Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
CL's Favourite Albums. QF3: Revolver vs The Dark Side of the Moon
Comments
-
Love Stevie and Marvin! Yes, all of the finalists sit firmly within the rock/folk bracket, as those tend to be the genres that have the albums that the majority of contributors prefer. That might have something to do with the background of a lot of posters, which is fine as it's 'CL's Favourite Albums'. The closest was Miles Davis' Kind of Blue with two votes (another album I own and listen to regularly).LennyLowrent said:
A bit pink innit..?Addick in SW16 said:
I do indeed:The_President said:
@Addick in SW16 - do you have the list of quarter finalists?, and i'll listen to them on my drive.The_President said:Whilst downloading Spotify in readiness for my loooong drive this weekend, i thought i'd listen to Floyds Animals. Another timeless piece - its only Floyd who could make Dog and Pig noises along with drunk Irish security guards sound musically brilliant.
Blood on the Tracks - Bob Dylan
Blue - Joni Mitchell
Bridge Over Troubled Water - Simon & Garfunkel
Dark Side of the Moon - Pink Floyd
Definitely Maybe - Oasis
Nevermind - Nirvana
Revolver - The Beatles
Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band - The Beatles
No Marvin Gaye's 'What's Going On'
No Stevie Wonder's 'innervisions' or 'songs in the key of life, Prince 'Sign o' the times'
Ninna Simone (any of them)
Or even little Michael..?
Innervisions for me...1 -
Revolver - I'm not a PF fan post Syd.2
-
Without the Doors that list is incomplete for me. But Blood on the tracks is way the best.Addick in SW16 said:
I do indeed:The_President said:
@Addick in SW16 - do you have the list of quarter finalists?, and i'll listen to them on my drive.The_President said:Whilst downloading Spotify in readiness for my loooong drive this weekend, i thought i'd listen to Floyds Animals. Another timeless piece - its only Floyd who could make Dog and Pig noises along with drunk Irish security guards sound musically brilliant.
Blood on the Tracks - Bob Dylan
Blue - Joni Mitchell
Bridge Over Troubled Water - Simon & Garfunkel
Dark Side of the Moon - Pink Floyd
Definitely Maybe - Oasis
Nevermind - Nirvana
Revolver - The Beatles
Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band - The Beatles2 -
Darkside, in this round.
0 -
This is like handbag fight at a trainspotters convention. For gods sake Roland sell the club the waiting is taking a dreadful toll.Henry Irving said:
Not if, as you've said, you won't go close to them.The_President said:
So, the same doesnt apply to me then for the first 3 ??Henry Irving said:
I know exactly how good, or bad, the others are. Most of them I'd listened to before you were born.PaddyP17 said:
And you'll never know how good the last six are, based on your comment immediately preceding...Henry Irving said:
Then you'll never know how good the first two are.The_President said:Personally i wouldnt even go close to the first 3
And why ask what the eight are and then not listen or re-listen to them?
No, I infer the opposite from what the president said.PaddyP17 said:
The_President's comment equally implies that he's come to his judgement based on listening to all eight, too. So he does know how "good" (or bad or mediocre or amazing or terrible) the first two are, I would think.Henry Irving said:
I know exactly how good, or bad, the others are. Most of them I'd listened to before you were born.PaddyP17 said:
And you'll never know how good the last six are, based on your comment immediately preceding...Henry Irving said:
Then you'll never know how good the first two are.The_President said:Personally i wouldnt even go close to the first 3
... And congratulations on being older than me? Being young doesn't preclude me from this discussion!
And no your age doesn't preclude you but lack of memory does. I've commented on all of them in the previous rounds.0 -
Except one person wasnt prepared to put his handbag down and had to continue - as usual.Wheresmeticket? said:
This is like handbag fight at a trainspotters convention. For gods sake Roland sell the club the waiting is taking a dreadful toll.Henry Irving said:
Not if, as you've said, you won't go close to them.The_President said:
So, the same doesnt apply to me then for the first 3 ??Henry Irving said:
I know exactly how good, or bad, the others are. Most of them I'd listened to before you were born.PaddyP17 said:
And you'll never know how good the last six are, based on your comment immediately preceding...Henry Irving said:
Then you'll never know how good the first two are.The_President said:Personally i wouldnt even go close to the first 3
And why ask what the eight are and then not listen or re-listen to them?
No, I infer the opposite from what the president said.PaddyP17 said:
The_President's comment equally implies that he's come to his judgement based on listening to all eight, too. So he does know how "good" (or bad or mediocre or amazing or terrible) the first two are, I would think.Henry Irving said:
I know exactly how good, or bad, the others are. Most of them I'd listened to before you were born.PaddyP17 said:
And you'll never know how good the last six are, based on your comment immediately preceding...Henry Irving said:
Then you'll never know how good the first two are.The_President said:Personally i wouldnt even go close to the first 3
... And congratulations on being older than me? Being young doesn't preclude me from this discussion!
And no your age doesn't preclude you but lack of memory does. I've commented on all of them in the previous rounds.0 -
Man's the class bullyThe_President said:
Except one person wasnt prepared to put his handbag down and had to continue - as usual.Wheresmeticket? said:
This is like handbag fight at a trainspotters convention. For gods sake Roland sell the club the waiting is taking a dreadful toll.Henry Irving said:
Not if, as you've said, you won't go close to them.The_President said:
So, the same doesnt apply to me then for the first 3 ??Henry Irving said:
I know exactly how good, or bad, the others are. Most of them I'd listened to before you were born.PaddyP17 said:
And you'll never know how good the last six are, based on your comment immediately preceding...Henry Irving said:
Then you'll never know how good the first two are.The_President said:Personally i wouldnt even go close to the first 3
And why ask what the eight are and then not listen or re-listen to them?
No, I infer the opposite from what the president said.PaddyP17 said:
The_President's comment equally implies that he's come to his judgement based on listening to all eight, too. So he does know how "good" (or bad or mediocre or amazing or terrible) the first two are, I would think.Henry Irving said:
I know exactly how good, or bad, the others are. Most of them I'd listened to before you were born.PaddyP17 said:
And you'll never know how good the last six are, based on your comment immediately preceding...Henry Irving said:
Then you'll never know how good the first two are.The_President said:Personally i wouldnt even go close to the first 3
... And congratulations on being older than me? Being young doesn't preclude me from this discussion!
And no your age doesn't preclude you but lack of memory does. I've commented on all of them in the previous rounds.0 -
Oh dear, another sense of humour failure.PaddyP17 said:
Man's the class bullyThe_President said:
Except one person wasnt prepared to put his handbag down and had to continue - as usual.Wheresmeticket? said:
This is like handbag fight at a trainspotters convention. For gods sake Roland sell the club the waiting is taking a dreadful toll.Henry Irving said:
Not if, as you've said, you won't go close to them.The_President said:
So, the same doesnt apply to me then for the first 3 ??Henry Irving said:
I know exactly how good, or bad, the others are. Most of them I'd listened to before you were born.PaddyP17 said:
And you'll never know how good the last six are, based on your comment immediately preceding...Henry Irving said:
Then you'll never know how good the first two are.The_President said:Personally i wouldnt even go close to the first 3
And why ask what the eight are and then not listen or re-listen to them?
No, I infer the opposite from what the president said.PaddyP17 said:
The_President's comment equally implies that he's come to his judgement based on listening to all eight, too. So he does know how "good" (or bad or mediocre or amazing or terrible) the first two are, I would think.Henry Irving said:
I know exactly how good, or bad, the others are. Most of them I'd listened to before you were born.PaddyP17 said:
And you'll never know how good the last six are, based on your comment immediately preceding...Henry Irving said:
Then you'll never know how good the first two are.The_President said:Personally i wouldnt even go close to the first 3
... And congratulations on being older than me? Being young doesn't preclude me from this discussion!
And no your age doesn't preclude you but lack of memory does. I've commented on all of them in the previous rounds.0 -
Okay, so we're pretty close here. Revolver currently in the lead 34 - 30. Voting closes tomorrow evening.0
-
Addick in SW16 said:
Okay, so we're pretty close here. Revolver currently in the lead 34 - 30. Voting closes tomorrow evening.
2 - Sponsored links:
-
Revolver0
-
If you want to call it that, fine. I have a lot of respect for many of your views on football and otherwise, HI - we agree on a lot - but whenever you disagree with someone, you absolutely can't resist making it a bit personal. It's like a compulsion. And it's mean; petty; and annoying.Henry Irving said:
Oh dear, another sense of humour failure.PaddyP17 said:
Man's the class bullyThe_President said:
Except one person wasnt prepared to put his handbag down and had to continue - as usual.Wheresmeticket? said:
This is like handbag fight at a trainspotters convention. For gods sake Roland sell the club the waiting is taking a dreadful toll.Henry Irving said:
Not if, as you've said, you won't go close to them.The_President said:
So, the same doesnt apply to me then for the first 3 ??Henry Irving said:
I know exactly how good, or bad, the others are. Most of them I'd listened to before you were born.PaddyP17 said:
And you'll never know how good the last six are, based on your comment immediately preceding...Henry Irving said:
Then you'll never know how good the first two are.The_President said:Personally i wouldnt even go close to the first 3
And why ask what the eight are and then not listen or re-listen to them?
No, I infer the opposite from what the president said.PaddyP17 said:
The_President's comment equally implies that he's come to his judgement based on listening to all eight, too. So he does know how "good" (or bad or mediocre or amazing or terrible) the first two are, I would think.Henry Irving said:
I know exactly how good, or bad, the others are. Most of them I'd listened to before you were born.PaddyP17 said:
And you'll never know how good the last six are, based on your comment immediately preceding...Henry Irving said:
Then you'll never know how good the first two are.The_President said:Personally i wouldnt even go close to the first 3
... And congratulations on being older than me? Being young doesn't preclude me from this discussion!
And no your age doesn't preclude you but lack of memory does. I've commented on all of them in the previous rounds.
Your comment about my age was clearly intended as a very veiled, very roundabout dig (i.e. I'm younger and therefore should know my place, or something), and because I like jazz I am therefore a pretentious wanker/musical masturbator/know-it-all, too.
You think you are always right and immediately resort to the ad hominem whenever someone disagrees with you. It's tiring.2 -
Watching DSOTM lose is breaking me right now2
-
This is a pop/rock list really.LennyLowrent said:
A bit pink innit..?Addick in SW16 said:
I do indeed:The_President said:
@Addick in SW16 - do you have the list of quarter finalists?, and i'll listen to them on my drive.The_President said:Whilst downloading Spotify in readiness for my loooong drive this weekend, i thought i'd listen to Floyds Animals. Another timeless piece - its only Floyd who could make Dog and Pig noises along with drunk Irish security guards sound musically brilliant.
Blood on the Tracks - Bob Dylan
Blue - Joni Mitchell
Bridge Over Troubled Water - Simon & Garfunkel
Dark Side of the Moon - Pink Floyd
Definitely Maybe - Oasis
Nevermind - Nirvana
Revolver - The Beatles
Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band - The Beatles
No Marvin Gaye's 'What's Going On'
No Stevie Wonder's 'innervisions' or 'songs in the key of life, Prince 'Sign o' the times'
Ninna Simone (any of them)
Or even little Michael..?
Innervisions for me...0 -
Don't judge people by your own behaviour. You're still upset that I don't like jazz so you imagined that I hadn't listened to all the albums. When I pointed out that not only had I heard them but I'd already commented on them you got upset and had another trantrum.PaddyP17 said:
If you want to call it that, fine. I have a lot of respect for many of your views on football and otherwise, HI - we agree on a lot - but whenever you disagree with someone, you absolutely can't resist making it a bit personal. It's like a compulsion. And it's mean; petty; and annoying.Henry Irving said:
Oh dear, another sense of humour failure.PaddyP17 said:
Man's the class bullyThe_President said:
Except one person wasnt prepared to put his handbag down and had to continue - as usual.Wheresmeticket? said:
This is like handbag fight at a trainspotters convention. For gods sake Roland sell the club the waiting is taking a dreadful toll.Henry Irving said:
Not if, as you've said, you won't go close to them.The_President said:
So, the same doesnt apply to me then for the first 3 ??Henry Irving said:
I know exactly how good, or bad, the others are. Most of them I'd listened to before you were born.PaddyP17 said:
And you'll never know how good the last six are, based on your comment immediately preceding...Henry Irving said:
Then you'll never know how good the first two are.The_President said:Personally i wouldnt even go close to the first 3
And why ask what the eight are and then not listen or re-listen to them?
No, I infer the opposite from what the president said.PaddyP17 said:
The_President's comment equally implies that he's come to his judgement based on listening to all eight, too. So he does know how "good" (or bad or mediocre or amazing or terrible) the first two are, I would think.Henry Irving said:
I know exactly how good, or bad, the others are. Most of them I'd listened to before you were born.PaddyP17 said:
And you'll never know how good the last six are, based on your comment immediately preceding...Henry Irving said:
Then you'll never know how good the first two are.The_President said:Personally i wouldnt even go close to the first 3
... And congratulations on being older than me? Being young doesn't preclude me from this discussion!
And no your age doesn't preclude you but lack of memory does. I've commented on all of them in the previous rounds.
Your comment about my age was clearly intended as a very veiled, very roundabout dig (i.e. I'm younger and therefore should know my place, or something), and because I like jazz I am therefore a pretentious wanker/musical masturbator/know-it-all, too.
You think you are always right and immediately resort to the ad hominem whenever someone disagrees with you. It's tiring.
0 -
Why did you bring my age into things then?Henry Irving said:
Don't judge people by your own behaviour. You're still upset that I don't like jazz so you imagined that I hadn't listened to all the albums. When I pointed out that not only had I heard them but I'd already commented on them you got upset and had another trantrum.PaddyP17 said:
If you want to call it that, fine. I have a lot of respect for many of your views on football and otherwise, HI - we agree on a lot - but whenever you disagree with someone, you absolutely can't resist making it a bit personal. It's like a compulsion. And it's mean; petty; and annoying.Henry Irving said:
Oh dear, another sense of humour failure.PaddyP17 said:
Man's the class bullyThe_President said:
Except one person wasnt prepared to put his handbag down and had to continue - as usual.Wheresmeticket? said:
This is like handbag fight at a trainspotters convention. For gods sake Roland sell the club the waiting is taking a dreadful toll.Henry Irving said:
Not if, as you've said, you won't go close to them.The_President said:
So, the same doesnt apply to me then for the first 3 ??Henry Irving said:
I know exactly how good, or bad, the others are. Most of them I'd listened to before you were born.PaddyP17 said:
And you'll never know how good the last six are, based on your comment immediately preceding...Henry Irving said:
Then you'll never know how good the first two are.The_President said:Personally i wouldnt even go close to the first 3
And why ask what the eight are and then not listen or re-listen to them?
No, I infer the opposite from what the president said.PaddyP17 said:
The_President's comment equally implies that he's come to his judgement based on listening to all eight, too. So he does know how "good" (or bad or mediocre or amazing or terrible) the first two are, I would think.Henry Irving said:
I know exactly how good, or bad, the others are. Most of them I'd listened to before you were born.PaddyP17 said:
And you'll never know how good the last six are, based on your comment immediately preceding...Henry Irving said:
Then you'll never know how good the first two are.The_President said:Personally i wouldnt even go close to the first 3
... And congratulations on being older than me? Being young doesn't preclude me from this discussion!
And no your age doesn't preclude you but lack of memory does. I've commented on all of them in the previous rounds.
Your comment about my age was clearly intended as a very veiled, very roundabout dig (i.e. I'm younger and therefore should know my place, or something), and because I like jazz I am therefore a pretentious wanker/musical masturbator/know-it-all, too.
You think you are always right and immediately resort to the ad hominem whenever someone disagrees with you. It's tiring.0 -
Revolver my favourite Beatles Album (only just over Sgt Peppers) and Dark Side of the Moon my favourite Pink Floyd Album (just over Wish You were here).
But overall - think I've got to go with Dark Side of the Moon.0 -
Get over itPaddyP17 said:
Why did you bring my age into things then?Henry Irving said:
Don't judge people by your own behaviour. You're still upset that I don't like jazz so you imagined that I hadn't listened to all the albums. When I pointed out that not only had I heard them but I'd already commented on them you got upset and had another trantrum.PaddyP17 said:
If you want to call it that, fine. I have a lot of respect for many of your views on football and otherwise, HI - we agree on a lot - but whenever you disagree with someone, you absolutely can't resist making it a bit personal. It's like a compulsion. And it's mean; petty; and annoying.Henry Irving said:
Oh dear, another sense of humour failure.PaddyP17 said:
Man's the class bullyThe_President said:
Except one person wasnt prepared to put his handbag down and had to continue - as usual.Wheresmeticket? said:
This is like handbag fight at a trainspotters convention. For gods sake Roland sell the club the waiting is taking a dreadful toll.Henry Irving said:
Not if, as you've said, you won't go close to them.The_President said:
So, the same doesnt apply to me then for the first 3 ??Henry Irving said:
I know exactly how good, or bad, the others are. Most of them I'd listened to before you were born.PaddyP17 said:
And you'll never know how good the last six are, based on your comment immediately preceding...Henry Irving said:
Then you'll never know how good the first two are.The_President said:Personally i wouldnt even go close to the first 3
And why ask what the eight are and then not listen or re-listen to them?
No, I infer the opposite from what the president said.PaddyP17 said:
The_President's comment equally implies that he's come to his judgement based on listening to all eight, too. So he does know how "good" (or bad or mediocre or amazing or terrible) the first two are, I would think.Henry Irving said:
I know exactly how good, or bad, the others are. Most of them I'd listened to before you were born.PaddyP17 said:
And you'll never know how good the last six are, based on your comment immediately preceding...Henry Irving said:
Then you'll never know how good the first two are.The_President said:Personally i wouldnt even go close to the first 3
... And congratulations on being older than me? Being young doesn't preclude me from this discussion!
And no your age doesn't preclude you but lack of memory does. I've commented on all of them in the previous rounds.
Your comment about my age was clearly intended as a very veiled, very roundabout dig (i.e. I'm younger and therefore should know my place, or something), and because I like jazz I am therefore a pretentious wanker/musical masturbator/know-it-all, too.
You think you are always right and immediately resort to the ad hominem whenever someone disagrees with you. It's tiring.0 -
Final Score:
Henry Irving 2- PaddyP17 - 2
Final count on the albums later today.6 -
I wouldn't concern yourself with HI, Paddy. He invariably resorts to ad hominem argument when he's floundering.0
- Sponsored links:
-
HI can't remember. Which is an age thing. ;-)Henry Irving said:
Get over itPaddyP17 said:
Why did you bring my age into things then?Henry Irving said:
Don't judge people by your own behaviour. You're still upset that I don't like jazz so you imagined that I hadn't listened to all the albums. When I pointed out that not only had I heard them but I'd already commented on them you got upset and had another trantrum.PaddyP17 said:
If you want to call it that, fine. I have a lot of respect for many of your views on football and otherwise, HI - we agree on a lot - but whenever you disagree with someone, you absolutely can't resist making it a bit personal. It's like a compulsion. And it's mean; petty; and annoying.Henry Irving said:
Oh dear, another sense of humour failure.PaddyP17 said:
Man's the class bullyThe_President said:
Except one person wasnt prepared to put his handbag down and had to continue - as usual.Wheresmeticket? said:
This is like handbag fight at a trainspotters convention. For gods sake Roland sell the club the waiting is taking a dreadful toll.Henry Irving said:
Not if, as you've said, you won't go close to them.The_President said:
So, the same doesnt apply to me then for the first 3 ??Henry Irving said:
I know exactly how good, or bad, the others are. Most of them I'd listened to before you were born.PaddyP17 said:
And you'll never know how good the last six are, based on your comment immediately preceding...Henry Irving said:
Then you'll never know how good the first two are.The_President said:Personally i wouldnt even go close to the first 3
And why ask what the eight are and then not listen or re-listen to them?
No, I infer the opposite from what the president said.PaddyP17 said:
The_President's comment equally implies that he's come to his judgement based on listening to all eight, too. So he does know how "good" (or bad or mediocre or amazing or terrible) the first two are, I would think.Henry Irving said:
I know exactly how good, or bad, the others are. Most of them I'd listened to before you were born.PaddyP17 said:
And you'll never know how good the last six are, based on your comment immediately preceding...Henry Irving said:
Then you'll never know how good the first two are.The_President said:Personally i wouldnt even go close to the first 3
... And congratulations on being older than me? Being young doesn't preclude me from this discussion!
And no your age doesn't preclude you but lack of memory does. I've commented on all of them in the previous rounds.
Your comment about my age was clearly intended as a very veiled, very roundabout dig (i.e. I'm younger and therefore should know my place, or something), and because I like jazz I am therefore a pretentious wanker/musical masturbator/know-it-all, too.
You think you are always right and immediately resort to the ad hominem whenever someone disagrees with you. It's tiring.0 -
Revolver wins this battle 35 - 31
Last quarter-final will be posted tomorrow.
Thanks for all of your votes and contributions.2 -
A lot closer than I thought it was gonna be.Addick in SW16 said:Revolver wins this battle 35 - 31
Last quarter-final will be posted tomorrow.
Thanks for all of your votes and contributions.0 -
WOW, unbelievable result. This is right up there with the votes for Trump and Brexit. It's a mad, mad world! The only comforting thought is that somewhere in a parallel universe people are calling these things correctly.3
-
And Stone Roses would still be in the contestStig said:WOW, unbelievable result. This is right up there with the votes for Trump and Brexit. It's a mad, mad world! The only comforting thought is that somewhere in a parallel universe people are calling these things correctly.
1 -
-
Just wondering if there's going to be an award night for this and if the possible winners have it down as a 'must go' in their diaries.0
-
Yes there will be an award night, Henry and Paddy are going to be the comperesShrew said:Just wondering if there's going to be an award night for this and if the possible winners have it down as a 'must go' in their diaries.
4 -
Someone celebrated ..?
https://youtu.be/9E2G3v1e288 0
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eVSlE28hOgI
