I'm not sure how anyone can judge how good he was for Charlton . He barely played. I'd be surprised if he spent more than an hour on the pitch in total.
edit: I was thinking of tedic. Sorry fiorini. Still thought you was crap for us though.
Very poor for us, I don't see how anyone can say otherwise. One kick that hit the cross bar was his total contribution. However he was young, physically weak but had skill potential. Whether a year a season makes a difference only time will tell. However I would have been dismayed if we'd re-signed him.
It is absolutely incredible how that one free kick (which didn't even go in) has rewritten his time at Charlton. An utterly useless lightweight.
Very poor for us, I don't see how anyone can say otherwise. One kick that hit the cross bar was his total contribution. However he was young, physically weak but had skill potential. Whether a year a season makes a difference only time will tell. However I would have been dismayed if we'd re-signed him.
It is absolutely incredible how that one free kick (which didn't even go in) has rewritten his time at Charlton. An utterly useless lightweight.
No one has said he was good for us. I, like others have simply stated that previous clubs fans rated him and thought he was of Championship quality. He was injured/recovering/overlooked his whole time with us then played ok in the last game which is not enough to judge him on.
I may not have got a signed shirt or a selfie from him but I’ll always have the memories. You’ll always have the Charlton faithful by your side, Lewis.
Very poor for us, I don't see how anyone can say otherwise. One kick that hit the cross bar was his total contribution. However he was young, physically weak but had skill potential. Whether a year a season makes a difference only time will tell. However I would have been dismayed if we'd re-signed him.
It is absolutely incredible how that one free kick (which didn't even go in) has rewritten his time at Charlton. An utterly useless lightweight.
I think that hyperbole to say he was completely useless, he very rarely played for us and when he did he id nothing of note. He wasnt Penney or Inniss bad.
Very poor for us, I don't see how anyone can say otherwise. One kick that hit the cross bar was his total contribution. However he was young, physically weak but had skill potential. Whether a year a season makes a difference only time will tell. However I would have been dismayed if we'd re-signed him.
It is absolutely incredible how that one free kick (which didn't even go in) has rewritten his time at Charlton. An utterly useless lightweight.
I think that hyperbole to say he was completely useless, he very rarely played for us and when he did he id nothing of note. He wasnt Penney or Inniss bad.
Equating Inniss with Penney??? Christ, he made mistakes but is this really how we're gonna remember him
I have the feeling that this might be a conversation that regularly pops up. I think he’ll do very well and end up playing above the standard we currently find ourselves.
I saw him playfor the U21 team. If had been one of ours hewould have been released at the end of the season. He made no positive impact even at that level.
Very poor for us, I don't see how anyone can say otherwise. One kick that hit the cross bar was his total contribution. However he was young, physically weak but had skill potential. Whether a year a season makes a difference only time will tell. However I would have been dismayed if we'd re-signed him.
It is absolutely incredible how that one free kick (which didn't even go in) has rewritten his time at Charlton. An utterly useless lightweight.
I think that hyperbole to say he was completely useless, he very rarely played for us and when he did he id nothing of note. He wasnt Penney or Inniss bad.
Equating Inniss with Penney??? Christ, he made mistakes but is this really how we're gonna remember him
No Inniss was actually worse for us than Penney. Penney played a couple games and was shocking then never saw our team again, clearly there was something up with Penney as there is no way he would have been a professional footballer if that was a fair representation of his ability.
Where as Innis was brought in to be our leader and organiser of the defence, and was played time after time where he would make mistakes that cost us goals and games. Then when he wasn't making mistakes he was making stupid decisions to get suspended like Wimbledon or pointlessly going in to the back of someone with a minute to go and pick up a second yellow.
None of this is a personal attack on him as i know he is apparently a nice bloke and he has "friends" on here, but as a player he is one of the worst CB's we have had in recent memory.
Very poor for us, I don't see how anyone can say otherwise. One kick that hit the cross bar was his total contribution. However he was young, physically weak but had skill potential. Whether a year a season makes a difference only time will tell. However I would have been dismayed if we'd re-signed him.
It is absolutely incredible how that one free kick (which didn't even go in) has rewritten his time at Charlton. An utterly useless lightweight.
I think that hyperbole to say he was completely useless, he very rarely played for us and when he did he id nothing of note. He wasnt Penney or Inniss bad.
Equating Inniss with Penney??? Christ, he made mistakes but is this really how we're gonna remember him
No Inniss was actually worse for us than Penney. Penney played a couple games and was shocking then never saw our team again, clearly there was something up with Penney as there is no way he would have been a professional footballer if that was a fair representation of his ability.
Where as Innis was brought in to be our leader and organiser of the defence, and was played time after time where he would make mistakes that cost us goals and games. Then when he wasn't making mistakes he was making stupid decisions to get suspended like Wimbledon or pointlessly going in to the back of someone with a minute to go and pick up a second yellow.
None of this is a personal attack on him as i know he is apparently a nice bloke and he has "friends" on here, but as a player he is one of the worst CB's we have had in recent memory.
His 'tackle' at Wimbledon was a disgrace. He could have finished the career of the guy.
Very poor for us, I don't see how anyone can say otherwise. One kick that hit the cross bar was his total contribution. However he was young, physically weak but had skill potential. Whether a year a season makes a difference only time will tell. However I would have been dismayed if we'd re-signed him.
It is absolutely incredible how that one free kick (which didn't even go in) has rewritten his time at Charlton. An utterly useless lightweight.
I think that hyperbole to say he was completely useless, he very rarely played for us and when he did he id nothing of note. He wasnt Penney or Inniss bad.
Equating Inniss with Penney??? Christ, he made mistakes but is this really how we're gonna remember him
No Inniss was actually worse for us than Penney. Penney played a couple games and was shocking then never saw our team again, clearly there was something up with Penney as there is no way he would have been a professional footballer if that was a fair representation of his ability.
Where as Innis was brought in to be our leader and organiser of the defence, and was played time after time where he would make mistakes that cost us goals and games. Then when he wasn't making mistakes he was making stupid decisions to get suspended like Wimbledon or pointlessly going in to the back of someone with a minute to go and pick up a second yellow.
None of this is a personal attack on him as i know he is apparently a nice bloke and he has "friends" on here, but as a player he is one of the worst CB's we have had in recent memory.
His 'tackle' at Wimbledon was a disgrace. He could have finished the career of the guy.
in the end he kind of finished his own, but that was just one of many. I think i remember one where he got sent off and I though fair enough nothing he can do there but the majority was just nonsense.
Always funny reading old comments on these threads. He definitely wasn't shit and it was just our fault for never giving him a chance post injury, apparently.
Always funny reading old comments on these threads. He definitely wasn't shit and it was just our fault for never giving him a chance post injury, apparently.
I'm not going to dig out the poster because it's not about them, but someone with inside info posted: "This is a signing they feel could be huge moving forwards."
Not defending anyone (Scott), but most would think that any fit youngster on the books of City, can do a job at a L1 club, or at least give a bette account for themselves than our 2 did.
Not defending anyone (Scott), but most would think that any fit youngster on the books of City, can do a job at a L1 club, or at least give a bette account for themselves than our 2 did.
Seems like a lot of their youngsters are just punts. Tedic, Matt Smith & Fiorini were all not good enough for us.
Always felt he was signed, because we had to take on another player from Man City, after the Tedic loan went to shite
He was an Appleton signing. He had already played at two clubs for him and at the time we signed him, Blackpool fans rated it as a coup that he’d dropped back into League One after being a standout for them in the Championship.
Clearly it turns out he’s not the same player post injury.
Comments
No one has said he was good for us. I, like others have simply stated that previous clubs fans rated him and thought he was of Championship quality. He was injured/recovering/overlooked his whole time with us then played ok in the last game which is not enough to judge him on.
Where as Innis was brought in to be our leader and organiser of the defence, and was played time after time where he would make mistakes that cost us goals and games. Then when he wasn't making mistakes he was making stupid decisions to get suspended like Wimbledon or pointlessly going in to the back of someone with a minute to go and pick up a second yellow.
None of this is a personal attack on him as i know he is apparently a nice bloke and he has "friends" on here, but as a player he is one of the worst CB's we have had in recent memory.
His 'tackle' at Wimbledon was a disgrace. He could have finished the career of the guy.
He was the sort of uninterested Man City loan signing perfect for the January window.
Actually joined yesterday before the derby game against Dundee. Was an unused sub as Dundee beat United for the first time in 7 years (8 games).
I bow to the genius of Andy Scott.
Clearly it turns out he’s not the same player post injury.