & Mascereno and got a slap on the wrist instead of a points deduction.
Rules are rules. I think the deadline is the end of this week. If Reading are not sold by the weekend then they should be kicked out.
But sadly the EFL are pussies & wont do anything until the end of the regular season.0 -
There is no doubt that the Mansfield shot hit the stanchion behind the goal and cannoned on to the back of the net. Mannion walked around the posts to collect the ball.
Never between the posts despite what the commentator said six times !
Now having just watched the highlights I can see what Bob Munro means and this time the ball does hit the side of the net and then appears to be over the line in the goal.
Quite bizarre.
Great 3 points in a strange old game.2 -
swords_alive said:golfaddick said:RC_CAFC said:How many times did that Sky commentator say they had a goal disallowed 😂. It wasn’t allowed because it never went in!
Otherwise next time could have serious consequences.Freddie Sears v Bristol City, 15th August 2009
When Freddie Sears found the back of the net past Bristol City ‘keeper Dean Gerken, he naturally wheeled away to join his teammates celebrating Palace’s opening goal of a controversial summer afternoon, oblivious to the ball which sailed back over his head towards the penalty spot.
It wasn’t until he’d turned around to see referee Rob Shoebridge deliberating with his linesman that Sears realised something wasn’t quite right.
His goal, which followed a considerable punt upfield from Julian Speroni, cannoned in and out of the net in the flash of an eye and seemed to evade Shoebridge, who awarded a goal kick instead.
Despite enjoying the better of the two teams' performance, Palace would go on to lose the clash 1-0 as Nicky Maynard stole a point from the Eagles in the 90th minute.
I seem to recall a goal Chelsea scored at Stamford Bridge - probably 1980s. The shot went just past the right hand post on the outside, hit the stanchion at the back and came straight back out. Ref gave the goal! I think that may have been one of the reasons stanchionless (is that a word even?) nets came in.0 -
bobmunro said:TellyTubby said:bobmunro said:TellyTubby said:bobmunro said:killerandflash said:RC_CAFC said:How many times did that Sky commentator say they had a goal disallowed 😂. It wasn’t allowed because it never went in!
I was very surprised that the ref didn't have the net checked - Sunday park game perhaps, but that should not happen in a professional game.
Neither went in the goal, both were outside. We had an excellent view from right behind that side of the goal.I KNOW THEY WERE NOT GIVEN!That's not my point - clearly the side netting was compromised. Why do you think linos check the nets before the game? The integrity of the netting should have been checked and repaired.
My mistake then. I didn't see their shot but Godden's looked like it settled inside the net. I must have been seeing things.
Their shot appeared to nestle at the back of the net but said to my son it looked like it could be on the outside of the net.
In any case I've not seen it happen TWICE in a match before....and so much so the commentator thinks it was in.1 -
golfaddick said:Bailey said:ButtleJR said:Superb result. Great atmosphere. Out of interest do readings results get removed if they don't find a buyer? I don't wish that on any club but could it benefit us?
West Ham cheated be playing Tevez & Mascereno and got a slap on the wrist instead of a points deduction.
Rules are rules. I think the deadline is the end of this week. If Reading are not sold by the weekend then they should be kicked out.
But sadly the EFL are pussies & wont do anything until the end of the regular season.8 -
bobmunro said:swords_alive said:golfaddick said:RC_CAFC said:How many times did that Sky commentator say they had a goal disallowed 😂. It wasn’t allowed because it never went in!
Otherwise next time could have serious consequences.Freddie Sears v Bristol City, 15th August 2009
When Freddie Sears found the back of the net past Bristol City ‘keeper Dean Gerken, he naturally wheeled away to join his teammates celebrating Palace’s opening goal of a controversial summer afternoon, oblivious to the ball which sailed back over his head towards the penalty spot.
It wasn’t until he’d turned around to see referee Rob Shoebridge deliberating with his linesman that Sears realised something wasn’t quite right.
His goal, which followed a considerable punt upfield from Julian Speroni, cannoned in and out of the net in the flash of an eye and seemed to evade Shoebridge, who awarded a goal kick instead.
Despite enjoying the better of the two teams' performance, Palace would go on to lose the clash 1-0 as Nicky Maynard stole a point from the Eagles in the 90th minute.
I seem to recall a goal Chelsea scored at Stamford Bridge - probably 1980s. The shot went just past the right hand post on the outside, hit the stanchion at the back and came straight back out. Ref gave the goal! I think that may have been one of the reasons stanchionless (is that a word even?) nets came in.0 -
Ooh the forum has just lost some colour. It’s all washed out. Has one of the mods got over excited after that win?5
-
Excellent battling away victory. Mansfield pressed with energy. They worked hard on stopping Tyreece Campbell on the left and Small on the right. They used momentum and pressed forward to get an equaliser.Lloyd Jones is a great player and when not playing is a miss. Macintyre did well especially since limited game time but defence was not so strong without Lloyd Jones.Good times find a way to win. Perfect timed subs and excellently time switch. Really enjoyed that brilliant Tyreece Campbell goal. Pleased for the away support to be able to enjoy that moment. Keep on working on hard as a team, taking each game at a time and winning and we have a great shot at going up.1
-
bobmunro said:TellyTubby said:bobmunro said:TellyTubby said:bobmunro said:killerandflash said:RC_CAFC said:How many times did that Sky commentator say they had a goal disallowed 😂. It wasn’t allowed because it never went in!
I was very surprised that the ref didn't have the net checked - Sunday park game perhaps, but that should not happen in a professional game.
Neither went in the goal, both were outside. We had an excellent view from right behind that side of the goal.I KNOW THEY WERE NOT GIVEN!That's not my point - clearly the side netting was compromised. Why do you think linos check the nets before the game? The integrity of the netting should have been checked and repaired.
My mistake then. I didn't see their shot but Godden's looked like it settled inside the net. I must have been seeing things.0 - Sponsored links:
-
killerandflash said:bobmunro said:swords_alive said:golfaddick said:RC_CAFC said:How many times did that Sky commentator say they had a goal disallowed 😂. It wasn’t allowed because it never went in!
Otherwise next time could have serious consequences.Freddie Sears v Bristol City, 15th August 2009
When Freddie Sears found the back of the net past Bristol City ‘keeper Dean Gerken, he naturally wheeled away to join his teammates celebrating Palace’s opening goal of a controversial summer afternoon, oblivious to the ball which sailed back over his head towards the penalty spot.
It wasn’t until he’d turned around to see referee Rob Shoebridge deliberating with his linesman that Sears realised something wasn’t quite right.
His goal, which followed a considerable punt upfield from Julian Speroni, cannoned in and out of the net in the flash of an eye and seemed to evade Shoebridge, who awarded a goal kick instead.
Despite enjoying the better of the two teams' performance, Palace would go on to lose the clash 1-0 as Nicky Maynard stole a point from the Eagles in the 90th minute.
I seem to recall a goal Chelsea scored at Stamford Bridge - probably 1980s. The shot went just past the right hand post on the outside, hit the stanchion at the back and came straight back out. Ref gave the goal! I think that may have been one of the reasons stanchionless (is that a word even?) nets came in.Just checked and I got the post wrong - it was the left hand post. Alan Hudson for Chelsea - in the 70s!
3 -
killerandflash said:bobmunro said:swords_alive said:golfaddick said:RC_CAFC said:How many times did that Sky commentator say they had a goal disallowed 😂. It wasn’t allowed because it never went in!
Otherwise next time could have serious consequences.Freddie Sears v Bristol City, 15th August 2009
When Freddie Sears found the back of the net past Bristol City ‘keeper Dean Gerken, he naturally wheeled away to join his teammates celebrating Palace’s opening goal of a controversial summer afternoon, oblivious to the ball which sailed back over his head towards the penalty spot.
It wasn’t until he’d turned around to see referee Rob Shoebridge deliberating with his linesman that Sears realised something wasn’t quite right.
His goal, which followed a considerable punt upfield from Julian Speroni, cannoned in and out of the net in the flash of an eye and seemed to evade Shoebridge, who awarded a goal kick instead.
Despite enjoying the better of the two teams' performance, Palace would go on to lose the clash 1-0 as Nicky Maynard stole a point from the Eagles in the 90th minute.
I seem to recall a goal Chelsea scored at Stamford Bridge - probably 1980s. The shot went just past the right hand post on the outside, hit the stanchion at the back and came straight back out. Ref gave the goal! I think that may have been one of the reasons stanchionless (is that a word even?) nets came in.
Coventry played on and the ref then consulted with his linesman and ruled it out. VAR would stop this type of thing now of course in the prem at least...Clive Allen v Coventry City, 6th September 1980
Clive Allen’s ‘goal’ against Coventry City was even more dramatic than Sears’ and, in the context of the season, even more damaging too.
Playing in a run of poor form, Palace had lost three out of their four opening matches when they travelled to Coventry for a clash with the Sky Blues in 1980.
When Jerry Murphy was felled on the edge of Coventry’s box, eventual top scorer Allen stepped up to rifle the effort at goal, an effort which would find the back of the net in fine fashion.
Ricocheting off the stanchion, Allen’s attempt sent the Palace players into that trademark of vintage celebrations - thrusting arms into the air and pausing on tip-toes.
But even that wasn’t enough to convince the referee and his linesman who both agreed the effort had struck the post and bounced back out.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4HCiBrKjNKE
“I feel disgusted about that decision today,” said manager Terry Venables, “because we went one-up and made a couple of individual mistakes and we’d been playing very well. We got the goal to get back into the game and he disallows it. There’s not even a doubt in my mind that that went in and hit the iron stanchion at the back.”
By the final whistle, Coventry had won the game 3-1 and Palace tumbled through a season that saw them relegated from the First Division into the second tier of English football, where they would languish for eight consecutive seasons.
It was a campaign that started with Vince Hilaire’s dismissal for pushing a referee and continued with loss after loss, making Allen’s misfortune another appropriate bump on a tough and damaging road.
3 -
Battled hard for that win in a game we probably would have lost over the last few years.
Thought McIntyre slotted in seamlessly and played really well.2 -
As I said during the 1st half......chalk & cheese compared to last Saturday. But a win is a win is a win to paraphrase Richard Burton.
The positives......
Great goal by TC. Really took it well & apart from our first goal about our only other shot on target.
No real negatives as such but just a game we had to grind out. Would definitely have lost it last season...and the season before that...and probably the one before that as well !
Godden's goal was the type of gift we used to give teams. Wasn't it against Burton a couple of years ago when we gave 2 like that ? What goes around comes around. Perhaps its finally our turn to get given gifts in front of goal.
On to Saturday & Lincoln at home. Nothing certain in football & we might have to grind out another win. Hopefully being at home might makes us better.
6 more games. Lets try for 2nd. If we fail at least we can secure 3rd. 4th at the very worst.
2 -
swords_alive said:killerandflash said:bobmunro said:swords_alive said:golfaddick said:RC_CAFC said:How many times did that Sky commentator say they had a goal disallowed 😂. It wasn’t allowed because it never went in!
Otherwise next time could have serious consequences.Freddie Sears v Bristol City, 15th August 2009
When Freddie Sears found the back of the net past Bristol City ‘keeper Dean Gerken, he naturally wheeled away to join his teammates celebrating Palace’s opening goal of a controversial summer afternoon, oblivious to the ball which sailed back over his head towards the penalty spot.
It wasn’t until he’d turned around to see referee Rob Shoebridge deliberating with his linesman that Sears realised something wasn’t quite right.
His goal, which followed a considerable punt upfield from Julian Speroni, cannoned in and out of the net in the flash of an eye and seemed to evade Shoebridge, who awarded a goal kick instead.
Despite enjoying the better of the two teams' performance, Palace would go on to lose the clash 1-0 as Nicky Maynard stole a point from the Eagles in the 90th minute.
I seem to recall a goal Chelsea scored at Stamford Bridge - probably 1980s. The shot went just past the right hand post on the outside, hit the stanchion at the back and came straight back out. Ref gave the goal! I think that may have been one of the reasons stanchionless (is that a word even?) nets came in.
Coventry played on and the ref then consulted with his linesman and ruled it out. VAR would stop this type of thing now of course in the prem at least...Clive Allen v Coventry City, 6th September 1980
Clive Allen’s ‘goal’ against Coventry City was even more dramatic than Sears’ and, in the context of the season, even more damaging too.
Playing in a run of poor form, Palace had lost three out of their four opening matches when they travelled to Coventry for a clash with the Sky Blues in 1980.
When Jerry Murphy was felled on the edge of Coventry’s box, eventual top scorer Allen stepped up to rifle the effort at goal, an effort which would find the back of the net in fine fashion.
Ricocheting off the stanchion, Allen’s attempt sent the Palace players into that trademark of vintage celebrations - thrusting arms into the air and pausing on tip-toes.
But even that wasn’t enough to convince the referee and his linesman who both agreed the effort had struck the post and bounced back out.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4HCiBrKjNKE
“I feel disgusted about that decision today,” said manager Terry Venables, “because we went one-up and made a couple of individual mistakes and we’d been playing very well. We got the goal to get back into the game and he disallows it. There’s not even a doubt in my mind that that went in and hit the iron stanchion at the back.”
By the final whistle, Coventry had won the game 3-1 and Palace tumbled through a season that saw them relegated from the First Division into the second tier of English football, where they would languish for eight consecutive seasons.
It was a campaign that started with Vince Hilaire’s dismissal for pushing a referee and continued with loss after loss, making Allen’s misfortune another appropriate bump on a tough and damaging road.
2 -
killerandflash said:swords_alive said:
By the final whistle, Coventry had won the game 3-1 and Palace tumbled through a season that saw them relegated from the First Division into the second tier of English football, where they would languish for eight consecutive seasons.
It was a campaign that started with Vince Hilaire’s dismissal for pushing a referee and continued with loss after loss, making Allen’s misfortune another appropriate bump on a tough and damaging road.
1 -
Addick Addict said:Those stats for the Wycombe v Shrewsbury game are somewhat amusing
Shots 32-2
Shots on target 8-0
Corners 13-0
Result 0-01 -
ValleyGary said:Too many minges.2
-
Fortune 82nd Minute said:I still think we are going to narrowly miss out on the top 2. If only we had started this run a few games earlier.5
-
@thickandthin63 said ‘A well dug out win,but wtf was Anderson thinking when he punted the ball straight to their keeper with about a minute left.’
Yep, no reason why it shouldn’t have sailed over the keepers head to seal a 3-1 win.1