Jscore: 8 mark of a good manager is what is done at half time, very pleased to see the results 2nd half Isted: 7 Thomas: 5 poor game nothing went right Hector: 7 Gillesphey: 5 poor for their goal Small: 8 Coventry: 6 Dobson: 10 lovely job George🤞 Edun: 2 Anderson: 8 Wickham: 8 May: 7 Ramsay: 8 Kanu: 8 Aneke: 7 Referee: 7
Jscore: 5 - Lop-sided set up that took until half time to correct Isted: 4.5 - Instills no confidence Thomas: 4.5 - Poor game Hector: 6.5 - Held the back line together Gillesphey: 5 - Seems to struggle every match Small: 5 - Very quiet game Coventry: 5 - Never shirked, but generally poor Dobson: 8 - Just gets better and better; our loss... Edun: 4 - I don't know why he is ever near the first team - offers nothing Anderson: 4.5 - He's not playing well and missed a sitter Wickham: 5.5 - Slow and awkward May: 5 - Didn't work for Alfie today - was he ill? Ramsay: 5.5 - Gave balance but some uncomfortable moments Kanu: 6 - Tried hard Aneke: 6 - Bullied them Referee: 6 - He was OK but his linos were awful
Jscore: 6 Strange line up to start...better balance and energy second half Isted: 5 Should have gone off for that tackle Thomas: 5 Poor guy has to play on his weak side and it showed Hector: 5.5 Just hacking the ball skywards time and again Gillesphey: 5 One too many poor performing CBs Small: 6.5 Better when allowed to play his normal game Coventry: 4.5 Game passed him by and awful effort on goal Dobson: 7.5 Pushed forward better second half and good goal Edun: 4 Out of position, out of salts, out the door Anderson: 7 Lots of energy and effort throughout, just needs to settle better on the ball Wickham: 6.5 No service but held the ball well when he could and lovely through ball for the goal May: 6 No service and bullied a bit by their big CBs Ramsay: 7 Instant impact, gave the side balance and went forward with intent Kanu: 6 Lots of effort but needs to bulk up a bit Aneke: 6.5 Trundles about and always offers a threat Referee: 7 Extra mark for the Isted yellow, his East Stand lino was a pain
Jscore: 5 but appreciate he's now in 'trying stuff for next season' mode. It didn't work. Isted: 5 kamikaze Thomas: 5 good attacking runs, brave, too many mistakes Hector: 5 has presence, but not demanding as he was in his 2-game purple patch Gillesphey: 4.5 average is being generous Small: 6 a threat Coventry: 4 worst game he's had for us Dobson: 7 MoM nicely taken Edun: 4 added nothing Anderson: 4.5 we're relying too much on this kid Wickham: 6.5 creditable assist and effort, but didn't impact the first half enough May: 6.5 as always, ran himself ragged and looked the only real threat Ramsay: 6.5 assured Kanu: 5 ran about without adding a lot Aneke: 5 outperformed by Wickham Referee: 5 generous to us. On another day both Isted and Coventry could've been in trouble.
Jscore: 3. Think hes done a good job. BUT, style far too slow passing the ball. Players always looking to play sideways or backwards. Poor team selection to start Isted: 4. Doesn't seem a top rate keeper even at league 1 level Thomas: 3. Passing atrocious Hector: 5.5. Better than other two. Gillesphey: 3. Apart from a good left foot, he looks very poor. Too slow, turning circle of an oil tanker. Pathetic in defending for the goal Small: 5.5. Not his best game, but strong and fast. We should definitely keep him Coventry: 4.5. Not great though don't think he's as bad as many do Dobson: 8. Head and shoulders above anyone else. Edun: 3. Really disappointed with this bloke. Doesn't seem to have anything. Nowhere near as good as Small. WTF did Jones play him on the right/at all? Anderson: 5.5. One of the better performers Wickham: 5. Slightly disappointed. Looks a bit rusty (no surprise). Poor service. One sublime pass for goal. May: 5. Didn't really work with him and Wickham. Maybe give it time. Should never have come off. Keep hauling him off, he'll want to be off!! Ramsay: 6. Like this bloke. Strong and fast Kanu: 5. Didn't really get into it, but I think generally he is improving Aneke: 5. OK for 30 mins. His best bit of work was when he shot from a silly angle when he should have squared it. Referee: 1. Gave everything to them. Thought him and one linesman were on the Shrewsbury payroll.
Jscore: 5 Very odd starting formation that was a complete failure, and taking May off is a mistake. Alfie is always our best chance of scoring and his energy levels mean he keeps going to the end. I also think a change from Anderson is needed.
Isted: 5 Not very re-assuring at all. He makes me nervous and I am sure he makes the defence nervous too. What the hell was he doing when he got yellow carded? We definitely need an upgrade. Thomas: 5.5 Played on the wrong side of the defence. Won lots of headers but his passing was very poor even by his standards. Hector: 6 Best defender, but that bar is very low. Gillesphey: 5 Not convinced by him yet. Small: 6 Did well. A proper wing-back. Coventry: 5 Very poor. Even his dead-ball kicks were awful. A replacement for Dobson? - You're having a laugh! Dobson: 7 Well deserved goal in his last home game. Lots of energy and effort as usual. MOM Edun: 5 Good for about first 10 minutes and then disappeared. Rightly subbed at half time. Anderson: 5.5 Lots of effort but gives the ball away too often. Should have buried the free header. Wickham: 6.5 Great pass for Dobbo. Worked hard on the scraps he was given May: 6 The usual level of effort. I have no idea why Jones has been subbing him recently. He is always our best chance of a goal so leave him on the pitch unless he is injured! Ramsay: 6 A few dodgy defensive moments but a huge upgrade on Edun when he came on. Kanu: 6 Lots of effort and did okay when he came on. Aneke: 5 Didn't do much. Should have passed when he blazed over.
Referee: 6 One of the better refs we have had (but that particular bar is so low it's practically on the floor). The lino by the Curbs stand looked to give at least two throw ins when the ball hadn't fully crossed the line. It's the whole of the ball mate!
Jscore: 4.5 - an odd formation and team selection but at least he belatedly changed it when we went behind. I don’t know why he took our principal goal threat, Alfie May, off - I thought he could have been deployed just behind Aneke and Kanu to good effect Isted: 4 - doesn’t command his area and rarely comes for a cross. Poor kicking, poor judgment and little communication with his defenders. There’s a reason why he had played so few league games at his age when he came to us Thomas: 4 - I like his determination and commitment but his distribution was awful Hector: 5 - back to his old tricks after a handful of good games. Really poor defending (amongst others) for Shrewsbury’s goal. Distribution generally poor Gillesphey: 4.5 - looks slow and cumbersome. Very unconvincing (more ineptitude from Andy Scott, I assume - thus it ever was) Small: 6 - beat his man and got to the byeline a few times and laid on the best chance of the second half for Anderson Coventry: 4.5 - does practically nothing for us when we are out of possession and little when he has the ball. A big improvement is required Dobson: 7: MoTM - a lovely goal and a typically committed and energetic performance. Who is going to put out the fires in midfield once he’s gone ? If the rumours about Scott are true, I cannot see how his position at the club is tenable, particularly given his lamentable record over three windows Edun: 5 - started in midfield and then switched to right back. Another poor signing that we’re stuck with Anderson: 6 - got stuck in and produced an energetic performance, albeit without any real end product. Missed our best chance of the second half Wickham: 6 - battled well against the dominant Dunkley and his colleagues and produced an excellent assist for Dobbo. His big problem is lack of mobility May: 6.5 - produced our only moment of quality in the first half with an audacious chip from a tight angle. Always looking to get things moving and I was disappointed to see him taken off (I have no doubt that Shrewsbury were pleased to see the back of him) Ramsay: 6 - brought some balance to the side Kanu: 6 - some good movement and pace down the right channel Aneke: 5.5 - found it difficult to make an impact and selfishly shot into the side netting from an acute angle when the situation cried out for a low cross into the six-yard box Referee: 6 - not a difficult game to referee and did ok.
Jscore: 2 got it wrong today playing diamond system pick the tight players Isted: 6 Thomas: 6 Hector: 7 Gillesphey: 8 Small: 6 Coventry: 6 Dobson: 5 Edun: 4 Anderson: 4 missed a sitter as well Wickham: 6 May: 6 Ramsay: 6 Kanu: 6 Aneke: 5 Referee 2 awful how he missed the pen fir the foul on Kanu
Are those the ones who’ve been on the piss the night before?
Comments
Isted: 4.5 - Instills no confidence
Thomas: 4.5 - Poor game
Hector: 6.5 - Held the back line together
Gillesphey: 5 - Seems to struggle every match
Small: 5 - Very quiet game
Coventry: 5 - Never shirked, but generally poor
Dobson: 8 - Just gets better and better; our loss...
Edun: 4 - I don't know why he is ever near the first team - offers nothing
Anderson: 4.5 - He's not playing well and missed a sitter
Wickham: 5.5 - Slow and awkward
May: 5 - Didn't work for Alfie today - was he ill?
Ramsay: 5.5 - Gave balance but some uncomfortable moments
Kanu: 6 - Tried hard
Aneke: 6 - Bullied them
Referee: 6 - He was OK but his linos were awful
Thomas: 4
Hector: 4
Gillesphey: 4
Small: 6
Coventry: 4
Dobson: 7
Edun: 4
Anderson: 6
Wickham: 6
May: 6
Ramsay: 5
Kanu: 6
Aneke: 4
Isted: 5
Thomas: 5
Hector: 6.5
Gillesphey: 7
Small: 6.5
Coventry: 6
Dobson: 7
Edun: 4
Anderson: 6.5
Wickham: 6.5
May: 7
Ramsay: 6.5
Kanu: 6
Aneke: 5.5
Referee: 5
Isted: 5
Thomas: 5
Hector: 6
Gillesphey: 6
Small: 6
Coventry: 5
Dobson: 7
Edun: 5.5
Anderson: 6
Wickham: 6.5
May: 6
Ramsay: 6.5
Kanu: 6
Aneke: 5.5
Referee: 5
Isted: 4.5
Thomas: 4.5
Hector: 5
Gillesphey: 6
Small: 7.5
Coventry: 5
Dobson: 7.5
Edun: 5
Anderson: 6
Wickham: 6
May: 6
Ramsay: 6.5
Kanu: 6.5
Aneke: 5
Referee: 4
Isted: 5
Thomas: 3
Hector: 6
Gillesphey: 6.5
Small: 6
Coventry: 5.5
Dobson: 7.5
Edun: 4
Anderson: 5
Wickham: 4
May: 5.5
Ramsay: 7
Kanu: 5
Aneke: 5.5
Isted: 4
Thomas: 3
Hector: 4
Gillesphey: 4
Small: 5
Coventry: 5
Dobson: 6.5
Edun: 4
Anderson: 5
Wickham: 6
May: 5
Ramsay: 6
Kanu: 5
Aneke: 4
Referee: 7
Isted: 4.5
Thomas: 5.5
Hector: 6
Gillesphey: 5.5
Small: 6
Coventry: 5
Dobson: 7.5
Edun: 4.5
Anderson: 5.5
Wickham: 6
May: 6.5
Ramsay: 6
Kanu: 5.5
Aneke: 5.5
Referee: 5
Isted: 6
Thomas: 5.5
Hector: 6
Gillesphey: 6
Small: 7
Coventry: 5
Dobson: 6.5
Edun: 6
Anderson: 6
Wickham: 5
May: 6
Ramsay: 6
Kanu: 6
Aneke: 6.5
Referee: 5.5
Isted: 5 Should have gone off for that tackle
Thomas: 5 Poor guy has to play on his weak side and it showed
Hector: 5.5 Just hacking the ball skywards time and again
Gillesphey: 5 One too many poor performing CBs
Small: 6.5 Better when allowed to play his normal game
Coventry: 4.5 Game passed him by and awful effort on goal
Dobson: 7.5 Pushed forward better second half and good goal
Edun: 4 Out of position, out of salts, out the door
Anderson: 7 Lots of energy and effort throughout, just needs to settle better on the ball
Wickham: 6.5 No service but held the ball well when he could and lovely through ball for the goal
May: 6 No service and bullied a bit by their big CBs
Ramsay: 7 Instant impact, gave the side balance and went forward with intent
Kanu: 6 Lots of effort but needs to bulk up a bit
Aneke: 6.5 Trundles about and always offers a threat
Referee: 7 Extra mark for the Isted yellow, his East Stand lino was a pain
Isted: 4. Doesn't seem a top rate keeper even at league 1 level
Thomas: 3. Passing atrocious
Hector: 5.5. Better than other two.
Gillesphey: 3. Apart from a good left foot, he looks very poor. Too slow, turning circle of an oil tanker. Pathetic in defending for the goal
Small: 5.5. Not his best game, but strong and fast. We should definitely keep him
Coventry: 4.5. Not great though don't think he's as bad as many do
Dobson: 8. Head and shoulders above anyone else.
Edun: 3. Really disappointed with this bloke. Doesn't seem to have anything. Nowhere near as good as Small. WTF did Jones play him on the right/at all?
Anderson: 5.5. One of the better performers
Wickham: 5. Slightly disappointed. Looks a bit rusty (no surprise). Poor service. One sublime pass for goal.
May: 5. Didn't really work with him and Wickham. Maybe give it time. Should never have come off. Keep hauling him off, he'll want to be off!!
Ramsay: 6. Like this bloke. Strong and fast
Kanu: 5. Didn't really get into it, but I think generally he is improving
Aneke: 5. OK for 30 mins. His best bit of work was when he shot from a silly angle when he should have squared it.
Referee: 1. Gave everything to them. Thought him and one linesman were on the Shrewsbury payroll.
Isted: 5
Thomas: 5
Hector: 5.5
Gillesphey: 5
Small: 7
Coventry: 4.5
Dobson: 7.5
Edun: 5
Anderson: 5.5
Wickham: 6
May: 6
Ramsay: 6
Kanu: 6
Aneke: 5.5
Referee: 6
Isted: 4
Thomas: 4
Hector: 4.5
Gillesphey: 4
Small: 5.5
Coventry: 5
Dobson: 8
Edun: 4
Anderson: 6
Wickham: 6
May: 6.5
Ramsay: 6
Kanu: 6.5
Aneke: 6
Referee: 4
Jscore: 5 Very odd starting formation that was a complete failure, and taking May off is a mistake. Alfie is always our best chance of scoring and his energy levels mean he keeps going to the end. I also think a change from Anderson is needed.
Isted: 5 Not very re-assuring at all. He makes me nervous and I am sure he makes the defence nervous too. What the hell was he doing when he got yellow carded? We definitely need an upgrade.
Thomas: 5.5 Played on the wrong side of the defence. Won lots of headers but his passing was very poor even by his standards.
Hector: 6 Best defender, but that bar is very low.
Gillesphey: 5 Not convinced by him yet.
Small: 6 Did well. A proper wing-back.
Coventry: 5 Very poor. Even his dead-ball kicks were awful. A replacement for Dobson? - You're having a laugh!
Dobson: 7 Well deserved goal in his last home game. Lots of energy and effort as usual. MOM
Edun: 5 Good for about first 10 minutes and then disappeared. Rightly subbed at half time.
Anderson: 5.5 Lots of effort but gives the ball away too often. Should have buried the free header.
Wickham: 6.5 Great pass for Dobbo. Worked hard on the scraps he was given
May: 6 The usual level of effort. I have no idea why Jones has been subbing him recently. He is always our best chance of a goal so leave him on the pitch unless he is injured!
Ramsay: 6 A few dodgy defensive moments but a huge upgrade on Edun when he came on.
Kanu: 6 Lots of effort and did okay when he came on.
Aneke: 5 Didn't do much. Should have passed when he blazed over.
Referee: 6 One of the better refs we have had (but that particular bar is so low it's practically on the floor). The lino by the Curbs stand looked to give at least two throw ins when the ball hadn't fully crossed the line. It's the whole of the ball mate!
Isted: 4
Thomas: 5
Hector: 7
Gillesphey: 6
Small: 7
Coventry: 4
Dobson: 6
Edun: 5
Anderson: 6
Wickham: 7
May: 6
Ramsay: 6.5
Kanu: 6
Aneke: 5
Isted: 4 - doesn’t command his area and rarely comes for a cross. Poor kicking, poor judgment and little communication with his defenders. There’s a reason why he had played so few league games at his age when he came to us
Thomas: 4 - I like his determination and commitment but his distribution was awful
Hector: 5 - back to his old tricks after a handful of good games. Really poor defending (amongst others) for Shrewsbury’s goal. Distribution generally poor
Gillesphey: 4.5 - looks slow and cumbersome. Very unconvincing (more ineptitude from Andy Scott, I assume - thus it ever was)
Small: 6 - beat his man and got to the byeline a few times and laid on the best chance of the second half for Anderson
Coventry: 4.5 - does practically nothing for us when we are out of possession and little when he has the ball. A big improvement is required
Dobson: 7: MoTM - a lovely goal and a typically committed and energetic performance. Who is going to put out the fires in midfield once he’s gone ? If the rumours about Scott are true, I cannot see how his position at the club is tenable, particularly given his lamentable record over three windows
Edun: 5 - started in midfield and then switched to right back. Another poor signing that we’re stuck with
Anderson: 6 - got stuck in and produced an energetic performance, albeit without any real end product. Missed our best chance of the second half
Wickham: 6 - battled well against the dominant Dunkley and his colleagues and produced an excellent assist for Dobbo. His big problem is lack of mobility
May: 6.5 - produced our only moment of quality in the first half with an audacious chip from a tight angle. Always looking to get things moving and I was disappointed to see him taken off (I have no doubt that Shrewsbury were pleased to see the back of him)
Ramsay: 6 - brought some balance to the side
Kanu: 6 - some good movement and pace down the right channel
Aneke: 5.5 - found it difficult to make an impact and selfishly shot into the side netting from an acute angle when the situation cried out for a low cross into the six-yard box
Referee: 6 - not a difficult game to referee and did ok.