Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Walsall v Charlton

Your marks 0.5 to 10.0 please

Rudd:
Solly:
Fox:
Konsa:
Pearce:
Holmes:
Foley:
Crofts:
Jackson:
Magennis:
Ajose:
Lookman:

Holmes-Dennis n/a
Bauer n/a

Comments

  • Your marks 0.5 to 10.0 please

    Rudd: 7
    Solly: 7.5
    Fox: 7
    Konsa: 8
    Pearce: 7
    Holmes: 7.5
    Foley: 7
    Crofts: 7
    Jackson: 7
    Magennis: 7
    Ajose: 8
    Lookman: 6
  • edited August 2016
    Rudd: 7 Possibly at fault for the goal but superb double save in first half, and the save at the end was excellent. Clearly meant a lot to him, could see him becoming a fan favourite.

    Solly: 7 Solid

    Fox: 7 Solid

    Konsa: 7.5 Very impressive, comfortable with the ball at his feet and seems very composed for one so young.

    Pearce: 7 Solid

    Holmes: 8 The clear standout performer on the pitch, just loves to run at people. Injured at the end, was signalling at the bench to come off, hamstring?

    Foley: 6.5 Solid but not spectacular

    Crofts: 7.5 Impressed. Does a similar job to Foley but thought he did it better, couple of crunching tackles.

    Jackson: 7 Solid

    Magennis: 7.5 Seemed to link up well with Ajose, excellent in the air, bags of pace and very strong.

    Ajose: 7.5 Both goals were scrappy but it doesn't matter how they're scored. Will hopefully kick on now.

    Lookman: 6 Not the impact he has had before.
  • Rudd: 8
    Solly: 7
    Fox: 7.5
    Konsa: 7.5
    Pearce: 7
    Holmes: 8
    Foley: 7
    Crofts: 7
    Jackson: 7
    Magennis: 7.5
    Ajose: 8
    Lookman: 6
  • Rudd 8 - three outstanding saves but at fault for goal
    Solly - 7 - as solid as always but missed simple chance
    Fox - 6 - didn't get forward but otherwise ok
    Konsa 7 - did nothing wrong
    Pearce 7 - likewise
    Holmes 8 - always positive and direct; assist for goal
    Foley 7 - underestimated; great work rate and covering
    Crofts 7 - a battler in the centre of the park
    Jackson - 5 largely anonymous
    Ajose - 6 two simple finishes and unlucky with cheeky lob
    Magennis 8 - outstanding; great signing

    Lookman - 6 - held ball up well to stop it pinging back
    Holmes Dennis 5 - barely involved
    Bauer 6 - good to see him back in unfamiliar role
  • Rudd: 7.5
    Solly: 8
    Fox: 6
    Konsa: 7
    Pearce: 6.5
    Holmes: 8
    Foley: 7
    Crofts: 6.5
    Jackson: 5.5
    Magennis: 8
    Ajose: 8
    Lookman: 6.5
  • edited August 2016
    Rudd: 7.5 Several top class saves, thought the goal went through him -1 point
    Solly: 7 Steady took the armband when JJ subbed and a booking for the team
    Fox: 7 Not his biggest fan but had a good game especially 2nd half
    Konsa: 7 Can't believe this kid is only 18, some crucial tackles & headers
    Pearce: 7.5 Old head seemed to have everything under control around him
    Holmes: 8 The driving force going forward good cross for 1st, a very good buy
    Foley: 6.5 Nothing special, squad player, did his bit for the cause though
    Crofts: 7 Tidy and experienced put in a good shift
    Jackson: 7 Captain fantastic kept going important player for us
    Magennis: 8.5 MOM just what we've needed since Yann left, led the line well great spin and set up for the 2nd goal
    Ajose: 8 Johnny on the spot 2 extra points for the goals
    Lookman: 7 replaced JJ and had to play deeper prefer him further forward

    Holmes-Dennis n/a Nothing to report in a very brief cameo appearance
    Bauer n/a Good to see him back, not sure him about being a midfielder though
  • Rudd - 7 (loses a mark for the goal)
    Solly - 7.5
    Fox - 7
    Konsa - 7
    Pearce - 7.5 (nice touch when he went and celebrated the winner with Rudd)
    Holmes - 8
    Foley - 6
    Crofts - 7
    Jackson - 6
    Magennis - 8.5
    Ajose - 8
    Lookman - 6.5
  • edited August 2016
    Rudd: 7
    Solly: 7.5
    Fox: 6.5
    Konsa: 7.5
    Pearce: 7
    Holmes: 8
    Foley: 5
    Crofts: 5
    Jackson: 6.5
    Magennis: 7
    Ajose: 7
    Lookman: 7.5
  • Rudd: 7.5 4 excellent saves and seems a team player with a good rapport with the back 4. Probably thinks he could have done better with their goal, but it did bounce in just in front of him.
    Solly: 5.5 solid defensively, but only average in bringing the ball out of defence and trying to find a Charlton player. Too many hopeful punts downfield to no one in particular. Solly and Fox have clearly been instructed to play very narrow, but this limits them playing the wingback role and pushing forward to create width in the attacking third. When he did, delivery was disappointing.
    Fox: 5.5 see Solly.
    Konsa: 7 better positionally than in the previous 2 games and won important headers, especially towards the end of the game. Still rather impetuous in trying to make clean tackles rather than shepherd the player out of the danger area. Gave away a free kick in injury time doing just this.
    Pearce: 8 Excellent performance, constantly talking to those around him, cajouling performance out of Konsa, and organising the defence when Walsall were attacking. Captain material when Jackson is not available.
    Holmes: 7.5 Not as good as against Shrewsbury. Stuggling with his ankle injury, but still a real crowd pleaser with his effort and running with the ball. Always eager to receive the ball off the back four.
    Foley: 6.5 solid performance, seems to be developing a good understanding with Crofts. Second half not as good, a few misplaced passes.
    Crofts: 9 MOM outstanding midfield display. Energy, understanding with players around him, calming things down when needed. Some excellent tackles and blocks, winning the ball back on several occasions and also starting off attacks.
    Jackson: 7 Typical Jackson, no lack of effort and showed some nice touches. With the full backs playing very narrow, he had a lot of work in covering out wide, which he did well. Struggled later on, probably due to his reported tight hamstring.
    Magennis: 9 Leaves everything on the pitch! Outstanding effort. Good target man, wins headers and links up play well. Fantastic run for our secong goal, left the defender in his wake. Even struggling with cramp late on he continued to put it all in. Early season contender for player of the year along with Holmes.
    Ajose: 7.5 seems a bit harsh having scored 2 goals. He is growing into the team and learning about his teammates. Needs to offer more in build up play. More to come
    Lookman: 6.5 Another cameo, with flashes of brilliance, but needs to offer more when we lose the ball high up the pitch, and supporting the full backs down the flanks.
  • Sponsored links:


  • Rudd 7
    Solly 7
    Fox 7
    Konsa 7
    Pearce 7
    Holmes 8
    Foley 7
    Crofts 7
    Jackson 6
    Magennis 7.5
    Ajose 8
    Lookman 6

  • Rudd: 8 - minus 1 for the goal that he should've saved. Plus 1 for th double save in the first half and the crucial save in the last minute. Not good to see him pull his hamstring at the end though.
    Solly: 7 - should've scored at the start of the second half. Solid at the back. A lot of punts forward but solid Solly.
    Fox: 7.5 - again, a lot of punts up field but done very well considering he had absolutely no protection from Jackson.
    Konsa: 7.5 - was solid. Some good tackles and a crucial clearing header at the end. Gave away a silly free kick near the end. That showed his inexperience but solid.
    Pearce: 6.5 - lacks pace but solid. He made a few very risky challenges that on an other day would have ended in penalties/cards being given against him.
    Holmes: 8 - the guy is our most creative player and made some very good runs forward
    Foley: 6 - didn't really notice him much. Some misplaced passes though. He's a decent back up. We need a more creative CM.
    Crofts: 8 - decent passing and is solid in the middle. Very similar to Danny Hollands. Loves a tackle.
    Jackson: 6.5 - he's not a winger at all. Made some good challenges but looked tired from the start.
    Magennis: 9 - both goals came from him. The first would've gone in without touching Ajose and he created the second. Some great surging runs forward and bullied the defenders. Stil by a fan of him on throw ins though. MOTM.
    Ajose: 8 - plus .5 for each goal. Not the best finishes in the world. In fact, probably flukes but I don't care how they come. Unlucky with that lob.
    Lookman: 7 decent when coming on

    Holmes-Dennis n/a
    Bauer n/a good to see him back
  • Rudd: 7.5 Should have stopped their goal but made up for it with the saves he did make. He can be the difference between win lose or draw. Had he saved it he'd be an 8.5.
    Solly: 7 As ever, mr dependable, not quite clicked with Holmes so offensively needs to do more.
    Fox: 7 Like Solly Fox is becoming a dependable player, he can yet be the next Steve Brown.
    Konsa: 7 Young, will make mistakes but frankly considering his experience it's hard to fault him when still very much learning the game.
    Pearce: 7.5 Good organiser, helpful to Konsa, him and Bauer will be quite some pairing.
    Holmes: 8 Lot of work/activity set up the 1st, looks to be struggling towards the end.
    Foley: 6.5 Playing out of position, and shows it at times, but you can't fault his commitment, which is why he gets a 6.5 rather than 5/5.5.
    Crofts: 7.5 Played well, showed his experience. Players like Croft will pull us up this season,
    Jackson: 7.99 Captain, wears his heart on his sleeve, as always put in a good shift, follows instructions to a tee, ultimate pro.
    Magennis: 8 Battled all day, big and strong target man, a 'Charlton type' player, not sure he'll score many but will be an integral part of the team, especially away from home.
    Ajose: 8 Starting to find his feet. Not sure the team are fully on his wave length....... yet
    Lookman: 6.5 flatters to deceive. Should have played up front when Ajose went off, Walsall were tired and through the middle he may of hurt them.
  • Rudd 6.5
    Solly 7
    Fox 7
    Konsa 7
    Pearce 7
    Holmes 7
    Foley 6
    Crofts 7
    Jackson 6
    Magennis 7
    Ajose 7.5

    Look man 6

  • Rudd: 7.5
    Solly: 7
    Fox: 7
    Konsa: 7.5
    Pearce: 7
    Holmes: 8
    Foley: 6.5
    Crofts: 7.6
    Jackson: 6.5
    Magennis: 7.5
    Ajose: 7
    Lookman: 5

  • Rudd: 7
    Solly: 6.5
    Fox: 6.5
    Konsa: 7.5
    Pearce: 7
    Holmes: 7.5
    Foley: 7
    Crofts: 7
    Jackson: 6
    Magennis: 8
    Ajose: 7.5
    Lookman: 6.5


  • Rudd 7
    Solly 6.5
    Fox 6.5
    Konsa 7
    Pearce 7
    Holmes 7.5
    Foley 6.5
    Crofts 7
    Jackson 6
    Magennis 7.5
    Ajose 7..5
    Lookman 6
  • Rudd: 7
    Solly: 6.5
    Fox: 6.5
    Konsa: 6.5
    Pearce: 6.5
    Holmes: 7.5
    Foley: 6.5
    Crofts: 7.5
    Jackson: 6
    Magennis: 8
    Ajose: 7.5
    Lookman: 6
  • Had only seen 4 of these players before!

    Rudd: 8 Really impressed. Amazing double save, plus save at end. Unlucky with their goal, bounce caught him out. Good rapport with the fans too.
    Solly: 6.5
    Fox: 6.5
    Konsa: 7 Impressive. Brilliant header just before time saved a certain goal.
    Pearce: 7 Also good. Put his body in the way to block several Walsall piledrivers
    Holmes: 9 A joy to watch. Imagine if we had one more like this and a prolific striker!
    Foley: 7
    Crofts: 6.5
    Jackson: 6.5
    Magennis: 7 Thought he looked like M Bent, and had attitude to match in first half - seemed rather lazy. But more than made up for it in the second. Header and run for second goal absolutely brilliant.
    Ajose: 6.5 Clinical finishes ;-) Hopefully the goals will improve his confidence no matter how they came. He was desperate to score, a few very dodgy first touches. Hopefully for him he'll get one at The Valley before the usual dicks get on his back.
    Lookman: 6.5

    Fans: 8
  • Rudd: 8
    Solly: 7
    Fox: 7
    Konsa: 7
    Pearce: 7
    Holmes: 8
    Foley: 6.5
    Crofts: 6.5
    Jackson: 6.5
    Magennis: 8.5
    Ajose: 8
    Lookman:6.5
  • Sponsored links:


  • Rudd: 7
    Solly: 6
    Fox: 6
    Konsa: 7
    Pearce: 7
    Holmes: 8
    Foley: 6
    Crofts: 7
    Jackson: 6
    Magennis: 7.5
    Ajose: 7
    Lookman: 6
  • Rudd: 7
    Solly: 7.5
    Fox: 7.5
    Konsa: 7
    Pearce: 7
    Holmes: 7.5
    Foley: 7
    Crofts: 7
    Jackson: 7
    Magennis:8
    Ajose: 7.5
    Lookman:7
  • Rudd: 6.5
    Solly: 7
    Fox: 6.5
    Konsa: 7.5
    Pearce: 6.5 
    Holmes: 7.5
    Foley: 6.5
    Crofts: 6.5
    Jackson: 6.5
    Magennis: 7.5
    Ajose: 7.5
    Lookman: 7
  • Rudd: 7.5
    Solly: 7.5
    Fox: 7
    Konsa: 7.5
    Pearce: 7
    Holmes: 7.5
    Foley: 6.5
    Crofts: 7.5
    Jackson: 6.5
    Magennis: 8
    Ajose: 7
    Lookman: 6.5
  • Rudd: 8.5 loses a mark for the goal conceded but gains an extra 0.5 for the fact that after we went 2-1 up he turned to us and raised his hand in a way to apologize for the goal he conceded. Made some fantastic saves too. Concerned he may have picked up a hamstring injury towards the end
    Solly: 7 solid
    Fox: 7 solid
    Konsa: 7 looks more settled now he's had a run of games
    Pearce: 6.5 harsh but loses 0.5 for another couple of heart in mouth moments, plays on the edge which isn't a bad thing but it will cost us at times like it did at Bury
    Holmes: 8 brilliant again, went off injured possibly a hamstring as well
    Foley: 6 made a few decent blocks, nothing spectactular but did a job
    Crofts: 7 nothing spectacular either but starting to see more of him on the ball than previous games
    Jackson: 6 made a few good blocks but think the Shrewsbury game took it all out of him
    Magennis: 9 MOM bloody loved the way he chases down his own flick ons and even set up the 2nd goal after doing so, also created the 1st goal
    Ajose: 8 gets an extra mark for the finishes in true poacher style, also hit the bar with a chip
    Lookman: 6 difficult for him to make an impact when playing deeper than he'd have liked
  • Rudd: 7.5
    Solly: 7.5
    Fox: 7.5
    Konsa: 8
    Pearce: 7.5
    Holmes: 8
    Foley: 6
    Crofts: 7
    Jackson: 6
    Magennis: 8
    Ajose: 8
    Lookman: 7

    Holmes-Dennis n/a
    Bauer n/a
  • Rudd: 8 Some excellent saves. Just one mistake that cost the goal.
    Solly: 7.5 Oh, if only he had taken that chance. Only had the goalkeeper to beat! Otherwise very solid.
    Fox: 7 Good defensively but distribution poor. Just lumped it upfield!
    Konsa: 8 Looks like he has been playing for years. Liked the way he did the basics right.. like boot it out when under pressure.
    Pearce: 8 Solid and looks quality.
    Holmes: 8 Great first half but seemed to fade a bit in the second. A quality player. Going to be huge for us this season.
    Foley: 6 Not sure what he brings to the table other than some solid work at the back. Zero creativity.
    Crofts: 6.5 As Foley but slightly better.
    Jackson: 6 Made some important tackles but looks out of place on left and tired quickly.
    Magennis: 8.5 Powerful player who will cause a lot of problems to defences. Excellent signing.
    Ajose: 8 Extra point for the goals. Needs to up his workrate though. Sometimes didn't look interested.
    Lookman: 6 A couple of good touches but otherwise disappointing.

    Support: 10 Great throughout. Proud to be Charlton despite the fact that me and my daughters got smoked out!
  • Rudd - 7.5
    Solly - 7.5
    Fox - 7
    Konsa - 7.5
    Pearce - 7.5
    Holmes - 8
    Foley - 6.5
    Crofts - 7
    Jackson - 6
    Magennis - 8.5
    Ajose - 8
    Lookman - 5.5
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!