Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Genuine FA cup Question

With the game being called off and the possibility of the game being call off on Wednesday, plus the on going problem with the pitch could the game be switch to an away tie in the future?

The only reason I ask is because low league clubs in the past have switched for larger grounds I know it's for money reasons

Comments

  • Almost certainly not.
  • Can only change venue on safety reasons.
  • Maybe we should play all our games away.
  • Maybe we could ask Pala**e if we can use Sh*thurst Park :p
  • Maybe we should play all our games away.

    Or play our home games in the first 2 and last 2 months of the season where it doesn't rain as much.

  • Gumbo said:

    With the game being called off and the possibility of the game being call off on Wednesday, plus the on going problem with the pitch could the game be switch to an away tie in the future?

    The only reason I ask is because low league clubs in the past have switched for larger grounds I know it's for money reasons

    No
  • Didn't the FA put a stop to lower-league clubs switching their home ties to bigger grounds?
  • MrOneLung said:

    Can only change venue on safety reasons.

    Player safety maybe?
  • Genuine FA Cup question:
    A Premiership team will probably win the FA Cup this season, why shouldn't it be Fulham?
  • Sponsored links:


  • Riviera said:

    Genuine FA Cup question:
    A Premiership team will probably win the FA Cup this season, why shouldn't it be Fulham?

    P'raps...
  • If we get home draws from here on in, with the state of our pitch we could end up in the semi-final draw!
  • Riviera said:

    Genuine FA Cup question:
    A Premiership team will probably win the FA Cup this season, why shouldn't it be Fulham?

    Because their doggy doo.
  • I know it wouldn't benefit us on this occasion but I genuinely believe that if a team cannot get their game on after two attempts then the other team should be given a bye through to the next round.

    Not fair on away supporters or management to have their plans up in the air on more than one occasion just to play a cup game.
  • Riviera said:

    Genuine FA Cup question:
    A Premiership team will probably win the FA Cup this season, why shouldn't it be Fulham?

    Has Curbs really come out with that old line of his again?? ;-)
  • Another fa cup question does anyone know when the draw for the next round is ?
  • edited January 2014
    cafctom said:

    I know it wouldn't benefit us on this occasion but I genuinely believe that if a team cannot get their game on after two attempts then the other team should be given a bye through to the next round.

    Really ? Why?

    What happens if we have a cold snap and all games are off for, say, a couple of weeks - would you simply put all of the away teams through automatically?
  • Another fa cup question does anyone know when the draw for the next round is ?

    Tomorrow at 2pm

  • edited January 2014
    I agree with Gumbo, if we cant get the game on at home by 3 weeks then we should be told forfeit or play at the other teams ground


    the lack of investment in the pitch stems all the way back to the relegation seasons and prob as far back as the relegation from the prem, its a disgrace that all involved at mgmt. level should be embarrassed of and another reason I am glad RM is a non exec now

    its been very easy to sit back and allow members of his board and mgmt leave and be treated with disrespect even though they stood by his side , it was also very easy to sit back and allow the flack (rightly so a lot of the flack they received) to TJ and MS at the same rate allowing the mgmt team be deconstructed because TJ and MS wanted to rebuild

    but the demise of the playing field the stadium all coincided with his stewardship and he too should be as accountable as anyone else
  • There is FA precedent for switching to the other teams ground - it's what happens in the Women's FA Cup
  • Sponsored links:


  • cafctom said:

    I know it wouldn't benefit us on this occasion but I genuinely believe that if a team cannot get their game on after two attempts then the other team should be given a bye through to the next round.

    Not fair on away supporters or management to have their plans up in the air on more than one occasion just to play a cup game.

    Not really fair on the smallest teams (like us) and would be the final nail in the coffin.
  • Gumbo said:

    With the game being called off and the possibility of the game being call off on Wednesday, plus the on going problem with the pitch could the game be switch to an away tie in the future?

    Yes. And no.

    I will explain... Rule 9 (a) (i) of the FA Challenge Cup Competition says that a tie *can* be switched (from the "home" ground to the "away" ground), subject to the FA Council approving the switch.

    But, Rule 9 (a) (ii) says that the home team must arrange a safety certificate within three days of the tie being drawn; when this is done, the FA Council decides to require the game to go ahead at that ground. (We should assume that this happened within three days of the Third Round draw).

    Rule 9 (a) (vi) states that the FA Council can wade in and change the venue of the game "if it is considered appropriate and necessary". Sounds like we can go the FA and say "look, our pitch is rubbish, can we play at Oxford?". However...

    ...(and, this is where it gets a bit tricky): Rule 9 (a) (viii) says that, if we declare that we can't host the match *after* the safety certificate has been produced, the FA Council can decide where the tie will be played and, next season, chuck us out of the FA Cup.

    So, it appears that we *can* get the game switched, but it would mean not playing in the FA Cup (the only big competition we've ever won), in the 110th anniversary season.

  • We could always play it at Ebbsfleet................
  • Thanks chizz
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!