Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Your Best Charlton XI....With a Twist

Name your best Charlton XI........ but only using players who HAVEN'T played for Charlton in the top division (old 1st Division or Premier League). Try to go for a 4-4-2 formation (plus a goalie!!).......
«13

Comments

  • Johns
    Curtis, Went, Costa, Minto
    Powell, Kinsella, Campbell, Simonson
    Firmani, Hales
  • Nicky Johns - I don't think he played in Div One.
    Billy Bonds
    Paul Went
    Bob Curtis
    Mike Bailey
    Paul Elliott
    Paul Walsh
    Len Glover
    Derek Hales
    Lee Bowyer
    Robert Lee.

    Not well balanced as a team. Sure there are a lot more.
  • dickplumb said:

    Johns
    Curtis, Went, Costa, Minto
    Powell, Kinsella, Campbell, Simonson
    Firmani, Hales

    Great team DIck but you can't have Johns, Costa, Minto or Kinsella. Bit like Slade yesterday.....you've got four to find!
  • Nicky Johns - I don't think he played in Div One.
    Billy Bonds
    Paul Went
    Bob Curtis
    Mike Bailey
    Paul Elliott
    Paul Walsh
    Len Glover
    Derek Hales
    Lee Bowyer
    Robert Lee.

    Not well balanced as a team. Sure there are a lot more.

    Sorry Billy....Johns and Rob Lee played in Div One at Selhurst.
  • This is going to take time
  • Simonsen said:

    dickplumb said:

    Johns
    Curtis, Went, Costa, Minto
    Powell, Kinsella, Campbell, Simonson
    Firmani, Hales

    Great team DIck but you can't have Johns, Costa, Minto or Kinsella. Bit like Slade yesterday.....you've got four to find!
    Or Firmani. Played in division 1 for Charlton pre Italy move.
  • 1. Henderson
    2. Solly
    3. Wiggins
    4. Webster
    5. Ben Haim
    6. Gudmonsson
    7. Bowyer
    8. Diarra
    9. Flanagan
    10. Simonsen
    11. Hales
  • Hamer
    Solly Bauer Morrison wiggins
    Buyens Shelvey Poyet Bowyer
    Yann Lookman
  • True, I am wrong.
    Will bring in Charlie Wright in goal.
    Colin Powell
  • Wright
    Curtis Bonds
    Reeves Went Bailey
    Glover Hales Flanagan Simonson Powell
    SUB Graham Moore
  • Sponsored links:


  • Dick Plumb has already included him but surely no team could possibly exclude Allan Simonsen?

    He is after all a former European Footballer of the Year and the only footballer to have scored in the European Cup, UEFA Cup, and Cup Winners' Cup finals and wasn't even 30 when he joined us. Not even Killer could match those credentials!
  • edited November 2016
    Tutt
    Curtis Bonds Went Minto
    Powell Bailey Simonson Glover
    Hales Tracey
  • Tutt

    Bonds
    Elliott
    Went
    Wiggins

    Powell (Colin)
    Campbell (Alan)
    Bowyer
    Glover

    Hales
    Flanagan

    It will be different tomorrow! Could have picked Simonsen of course but tried to go for players who played for a while ie at least a season.
  • Minto was a Selhurst era Div One player. Think he made his debut away to Millwall in 0-1 Xmas time defeat. Maybe move Bonds to left back and find another centre back?
  • Johns
    Curtis
    Minto
    Elliot
    Went
    Campbell
    Bowyer
    Simonsen
    Hales
    Walsh
    Flanagan

    The team balance and could do with Bailey, Bonds, Glover and Firmani but they were all before my time.

    My hunch is that its level of attacking flair might have been a little rich for Russell's blood.
  • Or even "the team is unbalanced..."
  • Simonsen said:

    dickplumb said:

    Johns
    Curtis, Went, Costa, Minto
    Powell, Kinsella, Campbell, Simonson
    Firmani, Hales

    Great team DIck but you can't have Johns, Costa, Minto or Kinsella. Bit like Slade yesterday.....you've got four to find!
    Wright in goal, Elliott centre half, Kinsey left back, Bailey midfield.

  • edited November 2016
    dickplumb said:

    Simonsen said:

    dickplumb said:

    Johns
    Curtis, Went, Costa, Minto
    Powell, Kinsella, Campbell, Simonson
    Firmani, Hales

    Great team DIck but you can't have Johns, Costa, Minto or Kinsella. Bit like Slade yesterday.....you've got four to find!

    Wright in goal, Elliott centre half, Kinsey left back, Bailey midfield.

    I think Kinsey played under Jimmy Seed in division 1. Not much admittedly but he played I believe.
  • Tutt
    Gomez
    Elliott
    Went
    Reid
    Powell (C)
    Campbell (either)
    Moore
    Bowyer
    Hales
    Kermorgant
  • Sponsored links:


  • Tutt
    Gomez
    Elliott
    Went
    Reid
    Powell (C)
    Campbell (either)
    Moore
    Bowyer
    Hales
    Kermorgant

    Oo....I like Gomez....good choice. But Reid played in Div One.
  • Hamer
    Solly Gomez Morrison Wiggins
    Cousins
    Stephens Jackson
    Shelvey
    Kermorgant Lookman
  • Based off what I've seen since mid 90s

    Hamer
    Solly
    Wiggins
    Gomez
    Ben Haim
    Shelvey
    Jackson
    Stephens
    Lookman
    Kermorgant
    BWP

  • LenGlover said:

    Tutt

    Bonds
    Elliott
    Went
    Wiggins

    Powell (Colin)
    Campbell (Alan)
    Bowyer
    Glover

    Hales
    Flanagan

    It will be different tomorrow! Could have picked Simonsen of course but tried to go for players who played for a while ie at least a season.

    But Len that's like saying I could have had one night of passion with Marilyn Monroe but opting for a lifetime with Ena Sharples instead ;-)
  • Kinsella scored against Man U at Old Trafford in our first season in the prem.
  • tricky said:

    1. Kermorgant
    2. Kermorgant
    3. Kermorgant
    4. Kermorgant
    5. Kermorgant
    6. Kermorgant
    7. Kermorgant
    8. Kermorgant
    9. Kermorgant
    10. Kermorgant
    11. Kermorgant

    Got a feeling your dreaming of that team
  • edited November 2016
    Wright
    Bonds Hinton Went Kinsey
    A Campbell Bowyer M Bailey Glover
    Hales P Walsh
  • Graham Tutt

    Billy Bonds
    Paul Elliott
    Pat Bauer
    Rhoys Wiggins

    Colin Powell
    Alou Diarra
    Allan Simonsen
    Keith Peacock

    Mike Flanagan
    Derek Hales
  • No point in selecting Simonsen, as good as the other nine outfield players were they wouldn't have been able to read his passes / through balls :wink:
  • tricky said:

    1. Kermorgant
    2. Kermorgant
    3. Kermorgant
    4. Kermorgant
    5. Kermorgant
    6. Kermorgant
    7. Kermorgant
    8. Kermorgant
    9. Kermorgant
    10. Kermorgant
    11. Kermorgant

    Got a feeling your dreaming of that team
    We're all dreaming of that team!
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!