Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks & Applescore: FA Cup R1: Charlton Athletic v Cray Valley (PM) (closes Monday teatime)

124»

Comments

  • Applescore: 1 - Too many changes
    WALKER: 5 - Didn't inspire any sort of confidence
    ABANKWAH: 5.5 - Did OK until he ran out of steam
    NESS: 3 - Really poor throughout
    THOMAS: 5 - Did OK
    EDUN: 5.5 - Got forward well but to little effect
    McGRANDLES: 6.5 - Was doing OK and running midfield until he ran out of steam
    ANDERSON: 3.5 - Really poor game
    FRASER: 7 - Good goal and kept trying
    C.CAMPBELL: 6 - Some good play but often to no end
    TEDIĆ: 3 - Totally anonymous bar one long range shot
    KIRK: 4 - Linked up OK but his finishing was awful
    ASIIMWE: 5 - Did OK
    T.WATSON: 4 - So, so negative
    MAY: 5 - Little impact
    Referee: 8 - I thought he did OK 
  • edited November 2023
    WALKER: 5
    ABANKWAH: 4
    NESS: 4
    THOMAS: 4
    EDUN: 5
    McGRANDLES: 5
    ANDERSON: 6
    FRASER: 4
    C.CAMPBELL: 5
    TEDIĆ: 3
    KIRK: 1 
    ASIIMWE: 5
    T.WATSON: 5
    MAY: 4
    Referee: 5
    Applescore 1
  • Watched on TV

    Applescore: 2 You can't seriously expect changing all eleven to work? Starting two just returning from injury was also risky.

    WALKER: 5 Nothing much to do but does not look good. Really hope AMB stays fit!
    ABANKWAH: 6 I thought he did quite well. Most of our attacking came down his side first half, and he put in a great block.
    NESS: 4 Very poor. Couldn't have done too much about the OG, but had been poor prior to and after that too. Nearly gave away a goal first half. Where is the player from last year before he got injured?
    THOMAS: 6 Thought he did okay and was our best defender. 
    EDUN: 5 Huffed and puffed but didn't add much either forward or back. Just back from injury though.
    McGRANDLES: 6 Did okay. Looked a bit rusty at times, but first game back from injury. He is not a replacement for Dobbo though.
    ANDERSON: 4 Very poor. Lost possession too easily in move that led to their goal.
    FRASER: 6 Well taken goal, several very good through balls, but not a captain. Lacked energy and urgency and should have dominated against such opposition.
    C.CAMPBELL: 7 The only player that looked as though he really wanted to give it a go
    TEDIĆ: 5 Lovely awareness to dummy for Fraser's goal. Some half decent touches, but nowhere near enough.
    KIRK: 4 Missed two very good chances and lacked effort. Is he useless or is confidence completely gone?
    ASIIMWE: 5 Didn't add anything.
    T.WATSON: 5 Didn't add anything.
    MAY: 5 Didn't add much, but at least put effort in

    Referee: 7 kept the game flowing. A few strange decisions, but mostly did fine.

    LEABURN: n/a Didn't add anything
    L.WATSON: n/a Didn't add anything
  • Applescore:0 all on him
    WALKER:  4 ok
    ABANKWAH: 3
    NESS:  1 needs a loan
    THOMAS: 3
    EDUN:  3
    McGRANDLES: 5 was alright
    ANDERSON: 4
    FRASER: 5 didnt impose himself
    C.CAMPBELL: 6 our best player
    TEDIĆ: 3
    KIRK: 1
    ASIIMWE: 3
    T.WATSON: 3
    MAY: 4
    Referee: 2 crap
    LEABURN: n/a
    L.WATSON: n/a


  • WALKER: 5
    ABANKWAH: 3
    NESS: 2
    THOMAS: 5
    EDUN: 5
    McGRANDLES: 6
    ANDERSON: 6
    FRASER: 3
    C.CAMPBELL: 3.5
    TEDIĆ: 3.5
    KIRK: 2
    ASIIMWE: 5
    T.WATSON: 5.5
    MAY: 5
  • WALKER: 3
    ABANKWAH: 3
    NESS: 4
    THOMAS: 3
    EDUN: 5
    McGRANDLES: 3
    ANDERSON: 6
    FRASER: 5
    C.CAMPBELL: 5.5
    TEDIĆ: 6
    KIRK: 2
    ASIIMWE: 3
    T.WATSON: 3
    MAY: 4
    Referee: 6
  • WALKER: 4
    ABANKWAH: 3 can see why he isn't playing, terminate the loan in January 
    NESS: 3.5 half the player he was before his injury. Really needs a confidence boost
    THOMAS: 3 any chance Cray want a centre half? Probably about there level
    EDUN: 4 5
    McGRANDLES: 4
    ANDERSON: 5
    FRASER: 6.5 best player for us by a mile and even then, he wasn't great
    C.CAMPBELL: 6 really needs to learn to shoot
    TEDIĆ: 5 15k a week we are supposedly paying for him, 100% of his wages from Man city. If that's true, ship him back, he aint work 1500
    KIRK: 5 not as bad as some make out, but someone tell him to take a man on and learn how to use his f###ing left foot
    ASIIMWE: 5.5
    T.WATSON: 5
    MAY: 6
    Referee: 7
    LEABURN: n/a
    L.WATSON: n
  • edited November 2023
    Applescore: 1 - It amazes me how these people get coaching badges. 
    WALKER: 4 - the punch for one of their crosses scared me. he looks very average. 
    ABANKWAH: 3 - caught out of position a few times. showed his lack of experience. 
    NESS: 3 - needs a decent partner to play alongside possibly, because he has gone downhill from last season. 
    THOMAS: 3 - waiting to see him play well.  
    EDUN: 4 - tried but did little. 
    McGRANDLES: 3 - still waiting for him to get up to speed, a year and a half since he joined us. 
    ANDERSON: 3 - U18 performance. needed his two experienced midfield partners to help him out. well, that didn't happen. 
    FRASER: 3.5 - nice finish for the goal. had a couple of other moments but on the most part disappeared. for someone as experience as him he really let himself down. Captain?! give me a break! 
    C.CAMPBELL: 5 - some decent attacking play. no real end product. 
    TEDIĆ: 2 - looked like he didn't want to be there and i wish he wasn't. 
    KIRK: 1 - no words..
    ASIIMWE: 4
    T.WATSON: 4
    MAY: 4 - bring on your top scorer. stick him on the wing. though may doesn't help himself. He wants to be everywhere and do everything. at one point he even became Cray Valleys physio. 
    Referee: 6
  • WALKER: 4
    ABANKWAH: 3
    NESS: 4
    THOMAS: 3
    EDUN: 4
    McGRANDLES: 3
    ANDERSON: 4
    FRASER: 5
    C.CAMPBELL: 4
    TEDIĆ: 5
    KIRK: 2
    ASIIMWE: 4
    T.WATSON: 4
    MAY: 5
  • Applescore:  2
    WALKER:  4
    ABANKWAH:  3
    NESS:  3
    THOMAS:  4
    EDUN:  3
    McGRANDLES:  5
    ANDERSON:  2
    FRASER:  5
    C.CAMPBELL:  7
    TEDIĆ:  4
    KIRK:  1
    ASIIMWE:  4
    T.WATSON:  3
    MAY:  5
    Referee:  5
  • Sponsored links:



  • Applescore: 1 - Shocking line up.  I agree we didn't need a full team out there but to make so many changes was askng for trouble as it was always going to be a disjointed performance.

    WALKER: 4 a bit flappy
    ABANKWAH: 5 Reasonable
    NESS: 3 What has happened to him
    THOMAS: 3 scares the hell out of me
    EDUN: 5 meh
    McGRANDLES: 3 honestly forgot he was playing for about an hour
    ANDERSON: 6 always wanted the ball but didn't do enough with it.  Lovely assist tbf
    FRASER: 4.5 one point for the goal but largely ineffective and off the pace
    C.CAMPBELL: 7 Looked probably the liveliest of our players
    TEDIĆ: 5 I genuinely cannot yet see what he is going to bring to the team. 
    KIRK: 2 Hides on the wing.  Poor finishing.  No bottle.  We can't get rid of him because nobody is stupid enough to pay anywhere near his current wages so he'll stick around until the end and will go on a free.
    ASIIMWE: 5 tried
    T.WATSON: 5 tried 
    MAY: 6 ran about but nothing really worked.
    Referee: 7
    LEABURN: n/a
    L.WATSON: n/a
    Annoyed with the selection.  Too many changes and too many players who don't know each other's game.
    No leadership AT ALL on the pitch.
    A very dark day in our history

    Having said that I reckon we'll win the replay 6-1 because we take it seriously
  • WALKER: 3
    ABANKWAH: 4
    NESS: 4
    THOMAS: 4
    EDUN: 5
    McGRANDLES: 5
    ANDERSON: 6
    FRASER: 6
    C.CAMPBELL: 7
    TEDIĆ: 3
    KIRK: 0
    ASIIMWE: 5
    T.WATSON: 5
    MAY: 6


  • WALKER: 5 - couldn't do much about the goal, looked a little dodgy on a couple of crosses.
    ABANKWAH: 5 - he tried but nothing really came off, at least he was always trying to receive the ball.
    NESS: 4 - worst I have seen him play, gone backwards since last season.
    THOMAS: 3 - really, really poor tonight. Somehow he is worse at CB than LB. Quite the feat.
    EDUN: 5 - looked rusty as expected, a few nice runs forward.
    McGRANDLES: 5 - did okay but not a capable deputy for Dobbo.
    ANDERSON: 5 - actually thought he did okay, at least tries to get on the ball and make things happen.
    FRASER: 5 - 7 first half, 3 second half.
    C.CAMPBELL: 6 - probably the only player to come out with any credit.
    TEDIĆ: 4 - sorry he is a donkey, he isnt even good in the air. Slow, lethargic. Send back.
    KIRK: 2 - that was a disgrace. Jumped out of tackles, gave the ball away and didnt chase back. Proper shit.



  • Applescore: 0
    WALKER: 5
    ABANKWAH: 2 
    NESS: 3
    THOMAS: 4 
    EDUN: 2
    McGRANDLES: 1 
    ANDERSON: 6
    FRASER: 3
    C.CAMPBELL: 3 
    TEDIĆ: 2
    KIRK: 0
    ASIIMWE: 5
    T.WATSON: 2 
    MAY: 6
    Referee: 4
  • Applescore: 5 Got it wrong but fair play for saying so afterwards
    WALKER: 4 
    ABANKWAH: 5 
    NESS: 4
    THOMAS: 6 
    EDUN: 4 
    McGRANDLES: 5 Chance to shine wasted 
    ANDERSON: 5 
    FRASER: 6 Good first half but faded badly, again
    C.CAMPBELL: 7 Gave the manager a timely reminder
    TEDIĆ: 4 Just lightweight
    KIRK: 2 No words
    ASIIMWE: 4
    T.WATSON: 4 
    MAY: 5
    Referee: 6 
    LEABURN: n/a
    L.WATSON: n/a
  • Applescore: 4
    WALKER: 4
    ABANKWAH: 2
    NESS: 3
    THOMAS: 4
    EDUN: 4
    McGRANDLES: 5
    ANDERSON: 4
    FRASER: 4
    C.CAMPBELL: 5
    TEDIĆ: 4
    KIRK: 1
    ASIIMWE: 4
    T.WATSON: 4
    MAY: 4
    Referee: 5
  • Applescore: 1 - Would have been zero if we'd lost, but picking a side that can only draw with a pub team is shameful
    WALKER: 4 Punching the ball away under no pressure when it was easier to catch, no way is this keeper competition for AMB
    ABANKWAH: 5.5
    NESS: 3
    THOMAS: 4
    EDUN: 5.5
    McGRANDLES: 4 
    ANDERSON: 5
    FRASER: 5
    C.CAMPBELL: 6
    TEDIĆ: 4 A £2-3m dud - what a bluff 
    KIRK: 2 Utter pony
    ASIIMWE: 5
    T.WATSON: 4
    MAY: 5
    Referee: 5
  • Applescore: 4
    WALKER: 4
    ABANKWAH: 5 Can we please play him in his correct position
    NESS: 3
    THOMAS: 4
    EDUN: 5
    McGRANDLES: 5
    ANDERSON: 4
    FRASER: 5 Flatters to deceive
    C.CAMPBELL: 7
    TEDIĆ: 3
    KIRK: 4
    ASIIMWE: 5
    T.WATSON: 4
    MAY: 5
    Referee: 5
  • Amazed to see some scores of 5 for Kirk.
    0 from me but can accept marks of 1 - 3 but 5 WOW. 
    PLEASE PLEASE never put him in a red shirt again.


  • Kirks score MUST be an all time lowest ever, deservedly so!
  • Sponsored links:


  • Applescore:   0   For disrespect to Cray Valley, the competition, supporters and the viewing public. 
    WALKER:   5.0 not convincing.
    ABANKWAH:   2.0  played out of position. Badly out of postion for the goal
    NESS:             2.0 OG not really his fault but had a howler of a game.
    THOMAS:        2.0 just a bad player.
    EDUN:             4.0  not fit yet, but against non league should have done better
    McGRANDLES: 4.0 see Edun comments ditto
    ANDERSON:     4.0  Headless chicken
    FRASER:           5.0 a player of his pedigree should have been running the game.
    C.CAMPBELL:   6.0 best charlton player on day.unday 
    TEDIĆ:             3,0 are we really paying him £15,000 a week?
    KIRK:               - 10  He would not have got into my old Woolwich & District Sunday League team.
    ASIIMWE:          4.0 better than Abamkwah
    T.WATSON:       3.0 not good enough
    MAY:                 5.0 why was he payed on the wing?
    Referee:            6.0
    LEABURN: n/a
    L.WATSON: n/a
  • CAFCDAZ said:
    WALKER: 4
    ABANKWAH: 3 can see why he isn't playing, terminate the loan in January 
    NESS: 3.5 half the player he was before his injury. Really needs a confidence boost
    THOMAS: 3 any chance Cray want a centre half? Probably about there level
    EDUN: 4 5
    McGRANDLES: 4
    ANDERSON: 5
    FRASER: 6.5 best player for us by a mile and even then, he wasn't great
    C.CAMPBELL: 6 really needs to learn to shoot
    TEDIĆ: 5 15k a week we are supposedly paying for him, 100% of his wages from Man city. If that's true, ship him back, he aint work 1500
    KIRK: 5 not as bad as some make out, but someone tell him to take a man on and learn how to use his f###ing left foot
    ASIIMWE: 5.5
    T.WATSON: 5
    MAY: 6
    Referee: 7
    LEABURN: n/a
    L.WATSON: n
    Uh... what? This can't be true. 
  • CAFCDAZ said:
    WALKER: 4
    ABANKWAH: 3 can see why he isn't playing, terminate the loan in January 
    NESS: 3.5 half the player he was before his injury. Really needs a confidence boost
    THOMAS: 3 any chance Cray want a centre half? Probably about there level
    EDUN: 4 5
    McGRANDLES: 4
    ANDERSON: 5
    FRASER: 6.5 best player for us by a mile and even then, he wasn't great
    C.CAMPBELL: 6 really needs to learn to shoot
    TEDIĆ: 5 15k a week we are supposedly paying for him, 100% of his wages from Man city. If that's true, ship him back, he aint work 1500
    KIRK: 5 not as bad as some make out, but someone tell him to take a man on and learn how to use his f###ing left foot
    ASIIMWE: 5.5
    T.WATSON: 5
    MAY: 6
    Referee: 7
    LEABURN: n/a
    L.WATSON: n
    Uh... what? This can't be true. 
    Tedic, nonsense. 15 K. You're having a laugh. Truly poor player. Barnsley made no move to get him back. Says  a lot
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!