Which team (in your opinion) is our strongest starting 11? Choice of 4

flyingkiwiDK

Team A

Hamer

Solly Morrison Cort Wiggins

Wilson Frimpong Stephens Kerkar

Hulse Haynes


OR

Team B

Hamer

Solly Morrison Cort Wiggins

Pritchard Jackson Stephens Kerkar

Fuller Kermorgant


OR

Team C

Hamer

Solly Morrison Cort Wiggins

Haynes Frimpong Jackson Kerkar

Fuller Kermorgant


OR

Team D

Hamer

Solly Morrison Cort Wiggins

Wilson Frimpong Jackson Kerkar

Haynes Kermorgant



For me it is Team "D". Discuss.

MuttleyCAFC

The great thing is, we can't be sure. Should be good finding out!

carly burn

Frimpong .
Pritchard. Stephens. Jackson.

stonemuse

MuttleyCAFC said:

The great thing is, we can't be sure. Should be good finding out!

Agreed, should be an interesting few weeks

SuperYann

shocked to see kerkar in all 4 teams. Would be: Hamer, Solly, Morro, Cort, Wiggins, Pritch, Frimmy, Stephens, Jacko, Yann, Fuller

North Lower Neil

Hamer,
Solly, Cort, Morro, Wiggins,
Frimpong,
Haynes, BWP, Hulse, Yann, Fuller.

I call it Team G.

falconwood_1

A

Scoham

A. Haynes has to be in there. Frimpong is here to play. Wilson's a more natural choice at right midfield. Jackson shouldn't play on the left. Yann and Fuller can fight Hulse for a place in the team.

The Red Robin

Hamer,

Solly, Morrison, Cort, Wiggins

Green, Pritchard, Stephens, Jackson

Haynes, Yann

Shrew

Hamer,
Solly, Cort, Morro, Wiggins,
Wilson, Frimpong, Jackson, Kerkar,
Haynes, Fuller

cs1986

I am amazed at the amount of ppl still putting JJ on left...
To a lesser extent no way kermo over fuller, just no way

Addick Addict

Team C (but Wilson for Kerkar - Haynes to switch to the left)

Hamer

Solly Morrison Cort Wiggins

Wilson Frimpong Jackson Haynes

Fuller Kermorgant

masicat

cs1986 said:

I am amazed at the amount of ppl still putting JJ on left...
To a lesser extent no way kermo over fuller, just no way

Agree with this.

Henry Irving

Hamer,
Solly, Cort, Morro, Wiggins,
Wilson, Frimpong, Stephens, Kerkar,
Haynes, Fuller

jakecafc

Henry Irving said:

Hamer,
Solly, Cort, Morro, Wiggins,
Wilson, Frimpong, Stephens, Kerkar,
Haynes, Fuller

This is the team for the minute..

sam3110

Button
Hughes, Taylor, Dervite, Evina
Green, Jonsson, Cook, JJ
Smith, BWP

;-)

MeebaumAzanitch

For me it has to be D. Wilson in his rightful position - he has earned it! Haynes deserves his place somewhere in the team. Frimpong not tried with us yet but seems to have that attitude we are missing. Kermorgant over Fuller who hasn't convinced me that he ain't a Jimmy Floyd in the making.

bolloxbolder

Hamer
Solly, Cort, Morrison,Wiggins
Wilson, Frimpong, Pritchard
Haynes, Hulse, Fuller

Salad

team Irving

North Lower Neil

Henry Irving said:

Hamer,
Solly, Cort, Morro, Wiggins,
Wilson, Frimpong, Stephens, Kerkar,
Haynes, Fuller

Agree with this. I think Yann and Haynes could work work really well, but Fuller is pure class.

GreenWithEnvy

Henry Irving said:

Hamer,
Solly, Cort, Morro, Wiggins,
Wilson, Frimpong, Stephens, Kerkar,
Haynes, Fuller

What no room for Waggy in your team then Henry? : P

Uboat

sam3110 said:

Button
Hughes, Taylor, Dervite, Evina
Green, Jonsson, Cook, JJ
Smith, BWP

;-)

Given the unpredictabilty of the championship, this team would probably win away at Palace.

bolloxbolder said:

Hamer
Solly, Cort, Morrison,Wiggins
Wilson, Frimpong, Pritchard
Haynes, Hulse, Fuller

You have a lot of faith in Frimpong.

francis4england

Henry Irving said:

Hamer,
Solly, Cort, Morro, Wiggins,
Wilson, Frimpong, Stephens, Kerkar,
Haynes, Fuller

Agree with this, although if Frimpong doesnt live up to the hype then I would play Pritch instead. I think I am one of the only who havent given up on BWP, he can still come good with a bit of confidence.

REMUSANCHEZ

bolloxbolder said:

Hamer
Solly, Cort, Morrison,Wiggins
Wilson, Frimpong, Pritchard
Haynes, Hulse, Fuller

TOTALLY AGREE !!! PERFECT TEAM !!! 4-3-3 forever !!!

Rizzo

SuperYann said:

shocked to see kerkar in all 4 teams. Would be: Hamer, Solly, Morro, Cort, Wiggins, Pritch, Frimmy, Stephens, Jacko, Yann, Fuller

From this I assume you prefer JJ at left midfield? Where he's been consistently awful this season. Also, no place for Haynes despite him having the only genuine pace in the squad and scoring 3 in 3?

Henry Irving

GreenWithEnvy said:

Henry Irving said:

Hamer,
Solly, Cort, Morro, Wiggins,
Wilson, Frimpong, Stephens, Kerkar,
Haynes, Fuller

What no room for Waggy in your team then Henry? : P

Not in front of Wilson, no. Great option off the bench if you need a goal or energy to hold on to a lead.

Mortimerician

cs1986 said:

I am amazed at the amount of ppl still putting JJ on left...
To a lesser extent no way kermo over fuller, just no way

I'd have Kermo over Falcao

Mortimerician

Henry Irving said:

Hamer,
Solly, Cort, Morro, Wiggins,
Wilson, Frimpong, Stephens, Kerkar,
Haynes, Fuller

More of less this: I'd probably go with Jacko in midfiled for general leadership quality and Kermo up front for battling qualities and what he adds at both ends of set pieces.

To be fair I'd not complain at all if I saw the likes of Waggy, Hulse, BWP, Stephens or Fuller in there. Squad seems to have gone from wafer thing to big-boned very quickly. Great for Powell to be able to switch things around: moving to a 5 man midfield or 433 without a great quality sacrafice.

GravesendAddick

Hamer
Solly morro cort wiggins
Wilson Stephens kerkar
Kermogrant
Haynes Fuller

cafcnick1992

Mortimerician said:

cs1986 said:

I am amazed at the amount of ppl still putting JJ on left...
To a lesser extent no way kermo over fuller, just no way

I'd have Kermo over Falcao

but Kermorgant is one of the most loved charlton players in the last decade!

Fuller or Haynes is a difficult one. I'd certainly trust Fuller more in front of goal but pace can get you a long way in the championship. Haynes is also on a bit of a run so it would probably be foolish to take him out of the side.

But anyway the competition for places is fantastic at the moment and I genuinely believe we're starting to build a very strong side

in SCP we trust

(oh, and team C)

The Red Robin

REMUSANCHEZ said:

bolloxbolder said:

Hamer
Solly, Cort, Morrison,Wiggins
Wilson, Frimpong, Pritchard
Haynes, Hulse, Fuller

TOTALLY AGREE !!! PERFECT TEAM !!! 4-3-3 forever !!!

4-3-3 would not work with those players out wide. You need pace and good crossers of the ball on both sides rather than centre forwards.