Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Alfie May - signed for Birmingham (p68 - Now Huddersfield )

1212224262771

Comments

  • LTKapal
    LTKapal Posts: 1,312
    Been nominated for player of the month for october
  • JaShea99
    JaShea99 Posts: 5,456
    Please don’t win it!
  • Callumcafc
    Callumcafc Posts: 63,757
    edited November 2023
    Up against Jordan Gibson (Carlisle), Luke Leahy (Wycombe) and Conor Shaughnessy (Portsmouth). It would be his third time winning the award after previously winning in February 2022 and March 2023.

    If he wins, he would be the first Charlton player to win since Ben Amos in October 2020. Prior to Amos, Jacko in January 2012. We didn't have any winners in the 2018-19 promotion season.


    Manager nominees are Darrell Clarke (Cheltenham), Neill Collins (Barnsley), Ian Evatt (Bolton) and John Mousinho (Portsmouth). If you believe in the curse, pin your hopes on the Pompey double. :-)
  • shirty5
    shirty5 Posts: 19,215
    To be announced tomorrow morning. Congratulations to Alfie if the club’s deleted tweet from this afternoon is anything to go by 
  • Well deserved Alfie. Now take us past Pompey and CVPM
  • BalladMan
    BalladMan Posts: 1,112
    Well deserved win. Alfie is trying to drag us to the championship single handedly. 
  • stonemuse
    stonemuse Posts: 33,993
    Well done Alfie 
  • Mendonca In Asdas
    Mendonca In Asdas Posts: 22,650
    edited November 2023
    Well done and well deserved Alfie, now go get the next one!!
  • BalladMan said:
    Well deserved win. Alfie is trying to drag us to the championship single handedly. 
    Harsh on Blackett-Taylor 
  • Sponsored links:



  • Callumcafc
    Callumcafc Posts: 63,757
    Now joint 4th top scorer after last night’s brace

    - Devante Cole (Barnsley): 9
    - Jamie Reid (Stevenage): 8
    - Dion Charles (Bolton): 7
    - Alfie May: 6

    Bishop (Pompey), Waghorn (Derby) and Wyke (Wigan) also on 6.
    After today…

    Cole 9
    Bishop 8
    Reid 8
    Charles 7
    May 7

    Rhodes, Waghorn and Wyke all on 6.
    October 21 update:

    Cole 9
    Bishop 8
    Reid 8
    Charles 8
    May 8
    Rhodes 8
    Oct 25:

    Cole 10
    Reid 9
    May 9
    Rhodes 9
    Hoskins 8
    Bishop 8
    Charles 8
    Half time, Oct 31

    Cole 11
    May 11
    Rhodes 9
    Bishop 9
    Charles 9
    Reid 9
    Nov 11:

    May 12
    Cole 11
    Bishop 10
    Reid 10
    Rhodes 9
    Charles 9
    Hoskins 9
  • 12 in his last 12 but 12 in 15 League 1 appearances this season. Pro rata, if he were to carry on at that rate then Alfie would end up with another 24 in the remaining 30 games making it 36 in total for the season. And unless I'm mistaken that would be a Club record. He can't do that. Can he? 
  • His goal probably showed the type of player he is yesterday. 

    Had absolutely no business being allowed to get a strike on goal given the way he got on to the end of thst through ball

    Great finish, the 'keeper will probably get stick, but whats the betting that May deliberately deflected the ball off Norris, making it harder to save, and to get it on target. 
  • MarcusH26
    MarcusH26 Posts: 8,029
    This might sound daft , but is Alfie the best pure finisher we've had since Darren Bent? Just seems to score all types of goals. 
  • shirty5
    shirty5 Posts: 19,215
    MarcusH26 said:
    This might sound daft , but is Alfie the best pure finisher we've had since Darren Bent? Just seems to score all types of goals. 
    Taylor
    Wright Phillips 
    Hunt
    Mendonca
    Hales
    Flanagan
    Horsfield
  • Garrymanilow
    Garrymanilow Posts: 13,159
    BWP was not a great finisher I don’t think. He has that obsessive ‘always get it on target’ ethos which meant he hit the keeper a lot. Good player, very good all round in terms of getting into the right areas and when he was on a streak he was deadly but god did he waste chances. That’s why he could never do it at Championship level; the fewer the chances, the less margin for error and he did love an error. Even in his 22 goal season he didn’t score between November and the end of February 
  • MarcusH26 said:
    This might sound daft , but is Alfie the best pure finisher we've had since Darren Bent? Just seems to score all types of goals. 
    I think he is less a finisher and more of a true goal scorer, the difference being he is someone who is not afraid to try and score and the law of averages means the more attempts you have the more likely it is one of them will go in. He misses with a lot of attempts but like a great goal scorer it doesn’t doesn’t dent his confidence or stop him from trying again, and again, and again. 

  • His goal yesterday was surely deflected?
  • fenaddick
    fenaddick Posts: 10,986
    it’s his attitude I love. Obviously he’s a great finisher etc but he never stops running and he is so passionate about the team. I saw him tweet to congratulate someone at Cheltenham scoring recently which I loved because it shows he makes genuine connections. It’s not just a job to him
  • Sponsored links:



  • fenaddick said:
    it’s his attitude I love. Obviously he’s a great finisher etc but he never stops running and he is so passionate about the team. I saw him tweet to congratulate someone at Cheltenham scoring recently which I loved because it shows he makes genuine connections. It’s not just a job to him
    Agreed. I know it was arguably a bit naive and generally I want a striker who’s primarily about getting goals but I loved the business of giving that pen to chuks to try and get him up and running. He understands it’s a team game and getting more belief, work rate, spirit, togetherness and just form out of everyone around him is going to make both him and the team play better. 
  • + I actually don’t think it was that naive as chuks is generally fine at pens 
  • blackpool72
    blackpool72 Posts: 23,667
    shirty5 said:
    MarcusH26 said:
    This might sound daft , but is Alfie the best pure finisher we've had since Darren Bent? Just seems to score all types of goals. 
    Taylor
    Wright Phillips 
    Hunt
    Mendonca
    Hales
    Flanagan
    Horsfield
    Great list.
    I would also add Melrose 
  • shirty5 said:
    MarcusH26 said:
    This might sound daft , but is Alfie the best pure finisher we've had since Darren Bent? Just seems to score all types of goals. 
    Taylor
    Wright Phillips 
    Hunt
    Mendonca
    Hales
    Flanagan
    Horsfield
    Great list.
    I would also add Melrose 
    And the sadly departed David Whyte probably too
  • And 
    Ray Treacy⚽️
  • mendonca
    mendonca Posts: 9,405
    Why is everybody mentioning their age and then love for Alfie May?! There are apps for that kinda thing.
  • JaShea99
    JaShea99 Posts: 5,456
    12 in his last 12 but 12 in 15 League 1 appearances this season. Pro rata, if he were to carry on at that rate then Alfie would end up with another 24 in the remaining 30 games making it 36 in total for the season. And unless I'm mistaken that would be a Club record. He can't do that. Can he? 
    No. And that’s not me being negative or doubting his ability, because I think he’s incredible, but it rarely works out like that.
  • We have a genuine gold standard striker for this level. We have a player like Leaburn to provide the physical / alternative threat. We have midfielders like Dobson, Watson, Fraser, and wingers like CBT. Two solid Center backs and who are forming a partnership.

    But for so many years we have said we needed a 20 goal a season striker. 

    We still don’t have one….. we have a 30 goal a season striker instead.

    If we don’t easily get in the play offs I think it would be a grotesque failure taking in to account all the above.
  • AndyG
    AndyG Posts: 5,905

    We have a genuine gold standard striker for this level. We have a player like Leaburn to provide the physical / alternative threat. We have midfielders like Dobson, Watson, Fraser, and wingers like CBT. Two solid Center backs and who are forming a partnership.

    But for so many years we have said we needed a 20 goal a season striker. 

    We still don’t have one….. we have a 30 goal a season striker instead.

    If we don’t easily get in the play offs I think it would be a grotesque failure taking in to account all the above.
    Absolutely spot on mate. 

    Although I think we will know a lot more about our chances after the next 3 games. MA seems to have added a bit more attitude to the squad hopefully that will mean we will beat the teams we should beat this season. The last few seasons it hasn’t been the performances against the top end of the table that cost us has it ?it’s the points dropped versus teams we should muller 
  • We have a genuine gold standard striker for this level. We have a player like Leaburn to provide the physical / alternative threat. We have midfielders like Dobson, Watson, Fraser, and wingers like CBT. Two solid Center backs and who are forming a partnership.

    But for so many years we have said we needed a 20 goal a season striker. 

    We still don’t have one….. we have a 30 goal a season striker instead.

    If we don’t easily get in the play offs I think it would be a grotesque failure taking in to account all the above.
    Must be just me who has yet to see this.