Who is the fattest player you have seen play for Charlton?

cafcrocky87

Andy Reid, Jimmy Floyd Piggybank or Big Fat Pete Garland?

Curb_It

Stood near Andy Reid once. Wasn't an ounce of fat on him. Short and sturdy that's what he was.

Carter

Neil Redfearn and Garland

Hasslebaink and Reid not in their league

Nicholas

John Barnes

Starinnaddick

Ralph Milne

JT

JFH

se9addick

Barnes

North Lower Neil

I was waiting for this after the 'fastest' thread!

Barnes is a good shout.

Six-a-bag-of-nuts

Dennis "Beer Gut" Bond

grumpyaddick

Fatty Elliot should be a strong contender.

When he dived during that last season with us it was like watching a sack of spuds fall off the back of a lorry..

cafctom

Never understood the whole 'fat' Andy Reid thing.

Would go with Barnes.

Off_it

Always thought this bloke had a "fat" head. Decent player though.

Absurdistan

mendonca

Extra points for pictures!

ISawLeaburnScore

Kermorgant at Welling last year was huge. Put on at least 2 stone in the off season.

jimmymelrose

Proably someone back between 1905 & the 1920's if you could measure everyone who's ever played for Charlton using the Body Mass Index.

Rock Spectacle

Nicola Berti.

PeakieRocket

There was a midfielder we had on loan from Spurs once - Scott something. He was a little chunky

incorruptible addick

Whos the fattest poster on CL? Or the ugliest?

All in the eye of the beholder.

Jeez, peeps. Get a friggng life.

Off_it

incorruptible addick said:

Whos the fattest poster on CL? Or the ugliest?

All in the eye of the beholder.

Jeez, peeps. Get a friggng life.

Well, we know who the most boring poster is. And that's one tough competition.

uncle

Off_it said:

incorruptible addick said:

Whos the fattest poster on CL? Or the ugliest?

All in the eye of the beholder.

Jeez, peeps. Get a friggng life.

Well, we know who the most boring poster is. And that's one tough competition.

Hahaha

incorruptible addick

Off_it said:

incorruptible addick said:

Whos the fattest poster on CL? Or the ugliest?

All in the eye of the beholder.

Jeez, peeps. Get a friggng life.

Well, we know who the most boring poster is. And that's one tough competition.

Ha. You win that every time you open your mouth, old fruit. Like shearing a pig, as Vladimir Putin put it. All squeal and no wool!!!

uie2

Poor peter g

Off_it

zzzzzzzzzzz ........... sorry, what was that?

boggzy

Andy Jones

cafctom

Off_it said:

incorruptible addick said:

Whos the fattest poster on CL? Or the ugliest?

All in the eye of the beholder.

Jeez, peeps. Get a friggng life.

Well, we know who the most boring poster is. And that's one tough competition.

LOL

Ormiston_Addick

PeakieRocket said:

There was a midfielder we had on loan from Spurs once - Scott something. He was a little chunky

Scott Houghton.

Ormiston_Addick

Peter Garland and John Barnes in my time.

kentaddick

kind of off topic but i'll say again, saw Garland 4 or 5 years ago i think playing for a kent league side and he ran the game, despite weighing more than the other 21 players put together.

Andy Reid I think just has a large frame, didnt one of the fitness coaches say he actually had the lowest body fat than anyone at the club?

I-SAW-POUSO-PLAY

Rob elliot

stonewallpenalty

kentaddick said:

kind of off topic but i'll say again, saw Garland 4 or 5 years ago i think playing for a kent league side and he ran the game, despite weighing more than the other 21 players put together.

Andy Reid I think just has a large frame, didnt one of the fitness coaches say he actually had the lowest body fat than anyone at the club?

That was the fat fighters club he went to.