AMB: 8 T.WATSON: 5 HECTOR: 7 JONES: 7 THOMAS: 7 DOBSON: 8 some excellent passes L.WATSON: 6 l TEDIĆ: 2 Did he play? Is there a contractual obligation MAY: 7 CBT: 7 less impressive than normal but excellent cross for Aneke ANEKE: 6 Good goal, but offered a chase and blew up after few yds T.C. 8 Great goal FRASER: 7 Made an impact LEABURN: 8 looked desperate to score ASIIMWE: 6 Referee: 7 but didnt like Aneke at all.
AMB: 7.5 T.WATSON: 6.5 HECTOR: 9 - MOTM - Was excellent for the full 90 mins. JONES: 7.5 THOMAS: 7 DOBSON: 7 L.WATSON: 6.5 - Reading did a number on him in first half. Teams will continue to mark him tightly as he so important to us. TEDIĆ: 5.5 MAY: 7 CBT: 8.5 ANEKE: 6.5 T.C.: 8.5 FRASER: 6.5 LEABURN: 6.5 ASIIMWE: 6
Applescore:9 AMB: 7, A couple of punch clears and a couple of missed crosses, but he saved what he had to. T.WATSON: 7, A better performance HECTOR: 8, Solid throughout JONES: 8, As above THOMAS:7, Improved in the second half, as did everybody. DOBSON: 7, Captains performance L.WATSON:6, Busy but not as effective as he has been. TEDIĆ: 5, I'm sounding like a broken record but he brings nothing to this team MAY: 7, Always available and deserved his goal CBT: 8, He gets a eight purely on his second half performance, that's how good he was ANEKE: 7, Fingers crossed he's ok T.C.: 9, This boy is going to be a very special player FRASER: 7, Played some lovely balls into our forwards LEABURN: 7, Aneke departs then you have to face this handful ASIIMWE: 7, All action performance Referee: 6, Not that bad
Applescore: 7 - if only we could play in the first like we do in the second. AMB: 8 T.WATSON: 7 HECTOR: 8.5 JONES: 8 THOMAS: 7.5 DOBSON: 8 L.WATSON: 7.5 TEDIĆ: 6 MAY: works his little socks off. 7.5 CBT: did nothing until he made three goals. 7.5 ANEKE: came to life, scored, got injured. 7 T.C.: 8 FRASER: 6.5 LEABURN: 8 ASIIMWE: 8 Referee: a couple of strange decisions, not least not booking one of theirs for persistent stopping of our momentum with niggly fouls. 7 Assistant referee on the AC Stand side: awake, spotted lots of offsides, wonders will never cease.
Applescore: 8 yet again the changes worked AMB: 7 T.WATSON: 7 best game he has had for us. HECTOR: 7 JONES: 7.5 THOMAS: 7 DOBSON: 6.5 L.WATSON: 6.5 TEDIĆ: 5.5 MAY: 7 CBT: 7 ANEKE: 6.5 T.C.: 7.5 FRASER: 6.5 LEABURN: 7.5 ASIIMWE: 7.5 Referee: 5 average, as normal.
Applescore: 6. Would be higher, but his insistance on playing Tedic on the right wing is baffling. AMB: 7. Fairly solid T.WATSON: 7. Pretty goog today HECTOR: 8. Best game for a while, but Reading were poor. JONES: 8. Really like him. THOMAS: 7. Reasonable game DOBSON: 7.5. Always good L.WATSON: 7.5. Like him. Good player TEDIĆ: 4. Offers nothing on the right wing. No pace. How he is starting ahead of TC is mystifying. MAY: 7.5. Proper player. Two good feet. CBT: 7.5. Poor first half. Very good second half. ANEKE: 7. Good goal. Still getting match fit. Hope his injury is minor T.C. 8 Real pace, scared them. Great goal FRASER: 7. Good player at this level LEABURN: 7.5. Normal service resumed ASIIMWE: 8. This boy is gonna be a top player. DO NOT SELL HIM FOR PEANUTS, AS WE ALWAYS SEEM TO DO. Referee: 7. Pretty good compared to many this season
Applescore: 7.5 Wud score higher but surely this first half thing isn’t intentional AMB: 7 overall decent T.WATSON: 6 ok but prefer Nathan so far HECTOR: 8 imperious today JONES: 7.5 striking up a good partnership THOMAS: 7 couple of loose passes but solid overall and done well DOBSON: 7.5 so good bad n ugly but a key cog in this machine for us L.WATSON: 6.5 not his day today but still a player TEDIĆ: 5 feel for him defo a player there but maybe needs to stop being played out wide and if Aneke out then come on for Leaburn last 20 up top MAY: 7.5 again not really in it first half bar getting ball n playing backwards. Second half was great and another goal CBT: 8 5 first half 9 second half and +1 for the assists ANEKE: 7 +.5 for the goal just seems so much better from bench tho. Let’s hope not another lengthy absence. T.C.: 8 motm for his goal assist and match winning performance FRASER: 6 rolls Royce of a player good to have him come on LEABURN: 7 glad he got his goal ASIIMWE: 7.5 has to start tues surely Referee: 7.5 wasn’t card happy one of the better ones so far this season
Applescore: 8 He's doing what I would which is always a good sign
AMB: 8 Some excellent saves & he looked more confident. T.WATSON: 6.5 Did what was required and is looking fitter. HECTOR: 8 best game this season. Possibly best game for Charlton. Looked sharper. JONES: 7 Excellent solid game. THOMAS: 7 Played well. DOBSON: 7 Typical Dobson. L.WATSON: 7 Good game. TEDIĆ: 5.5 Did ok, but he's not suited to playing wide. MAY: 7.5 Typical May & typical goalscorer's goal. CBT: 8.5 Outstanding 2nd half performance. ANEKE: 7 Caused them so many problems. Hope the injury is minor. T.C.: 8.5 He was on fire. Best game for Charlton & his goal could end up goal of the season. FRASER: 6 LEABURN: 8 Ran them ragged (with the other forwards). ASIIMWE: 7 Looks good & strong. Referee: 8 Thinking about it, he did very little wrong.
Applescore:8 AMB: 7.5 T.WATSON:7 HECTOR: 9 Best centre back at the club, so many spout crap on here saying he is rubbish JONES: 8 THOMAS: 7 Struggles with the ball at his feet going forward, but his height helps out big time defending crosses DOBSON: 7 L.WATSON: 7 TEDIĆ: 5 Looks poor on the right MAY: 7.5 CBT: 8.5 ANEKE: 7 Gutted for the bloke but we all knew deep down the next injury was coming T.C.: 8 FRASER: 7 LEABURN:7.5 ASIIMWE: 7.5
@jonniesta is it safe to assume you also meant an 8 for Jones? I've edited it in on that basis, but if there is a subtle difference in how you'd have scored them, you can go back in and edit it yourself as long as it's before tea-time. @Melrose I've corrected yours as well, as per your follow up post. You do know you can edit your posts in the first 24 hours don't you? If you're not sure how, DM me and I'll go through it with you.
Comments
T.WATSON: 6
HECTOR: 9
JONES: 8
THOMAS: 6
DOBSON: 7
L.WATSON: 6
TEDIĆ: 5
MAY: 6
CBT: 8
ANEKE: 6
T.C.: 7
FRASER: 7
LEABURN: 7
ASIIMWE: 7
AMB: 6.5
T.WATSON: 6.5
HECTOR: 8
JONES: 7
THOMAS: 7.5
DOBSON: 7
L.WATSON: 7
TEDIĆ: 6.5
MAY: 7.5
CBT: 8.5
ANEKE: 7.5
T.C.: 7.5
FRASER: 7
LEABURN: 8
ASIIMWE: 7
Referee: 8
AMB: 7
T.WATSON: 7.5
HECTOR: 7
JONES: 7.5
THOMAS: 7
DOBSON: 8
L.WATSON: 8
TEDIĆ: 6
MAY: 6.6
CBT: 8.5
ANEKE: 7
T.C.: 7
FRASER: 6
LEABURN: 6.5
ASIIMWE: 6.5
Referee: 7
AMB: 7
T.WATSON: 6
HECTOR: 8
JONES: 7.5
THOMAS: 7
DOBSON: 7.5
L.WATSON: 6.5
TEDIĆ: 5
MAY: 7
CBT: 8.5
ANEKE: 7
T.C.: 7.5
FRASER: 6
LEABURN: 7
ASIIMWE: 7.5
Referee: 6.5
Camará: n/a
T.WATSON: 6.5
HECTOR: 9 - MOTM - Was excellent for the full 90 mins.
JONES: 7.5
THOMAS: 7
DOBSON: 7
L.WATSON: 6.5 - Reading did a number on him in first half. Teams will continue to mark him tightly as he so
important to us.
TEDIĆ: 5.5
MAY: 7
CBT: 8.5
ANEKE: 6.5
T.C.: 8.5
FRASER: 6.5
LEABURN: 6.5
ASIIMWE: 6
AMB: 6.5
T.WATSON: 6
HECTOR: 9 flawless
JONES: 8
THOMAS: 7
DOBSON: 7
L.WATSON: 7
TEDIĆ: 5
MAY: 6.5
CBT: 7.5
ANEKE: 6.5
T.C.: 8
FRASER: 7
LEABURN: 7.5
ASIIMWE: 7
Referee: 6
Camará: n/a
AMB: 6.5
T.WATSON: 7.5
HECTOR: 8
JONES: 7.5
THOMAS: 7
DOBSON: 7.5
L.WATSON: 8
TEDIĆ: 6
MAY: 8
CBT: 8.5
ANEKE: 8
T.C.: 9
FRASER: 7
LEABURN: 8.5
ASIIMWE: 7.5
Referee: 6
AMB: 7, A couple of punch clears and a couple of missed crosses, but he saved what he had to.
T.WATSON: 7, A better performance
HECTOR: 8, Solid throughout
JONES: 8, As above
THOMAS:7, Improved in the second half, as did everybody.
DOBSON: 7, Captains performance
L.WATSON:6, Busy but not as effective as he has been.
TEDIĆ: 5, I'm sounding like a broken record but he brings nothing to this team
MAY: 7, Always available and deserved his goal
CBT: 8, He gets a eight purely on his second half performance, that's how good he was
ANEKE: 7, Fingers crossed he's ok
T.C.: 9, This boy is going to be a very special player
FRASER: 7, Played some lovely balls into our forwards
LEABURN: 7, Aneke departs then you have to face this handful
ASIIMWE: 7, All action performance
Referee: 6, Not that bad
Camará: n/a
AMB: 8
T.WATSON: 7
HECTOR: 8.5
JONES: 8
THOMAS: 7.5
DOBSON: 8
L.WATSON: 7.5
TEDIĆ: 6
MAY: works his little socks off. 7.5
CBT: did nothing until he made three goals. 7.5
ANEKE: came to life, scored, got injured. 7
T.C.: 8
FRASER: 6.5
LEABURN: 8
ASIIMWE: 8
Referee: a couple of strange decisions, not least not booking one of theirs for persistent stopping of our momentum with niggly fouls. 7
Assistant referee on the AC Stand side: awake, spotted lots of offsides, wonders will never cease.
Camará: n/a
AMB: 7
T.WATSON: 7 best game he has had for us.
HECTOR: 7
JONES: 7.5
THOMAS: 7
DOBSON: 6.5
L.WATSON: 6.5
TEDIĆ: 5.5
MAY: 7
CBT: 7
ANEKE: 6.5
T.C.: 7.5
FRASER: 6.5
LEABURN: 7.5
ASIIMWE: 7.5
Referee: 5 average, as normal.
T.WATSON: 6
HECTOR: 7
JONES: 7
THOMAS: 7
DOBSON: 7
L.WATSON: 7
TEDIĆ: 5
MAY: 7
CBT: 7
ANEKE: 7
T.C.: 7.5
FRASER: 7
LEABURN: 7
ASIIMWE: 7
Referee: 7
T.WATSON: 6
HECTOR: 6.5
JONES: 7
THOMAS: 6
DOBSON: 6
L.WATSON: 7
TEDIĆ: 5
MAY: 7
CBT: 8
ANEKE: 7
T.C.: 7
FRASER: 6
LEABURN: 7
ASIIMWE: 6
AMB: 7
T.WATSON: 6
HECTOR: 7
JONES: 7
THOMAS: 6
DOBSON: 7
L.WATSON: 6
TEDIĆ: 4
MAY: 8
CBT: 7
ANEKE: 7
T.C.: 8
FRASER: 8
LEABURN: 8
ASIIMWE: 7
Referee:
AMB: 7. Fairly solid
T.WATSON: 7. Pretty goog today
HECTOR: 8. Best game for a while, but Reading were poor.
JONES: 8. Really like him.
THOMAS: 7. Reasonable game
DOBSON: 7.5. Always good
L.WATSON: 7.5. Like him. Good player
TEDIĆ: 4. Offers nothing on the right wing. No pace. How he is starting ahead of TC is mystifying.
MAY: 7.5. Proper player. Two good feet.
CBT: 7.5. Poor first half. Very good second half.
ANEKE: 7. Good goal. Still getting match fit. Hope his injury is minor
T.C. 8 Real pace, scared them. Great goal
FRASER: 7. Good player at this level
LEABURN: 7.5. Normal service resumed
ASIIMWE: 8. This boy is gonna be a top player. DO NOT SELL HIM FOR PEANUTS, AS WE ALWAYS SEEM TO DO.
Referee: 7. Pretty good compared to many this season
AMB: 7
T.WATSON: 7
HECTOR: 8
JONES: 7.5
THOMAS: 7
DOBSON: 7.5
L.WATSON: 7
TEDIĆ: 5
MAY: 8
CBT: 8.5
ANEKE: 7
T.C.: 7.5
FRASER: 8
LEABURN: 7.5
ASIIMWE: 7.5
Referee: 8.5
AMB: 7
T.WATSON: 5
HECTOR: 7
JONES: 7
THOMAS: 6
DOBSON: 7
L.WATSON: 7
TEDIĆ: 5
MAY: 7
CBT: 9
ANEKE: 6.5
T.C.: 7.5
FRASER: 6
LEABURN: 7.5
ASIIMWE: 7.5
Referee: 8
Camará: n/a
AMB: 7 overall decent
T.WATSON: 6 ok but prefer Nathan so far
HECTOR: 8 imperious today
JONES: 7.5 striking up a good partnership
THOMAS: 7 couple of loose passes but solid overall and done well
DOBSON: 7.5 so good bad n ugly but a key cog in this machine for us
L.WATSON: 6.5 not his day today but still a player
TEDIĆ: 5 feel for him defo a player there but maybe needs to stop being played out wide and if Aneke out then come on for Leaburn last 20 up top
MAY: 7.5 again not really in it first half bar getting ball n playing backwards. Second half was great and another goal
CBT: 8 5 first half 9 second half and +1 for the assists
ANEKE: 7 +.5 for the goal just seems so much better from bench tho. Let’s hope not another lengthy absence.
T.C.: 8 motm for his goal assist and match winning performance
FRASER: 6 rolls Royce of a player good to have him come on
LEABURN: 7 glad he got his goal
ASIIMWE: 7.5 has to start tues surely
Referee: 7.5 wasn’t card happy one of the better ones so far this season
Camará: n/a - good to have him back
AMB: 6.5
T.WATSON: 5.5
HECTOR: 8
JONES: 7
THOMAS: 7.5
DOBSON: 6.5
L.WATSON: 7
TEDIĆ: 6
MAY: 6.5
CBT: 8
ANEKE: 6.5
T.C.: 8
FRASER: 7
LEABURN: 7
ASIIMWE: 7.5
Referee: 7
AMB: 7
T.WATSON: 6
HECTOR: 6
JONES: 6
THOMAS: 6
DOBSON: 7
L.WATSON: 6
TEDIĆ: 5
MAY: 7
CBT: 7
ANEKE: 6.5
T.C.: 7
FRASER: 7
LEABURN: 6.5
ASIIMWE: 7
Referee: 7
AMB: 6.5
T.WATSON: 7
HECTOR: 8
JONES: 7
THOMAS: 6.5
DOBSON: 7
L.WATSON: 6
TEDIĆ: 5
MAY: 7
CBT: 8
ANEKE: 7
T.C.: 7.5
FRASER: 6.5
LEABURN: 7
ASIIMWE: 6
Referee: 7
AMB: 7
T.WATSON: 6
HECTOR: 8
JONES: 8
THOMAS: 6
DOBSON: 8
L.WATSON: 7
TEDIĆ: 6
MAY: 7
CBT: 9
ANEKE: 7
T.C.: 9
FRASER: 6
LEABURN: 7
ASIIMWE: 8
Referee: 7
Camará: n/a
AMB: 7
T.WATSON: 5
HECTOR: 8.5
JONES: 7
THOMAS: 6
DOBSON: 8
L.WATSON: 7
TEDIĆ: 5
MAY: 8
CBT: 8
ANEKE: 7.5
T.C.: 8
FRASER: 7
LEABURN: 8
ASIIMWE: 8
Referee: 8
Camará: n/a
AMB: 6 Flaps at crosses
T.WATSON: 6
HECTOR: 7.5
JONES: 7
THOMAS: 7
DOBSON: 7
L.WATSON: 7
TEDIĆ: 5 Being played out of position
MAY: 7.5
CBT: 8 terrified them in second half
ANEKE: 7
T.C.:7.5
FRASER: 7
LEABURN: 7.5
ASIIMWE: 7.5
Referee: 7
AMB: 7.5
T.WATSON:7
HECTOR: 9 Best centre back at the club, so many spout crap on here saying he is rubbish
JONES: 8
THOMAS: 7 Struggles with the ball at his feet going forward, but his height helps out big time defending crosses
DOBSON: 7
L.WATSON: 7
TEDIĆ: 5 Looks poor on the right
MAY: 7.5
CBT: 8.5
ANEKE: 7 Gutted for the bloke but we all knew deep down the next injury was coming
T.C.: 8
FRASER: 7
LEABURN:7.5
ASIIMWE: 7.5
AMB: 6
T.WATSON: 6
HECTOR: 8
JONES: 7.5
THOMAS: 7.5
DOBSON: 8.5
L.WATSON: 6
TEDIĆ: 5
MAY: 7.5
CBT:8
ANEKE: 8
T.C.: 8
FRASER: 7
LEABURN: 7
ASIIMWE: 7.5
AMB: 7
T.WATSON: 7
HECTOR: 7.5
JONES: 7.5
THOMAS: 7
DOBSON: 7
L.WATSON: 7
TEDIĆ: 6
MAY: 6.5
CBT: 7
ANEKE: 6
T.C.: 8
FRASER: 6.5
LEABURN: 7
ASIIMWE: 7
Referee: 8.5