Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks; Charlton v Wigan (closes Monday lunchtime)

24

Comments


  • Amos: 7
    Inniss: 7.5
    Pratley: 7
    Famewo: 6.5
    Gunter: 6.5
    Watson: 6
    Shinnie: 6.5
    Forster-Caskey: 7.5 MOM
    Doughty: 5.5 Not my sort of player so probably biased
    Aneke: 7.5
    Smyth: 6.5
    Bogle: 5.5
    Referee: 4

  • edited October 2020
    Amos: 6.5
    Inniss: 7
    Pratley: 6
    Famewo: 8
    Gunter: 7.5
    Watson: 6
    Shinnie: 6.5
    Forster-Caskey: 6.5
    Doughty: 7
    Aneke: 8.5
    Smyth: 7
    Bogle: 6.5
    Referee: 4
  • Amos: 6.5
    Inniss: 7
    Pratley: 6
    Famewo: 7 
    Gunter: 6.5
    Watson: 3.5
    Shinnie: 5.5
    Forster-Caskey: 7 
    Doughty: 6
    Aneke: 7.5
    Smyth: 7
    Bogle: 6
    Referee: 3, he was crap and inconsistent (the latter far less forgivable than being crap imo)

    Purrington: n/a
    Washington: n/a
  • Amos: 6
    Inniss: 7
    Pratley: 6
    Famewo: 7.5
    Gunter: 6
    Watson: 5
    Shinnie: 6
    Forster-Caskey: 7
    Doughty: 6
    Aneke: 8 MOM
    Smyth: 7
    Bogle: 6
    Referee: 2 comedy ref - just terrible on every level
  • Amos: 7.5
    Inniss: 7
    Pratley: 7
    Famewo: 6
    Gunter: 6
    Watson: 6
    Shinnie: 6
    Forster-Caskey: 7.5
    Doughty: 6
    Aneke: 8
    Smyth: 7
    Bogle:6
    Referee: 6
  • edited October 2020
    Amos:      7
    Inniss:     7.5
    Pratley:    6.5
    Famewo:  6.5
    Gunter:     6
    Watson:    5
    Shinnie:      6.5
    Forster-Caskey: 7.5 
    Doughty:     7 
    Aneke:         8
    Smyth          7 
    Bogle:           5.5
    Referee:        5

    Purrington: n/a
    Washington: n/a


  • Amos:  7
    Inniss:  7
    Pratley:  6
    Famewo:  6
    Gunter:  6
    Watson:  4
    Shinnie:  6
    Forster-Caskey:  7 
    Doughty:  6
    Aneke:  8
    Smyth:  7 
    Bogle:  6
    Referee:  5
  • Amos: 7 solid 7, good save corner 1st half, potential howler second. But still solid.

    Inniss: 7 everywhere just like Pearce. I think he may become a favourite even if he is am ex Nigel.

    Pratley: 6.5 not his best, alot down to being needlessly out of position, actually pushed forward to support quite well in attack.

    Famewo: 7 didn't have to stand out like previous games today as the rest of the defence was better, but not a foot wrong and some good balls forward

    Gunter: 7.5 was made to earn his money today. Quite like him, certainly no worse than Matthews it appears on that performance.

    Watson: 4.85 he was really quite poor. Misplaced passes clumsy challenges and beaten for pace at every opportunity. Got away with their penalty shouts and got booked. Will be disappointed to see him start again Tuesday.

    Shinnie: 6 This is one signing I expect alot of alongside Madison. Wasn't bad today, but didn't really feel as in the game as some of the others today but quiet.

    Forster-Caskey:7 difficult this one, scored yes but I give more credit to their keeper ( who made 2 fantastic saves to stop us already being up already) saw loads of the ball, but will be remembered for what didn't come off. So I actually think it was a solid performance, as he was involved in everything.

    Doughty: 6.5 came in and or of the game, nothing seemed to have a massive impact either in attack or defence for the lad. Loved the winding up of the oppo and keeping a slightly cooler head in the confrontation.

    Aneke: 7.6 some absolutely class touches from him, turned every one in sight. Really wish he had scored the goal as he created himself enough chances. Can't moan about missing them if he created it for himself. Plus one one stopped superbly by their keeper.

    Smyth: 7.3 really impressed, seems to have a style we haven't had since Vetokele. Really worried their defence. Hope he has a better strike rate / injury record whilst with us than the aforementioned. Really excited to see more from him.

    Bogle:6.5 looked powerful, but clumsy. Wanted slightly more from his one proper shot. Chased down well for the time he was on.

    Referee: 3 Absolute clown. I think Wigan have more moan about than us. Missing the intentional headbitt on Doughty, the breaking up of all our play, I couldn't tell you what is worth a yellow card and not with this fella. I think Wigan have more moan about than us however one deffo penalty and one I could have given. Let alone never knowing who the ball went out from.

    Purrington: n/a
    Washington: n/a
  • Amos: 7
    Inniss: 7
    Pratley: 6
    Famewo: 7
    Gunter: 7
    Watson: 5
    Shinnie: 6
    Forster-Caskey: 7
    Doughty: 7
    Aneke: 8
    Smyth: 7
    Bogle: 6
    Referee: 4

    Purrington: n/a
    Washington: n/a
  • Amos: 6.5  Did well, apart from 2nd half when he made a save with his his legs wide open, instead of getting his body behind the ball. But he got away with it.
    Inniss: 7 Solid & in control.
    Pratley: 6 Some good some bad. No idea why Bowyer would play him on left & JFC on right. 
    Famewo: 6.5 Untroubled.
    Gunter: 6.5 Looked classy for this level.
    Watson: 6 Decent, but I'm expecting an improvement. 
    Shinnie: 6 Relatively quiet game.
    Forster-Caskey: 7 I'll give him extra 0.5 for the goal.
    Doughty: 6
    Aneke: 7.5 MOM
    Smyth: 6.5 Our best player early on but faded.
    Bogle: 6 
    Referee: 3 Absolute shite.
  • Sponsored links:


  • Amos: 7.5
    Inniss: 6
    Pratley: 6
    Famewo: 7
    Gunter: 7.5
    Watson: 6
    Shinnie: 6.5
    Forster-Caskey: 8
    Doughty: 6.5
    Aneke: 8
    Smyth: 7
    Bogle: 6.5
    Referee: 3 

  • Amos: 7
    Inniss: 6
    Pratley: 7
    Famewo: 6
    Gunter: 8
    Watson: 5
    Shinnie: 6
    Forster-Caskey: 7
    Doughty: 6
    Aneke: 9 MOTM
    Smyth: 7
    Bogle: 6
    Referee: 4

    Purrington: n/a
    Washington: n/a
  • Amos: 7
    Inniss: 7.5
    Pratley: 6
    Famewo: 8
    Gunter: 7.5
    Watson: 5.5
    Shinnie: 6.5
    Forster-Caskey: 8
    Doughty: 6.5
    Aneke: 8.5
    Smyth: 7
    Bogle: 6
  • Amos: 7
    Inniss: 7 - very good once he settled down
    Pratley: 6.5
    Famewo: 7.5 - looks a class player
    Gunter: 6.5
    Watson: 6 - very average performance, but showed his experience at the death
    Shinnie: 6.5
    Forster-Caskey: 7.5 - good performance, he needs to be further up the pitch to be effective
    Doughty: 6.5 
    Aneke: 8 - excellent, but needs to get his fitness sorted so he can play the full 90
    Smyth: 6.5 - lively debut
    Bogle: 6 - hopefully he will improve as he gets up to speed
    Referee: 4 

  • Amos:  7 A couple of iffy moments but generally good
    Inniss:  7 Solid
    Pratley:  6 Out of position in a position where we need more creativity
    Famewo:  7 I like this guy. Looks
    Gunter:  7.5 Defended well and I'd guess his pass completion rate was very good.
    Watson:  5 Disappointing. Hasnt found his feet yet
    Shinnie:  6.5 Some good moments. Think he will be a very good signing
    Forster-Caskey: 7.5 Best game since Derby last season
    Doughty: 6 Didn't look the same player after the injury
    Aneke:  8 Some wonderful touches. Can he do it every week?
    Smyth:  7  Good first half, faded in the second
    Bogle:  6 Looks strong but obviously rusty
    Referee:  4.5 Mixed bag!
  • Amos: 8  
    Inniss: 7  
    Pratley 6 : 
    Famewo: 7  
    Gunter: 8  
    Watson: 5  
    Shinnie: 6  
    Forster-Caskey: 7  
    Doughty: 6  
    Aneke: 8  
    Smyth: 6  
    Bogle: 6
    Referee: 4  
  • Amos: 7.5
    Inniss: 7
    Pratley: 7
    Famewo: 7:5
    Gunter: 7
    Watson: 6
    Shinnie: 6.5
    Forster-Caskey: 7
    Doughty: 6.5
    Aneke: 8
    Smyth: 7.5
    Bogle: 6.5
    Referee: 5.5
  • Amos: 7
    Inniss: 7.5
    Pratley: 7
    Famewo: 8
    Gunter: 7
    Watson: 4
    Shinnie: 6
    Forster-Caskey: 9.5 thought he was brilliant excluding the goal
    Doughty: 6
    Aneke: 8.5
    Smyth: 8 
    Bogle: 6
    Referee: 5
  • Amos: 8.5
    Inniss: 7
    Pratley: 6.5
    Famewo: 7
    Gunter: 6.7
    Watson: 6.5
    Shinnie: 7
    Forster-Caskey: 7.5
    Doughty: 7
    Aneke: 7.5
    Smyth: 7
    Bogle: 6
    Referee: 3
  • edited October 2020
    not sure of the formation but here goes

    Amos: 7.5
    Inniss: 7.5
    Pratley: 5.5
    Famewo: 7
    Gunter: 7
    Watson: 6
    Shinnie: 7
    Forster-Caskey: 7.5 MOTM
    Doughty: 6.5
    Aneke: 7.5
    Smyth: 6.5
    Bogle: 6.5
    Referee: 5 Weird 

    Purrington: n/a
    Washington: n/a


  • Sponsored links:


  • not sure of the formation but here goes

    Amos: 7 
    Inniss:  6
    Pratley:  5
    Famewo: 6.5
    Gunter:  6
    Watson:  4
    Shinnie:  5
    Forster-Caskey:  6
    Doughty:  6
    Aneke:  7.5
    Smyth:  6
    Bogle: 4
    Referee:  3.5

    Purrington: n/a
    Washington: n/a


  • Amos: 7
    Inniss: 6.5
    Pratley: 6.5
    Famewo: 7
    Gunter: 7
    Watson: 5.5
    Shinnie: 6.5
    Forster-Caskey: 7.5
    Doughty: 6.5
    Aneke: 7
    Smyth: 7
    Bogle:6.5
    Referee: 5
  • edited October 2020
    Amos: 6.5
    Inniss: 6.5
    Pratley: 6
    Famewo: 7
    Gunter: 6.5
    Watson: 5
    Shinnie: 6
    Forster-Caskey: 7
    Doughty: 6.5
    Aneke: 7
    Smyth: 7
    Bogle:6
    Referee: 5
  • not sure of the formation but here goes

    Amos: 8
    Inniss: 7
    Pratley: 5
    Famewo: 7
    Gunter: 7
    Watson: 6
    Shinnie: 6
    Forster- Caskey: 7
    Doughty: 7
    Aneke: 8
    Smyth: 6
    Bogle: 4
    Referee: 3

    Purrington: n/a
    Washington: n/a


  • Amos: 7
    Inniss: 7
    Pratley: 6
    Famewo: 7
    Gunter: 7
    Watson: 6
    Shinnie: 6
    Forster-Caskey: 8
    Doughty: 6
    Aneke: 8
    Smyth: 7
    Bogle:6
    Referee: 3

    Purrington: n/a
    Washington: n/a
  • I missed the first 23 minutes as i fell asleep putting the baby for a nap! So

    Amos: 7
    Inniss: 7
    Pratley: 7
    Famewo: 6.5 
    Gunter: 6
    Watson: 6.5
    Shinnie: 7
    Forster-Caskey: 8
    Doughty: 6.5
    Aneke: 8 MOTM
    Smyth: 7
    Bogle: 6.5
    Referee: 5
  • Amos: 7 Good game apart from the spill that could have cost us the game, offset by the point blank save.
    Inniss: 7.5 Excellent debut, looks a solid defender
    Pratley: 6 Mixed bag today, slow at times
    Famewo: 7.5 Another excellent debut
    Gunter: 7
    Watson: 6.5 Occasional glimpse of class but too much of the opposite.
    Shinnie: 7
    Forster-Caskey: 7 Worked hard, good goal
    Doughty: 6.5 
    Aneke: 8 Am looking forward to seeing him when, excellent  control, hold up and lay off
    Smyth: 7 Put in a real shift today
    Bogle: 6
    Referee: 3 Poor for both sides
  • Amos  8.0  I still think he is a better keeper than Philips. 
    Gunter 7.0  A good debut from.a professional defender. Will sharpen up with games. 
    Inniss 7.0  Good debut, passes a little heavy at times. Minutes will help. Big lad. Sarr with an edge.
    Famewo 7.0 best game yet really. Getting better all the time.
    Doughty 7.0  Surprised me that he got stuck in so well. Best game for a while. Certainly better attitude than Bonne.
    Shinnie 6.5  Fair debut. Again not yet match fit but will improve.
    Watson  6.5 Why so many bookings. However he gets stuck in and adds some grit. 
    Pratley 6.5  With so many new players around him it made things awkward for him. 
    Smyth 7.5 Lively, quick and tracks back too. Well done.
    Aneke  8.5 A really decent touch and movement.  Holds the ball well.  MoM
    Bogle 6.5 The way he moved off the defender for his shot suggests a thinking footballer . First game and little prep but looks strong and menacing. 
    Purrington 6.0 not enough time on to warrant more but did nothing wrong. 
    Washington 6.0 ditto.

    Referee 3.5. How Joe Watson got away with so many deliberate niggling fouls all seen by referee is mystifying.  How he is s referee, more so. 
     
    What about our match winner?


  • Amos: 7 - one great save but a couple of fumbles. But you can’t argue with 2 clean sheets
    Inniss: 8 - great debut
    Pratley: 6.5 - too slow and old to be starting these games
    Famewo: 8 - looks like he will do well for us 
    Gunter: 7.5 - proper right back, mostly played very well.
    Watson: 7 - a bit old and slow (see Pratley) but got in some decisive tackles at the end and it was a totally committed performance
    Shinnie: 7.5 - looked good on his debut 
    Forster-Caskey: 7.5 - an extra .5 for the goal, certainly improved after he scored
    Doughty: 7 - worked hard but nothing really came off.
    Aneke: 9 - led the line well had a couple of half chances and a very subtle touch for a big man. Reminded me of Leeeeeeaaburn!
    Smyth: 8 - tried hard, quick and nippy, the long throws give us an extra dimension
    Bogle: 7 - not really on long enough to  form a view
    Referee: 6 - some bizarre decisions but for once it didn’t cost us 

    Purrington: n/a
    Washington: n/a



  • Amos: 7.5
    Inniss: 7
    Pratley: 6
    Famewo: 6.5
    Gunter: 7.5
    Watson: 6
    Shinnie: 7.5
    Forster-Caskey: 7
    Doughty: 7
    Aneke: 8
    Smyth: 7
    Bogle:6.5
    Referee: 5
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!