Another wonderful season in L1 is almost upon us. For over 10 years we have been collating your player marks and reporting them and other stats back to you in the form of the Statbank. In the last couple of years we have also marked the referee.
So just to remind you of the system, it goes like this:
After every 1st team game I will put up a list of players and referee and given you all a couple of days to send in your marks to CL. All players who have completed at least 30 minutes on the pitch are on the list for marks. It is up to you how you mark them and the permissible marks are between 0.5 and 10 with halves allowed. Lifers can send in marks if they were at the match or watched it live on Charlton TV or any other steaming service.
Please do not comment on other Lifers marks on the players marks thread, but of course you can comment on the player’s performance.
I collate the marks and then publish the Statbank on CL. The number and type of stats increase as the season progresses. All 1st team matches are marked but only L1 matches count towards the end of season stats extravaganza.
One thing that I do ask of you, please keep to the list order that I put up when doing your marks as it makes it much easier for me when inputting them, last season there was one Lifer who continually did his own order of players which is one too many.
18
Comments
just a thought & appreciate all you do.
TELL ME WHAT YOU WANT
Do Lifers prefer me to use 20 or 30 minutes on the pitch as the cut off for being given a mark, of course AFKA does have a veto, I'll leave this open until Saturday morning
edit. I agree with Golfie’s point above.
Are we still using @Leuth to sign off everyone's scores?
For what it’s worth given the substitute rule change, I reckon 20 mins as a sub would be a reasonable length of time to consider.
When marking players I try to be consistent with myself, the kind of performance that gets a 7 from me one week is the same every week regardless of the player or result.
If anybody is interested, my thinking goes like this.
1 Once in a decade awful performance.
2 A non footballer performance.
3 A liability.
4 Poor.
5 Below average.
6 Average.
7 Good.
8 Very good (likely to be a MoM performance).
9 Excellent.
10 Out of this world outstandingly memorably brilliant.
I appreciate it would be impossible to do, so understand why you wouldn't do it, but a mark for everyone that started, unless obviously injured. Ie subed for being toilet or sent off early.
Leuth did last season with Gilbey !
Good address and a great birdie for Golfie.
Put me down for the 20 minute rule, anyone on the field on 70 minutes as with so many subs being used they will play to the 95 minute and that's without injuries. So Chuks wil get on from 60 to 75 minutes depending on the state of play.
20 mins works for me too.
Other minor rule change I would suggest is re sending offs. if someone starts and gets send off he should be marked imho.