Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Charlton v Rotherham

13

Comments

  • Pope - 8
    Solly - 7.5
    Fox - 6.5
    Diarra - 9
    Bauer - 8
    Gudmunsson - 7
    Ba - 6.5
    Kashi - 6.5
    Cousins - 7
    Watt - 6
    Vetokele - 5

    Makienok - 7.5
  • Pope - 8 Excellent reflex save to keep us in the game when it was 1-0
    Solly - 7 Much more like the player from two seasons ago
    Fox - 6 Good performance but still needs to work on his crossing
    Diarra - 8 A class player and reads the game so well
    Bauer - 7 Solid performance
    Gudmunsson 8 Looked dangerous when ever he was on the ball but should have scored
    Ba 6 Consistent performance, although not too much of note
    Kashi - 8 Another class performance (apart from that shot from distance!)
    Cousins - 8 Good movement but really should have scored.
    Watt - 7 Again, looked dangerous when ever he was on the ball
    Vetokele - 6 A few good touches but anonymous for much of the time

    Makienok - 7 We look far more threatening when he is on the pitch. Good assist
    Bergdich n/a Preferred him to Ba


  • Pope - 7.5 two very good saves. One world class.
    Solly - 7.0 Steady as ever.
    Fox - 6.5 poor crossing today
    Diarra - 8.5 not enough quality in Rotherham to test him today
    Bauer - 7.5 goal and stroll in the park
    Gudmunsson - 7.5 showed urgency in second half. Needs to get shots off quicker
    Ba - 6.5 not troubled but not fantastic today
    Kashi - 6.5 thought he was not up to speed agin very average oppo
    Cousins - 6.5 quiet first half. Better second. Two chances.
    Watt - 7.0 never going to look great playing as loan striker
    Vetokele - 5.5 huge worry. Nowhere near the player of last season.

    Makienok - 7.0 short cameo. Assist and I think we would have won with him starting
    Bergdich n/a looked lively but had little time to settle



  • Pope----7
    Solly---6.5
    Fox ---6.5 better when Bergditch came on
    Diarra---8 booked for what ?
    Bauer---7.5
    JBG ---7
    Kashi---6 all over the show and not always in a good way
    Ba--- 6
    Cousins---6 as usual much better when he was inside
    Watt---6.5 great with the ball at his feet, will frustrate but crack on.
    Vetokele---6 control is awful.

    Makienok---7 we looked much better with him on
    Bergdich----6 looked lively
  • Pope - 8
    Solly - 7.5
    Fox - 6.5
    Diarra - 7.5
    Bauer - 8
    Gudmundsson - 6.5
    Ba - 7
    Kashi - 6.5
    Cousins - 7
    Watt - 7.5
    Vetokele - 6.5

    Makienok - 7.5
    Bergdich n/a


  • Pope - 8 Not a busy day,but boy was he there when needed to be. I also generally like his distribution,always looking to bowl the ball out quickly and get the game going.
    Solly - 6 Better second half
    Fox - 5 Today we had last season Fox, a stranger to the opponents half
    Diarra - 8 Absolute rock,but why get involved with that tool Rotherham player after we scored and then arguing the toss with the ref after getting a yellow was stupid
    Bauer - 8 He scores goals as well, whow
    Gudmunsson - 6 Work hard, but was a blind alley day for JBG
    Ba - 5 Very lucky the ref was a completely useless. He put his head in the face of a Rotherham defender. Had to be calmed by Diarra ( I think) ironic considering his behaviour later on. PS credit to Rotherham player, he could have acted like a complete twat and gone down holding face etc etc , it happens.
    Kashi - 7 Came and went a bit
    Cousins - 7 Ditto
    Watt - 6 It's not all about you Tony. Having said that if some of the stuff he tried had come off we would all be creaming our pants.
    Vetokele - 5 Forgot he was playing. It was the most obvious substitution in a long time

    Makienok - 7 Can only assume recent injury prevented him from starting
    Bergdich n/a



  • Pope - 7
    Solly - 7
    Fox - 6
    Diarra - 7.5
    Bauer - 7
    Gudmunsson - 6.5
    Ba - 6
    Kashi - 7
    Cousins - 6
    Watt - 6
    Vetokele - 5

    Makienok - 7
  • Pope - 7; One fabulous save and a couple of other good ones, but I wish he would dominate his six yard box a bit more.
    Solly - 6; had loads of space but others struggled to get him the ball
    Fox - 5; Gave his wide man far too much room
    Diarra - 8; Great on the ball and won numerous tackles/headers
    Bauer - 7; Solid mainly, and a goal to boot (I had him as first scorer...)
    Gudmunsson - 6.5; Did OK but we expect a lot more from him nowadays - shooting was off target
    Ba - 5; Tried hard but lost the midfield battle
    Kashi - 7; Very tidy
    Cousins - 6; Some good play from out wide and decent inside too, but flitted in and out of the game
    Watt - 6.5; Some brilliance but only in flashes - not yet fit
    Vetokele - 4; Not fit and my worry is we may never see the Igor we had last August ever again?

    Makienok - 7; Changed the game and set up the goal - very important to the side in these sort of matches
  • Pope - 8.5 The save from the close range header was as good as you'll see.
    Solly - 7 Pretty average 1st half but got going in the 2nd half. Was knackered with about ten to go.
    Fox - 6 Did ok.
    Diarra - 9 Looked like he'd been playing as an International CB for his entire career.
    Bauer - 8 Another good performance and I should think there will be quite a few more goals to come too.
    Gudmunsson - 7 Maybe the International games took the edge of him but he was still good on the ball.
    Ba - 6.5 Put himself about and showed strength on the ball.
    Kashi - 6.5 Made himself available and tried to keep us moving.
    Cousins - 6.5 Two good efforts in the 1st half but came up against a good keeper. Did his best.
    Watt - 6.5 Not quite as sharp as he had been but has been injured. Still tried to create despite being heavily marked.
    Vetokele - 5.5 Returning from a long injury break and will take time to get going. Another important hour under his belt.

    Makienok - 7.5 Couldn't be risked for longer than 35 mins (he's too important long term). Showed his awareness again with the dummy for Watt and set up Bauer's goal.
    Bergdich n/a - Busy 18 min cameo. I think he'll start on Tuesday.
  • Pope - 7
    Solly - 6
    Fox - 5
    Diarra - 6
    Bauer - 7
    Gudmunsson - 7
    Ba - 6
    Kashi - 6
    Cousins - 7
    Watt - 6
    Vetokele - 4

    Makienok - 7
    Bergdich n/a
  • Sponsored links:



  • Pope - 8 (-2 for their goal, causing me to have a half time moan on the match thread, +4 for his second half brilliance, think our world would have fallen in if we'd gone 0-2 down)
    Solly - 7 good going forward all match
    Fox - 6 like him but my grandma could cross a ball better than he did yesterday
    Diarra - 8 class act, so calm and assured
    Bauer - 7 first of many goals I hope, defensively not as assertive as normal
    Gudmunsson - 6 one of his more frustrating days, had the chances but didn't convert, hope he'll find his shooting range soon, like last season
    Ba - 6 not sure why it all kicked off around him
    Kashi - 7 good but not at the level of QPR and Hull
    Cousins - 7 had the best chances, wish he would score more goals
    Watt - 6 flashes of brilliance but just wasn't on it and as others have said showed his petulant side too often
    Vetokele - 5 oh Igor what's happened to you?

    Makienok - 8 great impact, missed him badly defending corners too - suddenly everyone had free headers (or tap ins) in our box
  • Pope - 7
    Solly - 7
    Fox - 7
    Diarra - 8
    Bauer - 8
    Gudmunsson - 7
    Ba - 7
    Kashi - 7
    Cousins - 7
    Watt - 7
    Vetokele - 6

    Makienok - 7
    Bergdich n/a
  • Pope - 7
    Solly - 6
    Fox - 6
    Diarra - 9 was bloody brilliant
    Bauer - 8
    Gudmunsson - 6.5
    Ba - 6.5
    Kashi - 7
    Cousins - 6
    Watt - 6.5
    Vetokele - 6.5

    Makienok - 7
    Bergdich n/a
  • Pope - 8 I don't blame him as much as others for the goal. There were too many bodies in the way to claim, and the defence let him down badly letting the ball travel that far. A "worldly" in the second half, right up there with Deano's v Dugarry. Would be in any teams end-of-season highlights reel.

    Solly - 6 Got involved in the niggly stuff a little too much. Got forward well in the first half, but with half of the Valley pitch to run into in the second, hardly got in a cross of note.

    Fox - 6 Defended well enough, but must work on his crossing.

    Diarra - 9 MOTM Are some still unsure about him as a centre half? Won every header, more than a few telling interceptions and tackles, and was the fulcrum in the driving attacks in the 2nd half. Outstanding, and deserves the armband.

    Bauer - 8 Extra half for the goal, but not quite as dominant as in previous games. Still good though!

    Gudmunsson - 6.5 I can't work out what is wrong with JBG. His body language absolutely stinks. Still looked to be the creative spark, but last year would have buried that free kick, and the other chance.

    Ba - 6 Solid but not as good as the last few games.

    Kashi - 6 As Ba. The Peterborough goal seems to have given some serious delusions!

    Cousins - 6.5 Did well, including forcing their keeper into an outstanding save. Became more assertive after Bergdich was brought on.

    Watt - 7 Still love TW, and brings excitement every time he's on the ball. The problem is, we don't play the ball to his feet enough. But, Tony, there is no "I" in "Team", and if you have 3 on you, someone will be unmarked. We won't hold it against you if you pass occasionally...

    Vetokele - 5 For 15-20 minutes looked sharp and lively. Then slowly drifted out of the game. Hopefully just lack of game time, but is looking more and more 3rd choice, at best...

    Makienok - 7 Made a massive difference when he came on. His intelligence in bringing other players into the game is excellent. Another very good assist to his portfolio. As too Rotherham's goal. I'm pretty sure if the Viking Warrior had been on the pitch, he would have headed the ball 50 yards up the pitch, before it ever fell to the goal scorer...
  • Pope - 8.5 MOM two top saves. Kept us in it.
    Solly - 7
    Fox - 6.5
    Diarra - 8
    Bauer - 7.5
    Gudmunsson - 6.5 Strangely looked tired first half, much better 2nd half. Should have shot first time 2nd half.
    Ba - 6.5
    Kashi - 6.5
    Cousins - 6.5
    Watt - 6 Just had an off day, not much came off.
    Vetokele - 6

    Makienok - 8
    Bergdich n/a
  • Pope - 8
    Solly - 7
    Fox - 6.5
    Diarra - 8.5
    Bauer - 7.5
    Gudmunsson - 7
    Ba - 6.5
    Kashi - 6.5
    Cousins - 7
    Watt - 7
    Vetokele - 5.5

    Makienok - 7.5
  • Pope - 7 second-half save won Charlton the point
    Solly - 7 busy and angry
    Fox - 6 crossing sometimes let him down
    Diarra - 8 orchestrated things for periods esp. in first half
    Bauer - 7 classy
    Gudmunsson - 7 looks always likely to score
    Ba - 5 looks like he's got an attitude issue, hence substituted
    Kashi - 6 a live-wire who wanted more of the ball
    Cousins - 5 in and out of game
    Watt - 7 added new angles and dramatic changes in pace
    Vetokele - 5 looked Sordellesque

    Makienok - 7 his addition made team a more potent threat
    Bergdich n/a an improvement on Vetoleke
  • Pope - 8
    Solly - 7
    Fox - 6.5
    Diarra -8
    Bauer -8
    Gudmunsson -7.5
    Ba - 7
    Kashi - 7
    Cousins - 6.5
    Watt - 8
    Vetokele - 5

    Makienok - 7.5
    Bergdich n/a6.5
  • Pope - 9
    Solly - 7
    Fox - 6.5
    Diarra - 8
    Bauer - 8.5
    Gudmundsson - 7
    Ba - 6.5
    Kashi - 6
    Cousins - 7
    Watt - 7
    Vetokele - 6

    Makienok - 9 (extra mark for the assist and the clever dummy that put TW in)
  • Pope - 8
    Solly - 7
    Fox - 6
    Diarra - 8.5
    Bauer - 8
    Gudmunsson - 7
    Ba - 6
    Kashi - 6.5
    Cousins - 6.5
    Watt - 6.5
    Vetokele - 5

    Makienok - 7.5
  • Sponsored links:


  • Pope - 8 two great saves, distribution not very effective
    Solly - 7.5
    Fox - 6.5 OK but crossing poor
    Diarra -9 MOM best game he's had for us
    Bauer - 7.5
    Gudmunsson - 6
    Ba - 6
    Kashi - 6.5
    Cousins - 7 really needs to be playing in the centre
    Watt - 6.5
    Vetokele - 4.5 hope he just needs match fitness

    Makienok - 7
  • Pope - 7 - at least two great saves - one superb one. Maybe at fault for the goal though
    Solly - 6.5 - nothing wrong with the tackle he got booked for. won the ball and the guy tumbled because he knew he'd get a free kick for it.
    Fox - 6.5 no frills. Unappreciated because he doesn't take people on - that's not his game. Much improved
    Diarra - 7 standard stuff from him now
    Bauer - 7.5 deserved a goal. going to be so important this season but every chance he will be in the Premiership within a couple of years
    Gudmunsson - 6.5 - missed a couple of chances to shoot which is unusual
    Ba - 6.5 like him. missed his "head-butt". covers a lot of ground and has a knack of getting a tackle in
    Kashi - 6.5 - quieter but still impressive workrate
    Cousins - 7 - busy and unlucky not to score
    Watt - 6.5 he may be greedy sometimes but there are times he goes past a player with breathtaking ease. If he picked out the pass every time there is no way on earth he would be in the Championship. His first touch is outsanding
    Vetokele - 5 pants. has been for ages. always on his heels, not as quick as he used to be, not winning much in the air like he used to, doesn't look like scoring. I actually really like him but his game has gone to shit.

    Makienok - 8 - the difference. Keep him fit and we will do well
    Bergdich n/a



  • Pope - 8
    Solly - 5.5
    Fox - 7
    Diarra - 8
    Bauer -
    Gudmunsson -7
    Ba - 7
    Kashi - 8
    Cousins - 7
    Watt - 7.5
    Vetokele - 6

    Makienok - 7.5
  • Pope - 7.5
    Solly - 7
    Fox - 6
    Diarra - 8.5
    Bauer - 7.5
    Gudmunsson - 7.5
    Ba - 6
    Kashi - 6
    Cousins - 7
    Watt - 7
    Vetokele - 5.5

    Makienok - 7

  • Pope - 8
    Solly - 7
    Fox - 7
    Diarra - 8
    Bauer - 8
    Gudmunsson - 5
    Ba - 7
    Kashi - 7
    Cousins - 6
    Watt - 6
    Vetokele - 5

    Makienok - 7
    Bergdich n/a







  • Pope - 8
    Solly - 6
    Fox - 6
    Diarra - 7
    Bauer - 7
    Gudmunsson - 7
    Ba - 6
    Kashi - 7
    Cousins - 6
    Watt - 5
    Vetokele - 5

    Makienok - 7
    Bergdich n/a
  • Pope - 7
    Solly - 7
    Fox - 7
    Diarra - 8
    Bauer - 8
    Gudmundson - 7
    Ba - 6
    Kashi - 7
    Cousins - 7
    Watt - 7
    Vetokele - 5

    Makienok - 7
  • Pope - 8.5 That save from the header was class.
    Solly - 7 Got forward well and linked up with JBG better in 2nd half.
    Fox - 6.5 I wouldn't fancy playing left back with Cousins left mid, no support.
    Diarra - 9 MOM. Reads the game really well.
    Bauer - 8 Beast
    Gudmunsson - 6.5 Missed a good chance second half, always a threat on the ball.
    Ba - 6 Not his best game but still looked to be positive on the ball.
    Kashi - 6 Not as busy as usual. Not in the game as much due to oppo.
    Cousins - 6 Would be a 7 if he was asked to drift inside like he did, 5 if he wasn't as he left Fox with no support. I don't know so I'll go down the middle.
    Watt - 6.5 Lively in the second half, needs to get himself fit for 90 minutes of football and learn when to release the ball.
    Vetokele - 5.5 Not a game for him, Rotherham held a deep line and he didn't get a lot of service.

    Makienok - 7.5 Great impact when he came on.
    Bergdich n/a
  • Pope - 7
    Solly - 6
    Fox - 6
    Diarra - 8
    Bauer - 7
    Gudmunsson - 5
    Ba - 5
    Kashi - 6
    Cousins - 5
    Watt - 5
    Vetokele - 5

    Makienok - 7
    Bergdich n/a

  • Pope - 7.5
    Solly - 7
    Fox - 6.5
    Diarra - 8
    Bauer - 7
    Gudmunsson - 7
    Ba - 5.5
    Kashi - 6.5
    Cousins - 6.5
    Watt - 6
    Vetokele - 5

    Makienok - 7
    Bergdich - N/A
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!