Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Declan Rice chooses England

12357

Comments

  • Have the rules changed? I believe Mike Flanagan was approached by ROI but couldn’t as he had played 3 games for England B team.
  • DA9
    DA9 Posts: 11,091
    DA9 said:
    Born in England, to an English mother, Irish father, lived here all his life, has Irish heritage like a lot of us do, hardly a controversial choice IMO, far more ROI pllayers over the years have more tenuous rights to play for ROI in the past, Christ, under Jack Charlton you only had to drink a pint of the black stuff to qualify.
    Rice is not responsible for the rules, making choices like many did for ROI when Charlton was in charge as they knew they had no chance of an England call up, they wanted to play international football, some had never stepped foot in ROI before. 
    His father isn't Irish, it's his father's parents who were Irish. If they abolished the ridiculous grandparent rule, none of this argument would have happened
    Even less of a controversial choice then, English parents, born in London, lived in London all his life. 
  • Have the rules changed? I believe Mike Flanagan was approached by ROI but couldn’t as he had played 3 games for England B team.
    Yeah I think they changed a few years ago, you are only locked to a nation now if you play a competitve 1st team game, so friendlies do not count
  • cafcdave123
    cafcdave123 Posts: 11,491
    DA9 said:
    DA9 said:
    Born in England, to an English mother, Irish father, lived here all his life, has Irish heritage like a lot of us do, hardly a controversial choice IMO, far more ROI pllayers over the years have more tenuous rights to play for ROI in the past, Christ, under Jack Charlton you only had to drink a pint of the black stuff to qualify.
    Rice is not responsible for the rules, making choices like many did for ROI when Charlton was in charge as they knew they had no chance of an England call up, they wanted to play international football, some had never stepped foot in ROI before. 
    His father isn't Irish, it's his father's parents who were Irish. If they abolished the ridiculous grandparent rule, none of this argument would have happened
    Even less of a controversial choice then, English parents, born in London, lived in London all his life. 
    i dont think it controversial that he want to play for England, i think its shit form playing for Ireland then fucking them off as soon as England come along  
  • DA9
    DA9 Posts: 11,091
    DA9 said:
    DA9 said:
    Born in England, to an English mother, Irish father, lived here all his life, has Irish heritage like a lot of us do, hardly a controversial choice IMO, far more ROI pllayers over the years have more tenuous rights to play for ROI in the past, Christ, under Jack Charlton you only had to drink a pint of the black stuff to qualify.
    Rice is not responsible for the rules, making choices like many did for ROI when Charlton was in charge as they knew they had no chance of an England call up, they wanted to play international football, some had never stepped foot in ROI before. 
    His father isn't Irish, it's his father's parents who were Irish. If they abolished the ridiculous grandparent rule, none of this argument would have happened
    Even less of a controversial choice then, English parents, born in London, lived in London all his life. 
    i dont think it controversial that he want to play for England, i think its shit form playing for Ireland then fucking them off as soon as England come along  
    If you support the ROI , I get it, you may or may not, I doubt Irish fans were bemoaning the choices made by Mcclean, Duffy & Obafemi.
    it happens, it will happen again, McTominay chose Scotland over England last year, swings and roundabouts 


  • cafcdave123
    cafcdave123 Posts: 11,491
    DA9 said:
    DA9 said:
    DA9 said:
    Born in England, to an English mother, Irish father, lived here all his life, has Irish heritage like a lot of us do, hardly a controversial choice IMO, far more ROI pllayers over the years have more tenuous rights to play for ROI in the past, Christ, under Jack Charlton you only had to drink a pint of the black stuff to qualify.
    Rice is not responsible for the rules, making choices like many did for ROI when Charlton was in charge as they knew they had no chance of an England call up, they wanted to play international football, some had never stepped foot in ROI before. 
    His father isn't Irish, it's his father's parents who were Irish. If they abolished the ridiculous grandparent rule, none of this argument would have happened
    Even less of a controversial choice then, English parents, born in London, lived in London all his life. 
    i dont think it controversial that he want to play for England, i think its shit form playing for Ireland then fucking them off as soon as England come along  
    If you support the ROI , I get it, you may or may not, I doubt Irish fans were bemoaning the choices made by Mcclean, Duffy & Obafemi.
    it happens, it will happen again, McTominay chose Scotland over England last year, swings and roundabouts 


    Did McClean, Duffy and Obafemi have senior caps for other countries?

    McTominay didn't play for anyone at any level until he played for the Scotland senior side.


  • DA9
    DA9 Posts: 11,091
    DA9 said:
    DA9 said:
    DA9 said:
    Born in England, to an English mother, Irish father, lived here all his life, has Irish heritage like a lot of us do, hardly a controversial choice IMO, far more ROI pllayers over the years have more tenuous rights to play for ROI in the past, Christ, under Jack Charlton you only had to drink a pint of the black stuff to qualify.
    Rice is not responsible for the rules, making choices like many did for ROI when Charlton was in charge as they knew they had no chance of an England call up, they wanted to play international football, some had never stepped foot in ROI before. 
    His father isn't Irish, it's his father's parents who were Irish. If they abolished the ridiculous grandparent rule, none of this argument would have happened
    Even less of a controversial choice then, English parents, born in London, lived in London all his life. 
    i dont think it controversial that he want to play for England, i think its shit form playing for Ireland then fucking them off as soon as England come along  
    If you support the ROI , I get it, you may or may not, I doubt Irish fans were bemoaning the choices made by Mcclean, Duffy & Obafemi.
    it happens, it will happen again, McTominay chose Scotland over England last year, swings and roundabouts 


    Did McClean, Duffy and Obafemi have senior caps for other countries?

    McTominay didn't play for anyone at any level until he played for the Scotland senior side.


    Rice did not play a competitive game for ROI, same as Duffy and McClean for NI, but they did play at youth level before switching, as did Giggs as did Zaha 
  • DA9 said:
    DA9 said:
    DA9 said:
    DA9 said:
    Born in England, to an English mother, Irish father, lived here all his life, has Irish heritage like a lot of us do, hardly a controversial choice IMO, far more ROI pllayers over the years have more tenuous rights to play for ROI in the past, Christ, under Jack Charlton you only had to drink a pint of the black stuff to qualify.
    Rice is not responsible for the rules, making choices like many did for ROI when Charlton was in charge as they knew they had no chance of an England call up, they wanted to play international football, some had never stepped foot in ROI before. 
    His father isn't Irish, it's his father's parents who were Irish. If they abolished the ridiculous grandparent rule, none of this argument would have happened
    Even less of a controversial choice then, English parents, born in London, lived in London all his life. 
    i dont think it controversial that he want to play for England, i think its shit form playing for Ireland then fucking them off as soon as England come along  
    If you support the ROI , I get it, you may or may not, I doubt Irish fans were bemoaning the choices made by Mcclean, Duffy & Obafemi.
    it happens, it will happen again, McTominay chose Scotland over England last year, swings and roundabouts 


    Did McClean, Duffy and Obafemi have senior caps for other countries?

    McTominay didn't play for anyone at any level until he played for the Scotland senior side.


    Rice did not play a competitive game for ROI, same as Duffy and McClean for NI, but they did play at youth level before switching, as did Giggs as did Zaha 
    Giggs?  He played for England schoolboys because of the school he went to.
  • TelMc32
    TelMc32 Posts: 9,046
    Never did that when he was Irish G!!!  😉
  • Sponsored links:



  • BR7_addick
    BR7_addick Posts: 10,210
    edited February 2019
    He didn’t know what he signed up for when he was under 17s Ireland, he was groomed, surely he can change his mind and have his own peoples vote..
  • paulie8290
    paulie8290 Posts: 23,344
    Approved by Fifa already meaning Gareth can call him up for the next games.


    https://www.lovesportradio.com/news/sport/declan-rices-switch-to-england-from-republic-of-ireland-approved-by-fifa/
  • Thats happened quicker than expected...
  • masicat
    masicat Posts: 5,008
    Be careful what you wish for. A couple of months ago I would have called him a traitor. Every Cheltenham festival I dress in green, cheer the Irish horses and raise a glass to my Irish roots. I love all Irish music and have told my wife whenever I hear proper Irish music it sends a shiver up my spine. I only have one picture of my grandad who came over from Ireland and worked at The Arsenal in Woolwich. However, you only have to look at his face to see he liked a Guinness 
    and had probably grown up wanting to dig holes and kiss the Blarney Stone.
    THEN, my son joined Ancestry.co.uk. Turns out my great grandad was stationed in Ireland in the army, my grandad was only born there. As soon as he could he came back and lived his life in Woolwich. My family roots are in Downe, a mile from where I live. Have ditched the Pogue records, taken down the picture of Sir Jack Charlton and moved my drink to lager. Be careful what you wish for Declan.
  • MrOneLung
    MrOneLung Posts: 26,845
    Congratulations Declan - Young Irish Player of the Year


    https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/47542669
  • cafcsinger
    cafcsinger Posts: 5,548
    MrOneLung said:
    Congratulations Declan - Young Irish Player of the Year


    https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/47542669
    Farcical but hilarious  
  • paulie8290
    paulie8290 Posts: 23,344
    The midfielder will not be in Dublin on Sunday to collect his award.


    Probably because he would get lynched haha
  • ValleyGary
    ValleyGary Posts: 37,975
    Haha taking the piss 
  • SuedeAdidas
    SuedeAdidas Posts: 7,737
    About to be called up for next 2 Euro qualifiers. 

    We we should put him in U21 squad instead - just to piss our Irish friends off a bit more. 
  • guinnessaddick
    guinnessaddick Posts: 28,609
    edited March 2019
    About to be called up for next 2 Euro qualifiers. 

    We we should put him in U21 squad instead - just to piss our Irish friends off a bit more. 
    If that did happen, what’s stopping switching back?
  • Sponsored links:



  • SuedeAdidas
    SuedeAdidas Posts: 7,737
    edited March 2019
    I've no idea mate - the whole thing is a joke as far as I'm concerned. There is no way that he should have been allowed to switch to England at this stage of his career in my view.
  • cafcdave123
    cafcdave123 Posts: 11,491
    Just talking about this and one one the guys reckon that for him to be in this squad the request to FIFA would have to have been made before he announced that he was switching? (Not that it changes anything, he could have made the request and said nothing )
  • ValleyGary
    ValleyGary Posts: 37,975
    Future Ballon d'Or winner. English and proud.
  • killerandflash
    killerandflash Posts: 69,842
    I've no idea mate - the whole thing is a joke as far as I'm concerned. There is no way that he should have been allowed to switch to England at this stage of his career in my view.
    To me he should never have been eligible for ROI in the first place, I'd abolish the grandparent rule
  • redsek
    redsek Posts: 656
    I've no idea mate - the whole thing is a joke as far as I'm concerned. There is no way that he should have been allowed to switch to England at this stage of his career in my view.
    To me he should never have been eligible for ROI in the first place, I'd abolish the grandparent rule

    Different sport but I'm pretty sure Eoin Morgan's maternal grandparents were English. What's good for the goose and all that.


  • killerandflash
    killerandflash Posts: 69,842
    redsek said:
    I've no idea mate - the whole thing is a joke as far as I'm concerned. There is no way that he should have been allowed to switch to England at this stage of his career in my view.
    To me he should never have been eligible for ROI in the first place, I'd abolish the grandparent rule

    Different sport but I'm pretty sure Eoin Morgan's maternal grandparents were English. What's good for the goose and all that.


    Morgan's mother is English and he has had a British passport since he was born. And he has played in England for a long time too, so even though there's a side of me that feels it's a shame Ireland lost him, his case for playing for England is strong.
  • Redrobo
    Redrobo Posts: 11,330
    Given up getting the sportsman of the year then.
  • guinnessaddick
    guinnessaddick Posts: 28,609
    edited March 2019
    Redrobo said:
    Given up getting the sportsman of the year then.
    Shay  has retired.
  • Daarrzzetbum
    Daarrzzetbum Posts: 1,236
    Represented Ireland already should not be allowed to now represent England - simple as that