Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Charlton v Northampton (closes Wednesday teatime)

2

Comments

  • Ascore: 5
    AMB: 6
    REG: 6
    JONES; 4.5
    GILLESPHEY: 5.5
    T.WATSON: 4
    COVENTRY: 6
    DOBSON: 5
    BAKINSON: 5
    EDUN: 5
    MAY: 6
    LADAPO: 4
    THOMAS: 7
    Referee: 4
    FIORINI: n/a
    T.CAMPBELL: n/a
  • Ascore: 2 Probably picked a decent team but lack of substitutions awful as Lapado was awful all game, Bakinson was knackered after an hour and Dobbo isn’t an attacking midfielder.
    AMB: 7 Made some decent saves but distribution slow and poor
    REG: 5 Defended ok but doesn’t look to make a forward pass.
    JONES; 4 Played too deep and wasn’t winning headers
    GILLESPHEY: 6 Played well until that terrible header at the end leading to the 3rd goal.
    T.WATSON: 7.5 Good goal and our best attacking player all game.
    COVENTRY: 6 Done ok but not dominating
    DOBSON: 5 Tried as always but he’s not an attacking midfielder 
    BAKINSON: 5 (7 first half and 3 second). Constantly lost the ball due to being knackered - should have been substituted 
    EDUN: 6.5 Worked hard but his f8nal ball is crap. Unlucky to be sent off as second booking was harsh
    MAY: 4 Didn’t come off for him tonight
    LADAPO: 1 Very poor, can’t control the ball, can’t win a header and has no pace. 
    THOMAS: 8 Great second half, full of commitment and played well.
    Referee: 2 Normal crap, let the keeper time waste all game, stopped play for non injuries, shouldn’t have sent Eden off and should have given them a pen.
    FIORINI: n/a 3 Looks like a waste of space
    T.CAMPBELL: n/a 4 Got into some decent positions but delivered nothing
  • Apples 0 see ya
    Amb 6
    Reg 5.5
    Jones 5.5
    Gillespey 5.5
    T Watson 6
    Coventry 6
    Dobson 6
    Bakinson 6
    Edun 6.5
    May 5.5
    Ladapo 4.5
    Thomas 6
    Ref 3 



  • Ascore:              4.5   why no Kanu or L Watson.
    AMB:                  5.5            
    REG:                  5
    JONES;               5
    GILLESPHEY:     5     slowed up last 15 minutes 
    T.WATSON:         5.5. Extra half for goal, lightweight/bullied
    COVENTRY:        5.5. Started to dominate in 2nd half, then hooked  
    DOBSON:            6
    BAKINSON:         5.5.  Fitness issue last 15
    EDUN:                  5       Good going forward, bullied. Defensively 
    MAY:                     6      Tried hard 
     LADAPO.             3.5   two air shots when should score, not fit   
    THOMAS:             5.5
    Referee:                4
    FIORINI: n/a
    T.CAMPBELL: n/a    lost form & confidence, not progressing.

  • AMB: 6
    REG: 5
    JONES: 4
    GILLESPHEY: 5
    T.WATSON: 7
    COVENTRY: 6.5
    DOBSON: 7
    BAKINSON: 6.5
    EDUN: 6.5
    MAY: 6
    LADAPO: 5
    THOMAS: 7.5
  • At the game
    Ascore: Had to go
    AMB: 7
    REG: 6
    JONES; 6
    GILLESPHEY: 6
    T.WATSON: 6
    COVENTRY: 6
    DOBSON: 6
    BAKINSON: 7
    EDUN: 6
    MAY: 6
    LADAPO: 5
    THOMAS: 7 MOM

  • Watched on CharltonTV

    Applescore: Nope

    AMB: 5
    REG: 6
    JONES; 4
    GILLESPHEY: 6
    T.WATSON: 6
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOBSON: 7
    BAKINSON: 7
    EDUN: 6 
    MAY: 6
    LADAPO: 6
    THOMAS: 7

    Referee: 3
  • Ascore: 200%
    AMB: 6 some good saves tho got away with one 
    REG: 6 looked ok without being as pacey as I had hoped 
    JONES; 3 hopefully new gaffa can help get his form back 
    GILLESPHEY: 6 am ok 
    T.WATSON: 5.5 every time I curse him he then does some half decent
    COVENTRY: 6 good set pieces was ok
    DOBSON: 6.5 was good but seemed knackered at times too 
    BAKINSON: 6.5 a bit of the Pratleys about him 
    EDUN: 7 erratic but I like him always wanting the ball and one of few players wanting to be direct  
    MAY: 6 couldn't get it going today but always trying  
    LADAPO: 4 not what I was expecting dunno if was a case of trying to hard to score or he is genuinely just a bit of a donkey 
    THOMAS: 7 really good again our best defender of later 
    Referee: 1 what a prick 
    FIORINI: n/a not rating what I’ve seen so far defo not better than l.Watson 
    T.CAMPBELL: n/a needs a loan and we need to sign a wing back or winger 
  • Ascore:  1
    AMB:  4
    REG:  4
    JONES;  5
    GILLESPHEY:  5
    T.WATSON:  6
    COVENTRY:  4
    DOBSON: 4
    BAKINSON: 4
    EDUN:  6
    MAY: 6
    LADAPO:  5
    THOMAS:  5 
    Referee:  1.5

  • Ascore: 0
    AMB: 6
    REG: 5
    JONES; 4
    GILLESPHEY: 5
    T.WATSON: 5.5
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOBSON: 7
    BAKINSON: 5
    EDUN: 4
    MAY: 6
    LADAPO: 4
    THOMAS: 7
    Referee: 2
    FIORINI: n/a
    T.CAMPBELL: n/a

  • Sponsored links:


  • edited January 23
    Ascore: 2 At least he had the balls to sub Jones at half time. +1 for that!
    AMB: 5 One quality save but three goals against, crap distribution and a near penalty.
    REG: 5 Looked OK but not exactly eye-catching
    JONES; 3 Poor for the third consecutive game. I think he is missing Hector!
    GILLESPHEY: 5.5 Looked OK
    T.WATSON: 5 half a point for the goal
    COVENTRY: 6 Some nice touches but I hope there's more to come.
    DOBSON: 6 Looks like he cares, unlike some out there.
    BAKINSON: 5.5Hit and miss
    EDUN: 5 Never a sending off
    MAY: 6 He get points for his work rate but didn't look convincing
    LADAPO: 4 Off the pace.
    THOMAS: 6.5 Why didn't he start? Best defender in the last few games
    Referee: 3 Started OK but some baffling decisions later on.
    FIORINI: Surely more to come from him. 
    T.CAMPBELL: Out of position and oout of form.
  • edited January 24
    Ascore: 2
    AMB: 6 Couple of great saves that seem to have gone unnoticed. 
    REG: 6 Not sure. Good at times. 
    JONES; 3 People have raved about him while slagging off Hector, at a time when Hector was great and Jones was giving away goals left right and centre. I’ve been proved right for once. Off form.
    GILLESPHEY: 6 
    T.WATSON: 6 Best game from him, out of the blue. Fired up second half. Good goal.
    COVENTRY: 6
    DOBSON: 6 Fired up
    BAKINSON: 6.5 Not as good as last 2 games
    EDUN: 6 A bit fired up
    MAY: 6.5 Fired up. Nearly scored 
    LADAPO: 6 Not fit. He was better at Burton. 
    THOMAS: 7 Good again. Why did Appleton drop him?!
    Referee: 4 Hilarious. Got Edun decision wrong. Think he actually got the AMB incident right. 
  • Ascore: 4
    AMB: 5
    REG: 7
    JONES; 4
    GILLESPHEY: 7
    T.WATSON:  6
    COVENTRY: 6.5
    DOBSON:  7
    BAKINSON:  6.5
    EDUN: 6
    MAY: 6.5
    LADAPO: 6
    THOMAS: 7
    Referee: 4
  • Ascore: 2
    AMB: 5
    REG: 5
    JONES; 4
    GILLESPHEY: 5
    T.WATSON: 4
    COVENTRY: 5
    DOBSON: 6
    BAKINSON: 5
    EDUN: 6
    MAY: 5
    LADAPO: 4
    THOMAS: 6
    Referee: 3
    FIORINI: n/a
    T.CAMPBELL: n/a
  • edited January 24
    Ascore: 5
    AMB: 6
    REG: 5
    JONES; 5
    GILLESPHEY: 5
    T.WATSON: 5
    COVENTRY: 6
    DOBSON: 5.5
    BAKINSON: 5
    EDUN: 7
    MAY: 6
    LADAPO: 4
    THOMAS: 6
    Referee: 2

  • At the Valley

    AMB: 6
    REG: 5
    JONES; 5
    GILLESPHEY: 5
    T.WATSON: 5.5
    COVENTRY: 5
    DOBSON: 5.5
    BAKINSON: 6
    EDUN: 5
    MAY: 6
    LADAPO: 5
    THOMAS: 6
  • Ascore: 4
    AMB: 6 
    REG: 5
    JONES; 4
    GILLESPHEY: 5
    T.WATSON: 6
    COVENTRY: 5 
    DOBSON: 5
    BAKINSON: 5
    EDUN: 6
    MAY: 7
    LADAPO:  5
    THOMAS: 7 
    Referee: 3
  • At the game

    AMB: 6
    REG: 5.5
    JONES; 5.5
    GILLESPHEY: 5.5
    T.WATSON: 6
    COVENTRY: 6
    DOBSON: 6
    BAKINSON: 6.5
    EDUN: 6
    MAY: 6
    LADAPO: 5
    THOMAS: 7
    Referee: 5

  • AMB: 5 worrying performance. Good on shots but no longer believes in his own decision making.
    REG: 6, 
    JONES; 4, to mark someone you have to be closer than 5 yards - especially when he is standing on the penalty spot. Simples.
    GILLESPHEY: 5, have to be honest and say I can’t rember anything he did. He was therefore exceptionally good or was never involved.
    T.WATSON: 7. Good goal and supported well. New system should suit him.
    COVENTRY: 8, when he gets match fit he is going to run the show.
    DOBSON: 8, please don’t let him go
    BAKINSON: 6, Not fit but some good signs
    EDUN: 6, OK. Never a sending off. Needs to be more decisive in the last third.
    MAY: 6, one pissed off player. Any new manager will suit him
    LADAPO: 5, Clearly not match fit, but you can see he is a handful.
    THOMAS: 8 really impressed with his performance. Hope to see him make that position his own.
    Referee: 4, Shocking performance, penalty missed for both sides and hopelessly wrong for the red.

  • Ascore: 0 - see ya!
    AMB: 5 one real save of note, but lucky with the pen, provides the deference no confidences 
    REG: 5 was okay, slow on the ball, tired towards the end.. Not sure he is any better than Ness.
    JONES; 2 terrible again, passing all over the place, 100% his fault for the first goal, and 2nd goal he should be stepping out.. Just heading a ball doesn't make a good defender these days.
    GILLESPHEY: 6 was actually good, but not going to make anyone about 6.. passing range was good.
    T.WATSON: 6 was okay this week, but also stupid decision making.
    COVENTRY: 6 adds a little bit of control, but not sure if him or Dobbo are better at the base.
    DOBSON: 6 does okay in the more advance role, but as above is that the better position
    BAKINSON: 6 worked hard, got in to good positions, but lacked composure 
    EDUN: 5 really not sure, worked hard, but why does he always make mistake in doing the simple stuff
    MAY: 6 worked hard, is getting frustrated, having to create his own chances 
    LADAPO: 4 rusty, he is getting in to positions, only a matter of time
    THOMAS: 6 did well, and looked more solid.
    Referee: 
    FIORINI: n/a
    T.CAMPBELL: n/a
  • Sponsored links:


  • Ascore: 1 - For actually finding the way out...(and don't come back!)
    AMB: 7 - Couple of excellent saves
    REG: 5.5 - Difficult debut, did some things well
    JONES; 4.5 - Generally poor
    GILLESPHEY: 6 - Will be better when he knows everyone's name
    T.WATSON: 4 - He is awful (extra point for the goal)
    COVENTRY: 5 - Tried but difficult when we have so little ahead of him
    DOBSON: 5 - His last home game I think; nothing much worked 
    BAKINSON: 4.5 - Withdrawn from the more forward role he played so well last home game for some reason, unsuccessfully!
    EDUN: 3 - He gives the ball away every time; will be good to have an alternative now
    MAY: 5 - Almost won it but mostly poor
    LADAPO: 6 - Tried hard but no understanding with May
    THOMAS: 6.5 - Did OK (loved that he was clapping along to the Appleton out song 1st half!, but why pushed so far forward after Edun red?
    Referee: 7 - Better than a lot that we've had; let a lot go
  • AMB: 4
    REG: 4
    JONES; 3
    GILLESPHEY: 3
    T.WATSON: 4.5
    COVENTRY: 4
    DOBSON: 3
    BAKINSON: 4.5
    EDUN: 4
    MAY: 4
    LADAPO: 4
    THOMAS: 5
    Referee: 2

  • Ascore: bye bye 
    AMB: 5
    REG: 6
    JONES; 3
    GILLESPHEY: 5.5
    T.WATSON: 4
    COVENTRY: 5
    DOBSON: 5
    BAKINSON: 5.5
    EDUN: 5
    MAY: 6
    LADAPO: 4
    THOMAS: 7
    Referee: 4
    FIORINI: n/a
    T.CAMPBELL: n/a

  • Ascore: 5
    AMB: 6
    REG: 5.5
    JONES; 5
    GILLESPHEY: 6
    T.WATSON: 4
    COVENTRY: 6
    DOBSON: 6
    BAKINSON: 7
    EDUN: 6
    MAY: 6
    LADAPO: 5
    THOMAS: 6.5
    Referee: 4
    FIORINI: n/a
    T.CAMPBELL: n/a
  • Ascore: 2
    AMB: 6 one save was pretty spectacular (needs a better GK coach to help work on other areas of his game - still young and his shot stopping can be top drawer)
    REG: 6 encouraged 
    JONES; 5 needs an injection of confidence from a new manager
    GILLESPHEY: 7 encouraged 
    T.WATSON: 3 Squad player for the rest of the season at best please
    COVENTRY: 6 Tidy and worked hard - would have kept him on
    DOBSON: 6 Tried but role unnatural 
    BAKINSON: 5 Expect more from him 
    EDUN: 6 Progressive and unlucky but needs to be a bit more savvy
    MAY: 6 worked hard and his next goal will come soon 
    LADAPO: 6 A different style player than I had expected, but with the right formation and supply line could be very dangerous 
    THOMAS: 7 Did very well second half and mixed his game up well
    Referee: 5
    FIORINI: n/a
    T.CAMPBELL: n/a 
  • Ascore: 5
    AMB: 4
    REG: 5
    JONES; 3
    GILLESPHEY: 6
    T.WATSON: 6.5
    COVENTRY: 6.5
    DOBSON: 6.5
    BAKINSON: 7
    EDUN: 6.5
    MAY: 6.5
    LADAPO: 6.5
    THOMAS: 6.5
    Referee: 4
    FIORINI: n/a
    T.CAMPBELL: n/a
  • Ascore: 4
    AMB: 5
    REG: 6
    JONES; 4
    GILLESPHEY: 5
    T.WATSON: 6
    COVENTRY: 5
    DOBSON: 7
    BAKINSON: 6
    EDUN: 7
    MAY: 6
    LADAPO: 4
    THOMAS: 7
    Referee: 5
  • At the Valley:

    Ascore: 5 Bye, Michael. I can't say it has been a pleasure. Should not have started Jones or T Watson IMO, and late substitutions made us more vulnerable at the back. 

    AMB: 6 Some very good saves, but extremely lucky with the "penalty" that wasn't. Poor decision making initially. He needs to be rested.
    REG: 6 Looked okay. 
    JONES; 4 His recent form since returning from injury has been very poor. He should not have been started in favour of Thomas. Very poor (half) game.
    GILLESPHEY: 6 Looked okay but mistake for winning goal?
    T.WATSON: 5 I really struggle to see the positives that others see in him. Poor passing, poor crossing, stops and cuts back too much, poor defensively. We need better.
    COVENTRY: 6 Looks like a potentially very decent buy. Expecting much more in future.
    DOBSON: 6.5 Passing was off for much of the night, but worked his socks off as usual. If he leaves there will be a gaping hole.
    BAKINSON: 5 Doesn't look fully fit. Drifted in and out of the game too much.
    EDUN: 6 Started off very well then faded. Good going forward, not so good defensively.
    MAY: 6 Great work rate as usual, but clearly frustrated. Needs better service.
    LADAPO: 5 Doesn't look match fit. Some good hold up play, but lots of not so good. Needs a few games to get up to speed.
    THOMAS: 7 Our best defender. We looked so much better when he came on. Should have started.

    Referee: 3 Not very good at all. Fell to pieces when the pressure ramped-up. Got sending off wrong and "penalty" (but it was a long way away from where I was sat).
     
    FIORINI: n/a Looks very rusty. We looked worse when he came on.
    T.CAMPBELL: n/a Totally lacking in confidence, light-weight and poor defensively. Not a wing back though.
  • edited January 24
    Ascore: 2 - looked like an uncoached team at the back. Played off the park for the second half of the first half by a crap side.

    AMB: 5 - one great reflex save near the end, error which should have led to a penalty. Doesn't come for the ball enough, defence don't look like they trust him (Jones in particular)
    REG: 4.5 - whole defence looked shaky when ran at, and static first half, statues for their 2nd. Didn't impose himself like Jones did
    JONES; 4.5 - won his aerial stuff, looked ragged when they ran at us
    GILLESPHEY: 4.5 - couple of loose passes but fitted in with poor defence
    T.WATSON: 6 - ran and ran and won the ball back well for a few counters, just lacks the quality when he has the ball
    COVENTRY: 6 - unspectacular but looked fine
    DOBSON: 7 - only one really looking to play incisive passes and nearly connected a few times. Usual dobbo shift
    BAKINSON: 6.5 - some dodgey touches and lost the ball too much, but passed crisply and got involved in the game. Could have scored if he got the ball out of his feet
    EDUN: 8 - he was class second half, not much of a defender but my MoM. Ignoring the red card as it was him who was fouled for his second booking.
    MAY: 5.5 - not his best but trying to make things happen
    LADAPO: 4 - very poor today, made the wrong runs or didn't make them at all sometimes, touch let him down, couple of poor shot attempts. Chemistry is important and knowing what teammates will do so not writing him off at all
    THOMAS: 6.5 - defence improved when he came on, but mainly because we were on the ball more. Our best defender today though.
    Referee: 3 - big decisions all wrong, clearest penalty of all time for them and a shocker for the red card. Was waiting to give out a second yellow and wanting to give a performative yellow for diving and/or even out the clear error for his red card clouded his judgement on the pen. Game flowed okay, but didn't even look to hurry up Northampton players slowing it down second half.
    FIORINI: n/a
    T.CAMPBELL: n/a
  • AMB: 6.5 - Some very good saves, some hesitancy and was totally exposed. 
    REG: 6 - Rusty etc but I think there is a lot of promise here. 
    JONES; 5 - A couple of good things but overall he's struggling. 
    GILLESPHEY: 5.5 - Not bad in the air, nice to have a left-footer but needs games.
    T.WATSON: 6 - Did some good things and scored a neat goal. Unlucky to be subbed. 
    COVENTRY: 6 - Grew into the game and should have been left on to get used to 90 mins. 
    DOBSON: 5.5 - Tried but is very limited when it comes to forward play. 
    BAKINSON: 6 - Some good bits and another one who needs games. 
    EDUN: 6 - Unlucky red card and a couple of nice balls into the box. 
    MAY: 6 - Lots of effort and a very good low centre for the first goal. 
    LADAPO: - 5.5 I liked the timing of his runs and had one powerful shot from distance but was all over the place in front of goal. Looked well short of confidence. 
    THOMAS: 8 - Really good. Got tight, was composed and looked the part. 
    Referee: 4 - All a bit weird in the last 20 mins. In keeping with the whole affair really. 
    FIORINI: n/a - Fag-paper thin and looked a typical "Academy product" - maybe he'll surprise us by getting more involved but suspect he will need to start to make any impact.
    T.CAMPBELL: n/a - So indecisive. Needs to keep it simple; get distance on his runs by getting the ball out of his feet and get the ball into the box without delay. 
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!