Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Player Marks - Charlton v Cardiff

2

Comments

  • Etheridge 7
    Solly. 8
    Gomez 6
    Bikey. 7
    Ben Haim 7.5
    Gudmundsson 8.5
    Buyens. 8
    Jackson. 7
    Cousins. 7
    Harriott. 5
    Tucudean. 8

    Onyewu. 7
    Vetokele. 7
  • Etheridge 7 Grew in confidence
    Solly - 7.5
    Gomez - 4.5
    Bikey - 6 Very ropey until the last 30 mins where he became a different player
    Ben Haim - 7
    Gudmundsson - 7.5 Plays when he can be bothered. Fantastic goal.
    Buyens - 5 Some good passes, and always available, but a liability being caught in posession so many times in dangerous areas. SO SLOW. Actually reminds me of Semedo. That's not a good thing.
    Jackson - 6.5
    Cousins - 6.5 Constantly thwarted both in the air and on the ground by the Cardiff full-back, albeit half the time illegally. Always a threat though.
    Harriott - 6.5 For until the red card. Couldn't see what happened properly.
    Tucudean - 8 Constant battling and great set-ups/lay-offs etc.

    Onyewu - 7
    Vetokele - 5 Can't imagine Covered End singing George's name at the end if he'd missed THAT.

    Ref - N/A There's shit reffing and there's blatant cheating/attention seeking. Should be suspended for that performance.
  • Etheridge 7
    Solly 8
    Gomez 5
    Bikey 7
    Ben Haim 8
    Gudmundsson 8
    Buyens 7
    Jackson 5
    Cousins 4
    Harriet 4
  • Tucudean 8

    Onyewu 6
    Vetokele 7
  • Sorry wrong button pushing!!!
  • Etheridge 7
    Solly 7
    Gomez 7
    Bikey 6
    Ben Haim 7.5
    Gudmundsson 8
    Buyens 5
    Jackson 5
    Cousins 5
    Harriott 3
    Tucudean 7

    Onyewu 7
    Vetokele 6
  • Etheridge 7
    Solly 7
    Gomez 5
    Bikey 7
    Ben Haim 7.5
    Gudmundsson 8
    Buyens 7.5
    Jackson 5
    Cousins 7.5
    Harriet 3. Twit.

    K. Jones for them made it 10 v 10. Obviously taken early retirement!

    I have not seen tactics from a team since we played Cambridge Utd. From the kick off it was sent long to the corner. Long throw in. I would rather watch us lose than watch that.

    Superb come back we deserved to win.
  • Etheridge - 8
    Solly - 7
    Gomez - 7
    Bikey - 7
    Ben Haim - 7
    Gudmundsson - 7
    Buyens - 7
    Jackson - 6
    Cousins - 7
    Harriott - 5
    Tucudean - 8

    Onywu - 7
    Vetokele - 6
  • K. Jones for them made it 10 v 10. Obviously taken early retirement!

    He was excellent, played well, supported the team all over the pitch, and one of the few Cardiff players that did not try to time waste or cheat.
  • Surprised by how many low marks Tucadean is getting
  • Sponsored links:


  • For those who saw the match today your marks please:

    Etheridge - 7.5 Superb catching and punching. Very positive.
    Solly - 7.5 Good second half.
    Gomez - 5.5 Did his best but no left foot. Nowhere near strong enough in the air to be a 1st XI centre back so right back or midfield could be his thing.
    Bikey - 8 Much better fom him today. Got off the ground for his headers and used the ball well.
    Ben Haim - 9 Masterclass from a very talented player. Wish we had two of him...one to play at the back and the other to play in midfield.
    Gudmundsson - 7.5 Woeful 1st half but excellent in the 2nd. A player of his ability should get 10 goals a season.
    Buyens - 7.5 Nice to see him get forward because he has much to offer.
    Jackson - 5 Not in it.
    Cousins - 6.5 Stuck at it.
    Harriott - 5 Tried but so one footed. Nasty challenge for the red.
    Tucudean - 8 Tried hard and was still going at the end. Deserved a goal for his efforts and played some great balls round the corner for runners. So unlucky with the back heel cleared off the line.

    Onyewu - 7 Bit rusty (to be expected) but did the job well.
    Vetokele - 7 Looked bright and creative but can't finish one on ones. That's a real weakness and will stop him making the step up if he doesn't sort it.
  • Etheridge 7 solid dominated at crosses etc
    Solly 7 same old solly
    Gomez 7
    Bikey 7
    Ben Haim 7
    Gudmundsson 8 - reall took game to Cardiff and stunning g goal
    Buyens 6 - like buyens by slows game down too much sometimes
    Jackson 6 - off pace today
    Cousins 7
    Harriott 0- stupid tackle
    Tucudean -9 best game in a charlton shirt by a country mile was outstanding today

    Onyewu 6
    Vetokele 6 shocking miss
  • edited December 2014
    1StevieG said:


    Tucudean - 8 Beautiful dummy to let Igor in. Shame he couldn't score.

    .

    Think the ball was played by Tucadean and dummied by Buyens (?)
  • Bedsaddick.please explain your outrageously low score for the magnificent Ben Haim
  • Simonsen said:

    1StevieG said:


    Tucudean - 8 Beautiful dummy to let Igor in. Shame he couldn't score.

    .

    Think the ball was played by Tucadean and dummied by Buyens (?)
    If so then a beautiful pass by Tuc and nice swerve by Buyens!

  • Etheridge 7
    Solly 8
    Gomez 7
    Bikey 7
    Ben Haim 8
    Gudmundsson 8.5 MoM
    Buyens 7
    Jackson 5
    Cousins 7
    Harriott 4 (Idiot)
    Tucudean 7

    Onyewu 7
    Vetokele 6
  • edited December 2014

    For those who saw the match today your marks please:

    Etheridge 7.5. Commanded his box well
    Solly 8.5. Just excellent, would love to see him in our team in the PL
    Gomez 6. Decent but not at his best
    Bikey 7. Looks slow but did ok and one great cross field ball to JBG
    Ben Haim 7.5. Some nice touches
    Gudmundson 8.5 Bad first half, superb second. Unlucky to only get one goal, but what a goal it was
    Buyens 5. Light weight, can't tackle and 2 dreadful balls across the defence both intercepted.
    Jackson 6. Did ok in first game back
    Cousins 7. Clocks up the miles, excellent attitude
    Harriott 4. Looked poor then sent off for rash challenge
    Tucudean 9. MOM. Play like this each week and he would be in the side all the time, showed heart and ability.

    Onyewu 7. Looked like good back up
    Vetokele 5.5. Tried hard, but bought on to score. Had his chance and fluffed it.

  • Etheridge 8
    Solly 7
    Gomez 6.5
    Bikey 6
    Ben Haim 7.5
    Gudmundsson 9 Mom
    Buyens 7.5
    Jackson 6.5
    Cousins 7
    Harriott 5
    Tucudean 7.5

    Onyewu 6
    Vetokele 6.5
  • Etheridge 7.0
    Solly 7.0
    Gomez 6.0
    Bikey 7.0
    Ben Haim 7.5
    Gudmundsson 7.5
    Buyens 7.0
    Jackson 6.0
    Cousins 6.0
    Harriott 4.0
    Tucudean 8.0 - MOM

    Onyewu - 6.5
    Vetokele - 6.0
  • Etheridge 7.5 done well and knows how to catch a ball
    Solly 7 played well
    Gomez 6.5 struggled on the left at times thought it would have been better to player solly at left back as he has more experience.
    Bikey 6.5 solid
    Ben Haim 7 very good player.
    Gudmundsson 7 worked hard and a cracker of a goal.
    Buyens 7 such a good player when we actually attack. Not so good when on the back foot.
    Jackson 5 better when he went off. Maybe not fully fit.
    Cousins 6.5 done well but too predictable having to cut inside all the time.
    Harriott 2.5 looked crap not a striker.
    Tucudean 6.5 There is a very good player dying to get out of him but at the same time there is a really crap one too.

    Onyewu 6.5 done well
    Vetokele 6.5 looked a better team with him on. Shocking miss but was devestated. Shows he cares.
  • Sponsored links:


  • Etheridge 7 - commanded his box well
    Solly 7 - generally solid
    Gomez 6 - out of position
    Bikey 7 - seems to be in a dip of form of late but still solid enough
    Ben Haim 8 - brilliant bringing the ball out from the back
    Gudmundsson 8.5 MOM - get a 6 for the 1st half and a 9 for the second half where we saw the very best of him, been saying for weeks his best was yet to come including his screamer today. Extra mark for the goal
    Buyens 8 - keeps play ticking over, so many accurate passes just seem to be taken for granted
    Jackson 5 - off the pace
    Cousins 6 - industrious as ever
    Harriott 4 - genuinely missed the red card incident
    Tucudean 8 - think we saw the best of George today, only needed a goal to earn a MOTM performance.

    Onyewu 6 - didn't notice him
    Vetokele 6 - a shame he missed that chance but worked hard to get himself in that position in the 1st place
  • Etheridge 7.5
    Solly 8.5
    Gomez 6
    Bikey 7.5
    Ben Haim 8.5
    Gudmundsson 9
    Buyens 9
    Jackson 6
    Cousins 6.5
    Harriott 4
    Tucudean 8.5

    Onyewu 7
    Vetokele 7
  • Etheridge - 7. Looked good. Quick distribution. We've been crying out for that. Good on crosses.

    Solly - 8. Great performance. Especially as a winger second half.

    Gomez - 4. Poor today. Class act in the making and out of position but naïveté showed. He'll have better days.

    Bikey - 7. Crap first half. Inspirational second.

    Ben Haim - 9 mom

    Gudmundsson - 8. Absolutely stole a living in the first half. Negative and couldn't be arsed. Absolutely brilliant second half. Couldn't believe it was the same player. Goal of he season. Please do this all the time!!!!!!

    Buyens - 4. Poor all game. Kept playing backwards. Wayward passes would have cost us against a team that actually wanted to win the game unlike Cardiff who were a disgrace.

    Jackson - 4. Didn't know he was playing

    Cousins - 5. Gets all five for effort. Piss poor but not his fault. He's not a left.......oh FFS I give up.

    Harriott - 2. Brainless twat. Two points for puting his shirt on the right way round.

    Tucudean - 7. Not convinced he has a clue what he's doing but bust his buns all day and was unlucky not to score. Never seems to do the obvious but we liked dangerous today when he got involved.

    Onyewu - 5. Carthorse but did some good things. I suspect if we have to start him we will be stuffed.

    Vetokele 4. Sorry, harsh, but he had one job to do and he fcuked it up. Again!!!!!

    You do live up to your username don't you - 4 for Buyens, that's got to be a joke ffs!
  • Etheridge 7
    Solly 7
    Gomez 7
    Bikey 7
    Ben Haim 8.5
    Gudmundsson 7
    Buyens 7
    Jackson 6.5
    Cousins 6.5
    Harriott 5
    Tucudean 7

    Onyewu 7
    Vetokele 6.5

  • Etheridge 7
    Solly 7.5
    Gomez 7
    Bikey 7
    Ben Haim 8
    Gudmundsson 8
    Buyens 7
    Jackson 6
    Cousins 5
    Harriott 4
    Tucudean 7
    Onyewu 7
    Vetokele 7
  • Etheridge 7 distribution was good
    Solly 7.5
    Gomez 6.5
    Bikey 6.5 5.5 for 1st half 7.5 2nd half
    Ben Haim 8.5
    Gudmundsson 7.5 extra mark for the goal
    Buyens 7.5
    Jackson 6.5
    Cousins 6.5 not his best game
    Harriott 5
    Tucudean 7.5

    Onyewu 7
    Vetokele 7
  • Etheridge - 7 Nothing to do, kicking, catching decent.
    Solly - 7 Decent game, crossing not his best today.
    Gomez - 6.5 Not as good as I've seen him play, ball control not great.
    Bikey - 7.5 Solid, won the physical battle with Jones.
    Ben Ham - 9 MOM. Best attacker of the first half and a lot of the second. Brilliant.
    Gudmundsson - 8 First half subdued, second half awesome.
    Buyens - 7.5 tackled and worked really hard, passing was good as well.
    Jackson - 6 Just back and off the pace a touch.
    Cousins - 6 lacking confidence out of position? control of the ball has been poor recently and was bullied off the ball today.
    Harriot- 4 Nothing great in a poor first 30 min team performance. Gave the ref the chance he wanted to give Cardiff an advantage.
    Tucudean - 8 All over the pitch, in a good way. Unlucky not to score. Great performance.

    Onyewu 7 - Pace not his game, strength and passing ability is. Too strong for Cardiff who resorted to falling over.
    Vetokele - 6.5 Made a difference, but hard to forget the miss at the end. I was already celebrating, easy chance for someone of his quality.

    Ref - WTF!!
  • Etheridge 8 when he tried to pretend to throw the ball out and made himself look like an ass... I though it would be one of those days. Second half his distribution was brilliant. First half too slow but very promising.

    Solly 8 first half one of the better players. Second half he showed his quality and that's why he's a right back. Looks good when at the wing back role.

    Gomez 5 not a left back. He's too one footed. He's strong but gt caught out a few times.

    Bikey 7 first half he had some stupid moments. Real amateur stuff - second half he was a lot better. 3 at the back suited him well.

    Ben Haim 7 as above

    Gudmundsson 8 like all the others, first half he was shocking. Second half he was a constant danger and that goal was brilliant.

    Buyens 7.5 his link up play was very good and so was his tackling.

    Jackson 5.5 things were better when he was taken off! There was more energy in the middle of the park but I put it down to fatigue as he's just come back from injury.

    Cousins 6.5 looked good in the wing back role. Some moments of quality and other moments of crap. Kept battling though. Looked knackered at the end. He's an engine.

    Harriott 4 before the sending off he was on a par with the rest of the team. Tye tackle was high and he gave the ref a decision to make when he was already giving everything against us. Playing with 10 for so long could have an effect on the days to come.

    Tucudean 8.5 MOM before Vetokele came on he was the only player who I felt would make something happen. Igor came on and the link up play between them was brilliant. He brings others into the game and it goes unrecognised. He was tracking back in the first half and defended well too. Unlucky not too score today on a few occasions.

    Onyewu 7 solid at the back. He gave Bikey and Ben Haim the freedom to push higher up.

    Vetokele 7 links up well with George. Looked a threat today. Should've won the game for is though.


    In the first half I said to my mate "the refs been poor but we've been worse. We can't use him as an excuse"

    I tbought he was shocking today.
  • Etheridge - 6.5 A decent debut. Commanding and vocal, and was decisive when coming out for the ball. Kept the tempo high with his distribution when we had them under the cosh.

    Solly - 6.5 Did exactly what it said on the tin. A classic "Solly" display. Solid defensively, and a threat going forward.

    Gomez - 5.5 A fantastic player, being played out of position. In the first half, we had 2 young players playing on left, both of which who are right footed. Looked uncomfortable, and a dilemma for Big Bob.

    Bikey - 6.5 A few cracking cross field passes in the 1st half, and the usual mad 5 minutes. Looked comfortable in a 3 man defence.

    Ben Haim - 8.5 MOTM. An outstanding display. Led the charge from the back, with some outstanding runs. His ability to find players with a pass is excellent. Loved when he picked up the ball after the goal, placed it on the centre spot, and turned to the East Stand to gee the fans up.

    Gudmundsson - 8 Truly awesome performance in the 2nd half. It seemed like there were 2 of him on the pitch. A brilliant goal, all of his own making.

    Buyens - 7 Played everywhere. Covered in defence when the big men bombed forward. Kept the tempo high when we were dominating the game. Tight accurate passing.

    Jackson - 5.5 A little off the pace, after his injury, but showed his leadership. No dead balls, presumably to protect his injury(s). Lasted longer than I thought.

    Cousins - 6 A typical Jordan performance. Full of drive and energy. Not everything comes off for him, but never hides.

    Harriott - 2 I don't usually mark this low, but I thought he was woeful. Gave the ball away time after time, and then tried to foul the person he'd just given the ball to. Made it easy for the "referee" to brandish a red card. Let us, and his team mates down badly.

    Tucudean - 8 I knew there was a good player in there, and he showed it. Some of his touches, and link up play were excellent. Deserved a goal, but was denied by a cynical rugby tackle. Never stopped working.

    Onyewu - 6.5 Looked composed on the ball, and his long throws are a bonus. Can we sign him for longer, please, Mr. Duchatalet?

    Vetokele - 6 Looked much brighter for not having started. Was devastated after the miss. It was great to see all the players going to console him. Well done the fans, too, for not getting on his back and encouraging him.


    Hi Bob - 8 I wasn't happy with the way that he set the team up at the start, but timely, and aggressive substitutions swung the game. Whatever his half time team talk was, he should bottle it. It was difficult to believe they were the same players.

  • Etheridge 7 decent game commanded box well and came when he could for the ball

    Solly 6.5 quiet first half drove forward second

    Gomez 5.5 fantastic talent but big ask to play him on the left. still better than fox

    Bikey 7 monster and a grafter

    Ben Haim 7.5 he loves playing for charlton and a rock today

    Gudmundsson 8 if he could perform like that for 90 minutes he'd be at a bigger club

    Buyens 6.5 unusually poor distribution but still a presence on the pitch

    Jackson 5 didn't know he turned up. Point off for the fact he didn't get in the refs face when he started unravelling. captains job to put teams case forward and should have been on him from the beginning!

    Cousins 7 linked with Gomez well in first half. Liked the fact he kept cutting in on his right to open a bit of space

    Harriott 3 what a bell end

    Tucudean 8 MOM work rate second to none yesterday and at least he has some imagination even if it doesn't always come off

    Onyewu 6 did the job when he came on. Throw in could be a weapon if team give him options to aim for

    Vetokele 6 has missed a few 1-on-1's this season. Has lost his way in recent weeks. Point added as he was as gutted as we were at the end.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!