To be honest i'm not disappointed that we didn't sign Bonne, i'm disappointed that we knew we needed a striker all summer and we left it right up until deadline day and he was our only option.
The very fact that Sandgaard felt the need to put a statement out explaining it, tells me he also knows they've fucked up.
Well said. The issues with Aneke and Stockley were entirely predictable. And, we've seen more from Leaburn than I think any of us realistically expected. And yet it was still glaringly clear we needed another striker. And here we are.
TS, MS, and Gallen fucked up. They fucked up in paying big money and big wages for Stockley and Aneke when neither can be relied to play up front on their own regularly. And they fucked up both in not bringing in another forward, but also in not trying to move on a forward who doesn't fit the system or can't play regularly. I get that moving Stockley on (if that was even possible) was scary in June or July because you can do worse at this level than Stockley. But at some point, you have to speculate to accumulate.
You take a chance that you move on Stockley (or Aneke, but who would buy him?) and get a worse striker. But you also risk not moving him on and being stuck with him as your only fit experienced striker. And here we are.
The end of the window will make it feel worse than it actually was. I think it will turn out to be a good window. Sess, Wallacott, Egbo, JRS, O'Connell, and Payne look like good signings at this level. I haven't seen enough of McGrandles yet, but he seemed highly regarded at this level. But I'm not convinced it was good enough.
Anyway, don't let this ruin the football, at least not yet. We play nice football. We've got a bright, young, progressive coach. There are some very promising youngsters getting a look in, and none of them have looked out of their depth. There's a lot to be positive about as well.
I like the optimism. But the reality is that Egbo hasn’t played at all and may not get in the side. Sessegnon is injured and we are left with a totally untested option, who looks excellent in a confident side, but it would be naive to expect him to be an option there in the long term if things turn in the other direction, purely because he has never played there in his life before this season. We have been left with only 3 senior central defenders, one of whom is always injured. Midfield and wide areas look excellent but we have a striker that plainly cannot play in a 433 and another that is worth half an hour every so often. We must hope and pray that Leaburn and Kanu can step in, but chucking in kids if we do have a downturn wouldn’t be ideal.
In essence, if our aim is steady improvement, it MAY turn out to be an improvement on last season; clearly Garner is a significant upgrade and for that we must be grateful but he’s been hamstrung by not being given the centre halves and strikers that we need to be a force in the division. I do hope he wasn’t promised more and that he doesn’t become disgruntled.
This is nothing to do with Bonne - it wouldn’t have been perfect at all, but we left it so late that clearly he was the only option that we were looking at yesterday.
Matej Vydra Marc McNulty Andy Carroll Yaya Sanogo Hal Robson-Kanu Fraizer Campbell Isaac Vassell Jamie Thomas Oumar Niasse Sam Winnall Leon Clarke Nathan Delfouneso Josh Parker Lewis Mansell Tom Elliott Derick Osei Yaw Theo Robinson Caolan Lavery Ryan Hillier
would personally take izzy brown
Are u Browne? The most injury prone of the lot. No thanks to all of those. Although a couple I’ve never heard of tbf
And to think I once thought TS might buy the Valley one day. 😆
That’s the downfall ,just who will buy The Valley from Roland. Until that mess is sorted out we will always make a loss. Sandgaard has said we are working on it .
We we still be following Charlton when he has gone , providing he leaves us a club to follow.
Relieved we haven't got Bonne. We all know he isn't up to it and saw at the QPR game that was the case. It would have been dreadful signing him on a perm as I would rather go with Leaburn. Saying that where is the CH? £0 spent in the window combined with the redundancies like Olly confirms that TS doesn't have the money to take us forward. I'm genuinely worried now that he doesn't have the funds to keep us running. I think he is well meaning and wants the best for us but promotion will be a massive task. We really have to support the team now. The time to slag off TS will be when the season ends. Doing it now will shred Ooh Ah Mortimer's 25 per cent chance of reaching the top 6.
Good start to a season totally wasted by not adding just another couple of players.
Now watch Stockley or O'Connell get injured on Saturday, leaving us short of players where it's most needed.
And yes, I will laugh when this happens because we have all seen the writing on the wall but the club have done nothing to plug the gaps. You just can't help some people & Sandgaard will see on a weekly basis his "investment" reduce in value as our quest for promotion hits the buffers once again. He ain't getting out with a profit, just like RD. So he cuts costs to the extent that you wonder if he actually has a brain, let alone a business one.
Really seriously thinking about not going much more. Total waste of money.. I have a ST for this season but it may well be my last. Not just footballing reasons but all will become clearer in time.
You'd have thought free agent CBs would be easier to find that goalscoring strikers. Failing that, I hope Jason Pearce is keeping fit...
As an aside, when he was released as a player (alongside Famewo going back), I'm sure the intention would have been the bring in TWO additional CBs, otherwise we might just have given Pearce another year as 4th choice.
What are the rules on something like Pearcey coming back as a registered player. Could he do that? I personally felt he def had another season in him.
We have 2+ players for each position except central defence, what’s the only real disappointment for me. It leaves a bitter taste not getting the additional forward in but it is what it is.
Can't help feeling a bit letdown by how the window has ended. Striker and CB have been a known priority since Garner walked in the door and they haven't been properly addressed. Yes the likes of Ness,Deji, Leaburn and Kanu could all make impacts but it just feels like we're 2-3 senior players light.
Quite how we've ended up going into deadline day with all the eggs seemingly in one basket I don't know. Free agent market doesn't look especially great beyond Matej Vydra who I'm sure could still get a Championship club.
Garner has got the foundations of a good squad there , I just hope not having those final 2-3 pieces doesn't come back to seriously bite with injuries.
Bonne may not have been the first choice of most but he is competent for this level and would have been half decent cover. We are going into the rest of 2022 very exposed to a couple of injuries IMO. If people want to put a positive shine on that, good luck to them.
I despair at some of the people/depressives on here. So we didn't get a deal for MB over the line through no fault of our own. It happens. Grow up. Notwithstanding I remain quietly confident that this will be a very good season. After all the signs have been there for weeks on the pitch, where it matters. Even the youngsters are showing that if needs be they can step up.
In a way the last day was more disappointing because up until then it really had been pretty good. We've bought in some promising players and a coach with genuine talent and vision, we've even cleared out some of the dreck of seasons past.
We were very very close to having a squad/season that just maybe might have us believing again. Everyone knew what was needed to turn the squad into genuine contenders. Instead it's now just a case of seeing just what magic Garner can do when the inevitable injuries and suspensions kick in.
We’re left in a weird situation now where Stockley really doesn’t fit the system we want to play (and it shows) but we’re also screwed if he gets injured/suspended.
I wonder if this will prompt Garner to consider changing style to one that suits the players we have rather than the current system which seems built around players we wish we had.
I'm not having the "better no one than Bonne" bollocks either
We were never gonna pay for a forward to rival Stockley (imo) we spent close to a mil last season on forwards, Stockley is el capitán and gonna start, Chuks will have to earn his wage eventually coming off the bench, would we really have paid out for a third decent pedigree forward, plus wages to sit on the bench, unlikely, with someone like Simpson fair enough as they're still young enough to not expect the world and time to develop - resale etc.
A loan like Bonne would have given us an established forward to bridge the gap between Stockley and Aneke, we all know about Anekes injury history but look at Stockley, missed a good chunk of last season through an awkward injury and he played games not fully fit - even this season we've already had to play him unfit and we're only 6 games in.
Some say the deal collapsed because QPR couldn't get a forward in, others because they tried to diddle us at the last minute. But really, we just shouldn't have let ourselves get in that position in the first place.
A very disappointing end to the transfer window. I believe Garner is a decent manager and if we gave him the extra couple of players we need to challenge for the top six ( striker and centre half ) then most of us would be happy. As things stand we are going to finish mid table in the 3rd division and another opportunity wasted. Still there's nothing we can do about it as it's not us paying the bills. I just hope that when Guitar boy decides he's had enough that there will be someone out there prepared to pick up the pieces.
A very disappointing end to the transfer window. I believe Garner is a decent manager and if we gave him the extra couple of players we need to challenge for the top six ( striker and centre half ) then most of us would be happy. As things stand we are going to finish mid table in the 3rd division and another opportunity wasted. Still there's nothing we can do about it as it's not us paying the bills. I just hope that when Guitar boy decides he's had enough that there will be someone out there prepared to pick up the pieces.
I think we will come up short. That is very likely. It is typical Charlton that Garner would turn out to be good but not be fully backed. It is the story of the last decade and a bit of missed opportunities and the wankers who own us. Crooks or fools, take your pick but that is all you can F*ing choose from.
Comments
expect him to be an option there in the long term if things turn in the other direction, purely because he has never played there in his life before this season. We have been left with only 3 senior central defenders, one of whom is always injured. Midfield and wide areas look excellent but we have a striker that plainly cannot play in a 433 and another that is worth half an hour every so often. We must hope and pray that Leaburn and Kanu can step in, but chucking in kids if we do have a downturn wouldn’t be ideal.
Until that mess is sorted out we will always make a loss.
Sandgaard has said we are working on it .
cN you not read. Qpr changed the terms after Bonne passed a medical.
do you want to explain why you feel that is the owners fault?
Quite how we've ended up going into deadline day with all the eggs seemingly in one basket I don't know. Free agent market doesn't look especially great beyond Matej Vydra who I'm sure could still get a Championship club.
Garner has got the foundations of a good squad there , I just hope not having those final 2-3 pieces doesn't come back to seriously bite with injuries.
7/10 window that could have been a 9.
We were very very close to having a squad/season that just maybe might have us believing again. Everyone knew what was needed to turn the squad into genuine contenders. Instead it's now just a case of seeing just what magic Garner can do when the inevitable injuries and suspensions kick in.
Good luck Mr Garner. You're going to need it.
I wonder if this will prompt Garner to consider changing style to one that suits the players we have rather than the current system which seems built around players we wish we had.
We were never gonna pay for a forward to rival Stockley (imo) we spent close to a mil last season on forwards, Stockley is el capitán and gonna start, Chuks will have to earn his wage eventually coming off the bench, would we really have paid out for a third decent pedigree forward, plus wages to sit on the bench, unlikely, with someone like Simpson fair enough as they're still young enough to not expect the world and time to develop - resale etc.
A loan like Bonne would have given us an established forward to bridge the gap between Stockley and Aneke, we all know about Anekes injury history but look at Stockley, missed a good chunk of last season through an awkward injury and he played games not fully fit - even this season we've already had to play him unfit and we're only 6 games in.
Some say the deal collapsed because QPR couldn't get a forward in, others because they tried to diddle us at the last minute. But really, we just shouldn't have let ourselves get in that position in the first place.
Ah well, proper Charlton at least.
I believe Garner is a decent manager and if we gave him the extra couple of players we need to challenge for the top six ( striker and centre half ) then most of us would be happy.
As things stand we are going to finish mid table in the 3rd division and another opportunity wasted.
Still there's nothing we can do about it as it's not us paying the bills.
I just hope that when Guitar boy decides he's had enough that there will be someone out there prepared to pick up the pieces.