Both useless, make Leaburn look like Pele! Oh for Darren Bent, Mendonca, Andy Hunt, Yann, BWP and Tony Watt!
Having a bubble with that last one mate, if you throw his name in there you need to add about 20 names to the list that have played in the last couple of decades, all of which made a bigger contribution than TWatt
No way is Makienok in the same level of shite as Simon Church, nobody is.
Makienok has shown that when he is confident and in a team that actually makes chances, wins corners etc then he can be a nuisance.
Simon Church is the worst striker I have ever seen at Charlton in the 20 years I've been going. Atrocious.
So what if he is a likeable bloke? Gandhi is a likeable bloke but I wouldn't put him up front. Actually, then again......we've tried everything else.
I mean.... Sodje, Abbott, McLeod, Benson, Mooney all instantly spring to mind as worse from the past 5-10 years. I'd probably have Church over Reza at the moment. Not saying you're wrong, but I disagree!
Both useless, make Leaburn look like Pele! Oh for Darren Bent, Mendonca, Andy Hunt, Yann, BWP and Tony Watt!
Having a bubble with that last one mate, if you throw his name in there you need to add about 20 names to the list that have played in the last couple of decades, all of which made a bigger contribution than TWatt
If we are talking pure ability alone, then Tony Watt is one of the most naturally talented players Charlton have had since leaving the Premier League.
If you want to compare anyone in our squad with Simon Church its got to be Reza... Runs after the ball, closes the opposition down yet when it comes to doing the nitty gritty stuff between the Midfield and Attack you know he's not going to come out on top
I still prefer Reza because... Well... REZA
Enjoy Reza and Mak whilst they're still here
Come to The Valley and watch the Championship bench warmers of the future.
Depressing to even have this discussion. Not quite like "Hales is the better finisher but Flanagan is the better all round player" arguments back in the day.
Worth saying that a few posters on Preston's forum thought Makienok was tremendous on Tuesday night, yet I look at the players' marks and someone gave him a 3 whilst another poster claimed he doesn't want to play for us!
Comments
Makienok has shown that when he is confident and in a team that actually makes chances, wins corners etc then he can be a nuisance.
Simon Church is the worst striker I have ever seen at Charlton in the 20 years I've been going. Atrocious.
So what if he is a likeable bloke? Gandhi is a likeable bloke but I wouldn't put him up front. Actually, then again......we've tried everything else.
Little Si 5 goals in 55 games with no excuse.
Edit: Chris Dickson
Mak doesn't run around enough and positional sense very poor.
Both very weak physically.
Verdict, neither scored anywhere near enough goals neither good enough for championship.
I think we have an answer.
*Sobs into beer*