Manager rating Division One

stonemuse

Division One manager ranking 

https://x.com/3rdtierefl/status/1816544530868654424?s=46&t=Qjo0N44k_sCWGieSZzHjRQ

based on the experience, the budget the manager gets and how the poster feels if the manager will get on if they will succeed their expectations this season 

Scoham

Apparently Birmingham will exceed all expectations and get promoted…

AFKABartram

Saw a similar one last week with Jones about 14th 

oohaahmortimer

Our nutbag NJ to me could genuinely be 1 or 24 
I just don’t know 
I think he’s crackers but if he gets a wind behind him it could be a brilliant season
but IF things go pear shaped I can see it all unraveling quickly and the crank will be gone before you can say Llanfairpwllgwyngyllgogerychwyrndrobwllllantysiliogogogoch

thenewbie

oohaahmortimer said:

Our nutbag NJ to me could genuinely be 1 or 24 
I just don’t know 
I think he’s crackers but if he gets a wind behind him it could be a brilliant season
but IF things go pear shaped I can see it all unraveling quickly and the crank will be gone before you can say Llanfairpwllgwyngyllgogerychwyrndrobwllllantysiliogogogoch

In some ways he's got certain similarities to Bowyer - a very intense style and leans heavily on the personality of the manager. When it works out it works very well, if things go slightly wrong it can get quite a lot worse very quickly.

On the other hand, almost all of the signings so far seem to be in the mold Jones likes and several have already worked with him so I'm optimistic that it will all come together well.

That or he's gone by Christmas 😂 

golfaddick

There are a lot of good & experienced managers on that list.

Lincsaddick

Clough @ 22 ? .. presumably as he 'only' manages a newly promoted club 

Lincsaddick

oohaahmortimer said:

Our nutbag NJ to me could genuinely be 1 or 24 
I just don’t know 
I think he’s crackers but if he gets a wind behind him it could be a brilliant season
but IF things go pear shaped I can see it all unraveling quickly and the crank will be gone before you can say Llanfairpwllgwyngyllgogerychwyrndrobwllllantysiliogogogoch

easy for you (and Jones N) to say 

DyerConsequences

Critchley, Davies, Caldwell and Selles too high in my opinion. Challinor, Brady and Clough way too low.

DyerConsequences

An alternative one.

I think this is better, though not sure what Monk has done to justify being that high. Brady and Clough I'd also have a little higher, with Parkinson and Critchley also lower.

MintoHumbugs

The way NJ turned Charlton around after Appleton had turned them into serial losers must put him in top 3.

Stig

"based on the experience, the budget the manager gets and how the poster feels if the manager will get on if they will succeed their expectations this season"

Never did such a superficially objective looking list, turn out to be so pathetically subjective. Might as well have put the names in a hat and drawn them out at random.

ForeverAddickted

Not sure I'd have Dave Challinor top - Seeing he's untested at this level.

Jones and Evans make sense (with the former ahead of Evans) seeing that one has a League One title, the other has won promotion via. the Play-Offs - Then again Phil Parkinson has two promotions from this level.