Henderson - 5 one of his worst displays Solly - 7 Diarra - 5 The man is a liability Lennon - 6 Holmes Dennis -5 Berg Gudmundsson -5 Cousins - 4 Jackson - 4 Lookman - 8 He'll probably sell for £5M in January Reza - 6 Vaz Te - 7 Makienok - 2 Ba - 1
Henderson - 6 Solly - 6 Only because he got forward all the time Diarra - 5 when he plays in midfield he is great but this just not his position Lennon - 5 Holmes Dennis - 4 Berg Gudmundsson - 4 Cousins - 5 Jackson - 4 Lookman - 8 Reza - 5 Vaz Te - 7 Makienok - 3 Ba - 1
Henderson - 6 probably should have saved the 2nd Solly - 7 good game tried hard Diarra - 7 good game tried hard Lennon - 6.5 I thought he did well considering his inexperience Holmes Dennis - 7 good game Berg Gudmundsson - 4.5 I'm getting angry with JBG. He's just not putting in the effort & looks like he doesn't care. Cousins - 5.5 Usual game, but he has no support. Jackson - 6 Better than Saturday but still lagging after 70 mins. Lookman - 7.5 Excellent, why was he subbed ? Reza - 6 Tried but got nowhere again. Vaz Te - 5 insignificant for the most part. Makienok - 4 Embarassing. Ba - 2 He doesn't even resemble a professional footballer. Gives away or loses the ball the majority of the time.
Henderson - 6 should have done better with 2nd goal Solly - 6.5 some crucial tackles Diarra - 6 Lennon - 6 Holmes Dennis - 5.5 Berg Gudmundsson - 5 Cousins - 5 Jackson - 5 desire was there, but we were overrun in midfield Lookman - 7 at last someone who can score goals Reza - 5.5 Vaz Te - 5.5 Makienok - 6 the ironic cheers when he won a header got quite frequent... Ba - 4 knew he'd be booked. Can't pass or keep the ball.
Henderson - 7 Kept us in the game in the second half. Holmes-Dennis - 6 Lennon - 6 Some good bits, some wonky. Is he really better than Sarr? Diarra - 7 Solly - 6 Jackson - 7 But.....his pace has gone Gudmundsson - 5 Cousins - 6 Ghoochannejhad - 8 Man of the match. Always there. Always creating. Vaz Te - 8 Skilful, but, slow Lookman - 8 Nicked 2 goals early on then got marked out of the game Ba - 5 Tries and can do good moves but also clumsy Makienok - 6 Ahearne-Grant n/a
Henderson - 5 not himself Solly - 6.5 did his job and a bit more Diarra - 5.5 might be losing interest Lennon - 5.5 steep learning curve Holmes Dennis - 5 exposed and roasted 2nd half Berg Gudmundsson - 5 will the real JBG please stand up Cousins - 5.5 works hard but needs a partner who can put his foot on the ball Jackson - 5.5 works hard but needs a partner who can put his foot on the ball Lookman - 7 our 'out ball'. Leaves when he wants to Reza - 6 worked hard, but not suited to The Championship Vaz Te - 6 knows what he's doing, but needs to do more Makienok - 5.5 what do you expect? Not his fault he is 6' 8" and we signed him Ba - 5 some poor decisions
Henderson - 5 Did he call for the ball 1st goal and the second seemed to go though him regardless of deflection he was diving that way Solly - 7 cant fault his appetite Diarra - 5 not a centre back therefore cant be too critical Lennon - 7 shows promise Holmes Dennis - 5 was shown up a bit tonight but possibly knackered Berg Gudmundsson - 5 plays in a woeful midfield Cousins - 4 tties ever so much but perhaps tries too much, distribution woeful Jackson - 5, Legend but not his fault he cant do Saturday, Tuesday, Saturday Lookman - 8 great 1st half knackered thereafter (only a kid) Reza - 6 too lightweight Vaz Te - 4 unfit Makienok - 3 Sunday morning player Ba - Minus 2 one of the worst ever
Henderson - 7 Solly - 5 Diarra - 4.5 - his worst game in a Charlton shirt Lennon - 5 Holmes Dennis - 5.5 Berg Gudmundsson - 1 - doesn't warrant a place in the squad based on form this season, doesn't look interested, sell him, recall Harriott. Cousins - 1 - couldn't hit a cows arse with a banjo with his passing tonight, just as bad as JBG, Moussa should play ahead of him. Jackson - 6 - Poor JJ always tries his best and doesn't deserve having to carry the team on his back Lookman - 8 - Took his chances, Roland is rubbing his hands together Reza - 5 - Rubbish game from him tonight Vaz Te - 6 - Forced to play 90 minutes when in all truth he's probably not match-fit just yet Makienok - 5 - League One, gives pointless fouls away constantly Ba - 1 - I'd call him the new Bradley Pritchard but that's disrespectful to Pritchard
Henderson - 5 could have done better with the second goal Solly - 7 more like the old Solly Diarra - 4 couldn't cope with Heskey Lennon - 4 positionally weak Holmes Dennis - 4 good going forward but taken apart at will by Feeney Berg Gudmundsson - 6 nowhere near his best but, equally, nowhere near as bad as some are suggesting Cousins - 6.5 we all see it differently but I didn't think he was terrible Jackson - 5 not effective and not much evidence of leadership either Lookman - 7.5 enjoy him while it lasts Reza - 6 good effort but a bit short of fitness Vaz Te - 7.5 I thought he played well. Came to the ball and used it well. Makienok - 6 Ba - 4 look up and play the obvious ball to the man in space!!
Henderson - 7 Solly - 7 Diarra - 5 Lennon - 5 Holmes Dennis -6 Berg Gudmundsson - 5 Cousins - 4 Jackson - 5 Lookman - 7 Reza - 6 Vaz Te - 6 Makienok - 4 Ba - 3 Might be a bit harsh as it was not easy to come in to that, but he is a comedy footballer
Henderson - 6.5 - couple of good saves, average kicking Solly - 7 - solid, some excellent tackles not much offered going forward Diarra - 7 - solid but beaten for one of the goals prefer him in midfield Lennon - 6.5 - ok performance Holmes Dennis - 6.5 - flashes of great, flashes of bad, still prefer to fox Berg Gudmundsson - 5 - pretty non exsistant Cousins - 5 - not a great game lost out to boltons midfield Jackson - 5 - not a great game lost out to boltons midfield Lookman - 7.5 - 9 - 1st half 6 - 2nd half so 7.5 overall Reza - 8 - Tireless and may not of been his best game for us but was one of only players who seemed to want the ball and make continuous runs also won us the ball for the 1st and was his bit of class to set up 2nd Vaz Te - 7.5 - assist and all round good performance shame couldn't get any real clear cut chances Makienok - 6 - offered something different but not much time to really create much Ba - 4 - flashes of a poor man toure running though players one min then sunday league back passes the next, clumsy
Henderson - 6 Pope would get slaughtered for letting in their second, deflection or not. Solly - 7 One of our better players Diarra - 5.5 An average showing Lennon - 6 Composed on the ball, think he might settle down in the team as the season progresses. Holmes Dennis - 5 Skinned quite a few times and made it too easy for the bloke to cross for their first goal. Berg Gudmundsson - 5.5 Not at his best again. Cousins - 5 Saw him reprimand someone for a bad pass during the second half. Ironic. Jackson - 5 Love the guy but was pretty ineffective last night. Lookman - 8 Lively, nice touch, took his goals well. MOTM. Reza - 7 Played a part in both goals. Vaz Te - 6.5 Interesting how different people see it. I thought he was okay but clearly short of match fitness. Makienok - 4 Pointless bringing him on, offered nothing up front. Ba - 4 His final act in the game just summed up his career with us so far.
Colin 1961 Of course I was there but unlike you I am not the subject of almost total ridicule for your pathetic comments on numerous posts. I called the game as I saw it, as have others. I didn't make any criticism of your scores although I disagreed with them.
Colin 1961 Of course I was there but unlike you I am not the subject of almost total ridicule for your pathetic comments on numerous posts. I called the game as I saw it, as have others. I didn't make any criticism of your scores although I disagreed with them.
Is this grounds for a libellous action? Don't be nice sue him!
I don’t understand how Reza is getting a bad rating.. and Lookman is getting an amazing one?
What did Lookman do apart from score 2 goals put on a plate for him? Reza constantly wanted the ball, he made the second goal and his tireless work won the ball for the 1st.
We were shocking, and I don’t think any of the players are worthy of more than a 5. How Ba is a professional footballer I find it very hard to understand! Who the f**k saw talent in him?
I don’t understand how Reza is getting a bad rating.. and Lookman is getting an amazing one?
What did Lookman do apart from score 2 goals put on a plate for him? Reza constantly wanted the ball, he made the second goal and his tireless work won the ball for the 1st.
We were shocking, and I don’t think any of the players are worthy of more than a 5. How Ba is a professional footballer I find it very hard to understand! Who the f**k saw talent in him?
The same person who saw something in a Thuram, Nego, Peter Parsnip, Le Point...............Oh to hell with it, I can't be bothered to type the rest
Comments
Solly - 7
Diarra - 5 The man is a liability
Lennon - 6
Holmes Dennis -5
Berg Gudmundsson -5
Cousins - 4
Jackson - 4
Lookman - 8 He'll probably sell for £5M in January
Reza - 6
Vaz Te - 7
Makienok - 2
Ba - 1
Solly - 6 Only because he got forward all the time
Diarra - 5 when he plays in midfield he is great but this just not his position
Lennon - 5
Holmes Dennis - 4
Berg Gudmundsson - 4
Cousins - 5
Jackson - 4
Lookman - 8
Reza - 5
Vaz Te - 7
Makienok - 3
Ba - 1
Solly - 7 good game tried hard
Diarra - 7 good game tried hard
Lennon - 6.5 I thought he did well considering his inexperience
Holmes Dennis - 7 good game
Berg Gudmundsson - 4.5 I'm getting angry with JBG. He's just not putting in the effort & looks like he doesn't care.
Cousins - 5.5 Usual game, but he has no support.
Jackson - 6 Better than Saturday but still lagging after 70 mins.
Lookman - 7.5 Excellent, why was he subbed ?
Reza - 6 Tried but got nowhere again.
Vaz Te - 5 insignificant for the most part.
Makienok - 4 Embarassing.
Ba - 2 He doesn't even resemble a professional footballer. Gives away or loses the ball the majority of the time.
Solly 6.5
Holmes-Dennis 6
Diarra 6
Lennon 6
Gudmunddson 5.5
Cousins 5.5
Jackson 5.5
Lookman 7
Reza 6
Vaz te 6.5
Makienok 5
Ba 5
Solly - 6.5 some crucial tackles
Diarra - 6
Lennon - 6
Holmes Dennis - 5.5
Berg Gudmundsson - 5
Cousins - 5
Jackson - 5 desire was there, but we were overrun in midfield
Lookman - 7 at last someone who can score goals
Reza - 5.5
Vaz Te - 5.5
Makienok - 6 the ironic cheers when he won a header got quite frequent...
Ba - 4 knew he'd be booked. Can't pass or keep the ball.
Solly - 7
Diarra - 5.5
Lennon - 5.5
Holmes Dennis - 6.5
Berg Gudmundsson - 6
Cousins - 5
Jackson - 5
Lookman - 8
Reza - 7
Vaz Te - 7
Makienok - 6
Ba - 4
Holmes-Dennis - 6
Lennon - 6 Some good bits, some wonky. Is he really better than Sarr?
Diarra - 7
Solly - 6
Jackson - 7 But.....his pace has gone
Gudmundsson - 5
Cousins - 6
Ghoochannejhad - 8 Man of the match. Always there. Always creating.
Vaz Te - 8 Skilful, but, slow
Lookman - 8 Nicked 2 goals early on then got marked out of the game
Ba - 5 Tries and can do good moves but also clumsy
Makienok - 6
Ahearne-Grant n/a
Solly - 6.5 did his job and a bit more
Diarra - 5.5 might be losing interest
Lennon - 5.5 steep learning curve
Holmes Dennis - 5 exposed and roasted 2nd half
Berg Gudmundsson - 5 will the real JBG please stand up
Cousins - 5.5 works hard but needs a partner who can put his foot on the ball
Jackson - 5.5 works hard but needs a partner who can put his foot on the ball
Lookman - 7 our 'out ball'. Leaves when he wants to
Reza - 6 worked hard, but not suited to The Championship
Vaz Te - 6 knows what he's doing, but needs to do more
Makienok - 5.5 what do you expect? Not his fault he is 6' 8" and we signed him
Ba - 5 some poor decisions
Solly - 7 cant fault his appetite
Diarra - 5 not a centre back therefore cant be too critical
Lennon - 7 shows promise
Holmes Dennis - 5 was shown up a bit tonight but possibly knackered
Berg Gudmundsson - 5 plays in a woeful midfield
Cousins - 4 tties ever so much but perhaps tries too much, distribution woeful
Jackson - 5, Legend but not his fault he cant do Saturday, Tuesday, Saturday
Lookman - 8 great 1st half knackered thereafter (only a kid)
Reza - 6 too lightweight
Vaz Te - 4 unfit
Makienok - 3 Sunday morning player
Ba - Minus 2 one of the worst ever
Solly - 5
Diarra - 4.5 - his worst game in a Charlton shirt
Lennon - 5
Holmes Dennis - 5.5
Berg Gudmundsson - 1 - doesn't warrant a place in the squad based on form this season, doesn't look interested, sell him, recall Harriott.
Cousins - 1 - couldn't hit a cows arse with a banjo with his passing tonight, just as bad as JBG, Moussa should play ahead of him.
Jackson - 6 - Poor JJ always tries his best and doesn't deserve having to carry the team on his back
Lookman - 8 - Took his chances, Roland is rubbing his hands together
Reza - 5 - Rubbish game from him tonight
Vaz Te - 6 - Forced to play 90 minutes when in all truth he's probably not match-fit just yet
Makienok - 5 - League One, gives pointless fouls away constantly
Ba - 1 - I'd call him the new Bradley Pritchard but that's disrespectful to Pritchard
Solly - 7
Diarra - 6
Lennon - 6
Holmes Dennis - 6
Gudmundsson - 6
Cousins - 4
Jackson - 6
Lookman - 8.5
Reza - 6
Vaz Te - 6
Ba - 4
Makienok - 6
Henderson - 5 could have done better with the second goal
Solly - 7 more like the old Solly
Diarra - 4 couldn't cope with Heskey
Lennon - 4 positionally weak
Holmes Dennis - 4 good going forward but taken apart at will by Feeney
Berg Gudmundsson - 6 nowhere near his best but, equally, nowhere near as bad as some are suggesting
Cousins - 6.5 we all see it differently but I didn't think he was terrible
Jackson - 5 not effective and not much evidence of leadership either
Lookman - 7.5 enjoy him while it lasts
Reza - 6 good effort but a bit short of fitness
Vaz Te - 7.5 I thought he played well. Came to the ball and used it well.
Makienok - 6
Ba - 4 look up and play the obvious ball to the man in space!!
Ahearne Grant. n/a
Solly - 6
Diarra - 6
Lennon - 5
Holmes Dennis - 5
Gudmundsson - 7
Cousins - 5
Jackson - 6
Lookman - 9
Reza - 7
Vaz Te - 7
Ba - 6
Makienok - 7
Solly - 6
Diarra - 5
Lennon - 5
Holmes Dennis - 4.5
Berg Gudmundsson - 4
Cousins - 5
Jackson - 5
Lookman - 6.5
Reza - 6
Vaz Te - 5.5
Makienok - 5
Ba - 4
Solly - 7
Diarra - 5
Lennon - 5
Holmes Dennis -6
Berg Gudmundsson - 5
Cousins - 4
Jackson - 5
Lookman - 7
Reza - 6
Vaz Te - 6
Makienok - 4
Ba - 3 Might be a bit harsh as it was not easy to come in to that, but he is a comedy footballer
Solly - 7
Diarra - 6
Lennon - 6.5
Holmes Dennis -7
Berg Gudmundsson - 6.5
Cousins - 6
Jackson - 6
Lookman - 7.5
Reza - 7
Vaz Te - 7
Makienok - 5.5
Ba - 5.5
Solly - 7 - solid, some excellent tackles not much offered going forward
Diarra - 7 - solid but beaten for one of the goals prefer him in midfield
Lennon - 6.5 - ok performance
Holmes Dennis - 6.5 - flashes of great, flashes of bad, still prefer to fox
Berg Gudmundsson - 5 - pretty non exsistant
Cousins - 5 - not a great game lost out to boltons midfield
Jackson - 5 - not a great game lost out to boltons midfield
Lookman - 7.5 - 9 - 1st half 6 - 2nd half so 7.5 overall
Reza - 8 - Tireless and may not of been his best game for us but was one of only players who seemed to want the ball and make continuous runs also won us the ball for the 1st and was his bit of class to set up 2nd
Vaz Te - 7.5 - assist and all round good performance shame couldn't get any real clear cut chances
Makienok - 6 - offered something different but not much time to really create much
Ba - 4 - flashes of a poor man toure running though players one min then sunday league back passes the next, clumsy
Solly - 7 One of our better players
Diarra - 5.5 An average showing
Lennon - 6 Composed on the ball, think he might settle down in the team as the season progresses.
Holmes Dennis - 5 Skinned quite a few times and made it too easy for the bloke to cross for their first goal.
Berg Gudmundsson - 5.5 Not at his best again.
Cousins - 5 Saw him reprimand someone for a bad pass during the second half. Ironic.
Jackson - 5 Love the guy but was pretty ineffective last night.
Lookman - 8 Lively, nice touch, took his goals well. MOTM.
Reza - 7 Played a part in both goals.
Vaz Te - 6.5 Interesting how different people see it. I thought he was okay but clearly short of match fitness.
Makienok - 4 Pointless bringing him on, offered nothing up front.
Ba - 4 His final act in the game just summed up his career with us so far.
Of course I was there but unlike you I am not the subject of almost total ridicule for your pathetic comments on numerous posts. I called the game as I saw it, as have others. I didn't make any criticism of your scores although I disagreed with them.
What did Lookman do apart from score 2 goals put on a plate for him? Reza constantly wanted the ball, he made the second goal and his tireless work won the ball for the 1st.
We were shocking, and I don’t think any of the players are worthy of more than a 5. How Ba is a professional footballer I find it very hard to understand! Who the f**k saw talent in him?
http://forum.charltonlife.com/discussion/70363/charlton-v-bolton-post-match-thread#latest
Solly ... 7
Diarra ... 6
Lennon ... 6
Holmes-Dennis ... 5
Gudmundsson ... 5
Jackson ... 5
Cousins ... 5
Lookman ... 7
Reza ... 6
Vaz Te ... 6
Makienok ... 5
Ba ... 4
Solly - 7
Diarra - 6
Lennon - 6
Holmes Dennis -5
Berg Gudmundsson - 5
Cousins - 6
Jackson - 4
Lookman - 7
Reza - 6
Vaz Te - 6
Makienok - 6
Ba - 5
Ahearne Grant. n/a
Solly 6
Diarra 6
Lennon 6
Holmes Dennis 6
Gudmundsson 4
Cousins 3
Jackson 5
Lookman 6
Reza 5
Vaz Te 7
Makienok 4
Ba 3
Solly - 8 MOTM
Diarra - 6
Lennon - 5
Holmes Dennis - 6
Berg Gudmundsson - 4
Cousins - 4 - what has happened to JC- dreadful
Jackson - 4
Lookman - 7
Reza - 6
Vaz Te - 6
Makienok - 4
Ba - 3 usual
Solly - 6
Diarra - 7
Lennon - 6
Holmes Dennis - 4
Berg Gudmundsson - 5
Cousins - 4
Jackson - 6
Lookman - 8
Reza - 6
Vaz Te - 7
Makienok - 5
Ba - 4