Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Best 5 Charlton Centrebacks

harveys_gardenerharveys_gardener
in General Charlton
1. Costa
2. Rufus
3. Pates
4. Elliott
5. Went
«134

Comments

  • shootershill2tropicsshootershill2tropics
    what a great thread and starter call - i really cannot argue with that selection!
  • PeanutsMolloyPeanutsMolloy
    What, no Shirtliff?
  • shootershill2tropicsshootershill2tropics
    ok if it's top 6, then shirtliff should definitely be included!
  • paulie8290paulie8290
    edited June 2014
    Just for his consistency I would like to nominate Fortune to add to that list
  • AbsurdistanAbsurdistan
    Miguel Llera (to save Miss Piggy posting)
  • Valley11Valley11
    In no particular order - Webster, Rufus, Costa, Gatting, Brown

    Gatting may seem a strange one but always liked the way he was calm on the ball.
  • ChicagoAddickChicagoAddick
    That I have seen - Rufus, Elliott, Shirtliff, Webster, Costa.
  • shootershill2tropicsshootershill2tropics
    i have never seen mc carthy and liera play, apart from internet highlights, but even from across the atlantic they sounded accident prone and less than assured? surely they cannot compare with the blood n guts titans that started the thread?
  • AbsurdistanAbsurdistan
    Fish.
  • Sponsored links:


  • vancouverbcaddickvancouverbcaddick
    Derek Ufton
  • Man_About_TownMan_About_Town
    Hinton
  • HalixHalix
    Shirtliff
    Balmer
    Webster
    Costa
    Rufus (best!)
  • iaitchiaitch
    Chris Perry
  • boogicaboogica
    Steve thompson not the most gifted not as good as players mentioned but he would run through a brick wall for the cause.
  • dickplumbdickplumb
    Rufus, Went, Reeves, Elliott, Costa.
  • The Red RobinThe Red Robin
    edited June 2014
    I'll go on who I've seen in my lifetime:

    1.Costa
    2.Rufus
    3.Fish
    4.Perry
    5.Balmer
  • Red oneRed one
    paulie8290 said:

    Just for his consistency I would like to nominate Fortune to add to that list

    Behave
  • chester_conradchester_conrad
    edited June 2014
    Shirtliff
    Rufus
    Costa
    Webster
    Thompson
  • SimonsenSimonsen
    edited June 2014
    Shirtliff
    Costa
    Rufus
    Fish
    Pates

    Rufus and Pates would have been an excellent combination.
  • Sponsored links:


  • Amos on the wingAmos on the wing
    Shirtliff
    Rufus
    Costa
    Webster
    Fish


  • I-SAW-POUSO-PLAYI-SAW-POUSO-PLAY
    From my time supporting charlton

    Rufus
    Costa
    Fish (before his table accident in 2004)
    Youds
    Perry
  • HantsAddickHantsAddick
    Mine would be:

    Paul Went
    Peter Reeves
    Richard Rufus
    Stuart Balmer
    Paul Elliott

    Not in any particular order.
  • Pedro45Pedro45
    No Bobby Goldthorpe or Peter Shaw?
  • HantsAddickHantsAddick
    Pedro45 said:

    No Bobby Goldthorpe or Peter Shaw?

    Had forgotten those two. Can we have more than five?

  • RedChaserRedChaser
    edited June 2014
    Derek Ufton (full England international)
    Marvin Hinton (England U 23 international)
    Paul Elliott (England U21 international)
    Richard Rufus (Engalnd U21 international)
    Jorge Costa (full Portuguese international)
    Edit; Have had the pleasure of seeing all these ex players at the Valley in our colours.
  • GranpaGranpa
    Well done Man about Town, Marvin Hinton was the coolest Centre Half, if you don't mind, that I ever saw.
  • AddicksAddictAddicksAddict
    1 Elliot
    2 Ufton
    3 Rufus
    4 Costa
    5 Hinton

    Subs bench Went Reeves Fish
  • Richard JRichard J
    Good question . Here's my choice :

    1. Jorge Costa
    2. Richard Rufus
    3. Peter Shirtliff
    4. Paul Elliott
    5. Paul Miller (for the Battle of the Bridge)

  • Bryan_KynsieBryan_Kynsie
    Paul Went was a favourite icon but as a player he does not get into the top 5. Back then our defence was leaky and he wasn't playing against top class strikers. I think he gets into peoples lists because he was part of a team that many including me can still name man for man!

    No argument that Rufus was number 1.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!