Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Rumours Rumours - Summer 2021 edition (Deadline Day from p814)
Comments
-
Yes but if the player rumoured does sign.thenewbie said:
You are aware we haven't actually signed a right back aren't you? Because otherwise that "mindless" comment looks ever so slightly ironic...SELR_addicks said:We need players in about 7 different positons.
We instead sign a RB which is the only position we actually have players for.
Mindless.0 -
Do you have a link to the signing please?SELR_addicks said:We need players in about 7 different positons.
We instead sign a RB which is the only position we actually have players for.
Mindless.7 -
He sure did.Cafc43v3r said:Didn't Adkins sign Kane for Hull?1 -
IF the rumoured player does sign.Covered End said:
Do you have a link to the signing please?SELR_addicks said:We need players in about 7 different positons.
We instead sign a RB which is the only position we actually have players for.
Mindless.
Championship loan incoming and I don't see any other names rumoured.0 -
Apart from Lowery & Dempsey.SELR_addicks said:
IF the rumoured player does sign.Covered End said:
Do you have a link to the signing please?SELR_addicks said:We need players in about 7 different positons.
We instead sign a RB which is the only position we actually have players for.
Mindless.
Championship loan incoming and I don't see any other names rumoured.6 -
Getting them on loan are we?Covered End said:
Apart from Lowery & Dempsey.SELR_addicks said:
IF the rumoured player does sign.Covered End said:
Do you have a link to the signing please?SELR_addicks said:We need players in about 7 different positons.
We instead sign a RB which is the only position we actually have players for.
Mindless.
Championship loan incoming and I don't see any other names rumoured.1 -
I'm hoping we will sign one of the two on a permanent.SELR_addicks said:
Getting them on loan are we?Covered End said:
Apart from Lowery & Dempsey.SELR_addicks said:
IF the rumoured player does sign.Covered End said:
Do you have a link to the signing please?SELR_addicks said:We need players in about 7 different positons.
We instead sign a RB which is the only position we actually have players for.
Mindless.
Championship loan incoming and I don't see any other names rumoured.0 -
Todd Kane plays left back and right back happy in both rolesMickeyBennett said:Todd Kane is a right back - the last position we need - and a quick Twitter search shows he is widely regarded as a hapless punchline by QPR fans.
If we sign this guy it will confirm my suspicions that Ged Roddy is engaged in some kind of elaborate trolling campaign at Charlton Athletic's expense.0 -
I really hope not & If it is it screams desperation to sign just anybody.RedJohn said:
Todd Kane is most likely after checking various social media gossip.sammy391 said:Someone who had been on a stadium tour today had put on the Facebook group that there was a player being photographed in the stands today- and was kept out of the way of the tour
As been said earlier - he is a right back, a position that we have adequately covered. Yes, he may be able to play in other positions but you dont sign a rb to play lb. Lots of players can play in different positions - we had a few last season with Prately & Gunter playing as centre halves. But we already had them on the staff. You dont bring on a player to play them out of position.5 -
I'm sure Gunter would say the same.RonnieMoore said:
Todd Kane plays left back and right back happy in both rolesMickeyBennett said:Todd Kane is a right back - the last position we need - and a quick Twitter search shows he is widely regarded as a hapless punchline by QPR fans.
If we sign this guy it will confirm my suspicions that Ged Roddy is engaged in some kind of elaborate trolling campaign at Charlton Athletic's expense.
If you're a natural right-back you aren't as comfortable on the left, and definitely not comfortable to make attacking runs forward.0 -
Sponsored links:
-
Then that's a completely different thing. You specifically said "We instead sign a right back"... Which we haven't.SELR_addicks said:
Yes but if the player rumoured does sign.thenewbie said:
You are aware we haven't actually signed a right back aren't you? Because otherwise that "mindless" comment looks ever so slightly ironic...SELR_addicks said:We need players in about 7 different positons.
We instead sign a RB which is the only position we actually have players for.
Mindless.
Mindless.5 -
Ever heard of Dennis Irwin.......SELR_addicks said:
I'm sure Gunter would say the same.RonnieMoore said:
Todd Kane plays left back and right back happy in both rolesMickeyBennett said:Todd Kane is a right back - the last position we need - and a quick Twitter search shows he is widely regarded as a hapless punchline by QPR fans.
If we sign this guy it will confirm my suspicions that Ged Roddy is engaged in some kind of elaborate trolling campaign at Charlton Athletic's expense.
If you're a natural right-back you aren't as comfortable on the left, and definitely not comfortable to make attacking runs forward.2 -
ForeverAddickted said:
Adam Matthews can be backup RB to Todd Kane;ElliotCAFC said:
We won’t sign another RBRedJohn said:
Todd Kane is most likely after checking various social media gossip.sammy391 said:Someone who had been on a stadium tour today had put on the Facebook group that there was a player being photographed in the stands today- and was kept out of the way of the tour
Chris Gunter can be backup LB to Ben Purrington...
1 -
Naturally a right back though, isn’t he? Given that we only have naturally right footed wingers (Kirk & DJ) I really think we need an actual, natural, left footed left back. Not someone that’s a right back but reckons they can play left back, had enough of that with Gunter.RonnieMoore said:
Todd Kane plays left back and right back happy in both rolesMickeyBennett said:Todd Kane is a right back - the last position we need - and a quick Twitter search shows he is widely regarded as a hapless punchline by QPR fans.
If we sign this guy it will confirm my suspicions that Ged Roddy is engaged in some kind of elaborate trolling campaign at Charlton Athletic's expense.0 -
IF it was Kane, that would be madness really as he's played at LB a grand total of twice according to Transfermarket.
That said let's not all start having chickens yet. WIOTOS.
8 -
According to wiki he plays PREDOMINANTLY as a'right back l, bit can play right midfield or left back.RonnieMoore said:
Todd Kane plays left back and right back happy in both rolesMickeyBennett said:Todd Kane is a right back - the last position we need - and a quick Twitter search shows he is widely regarded as a hapless punchline by QPR fans.
If we sign this guy it will confirm my suspicions that Ged Roddy is engaged in some kind of elaborate trolling campaign at Charlton Athletic's expense.
If he is right footed I do not want him playing as a left back. We already have Gunter doing that role.....and not very well either.2 -
Crewe manager Artell said in an interview today he doesn’t expect any outgoings, hope you’re right thoughCovered_End_Lad said:I think Lowery will happen, likely to be close to if not on deadline day.3 -
Interesting that at Hull Adkins played mainly 4231 and Kane played on the left of the 3 more than once. I know ideally you want that player to be able to go both inside and outside and the full back more often outside.
Maybe we are going to off load Gunter, I think Adkins has only ever picked him at right back once?
Maybe it's all bollocks and we aren't signing Kane anyway.0 -
It's no different from the real world is it?Hal1x said:It shows how much football is now working in two different worlds now, when we are arguing over £300k and the "Big Boys" are splashing out £100 million on Grealish and his like. Can one player really be 300 times better than another? I cant see how such a wide gulf in values is sustainable.
A Maserati MC20 will cost you a minimum of £187k; a Dacia will not.
A work by David Hockney could set you back £80 million; a sketch by some local artist will not.
Dinner, B & B at the Michelin-starred Ynyshir will cost you £1,000 plus drinks....well, you get the idea.0 -
I don’t know much about Kane, but I’d do believe our full backs on both sides are currently one of the reasons we’re look so stodgy in attack. We need them to provide width and crosses and they’ve been doing neither. Gunter has more of an excuse (not that we we saw it from him at right back last season), but Matthew’s is in his natural position and still not getting forward enough.If Kane is that type of player, I think there definitely is room for another right back. Get a left back on loan as well and Gunter will be a utility player and possibly the player who provides more experienced backup as an option for cover Innis at RCB and an alternative to Deji.1
-
Sponsored links:
-
How and to who?! I can't see many clubs lining up to sign him at his current age/wage.Cafc43v3r said:Interesting that at Hull Adkins played mainly 4231 and Kane played on the left of the 3 more than once. I know ideally you want that player to be able to go both inside and outside and the full back more often outside.
Maybe we are going to off load Gunter, I think Adkins has only ever picked him at right back once?
Maybe it's all bollocks and we aren't signing Kane anyway.0 -
Be shocked if Lowery is still there come the end of the Transfer Window - I imagine the last paragraph talking about a player is with regards to him - After all they're in the exact same boat with him as we were with Phillips last year.PWADDICK said:
Crewe manager Artell said in an interview today he doesn’t expect any outgoings, hope you’re right thoughCovered_End_Lad said:I think Lowery will happen, likely to be close to if not on deadline day.
Either they take something now, or lose him for nothing next year - Its not like they expect to be challenging for the Championship either so cant really hope that a promotion push will help persuade him to stay.0 -
Dozens of clubs would snap your hand off for him. As an example Gillingham would probably love him for the season on loan of we paid most of his wages.thenewbie said:
How and to who?! I can't see many clubs lining up to sign him at his current age/wage.Cafc43v3r said:Interesting that at Hull Adkins played mainly 4231 and Kane played on the left of the 3 more than once. I know ideally you want that player to be able to go both inside and outside and the full back more often outside.
Maybe we are going to off load Gunter, I think Adkins has only ever picked him at right back once?
Maybe it's all bollocks and we aren't signing Kane anyway.
It wouldn't be cheap but it would free up a place in the squad if that was an issue.
I am guessing as to why we would be in anyway intrested in Todd Kane.1 -
thenewbie said:
How and to who?! I can't see many clubs lining up to sign him at his current age/wage.Cafc43v3r said:Interesting that at Hull Adkins played mainly 4231 and Kane played on the left of the 3 more than once. I know ideally you want that player to be able to go both inside and outside and the full back more often outside.
Maybe we are going to off load Gunter, I think Adkins has only ever picked him at right back once?
Maybe it's all bollocks and we aren't signing Kane anyway.
I can't believe he still gets a gig. I have rarely seen him play well for us. We seem like a charity for shite over aged players like him and Watson.0 -
-
The actions of the last two transfer windows suggest otherwise.Redrobo said:
That assumes that we have not been in negotiations with anybody or made any offers that were initially turned down.The Red Robin said:Loans are realistically the only option with such little time left in the window now. Quicker to complete and less negotiation on transfer fees and wages. I just can’t see there being the quality of Cullen, Bielik and Gallagher though. Another summer of rebuilding next year beckons.
There are some fantastic young players out there. Some are very close to being included into 1st team squads.We are obviously playing a high risk strategy, but the gains could be considerable.0 -
Todd Kane is alright I think. Played and scored against us for Oxford a few years back and was also at Hull with Adkins. Wouldn’t say either of our full backs are good enough so not an unnecessary signing at all.0
-
It's completely unnecessary if you ask me. We need a proper left back.The Red Robin said:Todd Kane is alright I think. Played and scored against us for Oxford a few years back and was also at Hull with Adkins. Wouldn’t say either of our full backs are good enough so not an unnecessary signing at all.1 -
Elliot lee from Luton signed49
-
Agree on the left back. I also think we need a better right back.Jac_52 said:
It's completely unnecessary if you ask me. We need a proper left back.The Red Robin said:Todd Kane is alright I think. Played and scored against us for Oxford a few years back and was also at Hull with Adkins. Wouldn’t say either of our full backs are good enough so not an unnecessary signing at all.0
This discussion has been closed.
