Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Options

Decent ref today I thought

Obviously didn't please the upper north youth but he let the the game flow, disregarded the pansies that let themselves get fairly barged off the ball and judged the 50/50 tackles for what they are, part of the game
«1

Comments

  • Options
    edited December 2012
    Joke ref IMO.
  • Options
    Didn't get the book out, and talked to the players to calm them down when necessary. I have seen worse referees at the Valley this season.
  • Options
    I agree he let the game flow, but he did us no favours. Everything that was 50/50 or even 60/40 he gave to Brighton. Hulse and Morro were both on the end of a lot of shirt-pulling, obstruction and fouls and got hardly any given.
    That said, was particularly impressed with haynes after a Brighton player barged him over when he was running down the right 2nd half, and while the crowd were shouting for the foul, he got up, took the ball back and carried on. Top man.
    Not the worse referee we've had this season, but that's not really a compliment.
  • Options
    Wasn't bad overall but it didn't look like a free kick to me that lead to their second goal.
  • Options
    I thought we bad our fair share of the decisions and the little goal area shannanihans by hulse and morro were probably judged rightly by the ref as our players trying to unsettle the Brighton defence
  • Options
    Some incorrect decisions, but he won't get everything right. Did ok I thought.
  • Options
    Great ref imo
  • Options
    The East Stand lino was awful.
  • Options
    Addickted said:

    The East Stand lino was awful.

    He looked about 12.

  • Options
    Okay in the first half, then turned into a rock hard roll of happy shopper bog paper during the 2nd half
  • Sponsored links:


  • Options
    Apart from blocking one of our attacks which then led to a Brighton counter and ignoring a blatant handball , I think he did ok. A lot better than some others.
  • Options
    wish he'd seen the off the ball elbow that floored hulse in the area after about 57 minutes
  • Options
    Very good ref. Best we have had in years IMO. Kept the game moving, no pointless silly bookings. Seems to have become a habbit to boo ref's from the pitch and it is a bit sad and tiresome tbh.
  • Options
    Thought he lacked any bottle when it came to big decisions to be honest, whilst he let the game flow it was because he missed or ignored many fouls, everytime we had a corner morro has pushed or had his shirt almost torn off his back.

    Don't agree with the good ref verdict above thought he was really poor.
  • Options
    Not sure what the 'upper north youth' means to be honest. Saw plenty of older fellas with the hump about him.
  • Options
    He was a farkin disgrace , Total kuntlox...
  • Options
    terrible and mainly for letting El Abd get away with murder at every set piece
  • Options
    Started off OK but worse as the game went on. The handabll he missed on one of their attcaks in the second half was unbeleivable as an example. Just lost it under their cynisym (spelt wrong) This reflects Poyet as a player , never dirty but very cyncical
  • Options
    This is a wind up right? One of the worst refs I've seen in years.
  • Options
    The ref would get a 7 out of 10. The lino in front of the East Stand, however, was a complete arsehole, missing offsides and fouls galore. 2/10, bottom of the class.
  • Sponsored links:


  • Options
    Thought both the ref and the East side Lino were awful. When Haynes was brought down by a tackle that would have seen a yellow card in rubgy, the lino completely missed it, the ref at first decided nothing was wrong and when Haynes got up and carried on eventually played advantage but then failed to so much as have a word with the offending player, who deserved a yellow (minimum). And that was just one of many incidents where it seemed BHA were given far more leniency and leeway than CAFC. I'm all for letting a game flow but when you blow up for something you need to make sure you do the same regardless of which team does it.
  • Options
    I'd give him 10/10 for that through ball.

    He gave us nothing all night. every 50/50 went Brighton's way.
  • Options
    El Abd got away with murder on morrison at every set piece. shockingly naive and woeful ref performance.
  • Options
    edited December 2012
    Rizzo said:

    Thought both the ref and the East side Lino were awful. When Haynes was brought down by a tackle that would have seen a yellow card in rubgy, the lino completely missed it, the ref at first decided nothing was wrong and when Haynes got up and carried on eventually played advantage but then failed to so much as have a word with the offending player, who deserved a yellow (minimum).

    Lino did flag, but ref played on when Haynes kept going. Agree, should have been pulled back for a yellow.
  • Options
    Assume this is a wind up. He was fucking terrible. El Ab did nothing but pull shirts for 90mins and wasnt pulled up. Missed 3-4 blatant handballs etc etc.
  • Options
    He was a fucking wind up merchant.
  • Options
    Not there today, but I thought the ref at the Dump last week was very good... ?
  • Options
    Rothko said:

    terrible and mainly for letting El Abd get away with murder at every set piece

    100% this.

  • Options
    last_line said:

    El Abd got away with murder on morrison at every set piece. shockingly naive and woeful ref performance.

    And this.

  • Options
    Davo55 said:

    The lino in front of the East Stand, however, was a complete arsehole, missing offsides and fouls galore. 2/10, bottom of the class.

    And this.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!