MacG: 4 Awful throw out for their 3rd goal Clare: 5 Needs to learn how to cross a ball and concentrate for 90 mins Pearce: 6 Won his battles today Famewo: 7 Best defender today Dobson: 7 Normal workhorse display but misplaced a few passes today Matthews: 6.5 Defended well Gilbey: 5 Started well but got worse & produced nothing Morgan: 6 Moved the ball well first half but drifted out the game B-T: 8 MOM but less a point for not tracking his man for their second goal Stockley: 5 Scored but couldn’t control the ball and passes went to them Burstow: 4.5 Didn’t look strong enough today but good assist for the Stockley goal Washington: 5 Lively cameo Referee: 5 Let the game flow but missed two possible pens for us Opposition: 5 Their game plan worked, soaked up our pressure and scored on the break
MacG: 4 lost us the game when it went to 3-1 Clare: 5.5 some good some bad , kicking the ball out for a corner ?? Pearce: 4 came up against a better class of player today Famewo: 5 again some good some bad Dobson: 6 can’t be mom every game Matthews: 5.5 forgot he was playing sometimes Gilbey: 2 poor Morgan: 3 had too many chances has Albie but no more please B-T: 7.5 frightened them all the time but lost his positioning for their 1st Stockley: 5 our own HR puff n stuff Burstow: 4 can’t understand why he’s being picked ? Washington: 5.5 made a difference JFC 6 again made a difference how can he be n/a , played better than some who played whole match Aneke 6 same as JFC and scored Referee: 6 annoying ref not up with play a lot of the time Opposition: 7 only because they had a plan and stuck to it which worked
JJ 3 same old excuses sorry not good enough in my view
MacG: 7 Clare: 7 Pearce: 8 Famewo: 7 Dobson: 6 Matthews: 6 Gilbey: 6 Morgan: 3 enough enough now surely B-T: 7. At fault for first goal but created our two Stockley: 5 Burstow: 3 at fault for second goal .. done nothing Washington: 5 Referee: 3 Opposition: 5
Just home & reading these scores. You really can just do one one with that score for Pearce. If you love him that much, get yourself on one of his half term courses. Completely daft!
MacG: 5 - gifted them the third goal. I hope that Maynard-Brewer can take the shirt next season and perform, as we need a serious upgrade on MacGillivray. We have had many able goalies over the years at Charlton but I'm afraid that Craig is not one of them Clare: 5 - good athleticism and ball-carrying ability but very weak for the third goal. In fairness, the bloke is not really a central defender and has done well this season playing out of position Pearce: 4 - struggled against a very able striker, who will probably be plying his trade in the Championship next season Famewo: 5 - his distribution is poor and his defending is uneven. I sincerely hope that we don't exercise the option to buy and that he returns to his parent club, along with all the other 5 loanees Dobson: 6 - did ok and was unlucky not to win a second half penalty. A good turn to create an opportunity in injury time Matthews: 6 - competent but offers little offensively. Perhaps not surprising, as he is a conventional defender, rather than a wing back Gilbey: 3 - one good run at the start but that was it. He tends to 'hide' in games and is a player we could very happily lose in the summer (although I doubt that anyone in League 1 would want to relieve us of him for the last year of his contract). Morgan: 5 - tidy at times but his final delivery was generally disappointing B-T: 8 - MoTM: ran them ragged and improved his final ball in the second half. Not so good defensively, but it might be more fruitful to play him further up the field. That is not, however, going to happen under Jacko, given his fixation with 3-5-2 Stockley: 5 - scored another goal and drew a good save from the keeper but his general play was slow and laboured. He failed to hold the ball up and bring others into play - something he has done reasonably well in the past . Is he really fit, given his back problems ? Burstow: 5.5 - a few good moments - notably, the clever knock-down for Stockley's goal - but he was well marshalled by the Morecambe central defenders and the service from midfield was poor Washington: 5 - stuck out on the right wing and struggled to get into the game Referee: 5 Opposition: 6 - they had a clear game plan and executed it well. Showed some mettle and mental strength, given their precarious position in the table.
MacG: 5 - we need better despite his recent improvement in coming for the ball Clare: 6 - He is one of our better players, generally positive in possession but backed off for third goal. Pearce: 5 - Hmmmm Famewo: 5.5 Dobson: 7 - Can we sign him up on a long term? Matthews: 6.5 - He has been one of our better players recently and would be worth a new contract but can't forget the rest of the season Gilbey: 4 - I don't rate him (and never have) even his early bit of wing play was followed with a full pelt across the box Morgan: 5 - Even his passing was off today B-T: 7.5 - Best player Stockley: 6 (+1 for goal) I so want to like him but he is so poor at many of the basics of football that I am beginning to think (despite his goals) that he is more of a negative to our play than a positive. He is also always moaning at other players. Not a captain. Burstow: 5.5 - I thought he did just about alright but I would have given another young player a go in a meaningless game (for us). Washington: 5 - Not really sure what he did Referee: 5 Poor but standard for this div Opposition: 6 - They weren't very good but still put 3 past us!
J.F-C: n/a - We need to sign him up for next season Aneke: n/a - Much better as a super sub, which is not a bad tactic if our starting forwards are fit
I can only think that a number of players know they are not going to be resigned, although all played so well against Rotherham last week, so what do I know!
MacG: 6 Clare: 7 worked hard Pearce: 6 Famewo: 6 Dobson: 7 Matthews: 6 Gilbey: 4 Morgan: 5 B-T: 8 our most exciting player Stockley: 6.5 Burstow: 6 Washington: 6 Referee: 7 would have been 8 if he gave us our deserved penalty Opposition: 7
MacG: 5 A great stop or two, but cost us a third Clare: 5 Did some stuff really well, but a bit sloppy and expect more Pearce: 5 Just didn’t feel as commanding as he can be Famewo: 5 I would love him to be consistently better than he has been when playing for us this season, but he is just too inconsistent and I hope this improves as he gains more experience (most likely away from the Valley…) Dobson: 6.5 not as good as he has been of late, but denied a penalty, turned brilliantly in their area late on and was his usual industrious self Matthews: 5.5 Some ok crosses, some below average. Time to part ways… Gilbey: 5 Thought he was right up for it today, but more like a damp through firework with a dry fuse. Sizzled for seconds and then fcuk all. What happened…? Morgan: 6 Some quality passing and he is adding to his defensive qualities, but would rather have had JFC on for the whole game. B-T: 8 Seems to be getting stronger by the game. His electric pace will serve us very well going into next season, if he can remain fit. An off your seat type player. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 Stockley: 7 Industrious and working hard toward a 20 goal milestone, which I think he will meet. Burstow: 5 Ran quite hard but unless we have already lined him up for a season long loan next season and want to further test his strengths, I have no idea why he was playing today? Washington: 5.5 Ran the channels, held the ball well, but not much else today. Referee: 5.5 Would have been 7 but for the pen miss. Opposition: 7 They will survive - Stockton is a menace!
MacG: 4 just not good enough. Set up their third . Clare: 5.5 runs well with the ball , but too casual at the back at times . Pearce: 4.5 tried, but up against a proper striker Famewo: 6 did well at times but to many mistakes Dobson: 6.5 below par but always gives 100% Matthews: 5.5 got some crosses in Gilbey: 2.5 brilliant for about 10 minutes then just gave up Morgan: 3.5 minced around a bit B-T: 8 MOM if he could just finish Stockley: 6 did ok but can't hardly ever control the ball Burstow: 2 useless , should never have started Washington: 4 better than Gilbey Referee: 5 Opposition: 6
MacG: 4 Nowhere near our worst keeper I’ve watched over the last 60 years but nowhere near the best either! Ridiculous throw out leading to their 3rd goal
Clare: 5 Good surging forward but got done for their 3rd not a defender
Pearce: 4.5 Got torn a new one by Stockton Famewo: 5.5 Best defender but faint praise indeed
Dobson: 6 Best midfielder usual decent performance Matthews: 5 Occasional forward play but too much crab football
Gilbey: 3 great early run but no end product then the invisible man took his bandages off
Morgan: 5 meh, JFC offered more in his brief cameo
B-T: 7.5 main attacking threat yet again extra 0.5 for assist Stockley: 5.5 poor first half showing, extra point for goal which was a tap in
Burstow: 5 Not ready for mens football extra 0.5 for assist
Washington: 5 little impact Referee: 5
Opposition: 6 Did their homework on us and took their chances well
MacG: 4 No! He can't save a long shot. And he gifted Morecambe their third. Clare: 4.5. Ridiculous. A simple pass goes astray. Pearce: 5. Tough, yet defeated by players in a team quicker than him. Famewo: 4.5. Silly. Trips over the ball. Dobson: 6. Improving - getting stronger with each game. Matthews: 4.5. Cross after cross does not beat the first man. Gilbey: 5 Intelligent runs - pass and receive. Nothing at the end. Morgan: 4 No! His hapless free-kicks - straight out of play - might work at Maidstone or Ebbsfleet. B-T: 4.5 The step-over past a step-over - and dribbles up his own arse. No footballing brain. Stockley: 5. One-dimensional. Immobile. My neighbour said he even falls over in slow motion. Burstow: 3 No! Headed to Stockley, otherwise utterly anonymous. Washington: 5 Good sprints - then bumbles and fluffs. Referee: 7 Perfect decisions. Opposition: 7 Morecambe were non-league until recently. They beat us at The Valley. Our wealthy and tight-fisted owner should sack Jackson and buy good players. Wigan have done it - and Ipswich too...
MacG: 4 Should have done a lot better with the goals, saying that, doesn't have much of a clued up defence in front of him.
Clare: 6 midfielder bwas the best defender today.
Pearce: 5 Everyone's hero last week is back to being past it.
Famewo: 5 Enjoying trying to guess how far his long balls will get before the opposition collect them.
Dobson: 7 The Usual. When your DM is offering you goals and naughty little turns in the oppo box, you're one wank team.
Matthews: 6 Not as good as his previous couple of games, not as bad as his worst games. Him, Gilbey and Clare looked pretty good in terms of understanding on the right in those opening 10 so that's nice for next season.
Gilbey: 5 Started alright then completely disappeared
Morgan: 5 meh, probably not kicking on on his 12th return to the team.
B-T: 7 Give it to Blackett-Taylor, sometimes works sometimes don't, just imagine how awful we'd look without him.
Comments
Clare: 5
Pearce: 4
Famewo: 5
Dobson: 7.5
Matthews: 6
Gilbey: 4
Morgan: 6
B-T: going forward 8.5, tracking back - 1.5 so a 7
Stockley: 7
Burstow: 5
Washington: 5
Referee: 5
Opposition: 6.5
J.F-C: n/a
Aneke: n/a
Clare: 5 Needs to learn how to cross a ball and concentrate for 90 mins
Pearce: 6 Won his battles today
Famewo: 7 Best defender today
Dobson: 7 Normal workhorse display but misplaced a few passes today
Matthews: 6.5 Defended well
Gilbey: 5 Started well but got worse & produced nothing
Morgan: 6 Moved the ball well first half but drifted out the game
B-T: 8 MOM but less a point for not tracking his man for their second goal
Stockley: 5 Scored but couldn’t control the ball and passes went to them
Burstow: 4.5 Didn’t look strong enough today but good assist for the Stockley goal
Washington: 5 Lively cameo
Referee: 5 Let the game flow but missed two possible pens for us
Opposition: 5 Their game plan worked, soaked up our pressure and scored on the break
Clare: 5.5 some good some bad , kicking the ball out for a corner ??
Pearce: 4 came up against a better class of player today
Famewo: 5 again some good some bad
Dobson: 6 can’t be mom every game
Matthews: 5.5 forgot he was playing sometimes
Gilbey: 2 poor
Morgan: 3 had too many chances has Albie but no more please
B-T: 7.5 frightened them all the time but lost his positioning for their 1st
Stockley: 5 our own HR puff n stuff
Burstow: 4 can’t understand why he’s being picked ?
Washington: 5.5 made a difference
JFC 6 again made a difference how can he be n/a , played better than some who played whole match
Aneke 6 same as JFC and scored
Referee: 6 annoying ref not up with play a lot of the time
Opposition: 7 only because they had a plan and stuck to it which worked
JJ 3 same old excuses sorry not good enough in my view
Clare: 5 - good athleticism and ball-carrying ability but very weak for the third goal. In fairness, the bloke is not really a central defender and has done well this season playing out of position
Pearce: 4 - struggled against a very able striker, who will probably be plying his trade in the Championship next season
Famewo: 5 - his distribution is poor and his defending is uneven. I sincerely hope that we don't exercise the option to buy and that he returns to his parent club, along with all the other 5 loanees
Dobson: 6 - did ok and was unlucky not to win a second half penalty. A good turn to create an opportunity in injury time
Matthews: 6 - competent but offers little offensively. Perhaps not surprising, as he is a conventional defender, rather than a wing back
Gilbey: 3 - one good run at the start but that was it. He tends to 'hide' in games and is a player we could very happily lose in the summer (although I doubt that anyone in League 1 would want to relieve us of him for the last year of his contract).
Morgan: 5 - tidy at times but his final delivery was generally disappointing
B-T: 8 - MoTM: ran them ragged and improved his final ball in the second half. Not so good defensively, but it might be more fruitful to play him further up the field. That is not, however, going to happen under Jacko, given his fixation with 3-5-2
Stockley: 5 - scored another goal and drew a good save from the keeper but his general play was slow and laboured. He failed to hold the ball up and bring others into play - something he has done reasonably well in the past . Is he really fit, given his back problems ?
Burstow: 5.5 - a few good moments - notably, the clever knock-down for Stockley's goal - but he was well marshalled by the Morecambe central defenders and the service from midfield was poor
Washington: 5 - stuck out on the right wing and struggled to get into the game
Referee: 5
Opposition: 6 - they had a clear game plan and executed it well. Showed some mettle and mental strength, given their precarious position in the table.
Clare: 6
Pearce: 5.5
Famewo: 5
Dobson: 6.5
Matthews: 5
Gilbey: 4
Morgan: 5
B-T: 7
Stockley: 7
Burstow: 4
Washington: 6
Referee: 4
Opposition: 7
Clare: 6
Pearce: 4
Famewo: 5
Dobson: 5
Matthews: 5
Gilbey: 4
Morgan: 4
B-T: 5
Stockley: 5
Burstow: 5
Washington: 4
Referee: 6
Clare: 6
Pearce: 5
Famewo: 2
Dobson: 5
Matthews: 5
Gilbey: 1
Morgan: 2
B-T: 5
Stockley: 5
Burstow: 1
Washington: 4
Clare: 5
Pearce: 4
Famewo: 4
Dobson: 6
Matthews: 4
Gilbey: 3
Morgan: 4.5
B-T: 6.5
Stockley: 4
Burstow: 4
Washington: 4
Clare: 6 - He is one of our better players, generally positive in possession but backed off for third goal.
Pearce: 5 - Hmmmm
Famewo: 5.5
Dobson: 7 - Can we sign him up on a long term?
Matthews: 6.5 - He has been one of our better players recently and would be worth a new contract but can't forget the rest of the season
Gilbey: 4 - I don't rate him (and never have) even his early bit of wing play was followed with a full pelt across the box
Morgan: 5 - Even his passing was off today
B-T: 7.5 - Best player
Stockley: 6 (+1 for goal) I so want to like him but he is so poor at many of the basics of football that I am beginning to think (despite his goals) that he is more of a negative to our play than a positive. He is also always moaning at other players. Not a captain.
Burstow: 5.5 - I thought he did just about alright but I would have given another young player a go in a meaningless game (for us).
Washington: 5 - Not really sure what he did
Referee: 5 Poor but standard for this div
Opposition: 6 - They weren't very good but still put 3 past us!
J.F-C: n/a - We need to sign him up for next season
Aneke: n/a - Much better as a super sub, which is not a bad tactic if our starting forwards are fit
I can only think that a number of players know they are not going to be resigned, although all played so well against Rotherham last week, so what do I know!
Clare: 7 worked hard
Pearce: 6
Famewo: 6
Dobson: 7
Matthews: 6
Gilbey: 4
Morgan: 5
B-T: 8 our most exciting player
Stockley: 6.5
Burstow: 6
Washington: 6
Referee: 7 would have been 8 if he gave us our deserved penalty
Opposition: 7
MacG: 5
Clare: 5.5
Pearce: 5.5
Famewo: 5.5
Dobson: 6.5
Matthews: 5.5
Gilbey: 5.5
Morgan: 6
B-T: 7
Stockley: 5
Burstow: 5
Washington: 5.5
Referee: 6
Opposition: 6.5
Clare: 5
Pearce: 4
Famewo: 5.5
Dobson: 6
Matthews: 5.5
Gilbey: 3
Morgan: 5
B-T: 7
Stockley: 6
Burstow: 5.5
Washington: 4
Referee: 6
Opposition: 6.5
Clare: 5
Pearce: 4
Famewo: 5
Dobson: 6
Matthews: 6
Gilbey: 4.5
Morgan: 6
B-T: 9
Stockley: 5.5
Burstow: 4
Washington: 5
Referee: 6
Opposition: 6.5
Clare: 5 Did some stuff really well, but a bit sloppy and expect more
Pearce: 5 Just didn’t feel as commanding as he can be
Famewo: 5 I would love him to be consistently better than he has been when playing for us this season, but he is just too inconsistent and I hope this improves as he gains more experience (most likely away from the Valley…)
Dobson: 6.5 not as good as he has been of late, but denied a penalty, turned brilliantly in their area late on and was his usual industrious self
Matthews: 5.5 Some ok crosses, some below average. Time to part ways…
Gilbey: 5 Thought he was right up for it today, but more like a damp through firework with a dry fuse. Sizzled for seconds and then fcuk all. What happened…?
Morgan: 6 Some quality passing and he is adding to his defensive qualities, but would rather have had JFC on for the whole game.
B-T: 8 Seems to be getting stronger by the game. His electric pace will serve us very well going into next season, if he can remain fit. An off your seat type player. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Stockley: 7 Industrious and working hard toward a 20 goal milestone, which I think he will meet.
Burstow: 5 Ran quite hard but unless we have already lined him up for a season long loan next season and want to further test his strengths, I have no idea why he was playing today?
Washington: 5.5 Ran the channels, held the ball well, but not much else today.
Referee: 5.5 Would have been 7 but for the pen miss.
Opposition: 7 They will survive - Stockton is a menace!
J.F-C: n/a
Aneke: n/a
Clare: 5
Pearce: 6
Famewo: 6
Dobson: 6.5
Matthews: 6
Gilbey: 5
Morgan: 5
B-T: 7.5
Stockley: 5.5
Burstow: 5
Washington: 6
Clare: 6
Pearce: 5
Famewo: 5
Dobson: 6
Matthews:5
Gilbey: 5
Morgan: 5
B-T: 7
Stockley: 6
Burstow: 5
Washington: 5
Referee: 6
Opposition: 6
Clare: 5 Good surging forward but got done for their 3rd not a defender
Pearce: 4.5 Got torn a new one by Stockton
Famewo: 5.5 Best defender but faint praise indeed
Dobson: 6 Best midfielder usual decent performance
Matthews: 5 Occasional forward play but too much crab football
Gilbey: 3 great early run but no end product then the invisible man took his bandages off
Morgan: 5 meh, JFC offered more in his brief cameo
B-T: 7.5 main attacking threat yet again extra 0.5 for assist
Stockley: 5.5 poor first half showing, extra point for goal which was a tap in
Burstow: 5 Not ready for mens football extra 0.5 for assist
Washington: 5 little impact
Referee: 5
Opposition: 6 Did their homework on us and took their chances well
Clare: 6
Pearce: 5
Famewo: 5
Dobson: 7 Immaculate. Could play further forward as @Leuth said.
Matthews: 5
Gilbey: 4
Morgan: 5
B-T: 8 Always a threat
Stockley: 5
Burstow: 4
Washington: 5
Referee: 6
Opposition 5 (but 9 for finishing).
Clare: 5.5
Pearce: 5.5
Famewo: 5.5
Dobson: 6.5
Matthews: 5.5
Gilbey: 4.5
Morgan: 5.5
B-T: 7
Stockley: 5.5
Burstow: 5.5
Washington: 5
Referee: 5
Opposition: 6
Clare: 5.5
Pearce: 6
Famewo: 6
Dobson: 7
Matthews: 6
Gilbey: 5
Morgan: 6.5
B-T: 8
Stockley: 6
Burstow: 6.5
Washington: 4
Referee: 4
Opposition: 5
Clare: 4.5. Ridiculous. A simple pass goes astray.
Pearce: 5. Tough, yet defeated by players in a team quicker than him.
Famewo: 4.5. Silly. Trips over the ball.
Dobson: 6. Improving - getting stronger with each game.
Matthews: 4.5. Cross after cross does not beat the first man.
Gilbey: 5 Intelligent runs - pass and receive. Nothing at the end.
Morgan: 4 No! His hapless free-kicks - straight out of play - might work at Maidstone or Ebbsfleet.
B-T: 4.5 The step-over past a step-over - and dribbles up his own arse. No footballing brain.
Stockley: 5. One-dimensional. Immobile. My neighbour said he even falls over in slow motion.
Burstow: 3 No! Headed to Stockley, otherwise utterly anonymous.
Washington: 5 Good sprints - then bumbles and fluffs.
Referee: 7 Perfect decisions.
Opposition: 7 Morecambe were non-league until recently. They beat us at The Valley. Our wealthy and tight-fisted owner should sack Jackson and buy good players. Wigan have done it - and Ipswich too...
J.F-C: n/a
Aneke: n/a
MacG: 4 Should have done a lot better with the goals, saying that, doesn't have much of a clued up defence in front of him.
Clare: 6
Pearce: 5
Famewo: 5
Dobson: 6
Matthews: 6
Gilbey: 4
Morgan: 4
B-T: 6
Stockley: 6
Burstow: 6
Washington: 5
Referee: 6 - missed two clear penalties
Opposition: 7
Clare: 6
Pearce: 6
Famewo:5
Dobson: 7
Matthews: 6
Gilbey: 6
Morgan: 6
B-T: 7.5
Stockley: 6
Burstow: 6
Washington: 5
Referee: 6
Opposition: 7
Clare: 6
Pearce: 5
Famewo: 5.5
Dobson: 7
Matthews: 6
Gilbey: 4
Morgan: 4.5
B-T: 7
Stockley: 4
Burstow: 5
Washington: 5.5
Referee: 7
Opposition: 7
Clare: 6
Pearce: 5
Famewo: 5
Dobson: 7
Matthews: 6
Gilbey: 4
Morgan: 4
B-T: 8
Stockley: 6.5
Burstow: 4
Washington: 5
Referee: 6
Opposition: 7