I see they will be taking our votes from the Reading game, a few weeks ago, I was voting for Scott Carson, but since DB has returned, my head has been swayed - what do we do?
Still got to be Scott Carson, IMHO. In all seriousness, if it were not for him we would probably have at least 7-8 less points and have no prayer of staying up and our goal diff would eb -40. Nobody else has been as good all season as he has.
Carson's save at Pompey from Cole's header got us a win rather than a draw. Also, made some unbelievable saves at home to Man City to protect a 1-0 win and also saved that penalty at home against Bolton which effectively saved the game plus he was also great away at Bolton when they could have had three goals if it weren't for his saves.
[cite]Posted By: Ormiston Addick[/cite]Carson's save at Pompey from Cole's header got us a win rather than a draw. Also, made some unbelievable saves at home to Man City to protect a 1-0 win and also saved that penalty at home against Bolton which effectively saved the game plus he was also great away at Bolton when they could have had three goals if it weren't for his saves.
alright,alright.well apart from them,what has carson ever done for us?
Others have had the odd good moment and have been mostly mentioned above other than El K who deserves a mention in dispatches for his free kicks against Blackburn and Bolton which gave us 4 precious points even if his defending has been heart in mouth at times!
1) He showed guts and commitment playing against Portsmouth (home) with a painful broken toe.
2) He sent the Palace down.
3) He had the good sense to go back to Stoke.
Actually, can I change my mind?
Scott Carson....one man fortress.
Just not sure about giving the Charlton player of the year to a Liverpool player. Sorry but I'd like to give it to someone who's actually ours.
By the way, John Fortune hasn't become a bad player overnight. He was outstanding alongside Fish: someone who spoke the same language as him. Don't think we should forget that.
Comments
2. Holland
3. Bent
In My Opinion
Will also not forget that at some of our lowest points last year, he seemed to care more than most of the others.
alright,alright.well apart from them,what has carson ever done for us?
Others have had the odd good moment and have been mostly mentioned above other than El K who deserves a mention in dispatches for his free kicks against Blackburn and Bolton which gave us 4 precious points even if his defending has been heart in mouth at times!
:)
2. D Bent
3. Captain Cleanshorts
Carson for consistency.
Darren for everything else, including playing on when clearly still not 100% fit.
I'd vote for Holland or Ambrose - at least they had the guts to clap us after the match at Forest. I don't forget that sort of thing.
1) He showed guts and commitment playing against Portsmouth (home) with a painful broken toe.
2) He sent the Palace down.
3) He had the good sense to go back to Stoke.
Actually, can I change my mind?
Scott Carson....one man fortress.
Just not sure about giving the Charlton player of the year to a Liverpool player. Sorry but I'd like to give it to someone who's actually ours.
By the way, John Fortune hasn't become a bad player overnight. He was outstanding alongside Fish: someone who spoke the same language as him. Don't think we should forget that.