Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Summer 2022 transfer rumours (Gilbey loan confirmed p513, a signing falls through last minute p541)
Comments
-
Definition of shifting goalposts. "I may be wrong, but I'm still right".IR94 said:
doesn't change the fact its a desperation signing, we are desperate for a CB, and have no other options lolRedrobo said:
He was with Wimbledon for three seasons. Hardly quick order.IR94 said:
definition of desperation signing, no other real viable cheap option, was basically him or nothing, still hope he does well mindCardinal Sin said:
Have to ask yourself why Wimbledon, Crewe and Reading have all let me go in fairly quick order. Hope he proves me wrong but looks like a desperation signing.cfgs said:
Terell Thomas has signed.0 -
.0
-
ok he was our prime targetWheresmeticket? said:
Definition of shifting goalposts. "I may be wrong, but I'm still right".IR94 said:
doesn't change the fact its a desperation signing, we are desperate for a CB, and have no other options lolRedrobo said:
He was with Wimbledon for three seasons. Hardly quick order.IR94 said:
definition of desperation signing, no other real viable cheap option, was basically him or nothing, still hope he does well mindCardinal Sin said:
Have to ask yourself why Wimbledon, Crewe and Reading have all let me go in fairly quick order. Hope he proves me wrong but looks like a desperation signing.cfgs said:Terell Thomas has signed.1 -
Are those the choices then? "Left Wimbledon Crewe and Reading in quick order" or "prime target "? Neither true.IR94 said:
ok he was our prime targetWheresmeticket? said:
Definition of shifting goalposts. "I may be wrong, but I'm still right".IR94 said:
doesn't change the fact its a desperation signing, we are desperate for a CB, and have no other options lolRedrobo said:
He was with Wimbledon for three seasons. Hardly quick order.IR94 said:
definition of desperation signing, no other real viable cheap option, was basically him or nothing, still hope he does well mindCardinal Sin said:
Have to ask yourself why Wimbledon, Crewe and Reading have all let me go in fairly quick order. Hope he proves me wrong but looks like a desperation signing.cfgs said:Terell Thomas has signed.1 -
I wasn't moaning earlier. I simply said I'd laugh if Stockley was out injured. Another poster jumped on that comment & so I replied.Clem_Snide said:
So why is virtually everything you post moaning about the situation then? If there is no point moaning about it perhaps you could change the record?golfaddick said:
As I keep saying, I want us to do well, but its laughable that we go into a season with just 2 fit strikers & then can't even strengthen on deadline day. We had 4 months to add to the 3 strikers we have......but didnt. No point moaning about it now so I just laugh. The owner thinks this is the way to go so why doubt him.....BR7_addick said:
I won’t, I’ll be annoyed because I’m a charlton fan who wants us to do well.golfaddick said:
I will laugh my arse of if true.EugenesAxe said:
Rumours Stockley is injuredLargeAddick said:
??Dazzler21 said:
Don't be so sure!Oh Eddie Youds... said:Even if Stockley is shite in training he is still going to start. He’s the only fit senior striker at the club…..that’s a large part of the problem. He has no competition at all (bar Leaburn who is not ready to start many games).
We desperately need Chuks back to avoid this being another wasted season.
Each to their own n all that.
If you happen to read my comments when I post I don't usually moan. I simply point out some home truths that people don't like to hear.11 -
golfaddick said:
I wasn't moaning earlier. I simply said I'd laugh if Stockley was out injured. Another poster jumped on that comment & so I replied.Clem_Snide said:
So why is virtually everything you post moaning about the situation then? If there is no point moaning about it perhaps you could change the record?golfaddick said:
As I keep saying, I want us to do well, but its laughable that we go into a season with just 2 fit strikers & then can't even strengthen on deadline day. We had 4 months to add to the 3 strikers we have......but didnt. No point moaning about it now so I just laugh. The owner thinks this is the way to go so why doubt him.....BR7_addick said:
I won’t, I’ll be annoyed because I’m a charlton fan who wants us to do well.golfaddick said:
I will laugh my arse of if true.EugenesAxe said:
Rumours Stockley is injuredLargeAddick said:
??Dazzler21 said:
Don't be so sure!Oh Eddie Youds... said:Even if Stockley is shite in training he is still going to start. He’s the only fit senior striker at the club…..that’s a large part of the problem. He has no competition at all (bar Leaburn who is not ready to start many games).
We desperately need Chuks back to avoid this being another wasted season.
Each to their own n all that.
If you happen to read my comments when I post I usually moan. I incessantly point out some painstakingly obvious home truths that people have heard before and are bored of hearing.
19 -
in Previous seasons maybe top six, currently though, nowhere near a promotion squad given the quality of the teams in this league.cabbles said:So if/once we get the forward in on a free transfer, that will be the class of 22/23 confirmed.
Mac
Wollacott
Clare
O’Connell
Thomas
Lavelle
Inniss
Egbo
Sessegnon
Dobson
McGrandles
JFC
Payne
Morgan
Fraser
CBT
Kirk
DJ
JRS
Aneke
Leaburn
Stockley
???
I know there’s a couple of youngsters like Henry, Clayden and Ness on the fringes, but what do we think? Is that a squad capable of promotion?6 -
The thing is, more people have come over to your way of thinking so less people attack you for it. Some people will always shoot the messenger sadly.golfaddick said:
I wasn't moaning earlier. I simply said I'd laugh if Stockley was out injured. Another poster jumped on that comment & so I replied.Clem_Snide said:
So why is virtually everything you post moaning about the situation then? If there is no point moaning about it perhaps you could change the record?golfaddick said:
As I keep saying, I want us to do well, but its laughable that we go into a season with just 2 fit strikers & then can't even strengthen on deadline day. We had 4 months to add to the 3 strikers we have......but didnt. No point moaning about it now so I just laugh. The owner thinks this is the way to go so why doubt him.....BR7_addick said:
I won’t, I’ll be annoyed because I’m a charlton fan who wants us to do well.golfaddick said:
I will laugh my arse of if true.EugenesAxe said:
Rumours Stockley is injuredLargeAddick said:
??Dazzler21 said:
Don't be so sure!Oh Eddie Youds... said:Even if Stockley is shite in training he is still going to start. He’s the only fit senior striker at the club…..that’s a large part of the problem. He has no competition at all (bar Leaburn who is not ready to start many games).
We desperately need Chuks back to avoid this being another wasted season.
Each to their own n all that.
If you happen to read my comments when I post I don't usually moan. I simply point out some home truths that people don't like to hear.3 -
golfaddick said:
I will laugh my arse of if true.EugenesAxe said:
Rumours Stockley is injuredLargeAddick said:
??Dazzler21 said:
Don't be so sure!Oh Eddie Youds... said:Even if Stockley is shite in training he is still going to start. He’s the only fit senior striker at the club…..that’s a large part of the problem. He has no competition at all (bar Leaburn who is not ready to start many games).
We desperately need Chuks back to avoid this being another wasted season.
You can say that againgolfaddick said:
I will laugh my arse of if true.EugenesAxe said:
Rumours Stockley is injuredLargeAddick said:
??Dazzler21 said:
Don't be so sure!Oh Eddie Youds... said:Even if Stockley is shite in training he is still going to start. He’s the only fit senior striker at the club…..that’s a large part of the problem. He has no competition at all (bar Leaburn who is not ready to start many games).
We desperately need Chuks back to avoid this being another wasted season.
Doh … Beaten to it by @EugenesAxe0 -
Are you serious? Do you really think true Charlton supporters would laugh when one of their own players get injured?MuttleyCAFC said:
The thing is, more people have come over to your way of thinking so less people attack you for it. Some people will always shoot the messenger sadly.golfaddick said:
I wasn't moaning earlier. I simply said I'd laugh if Stockley was out injured. Another poster jumped on that comment & so I replied.Clem_Snide said:
So why is virtually everything you post moaning about the situation then? If there is no point moaning about it perhaps you could change the record?golfaddick said:
As I keep saying, I want us to do well, but its laughable that we go into a season with just 2 fit strikers & then can't even strengthen on deadline day. We had 4 months to add to the 3 strikers we have......but didnt. No point moaning about it now so I just laugh. The owner thinks this is the way to go so why doubt him.....BR7_addick said:
I won’t, I’ll be annoyed because I’m a charlton fan who wants us to do well.golfaddick said:
I will laugh my arse of if true.EugenesAxe said:
Rumours Stockley is injuredLargeAddick said:
??Dazzler21 said:
Don't be so sure!Oh Eddie Youds... said:Even if Stockley is shite in training he is still going to start. He’s the only fit senior striker at the club…..that’s a large part of the problem. He has no competition at all (bar Leaburn who is not ready to start many games).
We desperately need Chuks back to avoid this being another wasted season.
Each to their own n all that.
If you happen to read my comments when I post I don't usually moan. I simply point out some home truths that people don't like to hear.13 - Sponsored links:
-
Hardly desperate signing when he been with us for nearly 4 weeks .. look at it the other he came in impressed everyone and we withdrew from the deal we had lined upIR94 said:
ok he was our prime targetWheresmeticket? said:
Definition of shifting goalposts. "I may be wrong, but I'm still right".IR94 said:
doesn't change the fact its a desperation signing, we are desperate for a CB, and have no other options lolRedrobo said:
He was with Wimbledon for three seasons. Hardly quick order.IR94 said:
definition of desperation signing, no other real viable cheap option, was basically him or nothing, still hope he does well mindCardinal Sin said:
Have to ask yourself why Wimbledon, Crewe and Reading have all let me go in fairly quick order. Hope he proves me wrong but looks like a desperation signing.cfgs said:Terell Thomas has signed.4 -
Or having been with us for THREE weeks why didn't we sign him earlier....unless we wanted somebody better, who turned us down or we couldn't afford!RonnieMoore said:
Hardly desperate signing when he been with us for nearly 4 weeks .. look at it the other he came in impressed everyone and we withdrew from the deal we had lined upIR94 said:
ok he was our prime targetWheresmeticket? said:
Definition of shifting goalposts. "I may be wrong, but I'm still right".IR94 said:
doesn't change the fact its a desperation signing, we are desperate for a CB, and have no other options lolRedrobo said:
He was with Wimbledon for three seasons. Hardly quick order.IR94 said:
definition of desperation signing, no other real viable cheap option, was basically him or nothing, still hope he does well mindCardinal Sin said:
Have to ask yourself why Wimbledon, Crewe and Reading have all let me go in fairly quick order. Hope he proves me wrong but looks like a desperation signing.cfgs said:Terell Thomas has signed.
Blind Faith on here at times.
2 -
This. I think last season this squad could make top 6 or be in for it at least last game of the season.TEL said:
in Previous seasons maybe top six, currently though, nowhere near a promotion squad given the quality of the teams in this league.cabbles said:So if/once we get the forward in on a free transfer, that will be the class of 22/23 confirmed.
Mac
Wollacott
Clare
O’Connell
Thomas
Lavelle
Inniss
Egbo
Sessegnon
Dobson
McGrandles
JFC
Payne
Morgan
Fraser
CBT
Kirk
DJ
JRS
Aneke
Leaburn
Stockley
???
I know there’s a couple of youngsters like Henry, Clayden and Ness on the fringes, but what do we think? Is that a squad capable of promotion?This year it’s too far off (depending if we do anything in Jan)
Problem is we can all see it, including Garner but the one who can’t see it is the one who writes the checks.0 -
Or we had him training with us and, having decided we want him we have been negotiating a contract. Agents aren’t dim. Much more likely to get a better deal when the window is shut.supaclive said:
Or having been with us for THREE weeks why didn't we sign him earlier....unless we wanted somebody better, who turned us down or we couldn't afford!RonnieMoore said:
Hardly desperate signing when he been with us for nearly 4 weeks .. look at it the other he came in impressed everyone and we withdrew from the deal we had lined upIR94 said:
ok he was our prime targetWheresmeticket? said:
Definition of shifting goalposts. "I may be wrong, but I'm still right".IR94 said:
doesn't change the fact its a desperation signing, we are desperate for a CB, and have no other options lolRedrobo said:
He was with Wimbledon for three seasons. Hardly quick order.IR94 said:
definition of desperation signing, no other real viable cheap option, was basically him or nothing, still hope he does well mindCardinal Sin said:
Have to ask yourself why Wimbledon, Crewe and Reading have all let me go in fairly quick order. Hope he proves me wrong but looks like a desperation signing.cfgs said:Terell Thomas has signed.
Blind Faith on here at times.
Always looking for the negative on here at times.1 -
And there is always a chance someone better becomes available at the end of the window.Redrobo said:
Or we had him training with us and, having decided we want him we have been negotiating a contract. Agents aren’t dim. Much more likely to get a better deal when the window is shut.supaclive said:
Or having been with us for THREE weeks why didn't we sign him earlier....unless we wanted somebody better, who turned us down or we couldn't afford!RonnieMoore said:
Hardly desperate signing when he been with us for nearly 4 weeks .. look at it the other he came in impressed everyone and we withdrew from the deal we had lined upIR94 said:
ok he was our prime targetWheresmeticket? said:
Definition of shifting goalposts. "I may be wrong, but I'm still right".IR94 said:
doesn't change the fact its a desperation signing, we are desperate for a CB, and have no other options lolRedrobo said:
He was with Wimbledon for three seasons. Hardly quick order.IR94 said:
definition of desperation signing, no other real viable cheap option, was basically him or nothing, still hope he does well mindCardinal Sin said:
Have to ask yourself why Wimbledon, Crewe and Reading have all let me go in fairly quick order. Hope he proves me wrong but looks like a desperation signing.cfgs said:Terell Thomas has signed.
Blind Faith on here at times.
Always looking for the negative on here at times.3 -
I am sure @golfaddick did not mean it literally, as I suspect you well know. Maybe a better way of putting it is that it would be laughable were Stockley to be injured, leaving us with only one fit inexperienced young striker, given the club had 4 months to add to the strikers we had and such a situation might have been avoided. Is that slightly more palatable for you?Clarky said:
Are you serious? Do you really think true Charlton supporters would laugh when one of their own players get injured?MuttleyCAFC said:
The thing is, more people have come over to your way of thinking so less people attack you for it. Some people will always shoot the messenger sadly.golfaddick said:
I wasn't moaning earlier. I simply said I'd laugh if Stockley was out injured. Another poster jumped on that comment & so I replied.Clem_Snide said:
So why is virtually everything you post moaning about the situation then? If there is no point moaning about it perhaps you could change the record?golfaddick said:
As I keep saying, I want us to do well, but its laughable that we go into a season with just 2 fit strikers & then can't even strengthen on deadline day. We had 4 months to add to the 3 strikers we have......but didnt. No point moaning about it now so I just laugh. The owner thinks this is the way to go so why doubt him.....BR7_addick said:
I won’t, I’ll be annoyed because I’m a charlton fan who wants us to do well.golfaddick said:
I will laugh my arse of if true.EugenesAxe said:
Rumours Stockley is injuredLargeAddick said:
??Dazzler21 said:
Don't be so sure!Oh Eddie Youds... said:Even if Stockley is shite in training he is still going to start. He’s the only fit senior striker at the club…..that’s a large part of the problem. He has no competition at all (bar Leaburn who is not ready to start many games).
We desperately need Chuks back to avoid this being another wasted season.
Each to their own n all that.
If you happen to read my comments when I post I don't usually moan. I simply point out some home truths that people don't like to hear.
By the way, is Stockley injured?8 -
Exactly! There are some people who hate being proven wrong.robinofottershaw said:
I am sure @golfaddick did not mean it literally, as I suspect you well know. Maybe a better way of putting it is that it would be laughable were Stockley to be injured, leaving us with only one fit inexperienced young striker, given the club had 4 months to add to the strikers we had and such a situation might have been avoided. Is that slightly more palatable for you?Clarky said:
Are you serious? Do you really think true Charlton supporters would laugh when one of their own players get injured?MuttleyCAFC said:
The thing is, more people have come over to your way of thinking so less people attack you for it. Some people will always shoot the messenger sadly.golfaddick said:
I wasn't moaning earlier. I simply said I'd laugh if Stockley was out injured. Another poster jumped on that comment & so I replied.Clem_Snide said:
So why is virtually everything you post moaning about the situation then? If there is no point moaning about it perhaps you could change the record?golfaddick said:
As I keep saying, I want us to do well, but its laughable that we go into a season with just 2 fit strikers & then can't even strengthen on deadline day. We had 4 months to add to the 3 strikers we have......but didnt. No point moaning about it now so I just laugh. The owner thinks this is the way to go so why doubt him.....BR7_addick said:
I won’t, I’ll be annoyed because I’m a charlton fan who wants us to do well.golfaddick said:
I will laugh my arse of if true.EugenesAxe said:
Rumours Stockley is injuredLargeAddick said:
??Dazzler21 said:
Don't be so sure!Oh Eddie Youds... said:Even if Stockley is shite in training he is still going to start. He’s the only fit senior striker at the club…..that’s a large part of the problem. He has no competition at all (bar Leaburn who is not ready to start many games).
We desperately need Chuks back to avoid this being another wasted season.
Each to their own n all that.
If you happen to read my comments when I post I don't usually moan. I simply point out some home truths that people don't like to hear.
By the way, is Stockley injured?
I still remain unconvinced and blimey, didn't that get me pelters!
I don't want to be proven right and neither does golfie!7 -
Must be somebody else using your account thengolfaddick said:
I wasn't moaning earlier. I simply said I'd laugh if Stockley was out injured. Another poster jumped on that comment & so I replied.Clem_Snide said:
So why is virtually everything you post moaning about the situation then? If there is no point moaning about it perhaps you could change the record?golfaddick said:
As I keep saying, I want us to do well, but its laughable that we go into a season with just 2 fit strikers & then can't even strengthen on deadline day. We had 4 months to add to the 3 strikers we have......but didnt. No point moaning about it now so I just laugh. The owner thinks this is the way to go so why doubt him.....BR7_addick said:
I won’t, I’ll be annoyed because I’m a charlton fan who wants us to do well.golfaddick said:
I will laugh my arse of if true.EugenesAxe said:
Rumours Stockley is injuredLargeAddick said:
??Dazzler21 said:
Don't be so sure!Oh Eddie Youds... said:Even if Stockley is shite in training he is still going to start. He’s the only fit senior striker at the club…..that’s a large part of the problem. He has no competition at all (bar Leaburn who is not ready to start many games).
We desperately need Chuks back to avoid this being another wasted season.
Each to their own n all that.
If you happen to read my comments when I post I don't usually moan. I simply point out some home truths that people don't like to hear.
3 -
cabbles said:So if/once we get the forward in on a free transfer, that will be the class of 22/23 confirmed.
Mac
Wollacott - These are both fine at this level, Woll before Mac obvs
Clare - acquitting himself well enough in his new role
O’Connell - donkey
Thomas - unproven
Lavelle - a slow lightweight Pearce
Inniss - made of glass unlikely to start more than 15 games and always has potential for calamity, like a fragile overweight Naby Sarr without the personality
Egbo - apparently another right back - not yet seen in action and no word on when that's even likely
Sessegnon - an able right back lumbered on the left because the squad is so thin
Dobson - our best player, hitherto overworked in Garner's one shape/tactic fits all
McGrandles - lightweight whose cameo in the first game was mercifully brief before Garner had sense forced on him
JFC - his best in CMF is better than anybody else we have but his best may be some years ago - an able left back when required in the past
Payne - thus far only seen charging about to no useful outcome
Morgan - had his best spell with us so far over the first few games but that bar is quite low
Fraser - sees and can make a nice pass or two but he's terribly lightweight and never lasts more than 60 minutes before he's shagged out
CBT - probably our best attacker, best combination of pace and guile, has been a bit injury prone
Kirk - a shameful pisstaker with some ability - if he never appeared in Charlton red again it would be too soon for me, he's blatantly robbing his living
DJ - underwhelming and now fatally undermined since we know he was on his way out until TS pulled the rug on deadline day
JRS - an exciting addition so far
Aneke - total waste of bundles of cash, he'll barely make another half dozen appearances TS's 2nd greatest folly so far
Leaburn - an exciting talent on whom far too much expectation is placed by Addicks and for too much reliance will be put because this squad has nobody else up front
Stockley - decent enough at this level, Garner's single system provides him with no service, poor sod is on a hiding to nothing unless and until Garner wakes the fuck up and applies any imagination or managerial skill to our predicament
??? - there will be no striking additions before January and no guarantees even then
I know there’s a couple of youngsters like Henry, Clayden (looks like a credible left(wing)back in the making) and Ness on the fringes, but what do we think? Is that a squad capable of promotion? Answer NO
6 -
It’s a miracle! Stockley’s six week injury healed in two days!
18 - Sponsored links:
-
Who’s that behind Payne in the pic?0
-
Marshall, assistant gaffer and that De Souza coach fella4
-
0 -
3 weeks for Garner to assess him and see if he was fit enough to warrant a one year contract.supaclive said:
Or having been with us for THREE weeks why didn't we sign him earlier....unless we wanted somebody better, who turned us down or we couldn't afford!RonnieMoore said:
Hardly desperate signing when he been with us for nearly 4 weeks .. look at it the other he came in impressed everyone and we withdrew from the deal we had lined upIR94 said:
ok he was our prime targetWheresmeticket? said:
Definition of shifting goalposts. "I may be wrong, but I'm still right".IR94 said:
doesn't change the fact its a desperation signing, we are desperate for a CB, and have no other options lolRedrobo said:
He was with Wimbledon for three seasons. Hardly quick order.IR94 said:
definition of desperation signing, no other real viable cheap option, was basically him or nothing, still hope he does well mindCardinal Sin said:
Have to ask yourself why Wimbledon, Crewe and Reading have all let me go in fairly quick order. Hope he proves me wrong but looks like a desperation signing.cfgs said:Terell Thomas has signed.
Blind Faith on here at times.
Seems reasonable.4 -
Might be an idea to run a 'Is Stockley injured? thread right through the season then Golfie can laugh his arse off every week.15
-
It's not about being proved right or wrong it is more about only seeing the negatives and labouring the same 'we need a striker ' point in just about every comment and every thread.It is unnecessary and damn right tedious, particularly when just about every poster agrees that we needed a striker and have being saying so since Washington left. The only real debate on this was when Garner said the priority was a CB to which many agreed but others thought a striker was more important. Of course you can't forget the outcry when an incoming striker looked to be Bonne and a few said 'I'd rather go without', well the minority got their wish with that one.supaclive said:
Exactly! There are some people who hate being proven wrong.robinofottershaw said:
I am sure @golfaddick did not mean it literally, as I suspect you well know. Maybe a better way of putting it is that it would be laughable were Stockley to be injured, leaving us with only one fit inexperienced young striker, given the club had 4 months to add to the strikers we had and such a situation might have been avoided. Is that slightly more palatable for you?Clarky said:
Are you serious? Do you really think true Charlton supporters would laugh when one of their own players get injured?MuttleyCAFC said:
The thing is, more people have come over to your way of thinking so less people attack you for it. Some people will always shoot the messenger sadly.golfaddick said:
I wasn't moaning earlier. I simply said I'd laugh if Stockley was out injured. Another poster jumped on that comment & so I replied.Clem_Snide said:
So why is virtually everything you post moaning about the situation then? If there is no point moaning about it perhaps you could change the record?golfaddick said:
As I keep saying, I want us to do well, but its laughable that we go into a season with just 2 fit strikers & then can't even strengthen on deadline day. We had 4 months to add to the 3 strikers we have......but didnt. No point moaning about it now so I just laugh. The owner thinks this is the way to go so why doubt him.....BR7_addick said:
I won’t, I’ll be annoyed because I’m a charlton fan who wants us to do well.golfaddick said:
I will laugh my arse of if true.EugenesAxe said:
Rumours Stockley is injuredLargeAddick said:
??Dazzler21 said:
Don't be so sure!Oh Eddie Youds... said:Even if Stockley is shite in training he is still going to start. He’s the only fit senior striker at the club…..that’s a large part of the problem. He has no competition at all (bar Leaburn who is not ready to start many games).
We desperately need Chuks back to avoid this being another wasted season.
Each to their own n all that.
If you happen to read my comments when I post I don't usually moan. I simply point out some home truths that people don't like to hear.
By the way, is Stockley injured?
I still remain unconvinced and blimey, didn't that get me pelters!
I don't want to be proven right and neither does golfie!
For the record I think, and as I have said previously, Sandgaard is out his depth and of course if he were to sell to a credible suitor(s) with enough money to fulfil our dreams then just about all of us would take that in a heartbeat. In the meantime, we are where we are and I for one willingly accept that there are positives as well as albeit too many negatives.
1 -
Is your penalty still in orbit?Bailey said:Might be an idea to run a 'Is Stockley injured? thread right through the season then Golfie can laugh his arse off every week.3 -
Billy_Mix said:cabbles said:So if/once we get the forward in on a free transfer, that will be the class of 22/23 confirmed.
Mac
Wollacott - These are both fine at this level, Woll before Mac obvs
Clare - acquitting himself well enough in his new role
O’Connell - donkey
Thomas - unproven
Lavelle - a slow lightweight Pearce
Inniss - made of glass unlikely to start more than 15 games and always has potential for calamity, like a fragile overweight Naby Sarr without the personality
Egbo - apparently another right back - not yet seen in action and no word on when that's even likely
Sessegnon - an able right back lumbered on the left because the squad is so thin
Dobson - our best player, hitherto overworked in Garner's one shape/tactic fits all
McGrandles - lightweight whose cameo in the first game was mercifully brief before Garner had sense forced on him
JFC - his best in CMF is better than anybody else we have but his best may be some years ago - an able left back when required in the past
Payne - thus far only seen charging about to no useful outcome
Morgan - had his best spell with us so far over the first few games but that bar is quite low
Fraser - sees and can make a nice pass or two but he's terribly lightweight and never lasts more than 60 minutes before he's shagged out
CBT - probably our best attacker, best combination of pace and guile, has been a bit injury prone
Kirk - a shameful pisstaker with some ability - if he never appeared in Charlton red again it would be too soon for me, he's blatantly robbing his living
DJ - underwhelming and now fatally undermined since we know he was on his way out until TS pulled the rug on deadline day
JRS - an exciting addition so far
Aneke - total waste of bundles of cash, he'll barely make another half dozen appearances TS's 2nd greatest folly so far
Leaburn - an exciting talent on whom far too much expectation is placed by Addicks and for too much reliance will be put because this squad has nobody else up front
Stockley - decent enough at this level, Garner's single system provides him with no service, poor sod is on a hiding to nothing unless and until Garner wakes the fuck up and applies any imagination or managerial skill to our predicament
??? - there will be no striking additions before January and no guarantees even then
I know there’s a couple of youngsters like Henry, Clayden (looks like a credible left(wing)back in the making) and Ness on the fringes, but what do we think? Is that a squad capable of promotion? Answer NO
0 -
Saw Scott Minto in Hays Galleria who very kindly stopped for a longer chat than he would have cared for. What an absolute top bloke. A reminiscing chat tbf and not sure why I am putting it on this thread 🤣 but just chuffed that he was willing to give as much time as he did to little old me. Thought I would share with my Charltonlife family.51
-
This is the transfer rumours thread 😉Pavoren007 said:Saw Scott Minto in Hays Galleria who very kindly stopped for a longer chat than he would have cared for. What an absolute top bloke. A reminiscing chat tbf and not sure why I am putting it on this thread 🤣 but just chuffed that he was willing to give as much time as he did to little old me. Thought I would share with my Charltonlife family.
or is he our new left back?5
