Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks- Charlton v BHA

13

Comments

  • Yeh lets all have a go and blame wilson
  • Etheridge 5
    Solly 6.5
    Wiggins 7
    Bikey 6.5
    Ben Haim 7
    Wilson 3
    Gudmundsson 6
    Jackson 5
    Cousins 8
    Tucudean 4
    Vetokele 5

    Gomez 6
    Watt 7
    Church 6
  • Etheridge 5.5 - Having a good enough game till the goal, then came the poor kicks.
    Solly 6.5 - Had a blunt first half, but good enough in the middle
    Wiggins 6 - Bit rusty but we have missed him, his rusty game was better than most others attempts to cover him.
    Bikey 5.5 - Looked too immobile for me today.
    Ben Haim 7.5 - Cut above the rest
    Wilson 2.5 - No defending, no desire, no control, no passing, no attacking, no excuse he was absolute toilet.
    Gudmundsson 5.5 - Wingers blow hot and cold, he was cool today.
    Jackson 5 - Not enough for me in the first half.
    Cousins 7 - Best performance I have seen in a long time from him, much better in passing, tackling and competing in general.
    Tucudean 4 - What did he do?
    Vetokele 5 - Few good turns to get away from players, but is now looking clumsy when he needs to look lethal.

    Gomez 7 - Fine performance by the young man, didn't put a foot wrong and offered more than both Solly and Wilson did down the right hand side.
    Watt 7 - A bit more match fitness and chemistry with his team mates and he can hopefully solve problems.
    Church 5.5 - Same old Church, most his runs were closing down the keeper.


  • Etheridge 4 woeful kicking does my head in . As for goal .
    Solly 6
    Wiggins 8
    Bikey 5
    Ben Haim 6
    Wilson 5
    Gudmundsson 6
    Jackson 5
    Cousins 7
    Tucudean 4
    Vetokele 6

    Gomez 6
    Watt 7
    Church 4
  • edited January 2015
    Etherise - 5 Almost nothing to do but still managed to look iffy.
    Solly - 6 Poor 1st half but improved when he went into midfield. Good shot against the bar.
    Wiggins - 6 Did ok. Hope his foot is ok.
    Bikey - 5.5 Couple of good tackles but can't head.
    Ben Haim - 6 Almost nothing to do.
    Wilson - 3 Ought to be embarrassed. Couldn't have been weaker.
    Gudmundsson - 5 Doesn't want to put his foot in at all. Needs to work harder.
    Jackson - 4 Stayed in formation but looked a passenger.
    Cousins - 6 Tried hard and at least won a few headers.
    Tucudean - 4 One blocked shot but second to the ball.
    Vetokele - 5 Won a few headers 2nd half but the miss against Cardiff seems to have knocked the bollocks out of him.

    Gomez - 6 Did ok. Good on the ball but not so good off it. Did he lose the man for their goal?
    Watt - 6.5 Showed good speed and intent. Should have cut back to unmarked Vetokele after surge into box. Lively debut.
    Church - 5.5 Plenty of effort but no guile.
  • Etheridge 5
    Solly 7
    Wiggins 5.5
    Bikey 5
    Ben haim 6.5
    Wilson 4
    Gudmunsson 5.5
    Jackson 4.5
    Cousins 6
    Tucudean 4.5
    Vetokele 5

    Gomez 6
    Watt 6
    Church 5
  • Etheridge - 5 and not just for the goal. L1 reserve keeper.
    Solly - 7 starting to look ok in middle
    Wiggins - 6.5 rusty but dependable
    Bikey - 6 sloppy again
    Ben Haim - 7.5 class act and cares
    Wilson - 4 was a supporter but poor
    Gudmundsson - 6 rubbish corners should only take from right
    Jackson - 4 past it
    Cousins - 6.5 energised and better with Watt as an outlet
    Tucudean - 5 needs a loan in L1
    Vetokele - 6 hard to criticise since playing through injury

    Gomez - 6.5 đeserves a run of games
    Watt - 7 good cameo. Looks dangerous
    Church - 5 why? Why upfront not on right
  • Etheridge 5 lost the cross for the goal and kicking was iffy
    Solly 6 improved 2nd half
    Wiggins 6.5 good to have him back
    Bikey 5.5 lapsidaisical at times
    Ben Haim 6 looking increasingly frustrated
    Wilson 3 he's now shite again!
    Gudmundsson 5 looks so much better on the right
    Jackson 2.5 becoming embarrassing
    Cousins 7 tried and made fewer errors than his team mates
    Tucudean 3.5 has the teflon touch
    Vetokele 5 so lacking confidence

    Gomez 6 composed
    Watt 7 glimpses of hope for us
    Church 4.5 ran around ineffectively as per usual
  • Etheridge 5
    Solly 7
    Wiggins 6
    Bikey 6
    Ben Haim 8
    Wilson 4
    Gudmundsson 5
    Jackson 5
    Cousins 7
    Tucudean 6
    Vetokele 6

    Gomez 7
    Watt 7
    Church 7
  • Etheridge 4
    Solly 7
    Wiggins 7
    Bikey 5
    Ben Haim 8
    Wilson 2
    Gudmundsson 4
    Jackson 4
    Cousins 6
    Tucudean 2
    Vetokele 5
    Gomez 7
    Watt 7
    Church 6
  • Sponsored links:


  • edited January 2015


    Wilson 2. I like the guy but this was one of the worst performances I have ever seen in a charlton shirt. Hiding. Confidence shot. Doesn't want to be here. Hope not to see him again. Thanks and Cheerio. One point for getting his pony tail sorted, the other for putting his boots on the correct feet.

    LOL!
  • Etheridge - 5
    Solly - 6.5
    Wiggins - 6
    Bikey - 6
    Ben Haim - 7
    Wilson - 3
    Gudmundsson - 5
    Jackson - 4.5
    Cousins - 6
    Tucudean - 4
    Vetokele - 5.5

    Gomez - 6.5
    Watt - 7
    Church - 6
  • Etheridge - 4 (absolutely incredible that anyone could mark him above 5 for that performance)
    Solly - 6.5
    Wiggins - 6
    Bikey - 5
    Ben Haim - 6
    Wilson - 4
    Gudmundsson - 6
    Jackson - 5
    Cousins - 6
    Tucudean - 4
    Vetokele - 5

    Gomez - 6
    Watt - 6.5 (looked shell-shocked at the end. Must be wondering what the hell has happened to his career)
    Church - 5

    Absolutely incredible that anyone could mark him above 4 for that performance.
  • Etheridge 6 Probably at fault for the goal, but produced a good save when Brighton were through one on one.
    Solly 7 Excellent shot on goal but not really a midfield player
    Wiggins 6 Good to see him back. Fairly solid without being outstanding
    Bikey 6 Another solid performance
    Ben Haim 7 Showed some real class
    Wilson 4 Back to the Wilson of old - shite!
    Gudmundsson 6 Battled but made little impression
    Jackson 6 Good chance from a corner and reasonable performance
    Cousins 6 given that he was back in his preferred position, I expected more. Average performance
    Tucudean 4 Why is this "waste of space" in the side?
    Vetokele 6 Well shackled with few opportunities

    Gomez 6 Looked more comfortable at home rather than when I saw him at Ipswich
    Watt 6 Looks promising. Wasted a good chance by not passing shortly after he came on
    Church 6 An improvement. Linked in well.

    Our lack of goals will be our downfall. We defend quite well but unless we start scoring we'll be in big trouble.
  • Etheridge - 4.5
    Solly - 7
    Wiggins - 7
    Bikey - 6
    Ben Haim - 7
    Wilson - 1
    Gudmundsson - 5
    Jackson - 3
    Cousins - 6
    Tucudean - 4
    Vetokele - 6

    Gomez - 6.5
    Watt - 7
    Church - 6
  • Etheridge 5
    Solly 8
    Wiggins 7
    Bikey 5
    Ben Haim 7
    Wilson 4
    Gudmundsson 5
    Jackson 4
    Cousins 6.5
    Tucudean 4
    Vetokele 5

    Gomez 7
    Watt 7
    Church 6.5
  • Etheridge - 4 (absolutely incredible that anyone could mark him above 5 for that performance)
    Solly - 6.5
    Wiggins - 6
    Bikey - 5
    Ben Haim - 6
    Wilson - 4
    Gudmundsson - 6
    Jackson - 5
    Cousins - 6
    Tucudean - 4
    Vetokele - 5

    Gomez - 6
    Watt - 6.5 (looked shell-shocked at the end. Must be wondering what the hell has happened to his career)
    Church - 5

    Absolutely incredible that anyone could mark him above 4 for that performance.
    Wilson was 3 points better than Jackson according to you.
  • Etheridge 5
    Solly 7.5
    Wiggins 6
    Bikey 7
    Ben Haim 7.5
    Wilson 4
    Gudmundsson 5
    Jackson 5
    Cousins 8
    Tucudean 4
    Vetokele 5

    Gomez 6
    Watt 7
    Church 6

  • Etheridge 5
    Solly 7
    Wiggins 6
    Bikey 5
    Ben Haim 6
    Wilson 5.5
    Gudmundsson 5.5
    Jackson 5.5
    Cousins 6.5
    Tucudean 5
    Vetokele 6

    Gomez 7
    Watt 6.5
    Church 6



  • Etheridge - 5.5 A real Curate's egg of a performance. A couple of fantastic saves, but some terrifying kicks, and a drop of a cross in the 1st half that nearly induced a heart attack.Partly at fault for the 22nd.

    Solly - 5.5 A few marks on here given through rose coloured spectacles. Absolutely terrible first half, the worst, I think, I have ever seen of him in his chosen position. Included letting a perfectly good pass bounce off him for a throw in. Better in the 2nd half, and unlucky not to score. Still not captain material.

    Wiggins - 5.5 Good to see him back. Not up to pace (obviously), but showed we do have a decent left back at the club. I was surprised he lasted the full 90 minutes. I hope we haven't risked him having a setback from his injury.

    Bikey - 6 Gave away a stupid free kick for the goal. Still looked strong, but lacking some of the intensity of early season. Bob, playing him up front REALLY doesn't work!

    Ben Haim - 7.5 MOTM Another top performance from our most consistent player. A fantastic last ditch tackle in the 2nd half. I find it disconcerting that the best passer we have at the club is not a midfielder, but a central defender. Bob, if Jacko isn't playing, give Tal the arm band?

    Wilson - 2 I like to think about marks for players, and not make snap decisions on player performances. I have thought long and hard about what Lawrie did right yesterday. I haven't been able to think of a single thing, so I have given him the same mark as his shirt number. Enough said!

    Gudmundsson - 5.5 Our most creative player, but needs to impose himself on the opposition more. Cast a forlorn figure sometimes. I felt sorry for him sometimes, as he was in acres of space in front of the East Stand in the 2nd half, only to see the ball launched into a mass of striped shirts. His body language at the end was truly awful.

    Jackson - 5.5 Not as bad as some think, especially as he was carrying a knock for most of the 1st half. Still the leader on the pitch, but seems to find it harder to get his battered body around the pitch. Must be worried watching the performance of Cousins in his absence.

    Cousins - 7 Gave our midfield a power and directness sadly lacking in the this poor run. Wholehearted and determined, gets forward well, and is probably the only midfielder who can win a header since the recall of Coquelin.

    Tucudean - 5.5 Plowed a lone furrow, with little help in the 1st half. Maybe, just maybe, he would look better if he got anything like some service. I hope his injury is not too bad, as it would be bad if we were to be short another striker.

    Vetokele - 6 Looks a shadow of the player who produced his early season performances. A poor first touch, and inability to bring others into the game. Even his lightning acceleration seems a thing of the past. However, battled on, and actually looked quite useful playing on the left. He looks short of confidence, but a goal might turn his season around.

    Gomez - 6.5 This kid is amazing. 17, but plays like a season pro. Has pace, and played without fear. Not faultless (he must take some responsibility for the goal), but is probably the future of the club. The new Richard Rufus?

    Watt - 6 A very promising cameo. Looks to have great ball control, and not frightened to take people on. Strong on the ball, too. Set up Solly for his shot. I didn't mind when he took on the keeper, as a bit of confidence/arrogance is good in a striker. And Igor probably would have missed. Also an edge to him that I like, shown by him pushing "the Beast" away in the closing minutes, when Bikey was arguing with the ref. How many of our places have looked willing to do that. Very promising.

    Church - 5.5 Another wholehearted display, without looking in any way dangerous. Somebody has to do the dirty work, and Churchy, at least, does not shirk from the responsibility.
  • Sponsored links:


  • Etheridge 5
    Solly 7
    Wiggins 7
    Bikey 7
    BenHaim 7.5
    Wilson 4
    Gudmundsson 5.5
    Jackson 5
    Cousins 7
    Tucudean 5.5
    Vetokele 5
    Gomez 7
    Watt 6.5
    Church 6
  • for those who saw the match today your marks please:

    Etheridge 5
    Solly 7
    Wiggins 7
    Bikey 6
    Ben Aim 8
    Wilson 3
    Gudmundson 5
    Jackson 4
    Cousins 7
    Tucudean 4
    Vetokele 6

    Gomez 7
    Watt 7
    Church 5
  • Etheridge - 4 one good save from Forster-Caskey. Appalling for the goal and watching again this morning, seems to actually pull his hand away at the end.

    Solly - 5 wonderful shot against the bar & relatively solid. Low mark because I am frustrated at knowing what he will do every time now. A little run down the sideline, stop, turn and pass backwards.

    Wiggins - 4 a couple of decent forages forward, but that was all.
    Bikey - 4 poor effort, misplaced passes, hopefully he'll be awake again next week
    Ben Haim - 7 best of the starting 11. Could see his frustration at his teammates several times

    Wilson - 3.5 I like Lawrie a lot, but that was a dreadful performance
    Gudmundsson - 4.5 needs to be on the right or sitting behind the forwards. Better than this

    Jackson - 5 one good chance off the line. Whilst he didn't get chance to do much else, his absence in 2nd half really shows the leadership he brings when he is there.

    Cousins - 5 a couple of errors, but otherwise OK. Just nothing extra.
    Tucudean - 3.5 awful and his failed attempts at fouling the opposition are laughable/painful* (*delete depending on mood)
    Vetokele - 5 needs a goal quickly. Leaps well for some good headers and flick-one but nothing coming off for him

    Gomez - 6 decent shift in 2nd half
    Watt - 7.5 showed some great touches, trickery & turn of speed. Obviously wants to shoot (sad how that isn't obvious for a number of others) and a decent passer too. One positive from yesterday.
    Church - 6.5 did what he does. Honest. Worked hard, chased down but no real chances for him.

    Tactics - 3 so many backward passes, so frustrating. No urgency from any player until Watt & Church came on. Brighton, although with a couple of recent good results, have been poor and needed to be pressured from the off. We just don't start til the 2nd half and even then only when we went behind.
  • Etheridge - 6
    Solly. 6.5
    Wiggins. 5.5
    Bikey - 6.5
    Ben Haim - 7.5
    Wilson - 5
    Gudmundsson - 6
    Jackson - 5
    Cousins 7.5
    Tucudean - 5
    Vetokele - 6

    Gomez - 7
    Watt - 7
    Church 7
  • Etheridge 4
    Solly 8
    Wiggins 6
    Bikey 6
    Ben Haim 7
    Wilson 1
    Gudmundsson 6
    Jackson 2
    Cousins 6
    Tucudean 1
    Vetokele 4

    Gomez 7
    Watt 7
    Church 6
  • Etheridge----5.5
    Solly-----7.5------------did well as a stop gap midfielder, cant be the answer
    Wiggins---6-----surprised he was in the starting 11, not fit
    Bikey----6
    Ben Haim---7
    Wilson----4--------o dear !----not interested at all
    Gudmenson---5.5----lost on the wing and lack of effort
    Jackson------5---lost
    Cousins----7---much better in the centre
    Tucadean----4.5---no thanks
    Vetokele----5----totaly Charltonised

    Gomez---6
    Watt----7----lets hope he lasts awhile before we feck him up
    Church---6.5---looked interested and deserves to be ahead of George
  • Etheridge 5
    Solly 6.5
    Wiggins 6
    Bikey 5.5
    Ben Haim 7
    Wilson 4
    Gudmundsson 6
    Jackson 4
    Cousins 5.5
    Tucudean 5
    Vetokele 5.5

    Gomez 6.5
    Watt 6.5
    Church 6

  • Etheridge 5 - at fault with goal
    Solly - 7 Played well in the middle and moved the ball nearly as good as any of our midfields can.
    Wiggins 6 - struggled in first half but became an attacking threat in the second.
    Bikey 6 - he played ok apart from the nonsense of him being Peeters Plan B when things arnt going right stick him up top.
    Ben Haim 6.5 - also slightly at fault for goal but it should of been the goalies.
    Wilson 3- worst game he has ever played.
    Gudmundsson 6 - did some neat stuff. wish he would switch wings every now and then to use his left foot to cross from the by line.
    Jackson 5 - played ok until injury set in after half an hour. then looked out of it till he came off at half time.
    Cousins 7 - keep him in the middle, he has more room to move the ball around.
    Tucudean 3 - another poor display.
    Vetokele 4 - slightly better than George only cos he has more pace. poor game.

    Gomez 7 - played really well when he came on.
    Watt 6 - looks good. strong and skilful. hope he is as good at the goal scoring. time will tell.
    Church 5 - rang around. slightly better that George and igor.
  • Etheridge 4
    Solly 6
    Wiggins 6
    Bikey 5
    Ben Haim 6.5
    Wilson 4
    Gudmundsson 6
    Jackson 5
    Cousins 7
    Tucudean 4
    Vetokele 5

    Gomez 7
    Watt 7
    Church 5.5
  • In his report in todays Times, Brian Glanville gave Etheridge 7 and every one of our others 6. Was he actually there?
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!