West Brom v Charlton | Sat 26 Oct | 3pm KO | Post-match Thread

mendonca

AddicksAddict said:

mendonca said:

I don't see Sarr as more than a deputy CB in the Championship. Like the guy but still needs to add some grit and nastiness. 

None of our other CBs could have provided that pass for our first v Derby. 

Agree with that observation.

MuttleyCAFC

VAR would have disallowed their second and despite it being a soft penalty, we have seen from experience that the penalty would have been referee's call. VAR would have won us the game.

Talal

MuttleyCAFC said:

VAR would have disallowed their second and despite it being a soft penalty, we have seen from experience that the penalty would have been referee's call. VAR would have won us the game.

Though technically the penalty incident wouldn't have occurred had their second been disallowed.

Dazzler21

Talal said:

MuttleyCAFC said:

VAR would have disallowed their second and despite it being a soft penalty, we have seen from experience that the penalty would have been referee's call. VAR would have won us the game.

Though technically the penalty incident wouldn't have occurred had their second been disallowed.

Technically? What technicalities do you think would have stopped us continuing to play to score? 

It could very well have still happened.

Talal

Dazzler21 said:

Talal said:

MuttleyCAFC said:

VAR would have disallowed their second and despite it being a soft penalty, we have seen from experience that the penalty would have been referee's call. VAR would have won us the game.

Though technically the penalty incident wouldn't have occurred had their second been disallowed.

Technically? What technicalities do you think would have stopped us continuing to play to score? 

It could very well have still happened.

That specific penalty incident wouldn't have happened as it would've been a different sequence of events. So can't really say VAR would've won us the game.

MuttleyCAFC

Well VAR didn't happen as it wasn't there - we are debunking the crap from West Brom fans, that's all.

Talal

MuttleyCAFC said:

Well VAR didn't happen as it wasn't there - we are debunking the crap from West Brom fans, that's all.

I know. But who cares what they think.

lancashire lad

We seem to do well against the good teams as we and they attack which gives us room to play our game, my concern is against the poorer teams that are more defensive and give us no room