Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Options

Summer 2025 Charlton Athletic Transfer Rumours

1334335337339340430

Comments

  • Exciting player but I don't really see how Apter fits in - he's definitely not a wingback and from his stats last season looks like less of a wingback than even Small! Neither does he appear to be a forward - but his goals look fairly promising. Then again, Campbell adapted well so I guess we'll see
    I presume he's going to be one of the 3 up front where he's free to drift around, in the same way as Campbell perhaps 
  • edited July 13
    As mentioned above I think apter will play the small role and possibly have a bit more end product and potency,with someone like Ramsey next to him any player on that right side will have more license to attack.
  • MarcusH26 said:
    Think Apter would also give you the versatility to slide in as a 10 in that 3421 second half shape. 
    I was going to add, perhaps it gives us versatility in shape and set up.  The back 5/wing backs however you prefer to frame it has worked well for us and I think that’s how NJ wants to shape the team, but we have a long long season ahead of us against much better teams than the ones we played last year.  Adaptability in formation/set up could really help if we can throw a few teams off thinking we’re very rigid in set up etc 
  • cabbles said:
    MarcusH26 said:
    Think Apter would also give you the versatility to slide in as a 10 in that 3421 second half shape. 
    I was going to add, perhaps it gives us versatility in shape and set up.  The back 5/wing backs however you prefer to frame it has worked well for us and I think that’s how NJ wants to shape the team, but we have a long long season ahead of us against much better teams than the ones we played last year.  Adaptability in formation/set up could really help if we can throw a few teams off thinking we’re very rigid in set up etc 
    Just like against Birmingham at home, they couldn't adapt to the surprise change in shape
  • Brad Hills who was linked to us was involved in a punch up with a Northampton player in a pre season match yesterday .. both players left the field with blood pouring down their faces … .. 
  • Sponsored links:


  • MarcusH26 said:
    I can't remember if this was from an interview or if he was a guest at a supporters group meeting.

    Didn't Chris Lock say last season they won't loan any young players below the National League anymore because he wants them in a full time environment and players were coming back with bad habits etc from NLS/Isthmian loans?

    Just something that sprung to mind with the likes of Rylah, Josh Laq , Pat Casey and potentially Mwamba. 
    Yes, it was Bromley Addicks.

    Loans will only be to full time clubs with proper monitoring, etc.
  • MarcusH26 said:
    According to NJ via Rich it's Kanu or Mbick going out on loan and the other will stay. 
    Which would suggest that one of the incoming players will be a striker.

    Don't let Golfie know as he'll be upset we're wasting money on forwards when he knows we don't need them.
    Eh ?

    I'm.all for bringing in more forwards. The more the merrier.

    In fact I'll be in raptures should the lad from Blackpool signs 🤭
  • MarcusH26 said:
    According to NJ via Rich it's Kanu or Mbick going out on loan and the other will stay. 
    Which would suggest that one of the incoming players will be a striker.

    Don't let Golfie know as he'll be upset we're wasting money on forwards when he knows we don't need them.
    Eh ?

    I'm.all for bringing in more forwards. The more the merrier.

    In fact I'll be in raptures should the lad from Blackpool signs 🤭
    A positive golfaddick I don’t think Iv ever seen that, gotta say it’s a very exciting time for the club and I’d imagine it’s been 15 years or so since the last.
  • Sponsored links:


  • If we are prepared to drop £1.5-2m on a player very similar to small, then it goes to show it wasn’t about the money when he went to Preston. Always got the impression NJ wasn’t convinced about Small. Certainly wouldn’t have been about his talent, must’ve been around his attitude and he did come with a reputation.
    Don’t know about his attitude but fairly convinced about his ability. 
    I’m pretty sure Small’s stats didn’t back up the hype for NJ.
  • sam3110 said:
    cafc4life said:
    We still need another striker for sure. Has to be a priority imo
    It all depends on how he lines us up at the start of the season. 

    Olaofe, Godden and Leaburn fighting to be the sole starter whilst we play 343 is probably enough, especially if Kanu and Mbick don't go on loan. 

    We'd then need more wingers as TC and Apter if he signs won't be enough, and you'd be relying on Carey to play out there or Leaburn, or playing Dixon. 

    If we're sticking to 352 then someone like DKD makes sense as he can play up top or in a 10, but then Apter makes less sense unless we use him as a super attacking RWB
    Glad you are not our manager.
    You would get us relegated for sure.
  • If we are prepared to drop £1.5-2m on a player very similar to small, then it goes to show it wasn’t about the money when he went to Preston. Always got the impression NJ wasn’t convinced about Small. Certainly wouldn’t have been about his talent, must’ve been around his attitude and he did come with a reputation.
    This rings true with what I’ve heard. Small and NJ didn’t always see eye to eye. I’m sure it was against Blackpool at home that Small got taken off in the first half? I defo think NJ wanted him to stay but wasn’t prepared to blow the budget to keep him. 
  • Yann897 said:
    Would still like a right wing back, as it may only
    L be JRC who can play there and he sounds like he’s better in midfield anyway. Another forward too please. 
    I’ll be surprised if we don’t bring in another right wing back.
    Ramsey will be playing there … 
    But you also said we would only be getting 7 in.
    So, is this your opinion or are you claiming to be in the know.
    Fwiw I'd prefer him at rcb.
  • Not seen him play, but the blackpool forum seems to suggest he's lacking pace. For those that know the player, is that a fair concern?

     I feel pace is important for the Small role.
  • Most important attribute for a wing-back is engine, not top speed 
  • Not seen him play, but the blackpool forum seems to suggest he's lacking pace. For those that know the player, is that a fair concern?

     I feel pace is important for the Small role.
    Well whoever does the FIFA stats, Small has 78 pace, Campbell 81, Apter 89 and Olaofe 91
  • Not seen him play, but the blackpool forum seems to suggest he's lacking pace. For those that know the player, is that a fair concern?

     I feel pace is important for the Small role.
    Bruce says he has the ability to go past people. That doesn’t scream lack of pace and even if he’s not that quick going past people is what matters however achieved. 
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!