The Wigan commentary was miles better - the guys actually told you what was happening, rather than discussing their fingerless gloves like Emma. We had a corner in the first half and she simply blathered on about something else. This really does need to be addressed.
We could also do with more input from Finchy, because he does have have some useful input.
I fell asleep during the second half only to be woken up by Emma's high pitched screech when the two Wigan goals went in. One of the worst ways I've ever been woken up during a good nap and its ruined my Saturday.
I've got to say before all the "dogooders" like sethplunb get on here, that its a mans game and its being spoiled by women getting involved ......there ... i said it and i am sure i'll regret it .... or perhaps not ...lol
She is reporting on a poor team with no investment and doing the best she can. There is no point of even trying to get someone as she is à lovely lady who loves the club. We accept things at Charlton not change them.
Listened on BBC Kent - hacked off because they put the FM dross on AM, and kept saying, "you can listen to live commentary of the Charlton game on 774". No I couldn't, because someone didn't do their job. Had to send them a message on Facebook before they got it right.
They save their worst commentator for the club they care least about. Vote with your feet and font renew. They will have to do something about it then.
I've got to say before all the "dogooders" like sethplunb get on here, that its a mans game and its being spoiled by women getting involved ......there ... i said it and i am sure i'll regret it .... or perhaps not ...lol
Do you mean me? A do-gooder? hmmmn. The woman commentator from Middlesboro was excellent as many agreed at the time.
I didn't listen to today's commentary but overall Emma has improved remarkably. I was one of her biggest critics before, so I feel it's time to stick up for her because I think she's been describing the play far far better. Let's please just put this down as an off day for now. Perhaps she wasn't used to the new players or something.
yes seth you teach my mates son , and i reserve any other comment , but the commentary was rubbish
Bit too much information, and may be out of date. I am semi retired, and only a temp one day a week merchant. I don't know your mates son, but it is flattering if he describes me as a do gooder.
commentary WAS totally rubbish .....can we have a better commentator? regardless of sex or race or religion, or profession or anything else ....... the commentary WAS shit it is EVERY time Emma does it. (she is a lovely person who is kind and everything to human kind ) But it doesn't detract from the fact ..........come on who else agrees ? be honest !
Yes Emma was poor today but she has generally improved. Jamie is better. When I get fed up with her blatherings I switch to the others sides commentary. One week I listened to the end of a Millwall game when they were getting done 5 0 or something. Now that was funny!
I got.nothing against a woman commentating but she is awful
knows absolutely nothing about football and tries to cover this up by talking shite about unrelated rubbish
total twat. The live commentary is one of my few links to the game as i dont live in the UK. I pay the subscription.but get.an unreliable service which even when working is sub standard
the reaction to the wigan.goals was inconsiderate for a supposed CAFC commentary team. But that's a point of style..doesnt matter so much..
I do not want to hear about fashion or soap operas when im trying to listen to a game of fitbae
Listen to the opposition commentary. 95% of the time they are better than us. Shame tho, it would be good to listen to decent commentary that was a little shade of red.
Comments
We could also do with more input from Finchy, because he does have have some useful input.
She is reporting on a poor team with no investment and doing the best she can. There is no point of even trying to get someone as she is à lovely lady who loves the club. We accept things at Charlton not change them.
100% support for Emma.
it doesn't matter about emma then!?!?!?!?
A do-gooder?
hmmmn.
The woman commentator from Middlesboro was excellent as many agreed at the time.
i'll ask again
how can a reasonable feedback mechanism be established?
She is absolutely dreadful.
I don't know your mates son, but it is flattering if he describes me as a do gooder.
i've tried asking a few times
and he is clearly a good guy
knows absolutely nothing about football and tries to cover this up by talking shite about unrelated rubbish
total twat. The live commentary is one of my few links to the game as i dont live in the UK. I pay the subscription.but get.an unreliable service which even when working is sub standard
the reaction to the wigan.goals was inconsiderate for a supposed CAFC commentary team. But that's a point of style..doesnt matter so much..
I do not want to hear about fashion or soap operas when im trying to listen to a game of fitbae