Pope - 7.5 - Nervy at the start but after the Phillips save looked very assured Solly - 7- Good battle with Mackie which he probably edged, solid. Bauer - 8 - Without trying to draw to many comparissons reminded me very much of Ben Haim, looks a shrewd buy Diarra - 7.5- Much like Pope started Shakey but absolutely dominant in the air against a very good striker in Austin Fox -7.5- Great goal, another who grew massively as the game progressed Gudmundsson -8.5- It is scary to think where we'd be without this man Ba -7- Moments of Brilliance with some sloppy touches, think he will improve on this performance though, also very strong. Kashi - 8- Expected him to play the CDM role but was absolutely everywhere, Strong, Calm and a decent passer, the heart of Midfield. Cousins - 7- Put in a shift on the left exactly like Luzon wanted, when we stuck him in CM for the last 15-20 he showed how effective he is. Ahearne-Grant -6- Needs some football, A lot of potential but still very Raw. he's unlcuky in the sense that a lot see him as the next "Gomez." Makienok - 6- Won some headers, lost a fair few, actually looked better with the ball at his feet, confused me as a player. Watt - 7.5 - Typical Watt performance, tricky, sometimes annoying but overall a very classy player. His ability to take the ball round players is incredible. Berditch N/a Ceballos n/a
Pope - 6.5 hardly troubled, crap kicking, good diving save Solly - 7 got stuck in with 'crazy arms' Mackie Bauer - 7.5 proper defending, get it out and away, but can pass too Diarra - 7 Barely missed a header, miskicked a couple of times Fox - 8 kept the winger quiet, well taken goal Gudmundsson - 7.5 cracking effort for the free kick, got things going when we were lacking in the first half Ba - 7 jittery and caught in possession first half, grew into the game Kashi - 9 MOM everywhere Cousins - 7 kept drifting in from the left, was getting frustrated and didn't influence the game as much as he can, but he was in the wrong position Ahearne-Grant - 6 inexperience and youthful exuberance meant he kept dropping too deep, which was Makienok's job. Needs to work on his positioning in relationship to others Makienok - 7 not going to score a lot of goals but harrasses defenders well and will wind a lot of people up. Needs to win more headers given his size Watt - 8 changed the pace of the game when he came on, good goal and worries defenders with his running Berditch N/a Ceballos n/a
Pope - 8 - fantastic handling, punching and reflex stop Solly - 7.5 Bauer - 8 - strong and solid, row z defender Diarra - 7.5 Fox - 7 - a few shaky moments, great strike for the goal Gudmundsson - 7 - superb free kick, some threatening moments Ba - 7 Kashi - 9 - superb, kishishev mk. 2? Cousins - 8 Ahearne-Grant - 5.5 - just looked out of his depth Makienok - 7.5 - great defensively Watt - 9 - so exciting when he gets on the ball
Pope - 6.5 Happy for him more than anything else. A couple of really good saves that were swerving all over the place but he dealt with them. Also claimed a couple of crosses well. Solly - 7 Solid as usual. Bauer - 8 Very impressed, looked solid. Diarra - 7 Did well other than a miss kick and a mix up towards the end. Fox - 7 Seems to have been taken tips on how to defend from Solly. Best I've seen him play. Gudmundsson - 7.5 Classy payer. Ba - 6.5 Disappointing first half but improved in the second half. Kashi - 7.5 Like the look of this lad. Looked aggressive and got stuck in. Cousins - 7 Not ideal having him on the left but he got involved. Have Fox good support. Ahearne-Grant - 5.5 Not his fault, he's just not ready yet, Didn't get a sniff. Makienok - 6.5 Not effective in the first half but looked much better with Watt alongside him. Watt - 8.5 Changed the game completely. Wouldn't have won it without him. As soon as he scored it gave everyone a lift and a bit of a confidence boost.
Pope - 7.5; some very good saves and decent command (couple of things to work on though). Solly - 7; juuuuuuust about coped with Mackie (who I'd LOVE at Charlton cos he's a right little shite, if that makes sense) Bauer - 7.5; like Michael Morrison but better. Diarra - 7.5; really surprised me. Didn't think he was any good pre-season but he's proved me very wrong today. Fox - 7.5; solid and a good goal. Gudmundsson - 7; didn't do too much - great free kick and always looked like a threat. Like his interplay with others. Ba - 6.5; looked a little behind because - confusingly - he was always looking for the next pass, making him slightly out of step with what was actually going on. Moves WAY too slowly for my liking. Kashi - 8; solid. Kashishev as I will now dub him absolutely smashed it. Really good performance - works hard, passes quickly, makes decisions quickly. If only he was technically sound (hence Kish comparisons I suppose)... Cousins - 7; worked his balls off and passed well. Don't like him on the wing though, mitigating his effectiveness. Ahearne-Grant - 6; only started apparently because Watt had a bit of an incident... Didn't quite look ready. But he will be one day and he will absolutely tear the opposition to shreds in time. Makienok - 7; great defensively but attack-wise still leaves stuff to be desired - and we did sign him as a striker. Decent linkup with Watt.
Watt - 8; took his goal well and looks like such a threat with the dribble. So excited to see what he'll be like this season. Bergdich N/A Ceballos N/A
Pope - 6.5 hardly troubled, crap kicking, good diving
Early contender for meanest rating of the season. His kicking was shaky to begin with, but 2nd half was very good. And the "hardly-troubled" one made a first - half save described by the QPR Twitter feed as "stunning "
Pope - 8.5 Solly - 7.5 Bauer - 8.5 Diarra - 7 could easily have been sent off for that extremely late challenge Fox - 8.5 Gudmundsson - 8 Ba - 6.5 Kashi - 8.5 Cousins - 7 Ahearne-Grant - 6 Makienok - 6 Watt - 9 as others said, a game changer
Comments
Solly - 7.5
Bauer - 7.5
Diarra - 7
Fox - 8
Gudmundsson - 7
Ba - 7.5
Kashi - 7.5
Cousins - 7.5
Ahearne-Grant - 6
Makienok - 6
Watt - 9 game changer
Berditch N/a
Ceballos n/a
Pope - 7
Solly - 6
Bauer - 8
Diarra 7.5
Fox - 6.5
Gudmundsson 7
Ba - 7
Kashi 9
Cousins - 7.5
Ahearne-Grant - 5.5
Makienok- 7
Watt - 8
Berditch N/a
Ceballos n/a
Solly - 8
Bauer - 7
Diarra - 8
Fox - 8
Gudmundsson - 8
Ba - 7
Kashi - 9 mom
Cousins - 7
Ahearne-Grant - 6
Makienok - 6
Watt - 8
Berditch N/a
Ceballos n/a
Solly - 8
Bauer - 7
Diarra - 7
Fox - 8
Gudmundsson - 8
Ba - 7
Kashi - 9
Cousins - 7
Ahearne-Grant - 6
Makienok - 6 first half, 8 second. 7
Watt - 9
Berditch N/a
Ceballos n/a
Solly - 8
Bauer - 8
Diarra - 8.5
Fox - 8
Gudmundsson - 8
Ba - 7
Kashi -9
Cousins - 8
Ahearne-Grant - 7
Makienok - 7
Watt - 8.5
Solly - 7- Good battle with Mackie which he probably edged, solid.
Bauer - 8 - Without trying to draw to many comparissons reminded me very much of Ben Haim, looks a shrewd buy
Diarra - 7.5- Much like Pope started Shakey but absolutely dominant in the air against a very good striker in Austin
Fox -7.5- Great goal, another who grew massively as the game progressed
Gudmundsson -8.5- It is scary to think where we'd be without this man
Ba -7- Moments of Brilliance with some sloppy touches, think he will improve on this performance though, also very strong.
Kashi - 8- Expected him to play the CDM role but was absolutely everywhere, Strong, Calm and a decent passer, the heart of Midfield.
Cousins - 7- Put in a shift on the left exactly like Luzon wanted, when we stuck him in CM for the last 15-20 he showed how effective he is.
Ahearne-Grant -6- Needs some football, A lot of potential but still very Raw. he's unlcuky in the sense that a lot see him as the next "Gomez."
Makienok - 6- Won some headers, lost a fair few, actually looked better with the ball at his feet, confused me as a player.
Watt - 7.5 - Typical Watt performance, tricky, sometimes annoying but overall a very classy player. His ability to take the ball round players is incredible.
Berditch N/a
Ceballos n/a
Solly - 8
Bauer - 8
Diarra - 8
Fox - 7.5
Gudmundsson - 8
Ba - 6
Kashi - 9 mom
Cousins - 7.5
Ahearne-Grant - 5
Makienok - 8
Watt - 7.5
Berditch N/a
Ceballos n/a
Solly - 8
Bauer - 8
Diarra - 7
Fox - 7.5
Gudmundsson - 8
Ba - 6
Kashi - 8.5
Cousins - 7
Ahearne-Grant - 6
Makienok - 6
Watt - 8
Solly - 7 got stuck in with 'crazy arms' Mackie
Bauer - 7.5 proper defending, get it out and away, but can pass too
Diarra - 7 Barely missed a header, miskicked a couple of times
Fox - 8 kept the winger quiet, well taken goal
Gudmundsson - 7.5 cracking effort for the free kick, got things going when we were lacking in the first half
Ba - 7 jittery and caught in possession first half, grew into the game
Kashi - 9 MOM everywhere
Cousins - 7 kept drifting in from the left, was getting frustrated and didn't influence the game as much as he can, but he was in the wrong position
Ahearne-Grant - 6 inexperience and youthful exuberance meant he kept dropping too deep, which was Makienok's job. Needs to work on his positioning in relationship to others
Makienok - 7 not going to score a lot of goals but harrasses defenders well and will wind a lot of people up. Needs to win more headers given his size
Watt - 8 changed the pace of the game when he came on, good goal and worries defenders with his running
Berditch N/a
Ceballos n/a
Solly - 8.5
Bauer - 9 Mom
Diarra - 7.5
Fox - 7
Gudmundsson - 7.5
Ba - 7
Kashi - 8
Cousins - 7.5
Ahearne-Grant - 5
Makienok - 7.5
Watt - 8
Solly - 7.5
Bauer - 8 - strong and solid, row z defender
Diarra - 7.5
Fox - 7 - a few shaky moments, great strike for the goal
Gudmundsson - 7 - superb free kick, some threatening moments
Ba - 7
Kashi - 9 - superb, kishishev mk. 2?
Cousins - 8
Ahearne-Grant - 5.5 - just looked out of his depth
Makienok - 7.5 - great defensively
Watt - 9 - so exciting when he gets on the ball
Solly 8
Bauer 7.5
Diarra 7.5
Fox 6 1st half 8 2nd half
Gudmundsson 7
Ba 6
Kashi 8.5
Cousins 6.5
Ahearn Grant 5.5
Makienok 7.5
Watt 8
Solly - 7 Solid as usual.
Bauer - 8 Very impressed, looked solid.
Diarra - 7 Did well other than a miss kick and a mix up towards the end.
Fox - 7 Seems to have been taken tips on how to defend from Solly. Best I've seen him play.
Gudmundsson - 7.5 Classy payer.
Ba - 6.5 Disappointing first half but improved in the second half.
Kashi - 7.5 Like the look of this lad. Looked aggressive and got stuck in.
Cousins - 7 Not ideal having him on the left but he got involved. Have Fox good support.
Ahearne-Grant - 5.5 Not his fault, he's just not ready yet, Didn't get a sniff.
Makienok - 6.5 Not effective in the first half but looked much better with Watt alongside him.
Watt - 8.5 Changed the game completely. Wouldn't have won it without him. As soon as he scored it gave everyone a lift and a bit of a confidence boost.
Solly - 7.5
Bauer - 8
Diarra - 8
Fox - 8
Gudmundsson - 8
Ba - 6
Kashi - 8
Cousins - 8
Ahearne-Grant - 6
Makienok - 7.5
Watt - 7.5
Berditch N/a
Ceballos n/a
Solly - 7; juuuuuuust about coped with Mackie (who I'd LOVE at Charlton cos he's a right little shite, if that makes sense)
Bauer - 7.5; like Michael Morrison but better.
Diarra - 7.5; really surprised me. Didn't think he was any good pre-season but he's proved me very wrong today.
Fox - 7.5; solid and a good goal.
Gudmundsson - 7; didn't do too much - great free kick and always looked like a threat. Like his interplay with others.
Ba - 6.5; looked a little behind because - confusingly - he was always looking for the next pass, making him slightly out of step with what was actually going on. Moves WAY too slowly for my liking.
Kashi - 8; solid. Kashishev as I will now dub him absolutely smashed it. Really good performance - works hard, passes quickly, makes decisions quickly. If only he was technically sound (hence Kish comparisons I suppose)...
Cousins - 7; worked his balls off and passed well. Don't like him on the wing though, mitigating his effectiveness.
Ahearne-Grant - 6; only started apparently because Watt had a bit of an incident... Didn't quite look ready. But he will be one day and he will absolutely tear the opposition to shreds in time.
Makienok - 7; great defensively but attack-wise still leaves stuff to be desired - and we did sign him as a striker. Decent linkup with Watt.
Watt - 8; took his goal well and looks like such a threat with the dribble. So excited to see what he'll be like this season.
Bergdich N/A
Ceballos N/A
MOM goes to Kashi though - just.
Solly - 7.5
Bauer - 8
Diarra - 7.5
Fox - 7.5
Gudmundsson - 7.5
Ba - 7.5
Kashi - 8.5
Cousins - 7.5
Ahearne-Grant - 6.5
Makienok - 7.5
Watt - 8
Bergdich - 7.5
Ceballos - n/a
Solly - 8.5
Bauer - 8
Diarra - 8
Fox - 8
Gudmundsson - 7.5
Ba - 6
Kashi - 8
Cousins - 8
Ahearne-Grant - 6
Makienok - 7
Watt - 7.5
Solly - 7
Bauer - 7.5
Diarra - 7
Fox - 8
Gudmundsson - 8.5
Ba - 7
Kashi - 9
Cousins - 8
Ahearne-Grant - 6
Makienok - 7
Watt - 8.5
Berditch N/a
Ceballos n/a
Solly - 7
Bauer - 8
Diarra - 7.5
Fox - 7.5
Gudmundson - 7
Ba - 7
Kashi - 8.5
Cousins - 7
Ahearne-Grant - 5.5
Makienok - 7.5
Watt - 8
Pope - 8
Solly - 6
Bauer - 8
Diarra - 7
Fox - 7
Gudmundsson - 7
Ba - 6
Kashi - 9
Cousins - 7
Ahearne-Grant - 6
Makienok - 7
Watt - 8
Berditch N/a
Ceballos n/a
Solly 7
Fox 7.5
Bauer 7
Diarra 7.5
Gudmunddson 8
Ba 7
Kashi 8.5
Cousins 6.5
Ahearnegrant 6
Makienok 7
Watt 8
Solly - 8
Bauer - 8.5
Diarra - 8
Fox - 8
Gudmundsson - 8
Ba - 8
Kashi - 9
Cousins - 7.5
Ahearne-Grant - 6.5
Makienok - 7
Watt - 8
Solly - 7.5
Bauer - 7.5 confident in him already
Diarra - 7.5
Fox - 7.5
Gudmundsson - 7.5
Ba - 7
Kashi - 8 everywhere
Cousins - 7.5
Ahearne-Grant - 6 not much to do
Makienok - 7
Watt - 7.5 game changer
Berditch N/a
Ceballos n/a
Solly - 7.5
Bauer - 7.5
Diarra - 7.5
Fox - 7
Gudmundsson - 7.5
Ba - 6
Kashi - 9
Cousins - 7
Ahearne-Grant - 5
Makienok - 6.5
Watt - 7
Pope - 8
Solly - 8
Bauer - 8.5
Diarra 9
Fox - 7.5
Gudmunddson 8
Ba -6.5
Kashi -9 mom
Cousins - 7.5
Ahearne-Grant -6
Makienok - 6.5
Watt -8
Berditch N/a
Ceballos n/a
Solly - 7.5
Bauer - 7.5
Diarra - 7
Fox - 7.5
Gudmundsson - 7.5
Ba - 7
Kashi - 8
Cousins - 8
Ahearne-Grant - 6.5
Makienok - 7
Watt - 8
Solly. 7.5
Bauer 8
Diarra 7.5
Fox. 7.5
Gudmundsson 7.5
Ba 7
Kashi 8
Cousins 7
Ahearne-Grant 6
Makienok. 7
Watt. 8
Solly - 7
Bauer - 8
Diarra - 7
Fox - 7
Gudmundsson - 7
Ba - 6
Kashi - 9
Cousins - 8
Ahearne-Grant - 6
Makienok - 6
Watt - 8
Solly - 7.5
Bauer - 8.5
Diarra - 7 could easily have been sent off for that extremely late challenge
Fox - 8.5
Gudmundsson - 8
Ba - 6.5
Kashi - 8.5
Cousins - 7
Ahearne-Grant - 6
Makienok - 6
Watt - 9 as others said, a game changer
Berditch n/a
Ceballos n/a