Rudd ... 6 : After a few shaky goals against Fleetwood and Wimbledon he's done really well of late
Solly ... 6 : Gets an additional mark for his goal line clearance yet in injury time, Ulvestad was with the ball with his back to the goal and no one came to support him, for me Solly should have been there ready to whip in the cross.
Fox ... 6 : Probably one of a few players who came out of yesterday with a bit of credit, did his job well
Konsa ... 5 : Was bullied by their No.12 who was winning everything
Bauer ... 7 : Best player on the pitch, best Defender in the League
Holmes ... 6 : Not his best of nights
Crofts ... 5 : Just couldnt put a foot right to begin with, gets an extra mark for the pass that lead to the goal
Jackson ... 4 : Just dog awful last night
Novak ... 4 : See Jackson, should have been taken off instead of Crofts, felt Foley coming on was a waste of a sub.
Magennis ... 6 : Took his goal well, yet should have squared the ball to Novak in the second half rather than shooting.
Lookman ... 6 : Showed intent, deserved a goal for that effort at the death
Rudd: 7 His saves kept us in the game. Solly: 5.5 Quiet performance - even when he took over as captain!! Fox: 6 One or two mistakes but he is definitely improving. Konsa: 5 Despite a couple of good tackles,unfortunately out of his depth, as shown by constant passing back to Rudd. Bauer: 6.5 Our best defender. Holmes: 6 Not his night and guilty of giving the ball away too much. Crofts: 5 Brings little to the side. Ulvestad: 6.5 A class player, who needs an equally gifted player alongside him. Jackson: 5 Fairly anonymous. Novak: 6 Reasonable performance. Maginnes: 7.5 By far our best player last night. Well taken goal and immense effort all night. Foley: 5 Not the answer to our deficiencies in midfield. Lookman: 5.5 Hardly involved, apart from hitting the crossbar!
Rudd: 6 Nothing to do really Solly: 6 Definite downward spiral in his form Fox: 6 As long as you dont expect too much from Fox you dont get dossapointed Konsa: 5 deinately a confidence player and being out of the team dont feel helped Bauer: 7 Was our best defender last night Holmes: 6 poor by his high standards but still tried Crofts: 6 thought it was wrong decision to pull him as he is a constant steady Ulvestad: 5 did not add anything to the team last night Jackson: 5 See Ulvstead Novak: 5 For a big lad he has no physical presence Maginnes: 7.5 Worked hard again took his goal well but needs to stop playing the man Foley: 5 Poor mans Croft Lookman: 6 Always a buzz when on the pitch and was unlucky to hit the bar but didnt really get into the game
Overall a poor team performance and Oldham were the better team. Slade looks happy with a point at the moment and knows we cannot hold onto a lead.
Rudd: 6 Solly: 4 Fox: 4 Konsa: 4 Bauer: 4 Holmes: 6 Crofts: 2 absolute toilet footballer Ulvestad: 6 Jackson: 3 genuinely forgot he was on. Stop playing him left FFS Novak: 2 Unfit and probably not very good anyway Maginnes: 6 Foley: 4 Lookman:6
Rudd: 6 Didn't do anything wrong Solly: 6.5 Great block and clearance, could have done more offensively Fox: 4 Stupid free kick to give away for the goal - passing up to usual poor standards - deserves to be dropped Konsa: 5 Has had his taste, needs a break Bauer: 6.5 Solid Holmes: 6 Not his best but was our only threat with Magennis and Lookman when he came on Crofts: 3 I could have done better with two dodgy knees - pathetic performance Ulvestad: 5 Not great but pick of the midfield Jackson: 4 Sad to see but he shouldn't be starting games Novak: 3 Might as well have had a statue on the pitch Maginnis: 7 did well, but needs a pacy striker playing off him Foley: 4.5 Foley for Crofts sums it up really Lookman : 6.5 Not his best but a threat. We needed just to get the ball to him.
Slade: 2 Very poor - Why was Botaka not given a chance?
Rudd: 7 did fine, had no chance with goal Solly: 6 did Ok but has lost some pace in the last 12 months. Fox: 6 the usual mix of the good, bad and ugly. Konsa: 5 looked shaky most of the night. Bauer:6.5 battled away. Holmes:6.5 1st touch a bit off, but tries to make things happen. Crofts:5.5 not quick enough Ulvestad:5.5 i can see potential but coming into a struggling team ? Jackson: 5 we all knew colin would be right one day ? top goal scorer thou. Novak:4 not fit. Maginnes:7.5 gives 100% but was Knacked in last 20 minutes. Foley:4.5 over run as soon as he came on. Lookman:6.5 should always start in home matches. would have been a cracking winner near the end.
Slade 3.5 hard job i know but you are struggling big time.
Foley doesn't even deserve 1, his first touch was to ping the ball out of play. He runs around like a headless chicken, pulling the midfield out of shape and creating gaps. He is the worst player I have seen play for Charlton in all my years, but again I said that about Simon Francis and he's now captain of a premier league side!
Rudd: 6 Solly: 6 Fox: 3 - skinned every time, and passes into tight areas and puts our own players under pressure Konsa: 6 - solid enough - needs a commanding presence alongside him Bauer: 5 - solid but should be leading that back four with Solly and pulling Konsa around Holmes: 6 - lots of fancy runs and tricks but nothing came of it Crofts: 5 - awful start, slowly got into it, uninspiring and slow Ulvestad: 7 - only player who actually got on the ball and didnt rush - wasn't amazing but was doing the jobs of jackson and crofts as they cant run Jackson: 4 - past it, not up to playing on the wing or CM. needs legs around him to make up for his lack of Novak: 2 - pathetic - looks 2 stone overweight and touch of a rapist Maginnes: 7 - tireless work, still isolated with a player next to him, Slade's tactics are awful - get around him and he will create link ups Foley: 0 - absolutely shambolic - can't play at this level - he has no positional sense at all and can't pass Lookman - 5 - bright spark, great strike unfortunate it didnt nestle.. poor corner at the death
Slade - 1 - Awful, tactically inept.. no back up plan.. rubbish subs.. we should be killing of a game against Oldham and winning 3/4/5 - 0 ... Doesn't know his best side, and doesn't seem to control players as Jackson drifts from Left side into the center and leaves huge gaps down the left hand side of the pitch. Shocking, not one to say 'OUT' but he is on his last legs, this league is very very poor and we are struggling to beat League 2 teams
Rudd: 6 Little to do Solly: 6 Average Fox: 6 Average Konsa: 5 Shaky at times. Bauer: 6 Holmes: 5 Poor, gave ball away too much, probably not fit. Crofts: 4 Poor Ulvestad: 5 Poor Jackson: 4 Poor Novak: 3 Poor not fit. Maginnes: 6.5 MOM decent Foley: 4 Poor Lookman: 6
Rudd: 6 Solly: 5.5 Fox: 5 Konsa: 5 Bauer: 6.5 Holmes: 6 Crofts: 5 (1 extra mark for the decent pass which led to the goal) Ulvestad: 5 Jackson: 4 Novak: 4 Maginnes: 7 (1 extra mark for the goal) Foley: 4 Lookman: 6
Rudd: 6 Solly: 6 Fox: 4 Konsa: 6 Bauer: 6 Holmes: 6 flashes of class Crofts: 4 Ulvestad: 5 Jackson: 5 Novak: 4 Maginnes: 4 Foley: 4 Lookman: 7 Looked dangerous when he got the ball near their area. Which wasn't often of course.
Ajose: n/a
Tragic all round performance. If Oldham are a bottom two club, then we've 'ad it.
Rudd: 6 Did his job exposed for their goal once again.
Solly: 6 Competent but not the Solly we have grown to love. Are his knees reacting to the number of matches he has played recently?
Fox: 6 Looked to be carrying an injury to me in the second half
Konsa: 6 Struggled manfully with the big lump he was marking. Once he is fully developed physically to cope with 'big lumps' he will play at a higher level than we are
Bauer: 6 Competent. He'll be off in January.
Holmes: 6.5 Not at his best but this lad never hides and he gave Solly a lot of defensive support as well as offering what little threat we had.
Crofts: 5.5 He does have qualities but last night he was SO slow and one paced it was painful and I'm not sure he kicked a ball forwards other than his weak shot straight at the keeper.
Ulvestad: 6 Offered a little bit going forward. At least he can run. Once he is fully fit he could be ok.
Jackson: 6 He has to be in the centre. Tries hard but no longer has the legs to breach the gap between midfield and the front two anymore it seems.
Novak: 5 Looks unfit and disinterested much of the time. Jury very much out.
Magennis: 7 Deserved his goal and kept at it with little or no service from our supine midfield
Foley: 5 As Crofts but worse
Lookman: 6.5 Showed his quality with his shot against the angle of the bar and post. Katrien has probably sold him already for January
Rudd: 6 - not much to do but very sound Solly: 5 - not one of his better games but left exposed on occasions Fox: 5 -generally ok but offered little offensively Konsa: 6 - did pretty well, although things got tougher in the second half when Oldham brought on their big substitute striker Bauer: 6.5 - really good in the first half. A more difficult second half in the face of continual pressure but still our best defender on the night Holmes: 6.5 - not his best game but, Lookman apart, our sole creator. If he gets injured, we'll be in big trouble Crofts: 3.5 - really poor. Gave the ball away consistently and was slow over the ground. I only remember him playing one meaningful forward pass, although thankfully Holmes took it and was able to play in Magennis for our goal Ulvestad: 5 - looked a bit lightweight but at least he has a modicum of passing ability and occasionally runs forward with the ball - something which is completely beyond Crofts, Foley and Jacko Jackson: 3 - completely anonymous and offers little protection defensively. Better used from the bench Novak: 4 - poor, recognising that the service to him and Magennis was atrocious. He nevertheless needs to sharpen up and work on his fitness. He didn't look like a man returning from injury who was keen to seize his chance Maginnes: 6 - worked hard as usual, with no proper support or service. We're going to wear this guy out, especially if Slade continues to play him up front on his own away from home Foley: 4 - he is not a midfielder Lookman: 6 - struggled to get into the game but, as usual, produced a couple of moments of magic. After Saturday's game - which he must start - we have a two week break from League action and that might be a good opportunity to send him away for a week's rest
Comments
Solly: 5
Fox: 4
Konsa: 5
Bauer: 6.5
Holmes: 5
Crofts: 3
Ulvestad: 5
Jackson: 4
Novak: 4
Magennis: 7
Foley: 5
Lookman: 6
What an absolute shower of shit
Solly 6
Fox 6
Konsa 6
Bauer 7
Holmes 6.5
Crofts 5
Ulvestad 5
Jackson 4
Novak 4.5
Maginnes 7
Foley 5
Lookman 6
Solly ... 6 : Gets an additional mark for his goal line clearance yet in injury time, Ulvestad was with the ball with his back to the goal and no one came to support him, for me Solly should have been there ready to whip in the cross.
Fox ... 6 : Probably one of a few players who came out of yesterday with a bit of credit, did his job well
Konsa ... 5 : Was bullied by their No.12 who was winning everything
Bauer ... 7 : Best player on the pitch, best Defender in the League
Holmes ... 6 : Not his best of nights
Crofts ... 5 : Just couldnt put a foot right to begin with, gets an extra mark for the pass that lead to the goal
Jackson ... 4 : Just dog awful last night
Novak ... 4 : See Jackson, should have been taken off instead of Crofts, felt Foley coming on was a waste of a sub.
Magennis ... 6 : Took his goal well, yet should have squared the ball to Novak in the second half rather than shooting.
Lookman ... 6 : Showed intent, deserved a goal for that effort at the death
Solly: 5.5 Quiet performance - even when he took over as captain!!
Fox: 6 One or two mistakes but he is definitely improving.
Konsa: 5 Despite a couple of good tackles,unfortunately out of his depth, as shown by constant passing back to Rudd.
Bauer: 6.5 Our best defender.
Holmes: 6 Not his night and guilty of giving the ball away too much.
Crofts: 5 Brings little to the side.
Ulvestad: 6.5 A class player, who needs an equally gifted player alongside him.
Jackson: 5 Fairly anonymous.
Novak: 6 Reasonable performance.
Maginnes: 7.5 By far our best player last night. Well taken goal and immense effort all night.
Foley: 5 Not the answer to our deficiencies in midfield.
Lookman: 5.5 Hardly involved, apart from hitting the crossbar!
Ajose: n/a
Solly: 6 Definite downward spiral in his form
Fox: 6 As long as you dont expect too much from Fox you dont get dossapointed
Konsa: 5 deinately a confidence player and being out of the team dont feel helped
Bauer: 7 Was our best defender last night
Holmes: 6 poor by his high standards but still tried
Crofts: 6 thought it was wrong decision to pull him as he is a constant steady
Ulvestad: 5 did not add anything to the team last night
Jackson: 5 See Ulvstead
Novak: 5 For a big lad he has no physical presence
Maginnes: 7.5 Worked hard again took his goal well but needs to stop playing the man
Foley: 5 Poor mans Croft
Lookman: 6 Always a buzz when on the pitch and was unlucky to hit the bar but didnt really get into the game
Overall a poor team performance and Oldham were the better team. Slade looks happy with a point at the moment and knows we cannot hold onto a lead.
Solly: 4
Fox: 4
Konsa: 4
Bauer: 4
Holmes: 6
Crofts: 2 absolute toilet footballer
Ulvestad: 6
Jackson: 3 genuinely forgot he was on. Stop playing him left FFS
Novak: 2 Unfit and probably not very good anyway
Maginnes: 6
Foley: 4
Lookman:6
Solly: 4
Fox: 4
Konsa: 4
Bauer: 4
Holmes: 6
Crofts: 3
Ulvestad: 4
Jackson: 3
Novak: 3
Maginnes: 7
Foley: 4
Lookman: 6
Solly: 6
Fox: 5.5
Konsa: 6
Bauer: 6.5
Holmes: 6
Crofts: 5.5
Ulvestad: 6
Jackson: 5
Novak: 5
Maginnes: 6.5
Foley: 5
Lookman 7
Solly: 6
Fox: 5.5
Konsa: 5.5
Bauer: 6.5
Holmes: 6.5
Crofts: 4
Ulvestad: 5.5
Jackson: 4.5
Novak: 5.5
Maginnes: 6.5
Foley: 5
Lookman: 6
Solly: 6.5 Great block and clearance, could have done more offensively
Fox: 4 Stupid free kick to give away for the goal - passing up to usual poor standards - deserves to be dropped
Konsa: 5 Has had his taste, needs a break
Bauer: 6.5 Solid
Holmes: 6 Not his best but was our only threat with Magennis and Lookman when he came on
Crofts: 3 I could have done better with two dodgy knees - pathetic performance
Ulvestad: 5 Not great but pick of the midfield
Jackson: 4 Sad to see but he shouldn't be starting games
Novak: 3 Might as well have had a statue on the pitch
Maginnis: 7 did well, but needs a pacy striker playing off him
Foley: 4.5 Foley for Crofts sums it up really
Lookman : 6.5 Not his best but a threat. We needed just to get the ball to him.
Slade: 2 Very poor - Why was Botaka not given a chance?
Solly: 6 did Ok but has lost some pace in the last 12 months.
Fox: 6 the usual mix of the good, bad and ugly.
Konsa: 5 looked shaky most of the night.
Bauer:6.5 battled away.
Holmes:6.5 1st touch a bit off, but tries to make things happen.
Crofts:5.5 not quick enough
Ulvestad:5.5 i can see potential but coming into a struggling team ?
Jackson: 5 we all knew colin would be right one day ? top goal scorer thou.
Novak:4 not fit.
Maginnes:7.5 gives 100% but was Knacked in last 20 minutes.
Foley:4.5 over run as soon as he came on.
Lookman:6.5 should always start in home matches. would have been a cracking winner near the end.
Slade 3.5 hard job i know but you are struggling big time.
Solly: 6
Fox: 6
Konsa: 5.5
Bauer: 5.5
Holmes: 6
Crofts: 4
Ulvestad: 5.5
Jackson: 5
Novak: 4.5
Maginnes: 6.5
Foley: 4.5
Lookman: 6
Rudd: 6
Solly: 6
Fox: 4
Konsa: 4
Bauer: 6
Holmes: 6
Crofts: 4
Ulvestad: 5
Jackson: 5
Novak: 3
Maginnes: 7
Foley: 4
Lookman 5
Solly: 6
Fox: 3 - skinned every time, and passes into tight areas and puts our own players under pressure
Konsa: 6 - solid enough - needs a commanding presence alongside him
Bauer: 5 - solid but should be leading that back four with Solly and pulling Konsa around
Holmes: 6 - lots of fancy runs and tricks but nothing came of it
Crofts: 5 - awful start, slowly got into it, uninspiring and slow
Ulvestad: 7 - only player who actually got on the ball and didnt rush - wasn't amazing but was doing the jobs of jackson and crofts as they cant run
Jackson: 4 - past it, not up to playing on the wing or CM. needs legs around him to make up for his lack of
Novak: 2 - pathetic - looks 2 stone overweight and touch of a rapist
Maginnes: 7 - tireless work, still isolated with a player next to him, Slade's tactics are awful - get around him and he will create link ups
Foley: 0 - absolutely shambolic - can't play at this level - he has no positional sense at all and can't pass
Lookman - 5 - bright spark, great strike unfortunate it didnt nestle.. poor corner at the death
Slade - 1 - Awful, tactically inept.. no back up plan.. rubbish subs.. we should be killing of a game against Oldham and winning 3/4/5 - 0 ... Doesn't know his best side, and doesn't seem to control players as Jackson drifts from Left side into the center and leaves huge gaps down the left hand side of the pitch. Shocking, not one to say 'OUT' but he is on his last legs, this league is very very poor and we are struggling to beat League 2 teams
Solly 6
Fox 5
Konsa 7
Bauer 6
Holmes 3
Crofts 3
Ulvestad 3
Jackson 3
Novak 2 - marked down because he's no stranger to the chip shop.
Maginnes 8 MOM
Foley 3
Lookman 4
Solly: 6 Average
Fox: 6 Average
Konsa: 5 Shaky at times.
Bauer: 6
Holmes: 5 Poor, gave ball away too much, probably not fit.
Crofts: 4 Poor
Ulvestad: 5 Poor
Jackson: 4 Poor
Novak: 3 Poor not fit.
Maginnes: 6.5 MOM decent
Foley: 4 Poor
Lookman: 6
Solly: 5.5
Fox: 5
Konsa: 5
Bauer: 6.5
Holmes: 6
Crofts: 5 (1 extra mark for the decent pass which led to the goal)
Ulvestad: 5
Jackson: 4
Novak: 4
Maginnes: 7 (1 extra mark for the goal)
Foley: 4
Lookman: 6
Ajose: n/a
Solly: 5
Fox: 5
Konsa: 5
Bauer: 6
Holmes: 5
Crofts: 5
Ulvestad: 6
Jackson: 5
Novak: 5
Maginnes: 6
Foley: 5
Lookman: 6
Solly: 7
Fox: 6
Konsa: 6
Bauer: 6
Holmes: 6
Crofts: 5
Ulvestad: 6
Jackson: 5
Novak: 5
Maginnes: 6
Foley: 5
Lookman: 6
Ajose: n/a
Solly: 6 Competent but not the Solly we have grown to love. Are his knees reacting to the number of matches he has played recently?
Fox: 6 Looked to be carrying an injury to me in the second half
Konsa: 6 Struggled manfully with the big lump he was marking. Once he is fully developed physically to cope with 'big lumps' he will play at a higher level than we are
Bauer: 6 Competent. He'll be off in January.
Holmes: 6.5 Not at his best but this lad never hides and he gave Solly a lot of defensive support as well as offering what little threat we had.
Crofts: 5.5 He does have qualities but last night he was SO slow and one paced it was painful and I'm not sure he kicked a ball forwards other than his weak shot straight at the keeper.
Ulvestad: 6 Offered a little bit going forward. At least he can run. Once he is fully fit he could be ok.
Jackson: 6 He has to be in the centre. Tries hard but no longer has the legs to breach the gap between midfield and the front two anymore it seems.
Novak: 5 Looks unfit and disinterested much of the time. Jury very much out.
Magennis: 7 Deserved his goal and kept at it with little or no service from our supine midfield
Foley: 5 As Crofts but worse
Lookman: 6.5 Showed his quality with his shot against the angle of the bar and post. Katrien has probably sold him already for January
Solly 5
Bauer 7
Konsa6
Fox 4
Jackson 4
Crofts 3
Ulverstad 5
Holmes 5
Novak 2
McGinnis 7
Foley 2
Look man 7
Solly: 5 - not one of his better games but left exposed on occasions
Fox: 5 -generally ok but offered little offensively
Konsa: 6 - did pretty well, although things got tougher in the second half when Oldham brought on their big substitute striker
Bauer: 6.5 - really good in the first half. A more difficult second half in the face of continual pressure but still our best defender on the night
Holmes: 6.5 - not his best game but, Lookman apart, our sole creator. If he gets injured, we'll be in big trouble
Crofts: 3.5 - really poor. Gave the ball away consistently and was slow over the ground. I only remember him playing one meaningful forward pass, although thankfully Holmes took it and was able to play in Magennis for our goal
Ulvestad: 5 - looked a bit lightweight but at least he has a modicum of passing ability and occasionally runs forward with the ball - something which is completely beyond Crofts, Foley and Jacko
Jackson: 3 - completely anonymous and offers little protection defensively. Better used from the bench
Novak: 4 - poor, recognising that the service to him and Magennis was atrocious. He nevertheless needs to sharpen up and work on his fitness. He didn't look like a man returning from injury who was keen to seize his chance
Maginnes: 6 - worked hard as usual, with no proper support or service. We're going to wear this guy out, especially if Slade continues to play him up front on his own away from home
Foley: 4 - he is not a midfielder
Lookman: 6 - struggled to get into the game but, as usual, produced a couple of moments of magic. After Saturday's game - which he must start - we have a two week break from League action and that might be a good opportunity to send him away for a week's rest
Solly: 7
Fox: 4
Konsa: 5
Bauer: 6
Holmes: 7 good defensively
Crofts: 6
Ulvestad: 6
Jackson:5
Novak: 3
Maginnes: 7
Foley: 4
Lookman: 7