Players Marks: Charlton Athletic v Swindon Town

lancashire lad

and for the final time this season your marks please:

Rudd:
Solly:
Bauer:
Pearce:
DaSilva:
Crofts:
Byrne:
Forster-Caskey:
Jackson:
Homes:
Magennis:

Ahearne-Grant n/a
Aribo n/a
Barnes n/a

Holdkneebomb

Holmes and da silva 8
, rest 7

sam3110

Rudd: 6.5 spilled a couple, punched a couple, saved a couple
Solly: 7 decent enough
Bauer: 7 not much to do, somehow booked
Pearce: 7 not much to do either
DaSilva: 7.5 will be at a top half championship team next year
Crofts: 6.5 great tracker and tackler, still can't pass for toffee
Byrne: 7 worked very hard, decision making let's him down sometimes
Forster-Caskey: 7.5 well taken goal, settled in now
Jackson: 8.5 what a man
Homes: 8 probably won't be here next season
Magennis: 8 good hustling performance against a shit defence

KAG worked hard when he came on, Barnes and Aribo too late to make any impact

Leuth

Rudd 7.5 good performance
Solly 7 not bad, backed off his man a bit at times
Bauer 8 very dominant show
Pearce 7.5 good display
Da Silva 8 excellent and too good for us probably
Crofts 6.5 bless him, typical ball-losing, ball-winning display
Byrne 6.5 good assist and very prominent. Kept doing the wrong thing but that's ok
JFC 8 at last starting to show what he can do
Jackson 6.5 shame he couldn't quite get his goal, game was bypassing him a bit but decent first half
Holmes 8.5 MOTM all were dazzled by the feet of Holmes
Magennis 8 back to the Magennis we knew before injury

Rob7Lee

Rudd 7 good performance, i'd have him back
Solly 7 mr steady, hope he's here next year
Bauer 7 did OK
Pearce 7 we need more like him
Da Silva 7 will be a good player
Crofts 6 does he know we play in red when he's passing?
Byrne 7 ditto Da Silva
JFC 7 one of his best games for us
Jackson 10 nothing needs saying..... disgraceful substitution by Robinson! Should have gone 442 with Jackson up with Magennis.
Holmes 7 that could be the last we see of him.....
Magennis 7 looked more like his old self.

Leuth

Disgraceful substitution? Allowing a standing ovation for an obviously tiring legend was completely appropriate

Rob7Lee

Leuth said:

Disgraceful substitution? Allowing a standing ovation for an obviously tiring legend was completely appropriate

Was slightly tongue in cheek, but he could have given him 10 minutes more and took him off in the 85th minute, he legs could have coped, didn't need to be the 74th minute, you can see how gutted he was to come off and wanted to stay on and try and get a goal as he told Robinson in the dug out, interestingly Solly equally seemed to have words about his own substitution, i'm guessing that was also for a farewell.......

seth plum

Rudd: 6
Solly: 6
Bauer: 6
Pearce: 6.5
DaSilva: 8
Crofts: 7
Byrne: 6.5
Forster-Caskey: 7
Jackson: 7
Holmes: 7.5
Magennis: 7.5

rananegra

Rudd: 7
Solly: 7.5
Bauer: 7
Pearce: 7
DaSilva: 7.5 be good if we can get him back
Crofts: 7.5 still lots of misplaced passes, but was good at breaking things up today
Byrne: 7 some mistakes, some really good play.
Forster-Caskey: 7 better
Jackson: 8 not sure he did much for the firs 15, but definitely rose to the occasion. Unlucky not to nick a goal.
Homes: 8
Magennis: 7.5 bit closer to the pre-injury Josh.

1StevieG

Rudd: 6.5
Solly: 6.5
Bauer: 6.5
Pearce: 6.5
DaSilva: 7 Loved the tekkers when using his back to stop the ball going out for a throw in.
Crofts: 6.5
Byrne: 6.5
Forster-Caskey: 6.5
Jackson: 6
Holmes: 7.5
Magennis: 7

CafcWest

Rudd: 7
Solly: 7
Bauer: 7
Pearce: 7
DaSilva: 8
Crofts: 7
Byrne: 7
Forster-Caskey: 7.5
Jackson: 6.5
Holmes: 7.5
Magennis: 7

AddicksAddict

Rudd: 6
Solly: 7.5
Bauer: 7.5
Pearce: 7.5
DaSilva: 7
Crofts: 6.5
Byrne: 6
Forster-Caskey: 6
Jackson: 5
Homes: 7
Magennis: 7.5

Not a great performance by any of them. The back four did enough, the goals were taken well, sadly JJ was off the pace.

AddicksAddict

Rob7Lee said:

Rudd 7 good performance, i'd have him back
Solly 7 mr steady, hope he's here next year
Bauer 7 did OK
Pearce 7 we need more like him
Da Silva 7 will be a good player
Crofts 6 does he know we play in red when he's passing?
Byrne 7 ditto Da Silva
JFC 7 one of his best games for us
Jackson 10 nothing needs saying..... disgraceful substitution by Robinson! Should have gone 442 with Jackson up with Magennis.
Holmes 7 that could be the last we see of him.....
Magennis 7 looked more like his old self.

It's not big, and it's not clever.

jbcafc

Rudd: 6
Solly: 7.5
Bauer: 6.5
Pearce: 7
DaSilva: 7
Crofts: 6.5
Byrne: 6.5
Forster-Caskey: 6.5
Jackson: 8.5
Holmes: 7.5
Magennis: 7.5

SouthWest_Addicks

Rudd: 6
Solly: 6
Bauer: 6
Pearce: 6
DaSilva: 6.5
Crofts: 6
Byrne: 6
Forster Caskey 6
Jackson: 6
Homes: 8
magennis: 6.5

Ahearne-Grant n/a
Aribo n/a
Barnes n/a

Low scores before Swindon were incredibly terrible.

Clem_Snide

Rudd - 6
Solly - 6
Bauer - 6.5
Pearce - 6.5
Da Silva - 7
Crofts - 6
Byrne - 5.5
Forster Caskey - 6.5
Jackson - 6
Holmes - 7.5
Magennis - 7

andynelson

lancashire lad said:

and for the final time this season your marks please:

Rudd: 7
Solly: 7
Bauer: 6
Pearce: 8
DaSilva: 8
Crofts: 7
Byrne7
Forster-Caskey: 7
Jackson: 10
Holmes: 8
Magennis: 7

Ahearne-Grant n/a
Aribo n/a
Barnes n/a

mogodon

Rudd - 6
Solly - 7
Bauer - 6
Pearce - 6
Da Silva - 7 (thought Robinson was going to explode with joy when he used his back to keep the ball in)
Crofts - 6
Byrne - 7
Forster Caskey - 7
Jackson - 6
Holmes - 8 (hope he's here next season as without him we lack so many options)
Magennis - 7 (would have been 8 had he put the right bloody studs in!)

harveys_gardener

Rudd: 7 dominant shame he's off
Solly: 6 will he ever get his mojo back?
Bauer: 7 hope he stays
Pearce: 7 decent but expected him to organise morre
DaSilva: 8 Page or Dasilva? Mmm toughie!
Crofts: 5 dogshit
Byrne: 6.5 better further forward
Forster-Caskey: 7 decent game
Jackson: 5 embarrasing hope he doesn't play again
Holmes: 7.5 involved in most of our decent stuff
Magennis: 7 no longer chases down but decent wiith the ball

LenGlover

6s all round except Holmes 7.5 for a goal and two assists and Jacko 6.5 for being Jacko

JamesSeed

Rudd: 7
Solly: 7
Bauer: 6.5
Pearce: 7.5
DaSilva: 7
Crofts: 7 (kept giving the ball away, then winning it back.
Byrne: 7
Forster-Caskey: 6.5 Bit slo-mo at times
Jackson: 8.5
Holmes: 8
Magennis: 7.5 It's taken him AGES to get back into this sort of form.

HantsAddick

Rudd - 6 A few errors today
Solly - 7
Bauer - 7
Perace - 6.5
DaSilva - 7
Crofts - 7 Worked hard.
Byrne 7.5 Good game.
Forster-Caskey - 6.5 Despite his goal, still too many errors
Jackson - 7
Holmes - 8.5 MOM
Magennis _ 8 More like the Josh we know.

Essex_Al

Rudd: 7
Solly: 7.5
Bauer: 7.5
Pearce: 7
DaSilva: 8.5
Crofts: 7
Byrne: 6.5
Forster-Caskey: 8
Jackson: 6
Homes: 8.5
Magennis: 8

Sheepie1985

Rudd: 6 - didn't call for the ball enough, at all actually. Spilled some balls too, have a feeling it's the last time we'll see him
Solly: 7 - liked his energy and movement, good to see him trying to get in the box
Bauer: 7 - solid
Pearce: 6.5 - I didn't really notice him
DaSilva: 7.5 - first time I've seen him play, great player with so much potential. Why was he wasted on the bench for so long?!
Crofts: 6 - lost the ball a lot but won it back
Byrne: 7.5 - good work ethic
Forster-Caskey: 7 - would be higher if it wasn't for the errors
Jackson: 8 - the man wanted to score so much in the second half! Great standing ovation and hope to see him on the pitch next season
Homes: 10 - the guy's touch and finesse is out of this world. Signs of a premier league performance today
Magennis: 7.5 - saw a few glimpses of his old self before getting injured today, hopefully next season will be his year

CyrilDavies

Leuth said:

Disgraceful substitution? Allowing a standing ovation for an obviously tiring legend was completely appropriate

Good job, as there was no chance after the game.

Mckforester

Rudd: 7
Solly: 6.5
Bauer: 6.5
Pearce: 6.5
DaSilva: 7
Crofts: 6.5
Byrne: 6.5
Forster-Caskey: 6.5
Jackson: 7
Homes: 8
Magennis: 7.5

thewolfboy

Rudd: 6 Prob last game
Solly: 7 Good performance
Bauer: 6
Pearce: 6
DaSilva: 7.5 Wish we had him next year
Crofts: 5.5
Byrne: 6 Prob his last game
Forster Caskey 6 Improving
Jackson: 6 Gave his all.
Homes: 8 Different class - he'll be off...
magennis: 6.5

Ahearne-Grant n/a Promising (in practice his shots were woeful!)
Aribo n/a
Barnes n/a congrats!

Buglehorn

Rudd: 6.5
Solly: 6.5
Bauer: 6
Pearce: 6
DaSilva: 7
Crofts: 6.5
Byrne: 6.5
Forster-Caskey: 7
Jackson: 6.5
Holmes: 8
Magennis: 7.5

Ahearne-Grant n/a
Aribo n/a
Barnes n/a

ateamofcorygibbs

Difficult to mark as Swindon were so so poor...

Rudd: 6.5 a few good saves
Solly: 6.5 defended well and got into the opposition area a few times as well - would have loved him to get a goal
Bauer: 6 centre backs were generally decent - maybe got in a bit of a muddle around their disallowed goal, but generally in control with not much to do
Pearce: 6 as above
DaSilva: 6.5 did a lot of running and produced a couple of inspired moments - leaping like a salmon to keep the ball in on the west touchline with his back was a highlight
Crofts: 6 typical Crofts performance with lots of battling tackles, some very good passes, and a fair sprinkling of mistakes and poor decisions
Byrne: 5.5 in and out of the game, but some good moments
Forster-Caskey: 5.5 good going forward at times, but a few dodgy moments too
Jackson: 5.5 for today but 10 for being one of the few things keeping charlton feeling even remotely like charlton the last three years. didn't do a lot in the game today - was desperate for a goal and spent a lot of time out of position trying to get it!
Holmes: 8 MOM brilliant player, class above
Magennis: 7 great header for the goal and linked up well with Holmes throughout. Still think he's more use with another striker playing off him, but he worked hard all game and played well

Leuth

"Difficult to mark, so I'll be really, really stingy"

Redrobo

Rudd: 6.5
Solly: 6.5
Bauer: 6
Pearce: 6
DaSilva: 7
Crofts: 6.5
Byrne: 7
Forster-Caskey: 7.5
Jackson: 6.5
Holmes: 8
Magennis: 7

Ahearne-Grant n/a
Aribo n/a
Barnes n/a