Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: P.J.Trophy Charlton v Crawley (closes Wednesday lunchtime)

your marks please:

Harness: 
Barker: 
Elerewe: 
Pearce: 
Roddy: 
Harness: 
Clare: 
Dobson: 
Blackett-Taylor: 
Clayden: 
Lee: 
Davison: 
Dempsey:
Kirk: 
Referee: 

Burstow: n/a
«1

Comments

  • Harness: 7
    Barker: 6
    Elerewe: 7
    Pearce: 6
    Roddy: 6
    Harness: 6.5
    Clare: 7
    Dobson: 6.5
    Blackett-Taylor: 7
    Clayden: 6.5
    Lee: 8
    Davison: 8.5
    Dempsey:7
    Kirk: 6.5
    Referee: 6
  • Harness: 7
    Barker: 8
    Elerewe: 8
    Pearce: 5.5
    Roddy: 6
    Clare: 6.5
    Dobson: 6.5
    Blackett-Taylor: 8.5
    Clayden: 7
    Lee: 8
    Davison: 8.5
    Dempsey:6
    Kirk: 6
    Referee: 6.5

    Burstow: n/a 8
  • edited August 31
    Harness: 7
    Barker: 6.5
    Elerewe: 6.5
    Pearce: 6
    Roddy: 6
    Clare: 6.5
    Dobson: 7
    Blackett-Taylor: 7
    Clayden: 7
    Lee: 7
    Davison: 7.5
    Dempsey:6.5
    Kirk: 6.5
  • Harness: 6.5 made one great save, distribution a bit inconsistent, not too bad though
    Barker: 6 gave it away for fun but fought nicely 
    Elerewe: 7.5 class 
    Pearce: 5 let's get on that coaching bench shall we 
    Roddy: 6.5 oh cmon he wasn't that bad. started to get more confident once Kirk came on
    Clare: 7 gives us a lot of mobility 
    Dobson: 8.5 MOTM well, if THIS is the real Dobson, I'm...confused tbh. Was immense. Found his level? ;) 
    Blackett-Taylor: 8 will hopefully scare better left-backs than Crawley's
    Clayden: 7 had been ineffective but then pulled off an excellent assist 
    Lee: 8 probably my new favourite Charlton player. Awesome goal and we've only just seen him getting started too. Knits it together and always wants the ball to feet
    Davison: 7.5 a lot of his link play didn't come off but you can't argue with his finishing 
    Dempsey: 6.5 energetic and feisty which is why he's gotten an extension, remains to be seen how well he uses the ball 
    Kirk: 7 started the move for the final goal really nicely 
    Referee I mean who really cares. 10. Idk 
  • Stream.

    Harness: 7
    Barker: 7
    Elerewe: 7
    Pearce: 7
    Roddy: 6.5
    Clare: 7
    Dobson: 7.5
    Blackett-Taylor: 7
    Clayden: 7
    Lee: 7
    Davison: 8
    Dempsey: 7
    Kirk: 7

    Referee: 8

  • Harness: 7
    Barker: 7
    Elerewe: 8
    Pearce: 6
    Roddy: 5
    Clare: 7
    Dobson: 7.5
    Blackett-Taylor: 8
    Clayden: 8
    Lee: 9 - he is class
    Davison: 9
    Dempsey: 6
    Kirk: 6
    Referee: 7 everything right, pen was very soft though.

    Burstow: n/a 10

  • Harness: 6
    Barker: 6
    Elerewe: 7
    Pearce: 6
    Roddy: 5
    Clare: 6
    Dobson: 7
    Blackett-Taylor: 7
    Clayden: 7
    Lee: 7
    Davison: 7
    Dempsey: 6
    Kirk: 6
    Referee: 7
  • Harness: 7 - assured
    Barker: 7 
    Elerewe: 7
    Pearce: 6.5
    Roddy: 6
    Clare: 7
    Dobson: 7
    Blackett-Taylor: 8.5 (motm)
    Clayden: 8
    Lee: 8.5
    Davison: 8
    Dempsey:6
    Kirk: 6
    Referee: 9

    Burstow: 8 - great header, really bright
  • Harness: 7 decent .
    Barker: 6.5 did ok, bit of a funny moment with Elerewe playing pinball in defence though!
    Elerewe: 7.5 hopefully will keep getting better, huge potential.
    Pearce: 6.5 did ok but a bit clumsy maybe for penalty?
    Roddy: 5 Didn't notice him much, don't think Purringtons place is under threat that's for sure.

    Clare: 7 some good work , should have put that header away though.
    Dobson: 7 Good work, lot of energy.
    Blackett-Taylor: 8.5 Really impressed tonight and great goal.
    Clayden: 8 that's more like it. Worked really hard and showed great pace.
    Lee: 9 MOTM wow what a player and great goal.
    Davison: 8.5 extra .5 for the hatrick , never stopped.
    Dempsey:6.5 battled Well while he was on.
    Kirk: 6.5 a few good bits of play but still yet to show what he's about I think.
    Referee: 

    Burstow 7.5 yes its maybe a high mark for a sub who only came on towards the end but what he did in those minutes was absolute quality.
  • Harness: 8 - Deserved a clean sheet, did alright
    Barker: 7 - Solid out of position
    Elewere: 7 - Another assured performance from him
    Pearce: 5 - Cant be giving away penalties like that in competitions like this
    Roddy: 6 - Struggled
    Clare: 6 - Drifts in and out of games, but does well when he gets involved
    Dobson: 7 - Decent display from him, a lot more to come I think from him
    Blackett-Taylor: 8 - Might turn out to be an underrated signing
    Clayden: 6 - Loan would do him the world of good this season
    Lee: 8 - Took his goal extremely well
    Davison: 9 - Hope he gets given his hat-trick, club top scorer if so

    Dempsey: 6 - Unfortunately didnt notice him
    Kirk: 7 - Continuing to settle in quite nicely
    Burstow: 8 - Howzat for your debut

    Referee: 8 - Didnt notice him either
  • Sponsored links:


  • Harness: 7.5 - very confident and tidy 
    Barker: 7
    Elerewe: 8 - very impressive. Looks like a star in the making
    Pearce: 6 - great servant but shouldn’t play in the first team 
    Roddy: 7 - thought he was quite good. 
    Clare: 6.5 - doesn’t look he has a great first touch
    Dobson: 8.5 - very solid and drove it on. 
    Blackett-Taylor: 7.5 - decent. 
    Clayden: 7 - tricky
    Lee: 8 - the biggest plus. Looks busy, inventive and good on the ball. And what a finish. Should replace Morgan ASAP. 
    Davison: 8.5 - so strong at holding up and very good finishes. 
    Dempsey: 6
    Kirk: 6
    Referee: 6

    Burstow: n/a 
  • Harness: 7
    Barker: 5
    Elerewe: 7
    Pearce: 6
    Roddy: 5
    Clare: 7
    Dobson: 7
    Blackett-Taylor: 8
    Clayden: 7.5
    Lee: 9
    Davison: 8
    Dempsey: 6
    Kirk: 6
    Referee: 7

    Burstow: n/a 
  • edited August 31
    Harness: 8 Stopped everything they threw at him, bar the penalty
    Barker. 8 Did well but looks too small for a centre back and not fast enough for a full back.
    Elerewe: 8. Class act, all the time in the world.
    Pearce: 7 Gave away a central free kick and a penalty to show why we have signed another CB
    Roddy: 5 Kept losing his man. Really a long way off.
    Clare: 7 Looked good until he got a knock
    Dobson: 7 Looked good at this level
    Blackett-Taylor: 7 Some great runs, good back up for DJ
    Clayden: 6.5 Lot to learn but some good crosses
    Lee: 9 MOM An attacking mid linking with the strikers, just what we have been missing
    Davison: 8 Never stopped and 2 good goals
    Dempsey:6 Not much of an impression
    Kirk: 6 Does not look to me that his head is right, unsurprisingly
    Referee: 7
    Burstow: n/a What a start, a goal and an assist. It was lovely seeing him being mobbed by his other youth mates
  • Harness: 7.5
    Barker: 7.5
    Elerewe: 8
    Pearce: 7
    Roddy: 7
    Clare: 7.5
    Dobson: 8.5
    Blackett-Taylor: 8
    Clayden: 7.5
    Lee: 9
    Davison: 8.5
    Dempsey:7
    Kirk: 7
    Referee: 7.5
  • Harness:  7.5
    Barker:   7
    Elerewe:   7
    Pearce:  6.5
    Roddy:   6
    Clare:   7
    Dobson:   7.5
    Blackett-Taylor:   7
    Clayden:   7
    Lee:  9
    Davison:   8
    Dempsey:  6.5
    Kirk:  6.5
    Referee:  6
  • Harness: 7
    Barker: 6
    Elerewe: 7
    Pearce: 6
    Roddy: 5 
    Clare: 7.5
    Dobson: 7.5
    Blackett-Taylor: 7.5 
    Clayden: 6.5
    Lee: 8
    Davison: 7.5 
    Dempsey: 5
    Kirk: 6
    Referee: 6
  • Harness: 7
    Barker: 6.5
    Elerewe: 7
    Pearce: 6
    Roddy: 6: 
    Clare: 7
    Dobson: 7
    Blackett-Taylor: 7.5
    Clayden: 7
    Lee: 7.5
    Davison: 7.5
    Dempsey: 6
    Kirk: 6
    Referee: 6
  • Harness: 7 good save and long kicking
    Barker: 6 steady
    Elerewe: 8 classy
    Pearce: 7 had to do work of 2 men due to
    Roddy: 2 never stopped a cross, we must have someone better in the U-23, 18, 12s?
    Clare: 6 good at 1st time stuff
    Dobson: 6.5 same
    Blackett-Taylor: 7 exciting watch
    Clayden: 6 promising
    Lee: 7.5 classy
    Davison: 8 good mobility, 2 good finishes
    Dempsey: 6 steady
    Kirk: 6 steady
    Referee: 7 not over fussy

  • Harness: 7
    Barker: 6
    Elerewe: 7
    Pearce: 6
    Roddy: 6
    Clare: 7
    Dobson: 7
    Blackett-Taylor: 7
    Clayden: 7
    Lee: 9
    Davison: 8
    Dempsey:6
    Kirk: 6
    Referee: 7

    Burstow: n/a
  • Harness 7 - good saves and handling, but would like to see more strength and command 
    Barker 6.5 - solid but gave it away too much
    Elerewe 7.5 - looked very assured, impressing me more every game
    Pearce 6.5 - for me that's a soft pen, he goes down so easily, but he was moving away from the goal so Pearce shouldn't have given the ref an option
    Roddy 6 - I still feel he's short of the required standard, but looked more comfortable today so hoping he'll develop well in the U23s
    Dobson 7.5 - covered so much ground and broke down attack after attack. Much better
    Clare 7.5 - touch of the match in keeping the momentum for the own goal. Overall very assured
    Blackett-Taylor 7.5 - got very lucky with his goal, but deserved it for his positivity. Serious pace
    Clayden 7 - had just cursed him for taking it too far again when he put in a peach of a cross for the 5th
    Lee 8 - would be a 9 if just the first half, was a level above everyone else (well, 3 levels above Crawley's left back and #5)
    Davison 8 MoM - stole Man of the Match in the last minute by showing such intent to score. Showed how much of a role he has to play. Well done lad.
    Dempsey 7 - energetic and accurate
    Kirk 6.5 - better than Saturday

    Ref - 6
  • Sponsored links:


  • Harness: 6.5
    Barker: 6
    Elerewe: 7
    Pearce: 6.5
    Roddy: 6 
    Clare: 7
    Dobson: 7
    Blackett-Taylor: 7.5
    Clayden: 7
    Lee: 8
    Davison: 7
    Dempsey: 7
    Kirk: 6.5
    Referee: 6
  • your marks please:

    Harness: 7 looks a good prospect 
    Barker: 7 worked really hard
    Elerewe: 7.5 another good performance 
    Pearce: 5 good captain, but time has caught up with him
    Roddy: 6 got forward well , positioning not great sometimes 
    Clare: 7 better today 
    Dobson: 7 as above
    Blackett-Taylor: 8 brilliant first half 
    Clayden: 7.5 a real livewire
    Lee: 8 exciting player 
    Davison: 8 a real handful tonight 
    Dempsey:6.5 busy player 
    Kirk: 6.5 did ok
    Referee: 8 

    Burstow: 8 very impressive 

  • Harness: 7
    Barker: 7
    Elerewe: 7
    Pearce: 6
    Roddy: 6
    Clare: 7.5
    Dobson: 7.5
    Blackett-Taylor: 7.5 
    Clayden: 7
    Lee: 8
    Davison: 7.5 
    Dempsey: 5
    Kirk: 7
    Referee: 6
  • Harness: 7
    Barker: 6
    Elerewe: 7
    Pearce: 6
    Roddy: 6
    Clare: 7 
    Dobson: 7 
    Blackett-Taylor: 8 
    Clayden: 7
    Lee: 8
    Davison: 8 
    Dempsey: 6
    Kirk: 6
  • Harness: 7
    Barker: 6
    Elerewe: 7
    Pearce: 6
    Roddy: 5
    Clare: 7
    Dobson: 7.5
    Blackett-Taylor: 7
    Clayden: 7
    Lee: 7.5
    Davison: 7
    Dempsey:6
    Kirk: 6
    Referee: 8

    Burstow: n/a looks a great prospect.
  • edited August 31
    addickson said:
    Harness: 7 good save and long kicking
    Barker: 6 steady
    Elerewe: 8 classy
    Pearce: 7 had to do work of 2 men due to
    Roddy: 2 never stopped a cross, we must have someone better in the U-23, 18, 12s?
    Clare: 6 good at 1st time stuff
    Dobson: 6.5 same
    Blackett-Taylor: 7 exciting watch
    Clayden: 6 promising
    Lee: 7.5 classy
    Davison: 8 good mobility, 2 good finishes
    Dempsey: 6 steady
    Kirk: 6 steady
    Referee: 7 not over fussy

    This is my first lancashire lad annoyance of the season, but richly deserved: don't be horrid
  • Harness: 6.5
    Barker:  7
    Elerewe: 7.5
    Pearce: 6.5
    Roddy: 6.5 did some things well, other times showed his inexperience. What is it with Charlton fans and left backs?
    Clare: 7 good energy, got clattered a lot
    Dobson:  7 good energy 
    Blackett-Taylor: 7.5 faded 2nd half but was terrorising Crawley
    Clayden: 7
    Lee: 8.5 best player on the pitch
    Davison: 7.5 did really well
    Dempsey: 6.5
    Kirk: 7.5
    Referee: 7 was OK actually, all the officials looked like they could keep up with play, why does that not happen for League 1?
  • Harness: 8
    Barker: 7
    Elerewe: 7.5
    Pearce: 7
    Roddy: 7.5
    Clare: 7.5
    Dobson: 8
    Blackett-Taylor: 8 
    Clayden: 7.5
    Lee: 8.5
    Davison: 8 
    Dempsey:7
    Kirk: 7
    Referee: 10
  • Harness: 7 - Didn't have loads to do, a very crucial save in the first half at 1-0 
    Barker: 7 - Started the second half poorly but overall a decent display. Not ready yet but has plenty of time to improve. A full season in the U23's should do him a world of good. 
    Elerewe: 7.5 - Like Barker showed a bit of inexperience at times but no doubt he's an exciting prospect
    Pearce: 7 - Minus .5 for a stupid foul regardless of whether the game was over. 
    Roddy: 5.5 - Actually showed pretty decent composure on the ball I thought. It's his defending and positioning that concerns me. Failed to stop dangerous crosses coming in on numerous occasions and was nowhere to be seen at other times. However, he is still a young lad and needs games in the U23's to improve. 
    Clare: 7.5 - Showed glimpses of real quality and overall was very good
    Dobson: 8 - Superb performance, broke up attacks, made runs forward and played some lovely passes, particularly for Lee's goal. 
    Blackett-Taylor: 8 - Fantastic first half, was scaring them everytime he got the ball, shown by the fact they changed their team at HT. Like most wingers he probably won't do it every game but given he's unlikely to be a starter it was nice to see. 
    Clayden: 8 - Thought he lacked composure in the first 30 mins and looked very raw. But then really improved and put in some fantastic crosses. Very unlucky not to score and what I liked was the fact he looked decent on both wings. 
    Lee: 8 - Tired and was pretty poor in the last 10 mins before coming off but was brilliant before that. Capped with a superb goal. Really excited by this signing. 
    Davison: 8.5 (MOTM) - Held it up well, made some decent runs and played a part in 3 goals. Still not convinced he has the ability to do it regularly in League 1 but couldn't ask for much more and was hopefully a real breakthrough performance for him. 
    Dempsey: 6 - Did ok but I'm not sure what his role will ever be. 
    Kirk: 6 - Came on at a time he didn't need to do anything. Helped us knock it round a bit. 
  • Harness: 7
    Barker: 7
    Elerewe: 7.5
    Pearce: 5.5
    Roddy: 6.5
    Clare: 7
    Dobson: 7
    Blackett-Taylor: 8.5
    Clayden: 7
    Lee: 8
    Davison: 8.5
    Dempsey:6.5
    Kirk: 6
    Referee: 7
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!