All time Charlton Academy XI

OsamaBenHamer

Don't know if this has been done before, but with all the recent talk of poyet vs parker etc and the thread about the best XI based on just one moment, thought this would be interesting.

In recent times we've had Shelvey, cousins, poyet, Parker and they're all centre mids!!! Suggestions?

Addickted4life

Rufus, Defoe, Konchesky, Bowyer, Lisbie, Solly, Fortune, Primus, Robert Lee have all come through the academy just off the top of my head.

DeeBee

Bartram (If he counts was technically at another club for a bit)
Solly-Rufus-Primus-Konchesky
Parker-Poyet-Bowyer
Lee
Lisbie-Defoe


That's without thinking about it much

C_A_F_C

Elliot
Solly Rufus Bonds Konchesky
Lee Parker Shelvey Peacock
Defoe Walsh

OsamaBenHamer

C_A_F_C said:

Elliot
Solly Rufus Bonds Konchesky
Lee Parker Shelvey Peacock
Defoe Walsh

Exactly the same team I've managed to put together, apart from I would have Bowyer at right mid

ForeverAddickted

Randolph
Solly - Rufus - Bonds - Konchesky
Poyet - Parker
Lee - Shelvey - Bowyer
Walsh

Subs: Elliot.. Wilson.. Fortune.. Peacock.. Cousins.. Defoe.. Leaburn

*Randolph edges the Goalkeeper position for me seeing that he's playing First-Team Football and has played in Europe for Motherwell... I've included Pigott because cant think of any other Strikers... Yes we had MacDonald and McCammon but were either as prolific as Joe at Youth level?

C_A_F_C

ForeverAddickted said:

Randolph
Solly - Rufus - Bonds - Konchesky
Poyet - Parker
Lee - Shelvey - Bowyer
Walsh

Subs: Elliot.. Wilson.. Fortune.. Peacock.. Cousins.. Defoe.. Pigott

*Randolph edges the Goalkeeper position for me seeing that he's playing First-Team Football and has played in Europe for Motherwell... I've included Pigott because cant think of any other Strikers... Yes we had MacDonald and McCammon but were either as prolific as Joe at Youth level?

Lisbie? Leaburn?

ForeverAddickted

C_A_F_C said:

ForeverAddickted said:

Randolph
Solly - Rufus - Bonds - Konchesky
Poyet - Parker
Lee - Shelvey - Bowyer
Walsh

Subs: Elliot.. Wilson.. Fortune.. Peacock.. Cousins.. Defoe.. Pigott

*Randolph edges the Goalkeeper position for me seeing that he's playing First-Team Football and has played in Europe for Motherwell... I've included Pigott because cant think of any other Strikers... Yes we had MacDonald and McCammon but were either as prolific as Joe at Youth level?

Lisbie? Leaburn?

Thanks completely forgot about Leaburn... Now amended to add him in as he left us for a Premier League side whereas Lisbie dropped down the Leagues

floydroadfaithfull

Parker 100% shame he never recaptured the the success he had here

Showmetheway2gohome

What about Scott minto Paul Elliot and mark Stuart

shirty5

Since Valley Gold was launched

Randolph
Solly
Konchesky
Rufus
Brown
Newton
Bowyer
Shelvey
Parker
Lisbie
Grant

shine166

Kim grant was awful

gilbertfilbert

Tutt

Solly
Rufus
Elliott
Minto

Lee
Bowyer
Parker
Peacock

Walsh
Leaburn

LenGlover

Tutt

Bonds

Rufus

Elliott

Minto

Lee

Bailey

Parker

Glover

Leaburn

Walsh P

No Bowyer no Peacock no Stevie Brown won't let you down to name but 3. Tomorrow's would be different again.

gilbertfilbert

Bailey, Bonds and Glover were just before my time, but I think you're probably right, Len.

JollyRobin

Jermaine Defoe doesn't get a look it?