Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Charlton v Shrewsbury, CLOSES Thursday Lunchtime

Marks between 0.5 - 10.0:

Rudd:
Solly:
Fox:
Konsa:
Pearce:
Foley:
Crofts:
Jackson:
Holmes:
Magennis:
Ajose:

Lookman: n/a
Novak: n/a
Botaka: n/a
«13

Comments

  • Rudd: 7
    Solly: 7
    Fox: 5.5
    Konsa: 7.5
    Pearce: 7
    Foley: 5.5
    Crofts: 6.5
    Jackson: 6
    Holmes: 8
    Magennis: 8 - proved me completely wrong
    Ajose: 6

    Lookman: n/a (Maradona Lookman - so good in his short cameo)
    Novak: n/a
    Botaka: n/a
  • right here goes

    Rudd 7.5 solid, good distribution, one good save, very nonchalant when catching (in a good way)
    Solly 6.5 surprisingly sloppy at times, still put the best cross of the game in
    Fox 6.5 did ok tbh, good on the floor, a few rushed clearances and everyone still hates him
    Konsa 8 supremely assured, Toney was a nervous wreck by the end
    Pearce 7.5 mostly came out to intercept at the right time
    Foley 6.5 saved a certain goal in the first half, played well from the wing, less so in the middle
    Crofts 8 he is going to be SUCH a player in this league, absolute class
    Jackson 6.5 really doesn't bring anything to the team except goals. neither he nor Foley are the answer in CM to partner Crofts. (but goals win games, right?)
    Holmes 8.5 that first goal was like a religious conversion (to being relieved I have a season ticket)
    Magennis 8.5 MOM Kermo with pace. I'm not even really kidding
    Ajose 5 nothing came off, but it will soon
  • Rudd: 6
    Solly: 6.5
    Fox: 6
    Konsa: 7
    Pearce: 6
    Foley: 6
    Crofts: 7
    Jackson: 7
    Holmes: 8.5
    Magennis: 7
    Ajose: 6.5
  • Rudd: 7 - not seriously tested but dos the job when required
    Solly: 7.5 - composed, sensible in position, rarely tested
    Fox: 5 - it's not a scapegoat, he was simply erratic in possession
    Konsa: 7 - mostly solid, a couple of poor touches
    Pearce: 6.5 - mostly solid, one slice up in the air that wasn't punished
    Foley: 5 - no threat through the middle, slow and misplaced multiple passes
    Crofts: 5.5 - slightly the better of a disappointing midfield pair
    Jackson: 6.5 - a well taken goal
    Holmes: 8.5 - direct, threatening and exciting
    Magennis: 8.5 - near unbeatable in the air, enthusiastic
    Ajose - 5.5 - struggled to read Magennis, missed a sitter
  • edited August 2016
    Rudd: 7 Dealt with everything easily
    Solly: 7 Solid
    Fox: 6 Decent, nothing spectacular but no real mistakes
    Konsa: 6.5 Really like the look of him. He made the odd mistake but nothing that has made us look in danger of conceding.
    Pearce: 6.5 Solid.
    Foley: 6 Probably our worst player on the night but he did stop a certain goal.
    Crofts: 7.5 Much better from him tonight.
    Jackson: 7 Looked decent but came up with yet another goal so an extra point for that.
    Holmes: 8.5 Unplayable at times. Absolute nightmare to deal with. In the end the only way to deal with him was to start kicking him. He meant his second ;)
    Magennis: 7 Created a couple of chances out of nothing. His pace, power and work rate was very impressive. A good player at this level.
    Ajose: 6 He just needs a goal and they will start to flow. He missed a sitter which he REALLY should have put in. I'm confident he'll get around 20 odd for us.
  • Rudd: 7 - Little to do. Good handling and kicking.
    Solly: 7 - Again, wasn't particularly tested but did what he had to do well. Great cross for Jackson's goal.
    Fox: 5.5 - Really don't know if he's up to it, so many aimless long balls and a few mistakes at the back too.
    Konsa: 6.5 - Inexperienced showed a couple times with a few mistakes on and off the ball but showed a lot of promise.
    Pearce: 6.5 - Shrewsbury offered little going forward but he played solidly throughout.
    Foley: 5 - First time seeing him play, thought he looked really poor when on the ball, doesn't look like he knows where to pass unless it's backwards. A lot of mistakes.
    Crofts: 6.5 - Similar story to Foley in terms of lacking any creative spark. Didn't give the ball away as much and so was solid in that respect but lacks imagination. Few good tackles though.
    Jackson: 6.5 - Good energy in the midfield which put him in place for the goal. If we don't bring anyone else in would like to see him and Crofts start on the weekend in the centre.
    Holmes: 8.5 - Fantastic performance. Energy, pace, skill and effort; real quality exemplified in his first goal - top signing.
    Magennis: 8.5 - Again another top signing, going to be a real asset in this league. Like Holmes he really puts himself about, but with the added advantage of being an absolute tank. Brilliant in the air - could work very well with Lookman.
    Ajose: 5 - Muscled out of the game, was very anonymous until he missed the sitter late on. Need to see him with the ball at his feet running at defenders, but until we get some creativity in the middle of the park he's going to struggle. Can't hold the ball up.

    Lookman: n/a - absolute class act.
    Novak: n/a
    Botaka: n/a
  • Rudd - 7
    Solly - 7.5
    Fox - 5
    Konsa - 7.5 Solid performance
    Pearce - 7.5
    Foley - 6
    Crofts - 7
    Jackson - 6.5
    Holmes - 8 MOTM two great goals will be a key player for us this season.
    Magennis - 7.5 Holds the ball up well some nice flick ons.
    Ajose - 6.5 Just needs one goal to get him scoring should of scored tonight.
  • Sponsored links:


  • Rudd: 7
    Solly: 7
    Fox: 6
    Konsa: 7
    Pearce: 7
    Foley: 5
    Crofts: 6
    Jackson: 6
    Holmes: 8
    Magennis: 8 big , powerful galloping horse. Was doing things Makienok should have been doing last season
    Ajose: 6
  • Rudd: 7 solid presence and handy save before HT
    Solly: 7 typically assured and unhurried
    Fox: 6 improving but still unconvinced
    Konsa: 8 very impressive Gomez-esque
    Pearce: 7 uncomplicated leader at the back
    Foley: 7 constant harrying - underrated
    Crofts: 7 see Foley - great workrate
    Jackson: 6 played in the hole, not wholly convincingly
    Holmes: 8 was ready to say 'no end product' before he scored the goal of the season
    Magennis: 8 - battering ram with a brain
    Ajose: 6 natural goal scorer (eventually)

    Lookman: 7 so much talent but too casual
    Novak: n/a
    Botaka: n/a
  • Rudd. 8 - not really tested, came out and claimed well, decent distribution- lucky to have him.
    Solly. 7.5 - not as good as Saturday but still solid.
    Pearce. 7 - getting better and will be a rock once settled.
    Konsa. 8 - couple of errors but made up for them immediately- will be a quality player.
    Fox. 7 - nothing great but nothing particularly bad either.
    Holmes. 9.5 - best 45 minutes I can remember a cafc player having in recent memory, MOM.
    Foley. 6.5 - still not convinced by him, can see why was only given 6 month deal.
    Crofts. 8 - calm head in the middle and did most things very well, will be an asset this season.
    Jacko. 7 - yes he is getting on and yes his legs aren't what they used to be but he knows how to put the ball in the net, love him.
    Magennis. 9 - is a beast and will bully the defences in this league, great signing and will be a real fans favourite.
    Ajose. 6.5 - nothing came off tonight but it will and he will score 15+ easily.
  • Rudd: 7
    Solly: 7
    Fox: 7
    Konsa: 8
    Pearce: 7
    Foley: 7
    Crofts: 7
    Jackson: 8
    Holmes: 9
    Magennis: 8
    Ajose: 7
  • edited August 2016
    Rudd: 8 - solid and made one very decent save. Gives the back line a very calm feel to it.
    Solly: 7.5 - does what he does.
    Fox: 7 - a bit sloppy and one footed but steady enough.
    Konsa: 8 - the new Rufus? Maybe. Robbed the ball off their striker a few times and won everything.
    Pearce: 7.5 - commanding and brave.
    Foley: 7 - busy but looks a squad man to me.
    Crofts: 7.5 - pretty good I thought. Couple of important block tackles.
    Jackson: 8 - ran his socks off. Extra half mark for the goal.
    Holmes: 9.5 - MOTM - brilliant display. Tackled, ran at opponents, scored two and was desperate for the hat trick.
    Magennis: 9 - very impressed. Might not score 20 but will help the team so much.
    Ajose: 7.5 - he was unlucky with two shots on the turn and maybe should have buried Lookman's rebounded shot. Really needs a goal and think more will follow.

    Lookman: n/a 7.5 - looked very dangerous out wide.
    Novak: n/a 7 - held a few high balls up. Not as good at that as Magennis but looked decent.
    Botaka: n/a 6 - crikey. Too early to judge but looks a bit lightweight to me.
  • Rudd 7.5
    Solly 6.5
    Fox 6
    Konsa 8
    Pearce 7
    Foley 6.5
    Crofts 7.5
    Jackson 7 - Man love is getting ridiculous
    Holmes 9.5 first half, unplayable... 6.5 second
    Magennis 8.5 MOTM
    Ajose 5 nothing came off, but it will soon
  • rudd 8

    solly 7.5
    fox 6
    konsa 7.5
    pearce 7
    foley 5
    crofts 8
    jackson 6.5
    holmes 9.5
    magennis 8.5
    ajose 6

  • Rudd: 7
    Solly: 7.5
    Fox: 7
    Konsa: 7
    Pearce: 7.5
    Foley: 8
    Crofts: 7.5
    Jackson: 7
    Holmes: 9.5
    Magennis: 8.5
    Ajose: 7


  • Rudd: 7.5 made a good save before half time and commanded his area.
    Solly: 7 dependable
    Fox: 6.5 did OK
    Konsa: 7 made a lot of interceptions
    Pearce: 8 Rock!
    Foley: 7.5 tidy player
    Crofts: 7.5 worked his socks off
    Jackson: 7.5 eye for a goal
    Holmes: 8.5 what can u say, league ones Messi
    Magennis: 7.5 worked hard
    Ajose: 7 didn't quite come off for him tonight

  • Rudd: 7 Looks a very good keeper
    Solly: 7.5 too good for this level
    Fox: 6.5 mix of good and bad
    Konsa: 8 Outstanding talent. Gomez like.
    Pearce: 7 generally solid. Couple of shaky moments
    Foley: 6.5 will be a good squad player and back up for Solly. Need to get another Cm in
    Crofts: 7.5 This seasons Andy Hughes. Will start more often than not
    Jackson: 7 done ok and another goal. Looked almost sprightly in the first half
    Holmes: 9 MOM. Almost unplayable at times
    Magennis: 8 New fans favourite. Perfect for this league
    Ajose: 6.5 Just needs a goal to get going. Will get 15+ This season

    Lookman: n/a Too good for league one. Pray we keep him
    Novak: n/a
    Botaka: n/a

    Great summary, my marks as well.
  • Sponsored links:


  • Rudd: 7.5 not much to do, couple of decent saves and claims
    Solly: 7 solid, unassuming performance
    Fox: 7.5 getting better and better, seemed to be a quicker too, don't know if league 1 players are all slower or his positioning had improved. Idiot behind me still called him a useless c*** at every opportunity, even when Foley pulled out of a challenge, it was Fox's fault
    Konsa: 7 great couple of blocks and challenges, let's the ball bounce occasionally though, maybe too relaxed at times?
    Pearce: 7 not troubled by much, pretty slow though
    Foley: 6 still think he's the weak link, but had a couple of marauding runs and had a fierce shot deflect wide
    Crofts: 7.5 looks much better now, passing forwards more and looking to link up play, but also breaking things up well
    Jackson: 7.5 will score another half a dozen goals this season, so influential even if he can't bomb around the pitch, has more time and space in this league and it means he can pick passes
    Holmes: 9 great first goal, sure he meant the corner too, gets nobbled a lot though we'll need to protect him as much as we can
    Magennis: 8 will win the hearts of the Valley Faithful with lung busting runs, unlucky not to score the one on one, it was a great save in the end. Throw is a useful weapon too
    Ajose: 6.5 trying too hard and things aren't working out for him at the moment, ball just won't drop. The miss near the end would have been tucked away if it was mid way through the season or when he was bang on form for Swindon. He'll score soon though and hopefully open the floodgates
  • Rudd 7 one excellent save first half and exudes confidence
    Solly 6 distribution not up to his usual standard tonight
    Fox 6 Did ok
    Konza 7 showed he can mixit tonight. Outstanding for his age but still a lot to learn.
    Pearce 7 looked very dependable tonight
    Foley 6 Did ok but we need something different in midfield
    Crofts 7 lots of important tackles and moved the ball a bit quicker tonight.
    Jackson 7 still an attacking threat
    Holmes 8 sparked us into life. Can see now why he was targeted by Northampton on Saturday. Hope he stays fit with the treament he is likely to get this season.
    Magennis 7.5 really made a nuisance of himself tonight. Unlucky not to score, deserved it.
    Ajose 6 nothing really came off for him tonight but the goals will come.
  • Rudd: 7
    Solly: 6
    Fox: 6
    Konsa: 8
    Pearce: 6.5
    Foley: 5.5
    Crofts: 6.5
    Jackson: 7
    Holmes: 9
    Magennis: 8
    Ajose: 5.5
  • Rudd: 7
    Solly: 6
    Fox: 6
    Konsa: 7
    Pearce: 7
    Foley: 6
    Crofts: 7.5
    Jackson: 7
    Holmes: 8.5
    Magennis: 8
    Ajose: 6
  • Rudd: 7.5 - Solid, brings a calmness to the def
    Solly: 7 - Typical Solly
    Fox: 6.5 - Good defensively again, aweful going forward
    Konsa: 7 - His only going to get better
    Pearce: 7 - Done what needed to be done
    Foley: 7- Some good tackles but agree his a squad player
    Crofts: 7 - done well in the middle
    Jackson: 7.5 - 2 goals already, has a massive part to play this season still for me
    Holmes: 9 - Outclassed them tonight, would have been a 10 if he got that hatrick
    Magennis: 9 - Honestly this guy didn't lose a header all night, proper tank who scared the living daylights outta the opposition fast direct and strong, quality
    Ajose: 5.5 - Theres a player in there, just needs a goal

    Lookman: n/a - His a different class honestly need to keep him this season
    Novak: n/a
    Botaka: n/a
  • Rudd: 7 - did all the basics right
    Solly: 7 - solid
    Fox: 6 - generally did ok
    Konsa: 7 - ironed out the mistakes from Saturday, ahead of Relegator in the pecking order
    Pearce: 7 - solid
    Foley: 6 - an improvement since Bury but lets see how he does on Saturday
    Crofts: 7 - also an improvement since Bury, picked a few passes but again lets see how he does on Saturday
    Jackson: 7 - extra mark for the goal and starting the move for his goal too getting the ball out wide
    Holmes: 9 MOM - the difference between the two teams, vital he stays fit and is looked after
    Magennis: 8 - really bullied the Shrewsbury defence, looks like we may have replaced Kermorgant at last
    Ajose: 6 - not helped by the lack of creativity in midfield, service was far better suited for Magennis tonight
  • Leuth said:


    Jackson 6.5 really doesn't bring anything to the team except goals. neither he nor Foley are the answer in CM to partner Crofts. (but goals win games, right?)

    I'd have him in all day long if all he brought to the team was goals.

    I thought he offered nothing on Saturday... He then popped up with a goal which ultimately got us a much needed point. You are right. He definitely needs a 'Dale Stephens' next to him so that he can play the 'Danny Hollands' typed role.
  • Rudd:7.5 quality keeper at this low level.
    Solly: 7 played OK, did a job.
    Fox: 6.5 the usual good bad and the ugly.
    Konsa:7.5 had a good battle with the 9,
    Pearce: 7 Decent League 1 CB.
    Foley: 6.5 grafter, but unsure about him.
    Crofts:6.5 works hard.
    Jackson:7 the game doesn't bypass him at this low level. another goal.
    Holmes:9 was superb with and without the ball. 2 cracking goals.
    Magennis:8 led the line well. strong old fashion number 9
    Ajose:6.5 not his night but should do well once he breaks his duck.
  • Rudd: 7.5
    Solly: 7
    Fox: 6.5
    Konsa: 7.5
    Pearce: 7
    Foley: 6
    Crofts: 7.5
    Jackson: 7
    Holmes: 8.5
    Magennis: 8
    Ajose: 6
  • Rudd: 7 Prem goalie, looks like the best we've had since Deano, oozes (sp?) class.
    Solly: 7 Another v good game. You've gotta love Chris Solly.
    Fox: 6 Miscontrolled ball at start and it ran off, lots of poor passing as usual. Some decent play & passion.
    Konsa: 6 Similar to Saturday he will be a very good player. Plenty of good play & a number of mistakes.
    Pearce:7 Solid game & starting to settle down.
    Foley: 6 Same as Saturday, competent but doesn't add much.
    Crofts: 7.5 Best game so far. A lot of good work & much less wayward passing. Looked good tonight.
    Jackson: 7 Decent game scored again & looks far fitter than last week.
    Holmes: 9 Oh my, what a game. Scored with a run from half way line & also from a corner. Brilliant.
    Magennis:7 Another good game. He's a right handful.
    Ajose: 6 Working hard, but little is coming off for him & he missed an open goal.

    Lookman: n/a Another excellent performance, ran them ragged.
    Novak: n/a Hardly had any game time
    Botaka: n/a Ditto

Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!