How many from the current crop would get into the 2019 playoff-winning side

cafctom

I still think the 2019 team is significantly better than the current one.

And the 2012 team walks all over both of them.

Mendonca In Asdas

Ask me at the end of season, if we keep winning and end up in the top 2, I might have to change my mind.

killerandflash

Callumcafc said:

AMB over Phillips even?

Was Jed Steer, the keeper in the first half of 18/19, better than both?

Garrymanilow

Bowyer would have absolutely loved Ramsay, Docherty and Edwards. I think he would have yelled at Small all the time and Small would have tuned out completely. He might have literally murdered Gillesphey

JustFloydRoad

Imagine if we had those Gilbert corners back in 2019.

LittleAddick

Dare I bring this back up? I think our whole back 4 gets into the side

Scoham

Jones and Ramsay are comfortably as good as our best players in the 11/12 and 18/19 teams. 

Plenty of others could have played big parts in those squads. Green, Wagstaff, Hollands, Matt Taylor, Reeves, Parker, Purrington, Solly (18/19) etc weren't Championship quality but they didn't need to be.

What's missing from this team is one or two real stand out attacking players. 11/12 had Kermorgant, 18/19 had Aribo, Taylor and for half a season Grant.

Big credit to Jones for getting us to this point, it's a real team effort without that attacking player or two who can be relied on to regularly change games.

North Lower Neil

Phillips

Jones
Bauer
Bielik
Ramsay/Small
Coventry 
Cullen
Aribo
Edwards
Taylor
Campbell

5 this year, 6 for 2019, though I can see arguments for a couple either way.

Callumcafc

Just came up in the ongoing playoffs chatter on the other thread.

So how many make it in now?

se9addick

Callumcafc said:

Just came up in the ongoing playoffs chatter on the other thread.

So how many make it in now?

I still think the 2019 team are the better side overall and would probably beat the 2025 team fairly comfortably. The 2025 team have gone up significantly in my estimation though!

MuttleyCAFC

Phillips, Dijksteel, Bauer, Sarr (Pearce 45'), Purrington, Cullen, Bielik, Pratley (Williams 71'), Aribo, Parker, Taylor. Subs not used: Maxwell, Solly, Lapslie, Forster-Caskey, Reeves.

I think that side has room for Ramsey, Edwards, Jones, Coventry, TC, Small and Godden. That's six out of eleven. Gillesphey, Docherty, Mannion and Berry would make the bench.

msomerton

simply none.

The Red Robin

Possibly Aneke or Godden over Parker but other than that, none. 

Redskin

Braziliance said:

                              532

                           Phillips
Ramsay Bauer Jones Lockyer Small 
                   Cullen Coventry
                             Aribo
                     Leaburn Taylor

I think that team would be competitive in the championship potentially.

I'd have Godden over Leaburn any day of the week.

superclive

phillips
ramsay
Baur
Jones
Edwards

cullen
beliek
aribo
Coventry

Taylor
Godden or TC

Scoham

msomerton said:

simply none.

You’d have Parker over TC, Purrington over Edwards, Pearce/Sarr over Jones, Dijksteel over Ramsay?