MANNION; 7 some good saves but -1 for the goal R.E.G.: 6 no Ramsey but did ok. A.MITCHELL: 6 played ok but missed Jones GILLESPHEY: 4 gives the ball away so much with aimless kicks. EDWARDS: 6 great first cross and was ok but didn't repeat too often. COVENTRY: 6 wasn't sharp but gives 100% TAYLOR: 5.5 some good touches and only 2nd game back ANDERSON: 5 he runs a lot ! A.CAMPBELL: 5.5 he runs a lot ! LEABURN: 7 showed some good form and rustiness with his 1st start in nearly a year. GODDEN: 6.5 played ok but just one half chance. WATSON: 6.5 had a decent half SMALL: 6.5 showed willingness to get the ball into the area BERRY: 8 for two well taken goals Referee: 7.5 good performance
MANNION; 7 Made some good saves and should have had protection for the 1st R.E.G.: 6 Steady but then let's himself down with aimless long balls A.MITCHELL: 7 Steady and covered well GILLESPHEY: 6 Slow on the turn EDWARDS: 4 Distribution and control poor. COVENTRY: 4 Worst I've seen in a game. Keep the ball on the floor as passing was poor. TAYLOR: 4 Not effective a free kicks were poor in their delivery ANDERSON: 2 Why take a throw to a player who cannot shield and cannot pass. A.CAMPBELL: 4 No industry albeit twice got into position where others should have passed for him to score. LEABURN: 4 Weak and poor all round. Keep it simple when all the flicks don't come off. GODDEN: 4 Not involved enough WATSON: 6 Steady SMALL: 4 Has talent but not enough nous. BERRY: 8 2 x excellent finishes Referee:7 Ok
MANNION; 5 - blotted his copybook with their first goal
R.E.G.: 5 - looked very shaky in the first half, albeit against their best player
A.MITCHELL: 6 - the only player who defended well - his primary job - even though his distribution remains poor.
GILLESPHEY: 4 - really poor. Slow to react and even slower over the ground. For an experienced player, he lacks defensive nous
EDWARDS: 5 - below par
COVENTRY: 5 - part of a midfield that was overrun and outplayed by Barnsley
TAYLOR: 5 - ditto. Maybe two games in 4 days after such a long time out resulted in fatigue
ANDERSON: 4 - gave the ball away repeatedly and was rash in his positional play and attempts to win the ball back. Rightly hooked at half time
A.CAMPBELL: 4 - was a bit livelier (if largely ineffective) in the first half but jogged around in the second as if he was having a Sunday afternoon kick about down the park. Totally unacceptable
LEABURN: 6 - showed a few good touches as well as understandable rustiness
GODDEN: 5 - I fear his best days are well behind him
WATSON: 6 - did ok
SMALL: 6.5 - a few good runs and at least shows some attacking intent
BERRY: 8 - got us out of jail with two very nice finishes. Could have had a hat-trick but for a miskick just after he came on
Just a quick reminder, if you want to comment on other people's marks, do it over on the post match thread not here, as it makes Lancs' job more difficult.
@Cafcwest you had Leaburn marked at 56.5, which I assume was a typo rather than overenthusiasm, so have had a go at correcting it. If that's not what you meant you've got until tomorrow afternoon to edit your post to change it.
MANNION; 6 was at fault for the goal, and couple of punches he missed, but then also was big at crosses and made couple of good saves, mixed night for him. R.E.G.: 6 did okay, body position is bad when he is left one on one, which is a big issue. A.MITCHELL: 5 didn't think he was that good, was shakey on the goal, gave the ball away needless. GILLESPHEY: 4 was very poor, and I think should have got a block for the ball.. Some very bad passes, which on another day would have cost us. EDWARDS: 6 was okay, needs to improve on crossing, little between him and Small for me. COVENTRY: 4 I would go to say, that was the worse Charlton performance, I am huge fan, but I thought he was poor last night, gave the ball away time after time, which is unlike him. Hopefully just a blip. TAYLOR: 6 was good on the ball again, happy to take the ball in tight areas and under pressure. He does look for more forward passes, but I would like him to really stamp his mark on the game and on this team ANDERSON: 5 was okay, maybe slightly unlucky to be taken off rather than Campbell. For me, they are pretty much the same, run a lot, little quality. A.CAMPBELL: 5 as mentioned above run a lot, little quality LEABURN: 6 frustrating night Leaburn, some great stuff, and some poor stuff. For me, a little too greedy.. Also get the impression he isn't the most popular, and I thought this on Saturday.. GODDEN: 6 had a couple of good chances, and should have taken one, but he is smart in movement, and some of his touches. WATSON: 6 did okay when he come on. SMALL: 6 did okay, again crossing not great. BERRY: 8 thought won us the game, with two smart finishes. Referee: 7 was okay, looked world class from the referee performance on Saturday.
MANNION; 6 - Forgot how to hold onto the ball, not just the goal but a few cross in he chose to punch. R.E.G.: 5 - Early booking, disappeared after A.MITCHELL: 6 - One CB doing the job of 2 GILLESPHEY: 4 - Can we have the other Mitchell or Potts in please. Thank you. EDWARDS: 5 - Yet to see the attacking crosser that was playing in Scotland COVENTRY: 6 - His usual self, just dont try and pass forward, its not worth surrendering possession TAYLOR: 6 - Another promising display, tired, harsh criticism for the goal as its a legacy issue of ours. ANDERSON: 4 - Nothing worth mentioning over than totally ineffective A.CAMPBELL: 5 - see above, gets the extra mark for winning a couple of fouls and 2 good passing moves. LEABURN: 6 - Tried to go it alone a bit too much, hopefully just rustiness. GODDEN: 6 - Goal threat(ish) knows how to get shots off, just dont give him enough opportunities to do it... WATSON: 6 - Better than REG at RB SMALL: 6.5 - Better than Edwards at LB, hopefully over his little tiff and back to last seasons player BERRY: 7 - Maybe not some sort of league one Brazilian but not far off, best attacking mid at the club so how about stating him some more eh?
Referee: 7 - Was too numbed by our performance to notice him, which probably means he was pretty good!
Comments
R.E.G.: 4
A.MITCHELL: 6
GILLESPHEY: 4
EDWARDS: 5
COVENTRY: 6
TAYLOR: 5
ANDERSON: 4
A.CAMPBELL: 4
LEABURN: 6
GODDEN: 5.5
WATSON: 6
SMALL: 6
BERRY: 8
Referee: 6
R.E.G.: 6
A.MITCHELL: 7.5
GILLESPHEY: 5
EDWARDS: 6
COVENTRY: 6
TAYLOR: 6
ANDERSON: 4
A.CAMPBELL: 4
LEABURN: 6.5
GODDEN: 6.5
WATSON: 6.5
SMALL: 6.5
BERRY: 7.5
Referee: 7
R.E.G.: 6 no Ramsey but did ok.
A.MITCHELL: 6 played ok but missed Jones
GILLESPHEY: 4 gives the ball away so much with aimless kicks.
EDWARDS: 6 great first cross and was ok but didn't repeat too often.
COVENTRY: 6 wasn't sharp but gives 100%
TAYLOR: 5.5 some good touches and only 2nd game back
ANDERSON: 5 he runs a lot !
A.CAMPBELL: 5.5 he runs a lot !
LEABURN: 7 showed some good form and rustiness with his 1st start in nearly a year.
GODDEN: 6.5 played ok but just one half chance.
WATSON: 6.5 had a decent half
SMALL: 6.5 showed willingness to get the ball into the area
BERRY: 8 for two well taken goals
Referee: 7.5 good performance
R.E.G.: 6
A.MITCHELL: 6
GILLESPHEY: 5
EDWARDS: 6
COVENTRY: 6.5
TAYLOR: 6
ANDERSON: 5
A.CAMPBELL: 4
LEABURN: 6.5
GODDEN: 6
WATSON: 6.5
SMALL: 7
BERRY: 7.5
Referee: 7
R.E.G.: 6
A.MITCHELL: 6.5
GILLESPHEY: 5.5
EDWARDS: 6
COVENTRY: 6
TAYLOR: 6
ANDERSON: 5
A.CAMPBELL: 6
LEABURN: 5
GODDEN: 6.5
WATSON: 6
SMALL: 6
BERRY: 8
Referee: 7
R.E.G.: 6
A.MITCHELL: 7.5
GILLESPHEY: 5
EDWARDS: 6
COVENTRY: 6
TAYLOR: 6.5
ANDERSON: 4.5
A.CAMPBELL: 5.5
LEABURN: 6
GODDEN: 6
WATSON: 6
SMALL: 6.5
BERRY: 8
Referee: 7
R.E.G.: 6 Steady but then let's himself down with aimless long balls
A.MITCHELL: 7 Steady and covered well
GILLESPHEY: 6 Slow on the turn
EDWARDS: 4 Distribution and control poor.
COVENTRY: 4 Worst I've seen in a game. Keep the ball on the floor as passing was poor.
TAYLOR: 4 Not effective a free kicks were poor in their delivery
ANDERSON: 2 Why take a throw to a player who cannot shield and cannot pass.
A.CAMPBELL: 4 No industry albeit twice got into position where others should have passed for him to score.
LEABURN: 4 Weak and poor all round. Keep it simple when all the flicks don't come off.
GODDEN: 4 Not involved enough
WATSON: 6 Steady
SMALL: 4 Has talent but not enough nous.
BERRY: 8 2 x excellent finishes
Referee:7 Ok
R.E.G.: 4
A.MITCHELL 6
GILLESPHEY: 4
EDWARDS: 5
COVENTRY: 5
TAYLOR: 5
ANDERSON: 4
A.CAMPBELL: 4
LEABURN: 5.5
GODDEN: 5
WATSON: 5
SMALL: 5
BERRY: 7 MotM. Very good finishes.
R.E.G.: 4
A.MITCHELL 6
GILLESPHEY: 4
EDWARDS: 5
COVENTRY: 5
TAYLOR: 5
ANDERSON: 4
A.CAMPBELL: 4
LEABURN: 5.5
GODDEN: 5
WATSON: 5
SMALL: 5
BERRY: 7 MotM. Very good finishes.
R.E.G.: 6
A.MITCHELL: 6
GILLESPHEY: 4
EDWARDS: 6
COVENTRY: 6
TAYLOR: 6
ANDERSON: 4
A.CAMPBELL: 4
LEABURN: 5 stop with the greed man
GODDEN: 5.5
WATSON: 5
SMALL: 6
BERRY: 8
Referee: 6 Seen worse all season.
T.Campbell: n/a Should be getting at least 35 mins off the bench. Changed our game.
MANNION; 6
R.E.G.: 5.5
A.MITCHELL: 7
GILLESPHEY: 5
EDWARDS: 6
COVENTRY: 6
TAYLOR: 7
ANDERSON: 4
A.CAMPBELL: 4.5
LEABURN: 7 (+ 1 for save)
GODDEN: 6
WATSON: 6
SMALL: 7
BERRY: 8
REF: 8
R.E.G.: 5
A.MITCHELL: 5.5
GILLESPHEY: 5
EDWARDS: 4.5
COVENTRY: 5.5
TAYLOR: 5.5
ANDERSON: 4.5
A.CAMPBELL: 4
LEABURN: 5
GODDEN: 5
WATSON: 5
SMALL: 5.5
BERRY: 7.5
Ref: 8
R.E.G.: 5
A.MITCHELL: 7
GILLESPHEY: 4
EDWARDS: 5
COVENTRY: 5
TAYLOR: 5
ANDERSON: 4
A.CAMPBELL: 5
LEABURN: 5
GODDEN: 5
WATSON: 5
SMALL: 5
BERRY: 9
Referee: 5
R.E.G.: 6 did okay, body position is bad when he is left one on one, which is a big issue.
A.MITCHELL: 5 didn't think he was that good, was shakey on the goal, gave the ball away needless.
GILLESPHEY: 4 was very poor, and I think should have got a block for the ball.. Some very bad passes, which on another day would have cost us.
EDWARDS: 6 was okay, needs to improve on crossing, little between him and Small for me.
COVENTRY: 4 I would go to say, that was the worse Charlton performance, I am huge fan, but I thought he was poor last night, gave the ball away time after time, which is unlike him. Hopefully just a blip.
TAYLOR: 6 was good on the ball again, happy to take the ball in tight areas and under pressure. He does look for more forward passes, but I would like him to really stamp his mark on the game and on this team
ANDERSON: 5 was okay, maybe slightly unlucky to be taken off rather than Campbell. For me, they are pretty much the same, run a lot, little quality.
A.CAMPBELL: 5 as mentioned above run a lot, little quality
LEABURN: 6 frustrating night Leaburn, some great stuff, and some poor stuff. For me, a little too greedy.. Also get the impression he isn't the most popular, and I thought this on Saturday..
GODDEN: 6 had a couple of good chances, and should have taken one, but he is smart in movement, and some of his touches.
WATSON: 6 did okay when he come on.
SMALL: 6 did okay, again crossing not great.
BERRY: 8 thought won us the game, with two smart finishes.
Referee: 7 was okay, looked world class from the referee performance on Saturday.
T.Campbell: n/a
R.E.G.: 5
A.MITCHELL: 5.5
GILLESPHEY: 4.5
EDWARDS: 5.5
COVENTRY: 5.5
TAYLOR: 6
ANDERSON: 5
A.CAMPBELL: 4.5
LEABURN: 6
GODDEN: 5.5
WATSON: 5.5
SMALL: 6.5
BERRY: 8
Referee: 7
R.E.G.: 6
A.MITCHELL: 5
GILLESPHEY: 5
EDWARDS: 5
COVENTRY: 7
TAYLOR: 6
ANDERSON: 5
A.CAMPBELL: 5
LEABURN: 6
GODDEN: 6
WATSON: 6
SMALL: 6
BERRY: 8
Referee: 7
R.E.G.: 6
A.MITCHELL: 5.5
GILLESPHEY: 5
EDWARDS: 5
COVENTRY: 5
TAYLOR: 5.5
ANDERSON: 5
A.CAMPBELL: 5
LEABURN: 6
GODDEN: 6
WATSON: 5.5
SMALL: 5.5
BERRY: 8
Referee: 7
MANNION; 6 - Forgot how to hold onto the ball, not just the goal but a few cross in he chose to punch.
R.E.G.: 5 - Early booking, disappeared after
A.MITCHELL: 6 - One CB doing the job of 2
GILLESPHEY: 4 - Can we have the other Mitchell or Potts in please. Thank you.
EDWARDS: 5 - Yet to see the attacking crosser that was playing in Scotland
COVENTRY: 6 - His usual self, just dont try and pass forward, its not worth surrendering possession
TAYLOR: 6 - Another promising display, tired, harsh criticism for the goal as its a legacy issue of ours.
ANDERSON: 4 - Nothing worth mentioning over than totally ineffective
A.CAMPBELL: 5 - see above, gets the extra mark for winning a couple of fouls and 2 good passing moves.
LEABURN: 6 - Tried to go it alone a bit too much, hopefully just rustiness.
GODDEN: 6 - Goal threat(ish) knows how to get shots off, just dont give him enough opportunities to do it...
WATSON: 6 - Better than REG at RB
SMALL: 6.5 - Better than Edwards at LB, hopefully over his little tiff and back to last seasons player
BERRY: 7 - Maybe not some sort of league one Brazilian but not far off, best attacking mid at the club so how about stating him some more eh?
Referee: 7 - Was too numbed by our performance to notice him, which probably means he was pretty good!
T.Campbell: n/a
R.E.G.: 6
A.MITCHELL: 6
GILLESPHEY: 5
EDWARDS: 5
COVENTRY: 6
TAYLOR: 6
ANDERSON: 5
A.CAMPBELL: 5
LEABURN: 6
GODDEN: 6
WATSON: 7
SMALL: 6.5
BERRY: 8
Referee: 7
R.E.G.: 5
A.MITCHELL: 6
GILLESPHEY: 5
EDWARDS: 6
COVENTRY: 6
TAYLOR: 6
ANDERSON: 5
A.CAMPBELL: 4
LEABURN: 6
GODDEN: 6
WATSON: 6
SMALL: 6
BERRY: 8
Referee: 7
R.E.G.: 4
A.MITCHELL: 6
GILLESPHEY: 4
EDWARDS: 5
COVENTRY: 6
TAYLOR: 5
ANDERSON: 4
A.CAMPBELL: 4
LEABURN: 5.5
GODDEN: 5.5
WATSON: 5
SMALL: 6
BERRY: 7.5
R.E.G.: 5
A.MITCHELL: 5
GILLESPHEY: 5
EDWARDS: 5
COVENTRY: 6
TAYLOR: 6
ANDERSON: 5
A.CAMPBELL: 6
LEABURN: 6
GODDEN: 6
WATSON: 7
SMALL: 7
BERRY: 8
R.E.G.: 6
A.MITCHELL: 6.5
GILLESPHEY: 6.5
EDWARDS: 6
COVENTRY: 6.5
TAYLOR: 6.5
ANDERSON: 4.5
A.CAMPBELL: 4.5
LEABURN: 6
GODDEN: 6
WATSON: 6
SMALL: 6
BERRY: 8
Referee: 7