Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Charlton v WBA (closes Monday lunchtime )

13

Comments

  • At the Valley or from a live stream, your marks please 

    Phillips: 7
    Lockyer: 7
    Oshilaja: 7
    Sarr: 7.5 That tackle. 
    Matthews: 6.5
    Pratley; 7
    Gallagher: 7.5
    Dempsey: 6
    Doughty: 7
    Davison; 7.5
    Green: 7 Good skill. Works hard. I know he was very highly regarded at Villa. Really looking forward to seeing more of him. If he can show some consistency he'll be a real coup. 
    Forster-Caskey: 6 Gave him a standing ovation in my living room when he came on. A year and a half with almost no football. He looked rusty, but just so happy to have him back. We desperately need a play like him in midfield. 
    Williams: 7 He's got to be a right pain in the arae to play against 
    Referee: 5

    Hemed: The bits we've seen of him, and what I remember seeing of him at Brighton, there's a real play there. He's got an excellent first touch. He's big and strong and he can score goals. I'm really looking forward to seeing more of him second half. 

  • Phillips:  6.5
    Lockyer: 7
    Oshilaja: 6.5
    Sarr:  7
    Matthews: 7
    Pratley; 7.5
    Gallagher: 6.5
    Dempsey: 5.5
    Doughty:  6.5
    Davison;  7
    Green: 7
    Forster-Caskey: 7
    Williams: 7
  • edited January 2020
    Phillips: 7 - Some smart saves again. 
    Lockyer: 7 - Big mistake for their goal but great timing for his goal. Shame he won't be given it though!
    Oshilaja: 7.5 - Oshi is a really good blocker. He did several times last week and was at it again today. 
    Sarr: 8 - Some blocks, a lot of very good passing, a nice cushioned header for Davison and an amazing sliding tackle to prevent a goal. 
    Matthews: 7 - Another good shift. He's not going to burn past anyone (like Doughty) but he's quick to get us up the pitch and to recover.
    Pratley; 8 - Did so much work, headers, tackles, interceptions, twists, turns. He will have enjoyed that yesterday. 
    Gallagher: 6 - Wasn't quite at it. Was surprised he didn't hit the target when their goalie passed straight to him and it seemed to affect him. He did get better when JFC came on to help.
    Dempsey: 6 - Plenty of effort and a couple of good tackles. Not a bad player and the experience will have done him no harm at all. 
    Doughty: 7.5 - His crossing is very hit and miss but luckily he got one spot on for Lockyer. Defensively did ok and was good with the ball at his feet. Even when players come back, he should be in the squad. 
    Davison; 8 - Showed that he has got an all-round game. Good touch, pretty quick, pretty physical, very willing, striker's instinct. Sign him up on a long term deal now. 
    Green: 7 - Looked strong. Given that he hasn't played much I thought he looked pretty sharp. 
    Forster-Caskey: 7 - Buzzed around nicely. Good to have him back. 
    Williams: 7 - Same as JFC. Gives us a totally different look when he's running with the ball, looking for one-twos. 
    Referee: 6 - He certainly didn't spoil the game, which is my benchmark. I liked the bundle in the middle of the pitch; we stopped but WBA played to the whistle! 

    Hemed: n/a - He was ok. Looked a bit sharper than previous occasions and good to get his experience on at that stage. I think he'll do a decent job from now on. 
  • Having watched the highlights I have returned to my marks and increased Oshilaja’s score. My mistake.
  • edited January 2020
    Phillips: 7 No blame for first because he was set for first effort that was blocked
    Lockyer: 7 Lost a point their first, gained a point for our second 
    Oshilaja: 6.5 To blame for second. An easy clearance or even chance to control the ball he completely messed up looked decent otherwise
    Sarr: 8.5 Key part for our first and what a tackle. That was effectively a goal.
    Matthews: 6.5 Solid
    Pratley: 7.5 Made it a war which was needed for us
    Gallagher: 7 Involved and important cog in the wheel. Disapointed he didn't do better when 0-0 and passed in second half when a shot was open to him. 
    Dempsey: 5.5 Was a person on the pitch.
    Doughty: 7.5 A massive bonus from our injury crisis along with Bonne. Looking like an established player now. Seems to be developing a great understanding with Gallagher.
    Davison: 7.5 I have questioned what he brings but he has found his feet and I liked what I saw.
    Green: 7 Good with ball at his feet
    Forster-Caskey: 6 Good to see him back
    Williams: 7.5 Lively considering his absence. Great to have him back.

  • Phillips:  7
    Lockyer: 6.5
    Oshilaja: 7.5
    Sarr: 8.0
    Matthews: 7.5
    Pratley; 7.5
    Gallagher: 7.5
    Dempsey: 7
    Doughty: 7.5
    Davison; 7.5
    Green: 7
    Forster-Caskey: 7
    Williams: 7
    Referee: 6

    Hemed: n/a
  • Phillip's 7
    Lockyer 6
    Oshilaja 6
    Mathews 5
    Sarr 8 for that great tackle that kept us in the game.
    Pratley 7
    Dempsey 5
    Doughy 7
    Davison 7
    Green 6
    Fostercasky 7
    William's 7

  • Phillips: 6 Solid enough despite not having much to do! Feel he will be disappointed especially with the first goal.
    Lockyer: 7 Struggling a bit, could see that mistake for first goal coming from a mile off, made up for it all with that majestic header for the equaliser.
    Oshilaja: 7 Solid unit enjoyed him playing sort of as a sweeper for us, best position for him. Passing is still shocking needs to stop trying the glory ball... although saying that one great pass but doesn't make up for countleas misplaced passes.
    Sarr: 7.5 Solid enough, still unnerves me sometimes feels like he can do something amazing but then a cock up is always on the cards. Extra half poing for that amazing last ditch tackle.
    Matthews: 6 Works hard and seems to be in right position defensively always so can't fault it.
    Pratley: 8.5 POM Experienced! Pure experience getting us through the games! Kept everyone ticking and constantly talking to and encouraging the kids around him.
    Gallagher: 6 Solid display had a tough game in that midfield. Should have scored early on! 
    Dempsey: 5 Not good enough at this level. Tried his best but not ready for championship football
    Doughty: 8 Absolute find of the season! Able to beat any opponent, passing and delivery is improving every game! Has improved so so so so much since that league cup game against Forest green rovers.
    Davison: 8 Absolute battler! Might not be the biggest, fastest ir strongest but he took on 2 big lads in Bartley and Ajayi and got the better of both of them. Deserved that goal  for all his hard work 
    Green: 6 Looked like a great signing first half some lovely touches, faded away second half.

    Forster-Caskey: 5 Always liked him but definitely struggling with all these injuries hopefully he can get back to his best.
    Williams: 6 So happy to see this little man back playing! Brings so much quality to the team when he plays! 

    Referee: 1 Absolute bottle job! West Brom were so dirty and could have had more than 1 sending off. Also never ever seen a referee just run past players grappling on the floor... he genuinely even see it happening! Ball watching referee 


  • Sponsored links:


  • Phillips: 8
    Lockyer: 8
    Oshilaja: 5
    Sarr: 8.5
    Matthews: 7.5
    Pratley; 8.5
    Gallagher: 5.5
    Dempsey: 5.5
    Doughty: 6.5
    Davison; 7
    Green: 7
    Forster-Caskey: 7
    Williams: 6
    Referee: 4
  • Phillips: 7.5 not a lot to do, good save early doors.
    Lockyer:  7 poor by his standards but redeemed himself with a  goal
    Oshilaja: 7
    Sarr:  7.5
    Matthews: 7.5 
    Pratley;  8.5 everywhere. 
    Gallagher: 7 not his best game for us
    Dempsey:  6.5 not really ready at this level
    Doughty: 7.5 
    Davison; 8 really impressed - was today his first league start? 
    Green: 7.5 looks tricky
    Forster-Caskey: 7.5 a bit rusty but his experience was useful
    Williams: 8 an electric player, a joy to watch him
    Referee: 4 decisions weren't bad when he made them but lost control which is worse than a bad decision
  • Phillips 7
    Lockyer 6.5
    Oshilaja 7
    Sarr 7
    Matthews 7
    Pratley 8
    Gallagher 7
    Dempsey 6
    Doughty 6.5
    Davidson 7.5
    Green 7

    Forster-Caskey: 6 
    Williams: 7
  • Phillips: 7 Solid,as usual.
    Lockyer: 7 Bad mistake for their goal, ball got a bit stuck under his feet.But great header for his goal. Again,solid,as usual.
    Oshilaja: 7.5 Good player, always seems to play well when he does play.
    Sarr: 7.5 extra half point for THAT tackle..
    Matthews: 6.5 Solid
    Pratley: 6.5. Yes, does get his foot in and disposess players regularly, but still concerned with the hole that he leaves behind him which seems to be exploited regularly by opposition, as he's not quick enough to fill it.Maybe when Josh is back that will be less evident.
    Gallagher: 7 Good game as usual.always made space, and was always available
    Dempsey: 5 not sure of the logic of him playing before others who were on the bench.
    Doughty: 8 what  a player we have here - next academy player to leave for big money? Should be a regular on teeam sheet now.
    Davison: 7.5 Very good game, normally with players chucked in from non-league they lack presence and nous - not this fella.
    Green: 7 like him, will be a good signing.
    Forster-Caskey: 5 didnt really notice him tbh
    Williams: 7 Welcome back Jonny.
  • Phillips: 7
    Lockyer: 3
    Oshilaja: 3
    Sarr: 7
    Matthews: 7 
    Pratley; 9.5
    Gallagher: 8
    Dempsey: 6
    Doughty: 8
    Davison; 9
    Green: 6
    Forster-Caskey: 7 
    Williams: 6
    Referee: 0
  • Phillips: 6
    Lockyer: 6
    Oshilaja: 7
    Sarr: 6
    Matthews: 7
    Pratley; 8
    Gallagher: 7
    Dempsey: 7
    Doughty: 7
    Davison; 8
    Green: 7

    Referee: 2

    Forster-Caskey: 6
    Williams: 6
  • Phillips 7
    Lockyer 7
    Oshilaja 7.5
    Sarr 8
    Matthews 7
    Pratley 7.5
    Gallagher 6.5
    Dempsey 5.5
    Doughty 7.5
    Davison 7
    Green 7
    Forster-Caskey: 6.5 
    Williams: 6.5
  • Phillips: 7 No real chance with the goals
    Lockyer: 7 Bad mistake for their goal but great header for the equaliser.
    Oshilaja: 7.5 Competed well
    Sarr: 8 Great challenge to prevent a goal.
    Matthews: 6 Jury still out. OK defensively but can be a bit negative at times.
    Pratley; 8.5 Relished the battle
    Gallagher: 7 Quietish game for him
    Dempsey: 6 Didn't really notice him.
    Doughty: 8.5 Continues to impress.
    Davison; 9 MOM Worked really hard and made a real nuisance of himself. Well taken goal as well
    Green: 7.5 Started slowly but got better as the game went on.

    Forster-Caskey: 7
    Williams: 8 
    Hemed 6

    Referee 5

  • Phillips: 7
    Lockyer: 7
    Oshilaja: 7
    Sarr: 7
    Matthews:7 
    Pratley; 9
    Gallagher: 8
    Dempsey: 6
    Doughty: 8
    Davison; 8
    Green: 7.5
    Forster-Caskey: 7
    Williams: 7.5
    Referee: 2 we have had some terrible refs but he has to have been the worst
  • Phillips: 7.5 - One excellent 1st half save, and fairly solid and commanding throughout
    Lockyer: 6.5 - Did a lot of very good work, scored, but glaring mistake for their first goal
    Oshilaja: 7 - Got stuck in!
    Sarr: 7 - Did well with an assist and a brilliant goal saving tackle, but often exposed by pace
    Matthews: 6 - Had a better game but he never exudes confidence to me and is often caught the wrong side of players
    Pratley; 7 - Amazing player; no skill at all but gives 100% every time, and loves winding up the oppo!
    Gallagher: 6 - Missed an early chance and failed to shine after that
    Dempsey: 5.5 - Worked hard but rabbit in headlamps at times
    Doughty: 8 - Wow, what a prospect this lad is; so confident going forwards and great assist too
    Davison; 7 - Worked very hard against experienced defenders and fully deserved his goal
    Green: 6.5 - Good effort with natural pace
    Forster-Caskey: 6 - Didn't flinch and provided good experience when required
    Williams: 7 - Welcome back JW!
    Referee: 7 - I thought he did OK; though he flourished the yellow card quite a lot he missed the Lockyer/Robson-Kanu wrestle despite it going on just yards away
  • Sponsored links:


  • Phillips: 7
    Lockyer: 7
    Oshilaja: 7
    Sarr: 7.5
    Matthews: 7
    Pratley; 7.5
    Gallagher: 6.5
    Dempsey: 6
    Doughty: 7
    Davison; 8
    Green: 6
    Forster-Caskey: 6
    Williams: 6.5

    Referee: 4
  • Phillips: 8
    Lockyer: 7
    Oshilaja: 8
    Sarr: 8
    Matthews: 6
    Pratley; 7
    Gallagher: 6
    Dempsey: 5
    Doughty: 8
    Davison; 8
    Green: 8
    Forster-Caskey: 7
    Williams: 7
  • edited January 2020
    Live stream
    Phillips: 8
    Lockyer: 5
    Oshilaja: 7
    Sarr: 9
    Matthews: 7
    Pratley; 8
    Gallagher: 7
    Dempsey: 6
    Doughty: 6
    Davison; 8
    Green: 7
    Forster-Caskey: 6
    Williams: 6
    Referee: 4

    Hemed: n/a

    Very good team performance. 
  • Phillips: 7
    Lockyer: 7.5
    Oshilaja: 7
    Sarr: 7
    Matthews: 7
    Pratley; 8
    Gallagher: 7.5
    Dempsey: 7
    Doughty: 7.5
    Davison; 9
    Green: 8
    Forster-Caskey: 7
    Williams: 7
    Referee: 6
  • Phillips: 8
    Lockyer: 7
    Oshilaja: 8
    Sarr: 7
    Matthews: 7
    Pratley; 8.5
    Gallagher: 7
    Dempsey: 6.5
    Doughty: 7
    Davison; 8
    Green: 7
    Forster-Caskey: 7
    Williams: 7
    Referee: Twat

    Hemed: n/a
  • Phillips: 8 solid performance
    Lockyer: 7 poor judgement for first goal but redeemed with equaliser
    Oshilaja: 7 Played great first 60 min then tired??? Mistakes for baggie 2nd goal
    Sarr: 7 sound
    Matthews: 8 Great performance
    Pratley; 7 seemed out of energy
    Gallagher: 7 battling as usual but we'll contained
    Dempsey: 6 made mistakes not needed but good account
    Doughty: 7 good continues to improve
    Davison; 7 wish he could win though hwaaders but good first goal
    Green: 7 looked useful and wants them to play wuicker
    Forster-Caskey: 7 gave us stability we needed in middle
    Williams: 7 dangerous - more games would be great
    Referee: 5 fair to start with then ignored Lockyer wrestling and should have done something about baggie fans keeping the ball.
    Pratley- out of energy 🤷🏻‍♂️
  • Phillips: 7 - solid as ever
    Lockyer: 6 - a big mistake for the first goal, a good header for our equaliser
    Oshilaja: 6.5 - his passing can be a bit erratic but he did ok overall
    Sarr: 7.5 - a fine assist for our first goal and an amazing, goal-saving tackle in the second half
    Matthews: 6.5 - decent enough
    Pratley: 8.5:MoM - a magnificent first half performance by Pratters. He covered a huge amount of ground, held our young team together and gave a virtuoso display of the dark arts
    Gallagher: 6.5 - not much went for him earlier in the game but his level picked up towards the end
    Dempsey: 5.5 - worked hard but not really ready for this level
    Doughty: 7 - a fine player who looks very much at home
    Davison: 8 - did exceptionally well against their 6ft 5 and 6ft 4 giants at the back. Gave as good as he got and made a thorough nuisance of himself throughout. The goal will do him the world of good
    Green: 7 - a very clever and speedy player. An encouraging and very promising performance
    Forster-Caskey: 6.5 - looked tidy when he entered the fray and it's great to see him back
    Williams: 7 - caused them trouble and drew his usual quota of fouls. We have really missed his ball carrying ability
    Referee:4 - a difficult game to referee but he let too much go
  • edited January 2020
    Watched on dodgy porn site

    Phillips: 7.5
    Lockyer: 7.5 not so great then great 
    Oshilaja: 7.5
    Sarr: 8 great, then not so great, then very great
    Matthews: 7.5
    Pratley;  9 great great great great
    Gallagher: 7.5
    Dempsey: 7.5
    Doughty: 7
    Davison; 7.5 grrrreeeaaatttt
    Green: 7.5 greatish
    Forster-Caskey: 7.5 greetings...
    Williams: grated
    Referee: 4.6 grrrrrrr

    Hemed: n/a
    Love that. But no mark for Williams @LennyLowrent
  • LL are you Paul Merson, he only seems to use the adjective great when describing football action, eg. great ball, great pass, great cross, great shot, great goal.
  • Phillips: 8
    Lockyer: 7
    Oshilaja: 7
    Sarr: 7
    Matthews: 6
    Pratley; 9
    Gallagher: 7
    Dempsey: 6
    Doughty: 7
    Davison; 8
    Green: 8
    Forster-Caskey: 7
    Williams: 7
    Referee: 3
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!