Hamer - 9 MOM (changed this a few times not sure I've ever given many a 9) Huge improvement hasn't made me anxious at all yet this season. Last season there was many hands to head in anxious moments Solly - 6 Morrison - 7 Cort - 7 Wiggins - 6 Pritchard - 6 Hollands - Stephens - 7 Jackson - 5.5 Kermorgant - 7.5 Wright Phillips - 8
Beds I am not questioning your mark or saying it's wrong, but why only a 6.5? Others are marking him 8.5/9. How do you think he performed?? I wasn't there so I can't say you're right or wrong but I am just interested.
Beds I am not questioning your mark or saying it's wrong, but why only a 6.5? Others are marking him 8.5/9. How do you think he performed?? I wasn't there so I can't say you're right or wrong but I am just interested.
I think his distribution once he has the ball is really poor.He tries that Dean Kiely curled long kick to the right winger ( which we dont play/have ) and it loses momentum when he should be giving it to Wiggins who is more often than not on his own on the left. I will concede though that 6.5 mark may have been a bit harsh.
Hamer- 8 - Good saves, would have liked him to have showed a little more urgency towards the end Solly- 7 - Solid as ever. Has played better Morrison- 8 - Very Solid. MOTM Cort - 6 - Few slips and errors today. Dominated in the air but CB's CANNOT get caught in possession. Wiggins - 7 - Similar to Solly, good but not his best, didn't sparkle today Pritchard - 7 - Lots of running but seemed a little slow to react towards the end. Don't know whether it was tiredness or struggling with the conditions. Hollands- 7 - Solid but just doesn't dominate games in the way you want him to. Stephens- 7 - Similar to Hollands, good, but not dictating our attacking play in the way I would like him to Jackson- 6 - Unusually anonymous today, also out of position a lot. Kermorgant - 7 - Worked hard won allot in the air - they marshaled him well and he just won't be able to dominate as much as last year. Wright Phillips - 7 - Worked really hard and played for the team.
Hamer 8 solid. Looks so much more confident and composed Solly 6 solid but as @legaladdick said got dragged in too much and gave his winger too much space at times Morrison 7 solid Cort 5.5 looked very suspect at times when ball at his feet Wiggins 5.5 poor distribution Pritchard 6 Lots of energy but too often a poor first touch. Hollands 7 Does so much good work Stephens 6 some good stuff but gives it away cheaply too often Jackson 4.5 good corners but little else Kermorgant 8 MOM His energy and effort is immense Wright Phillips 7 much improved - has definitely stepped it up
Hamer 9 MOTM Could he have done any better - definitely lot - we have a real prospect here Solly 6.5 Defensively good, offensively not his best - we need our full backs to become wing backs with our formation. Morrison 8 Can't fault him Cort 6.5 Conditions didn't suit and he looked a bit clumsy but fought his way through the game admirably Wiggins 6.5 ditto Solly Pritchard 6 Not his best game- put in the work but some of the qulaity he has shown wasn't evident today Hollands 7 Has a simple but important role in the side and did it well Stephens 8 my pick of the midfiled -looks good on the ball Jackson 6 In the team for his goals and delivery - no goals and deklivery was good rather than his usual excellent but conditions didn't help Kermorgant 8 Won the headers, unlucky first half and scored a good goal that should have counted. Wright Phillips 8 Worked very hard with little service - made the goal we were cheated out of.
RugbyAddick said: Beds I am not questioning your mark or saying it's wrong, but why only a 6.5? Others are marking him 8.5/9. How do you think he performed?? I wasn't there so I can't say you're right or wrong but I am just interested.
I think his distribution once he has the ball is really poor.He tries that Dean Kiely curled long kick to the right winger ( which we dont play/have ) and it loses momentum when he should be giving it to Wiggins who is more often than not on his own on the left. I will concede though that 6.5 mark may have been a bit harsh.
Sorry, I don't think it' right to comment on someones opinion, but this is ridiculous. You cannot mark Hamer down as he was bloody superb.
Hamer 9 mom Solly 7 Morrison 7 Cort 6 - some dodgy play with the ball at his feet. Just get it out. Wiggins 7 Pritchard 5.5 some bad first touches and crosses. felt like he was always drifting into the middle and giving us almost no width. Hollands 7 Stephens 6.5 Jackson 5.5 not a left winger in this league Kermorgant 7 Wright Phillips 8 chased down everything and worked hard
The small number of people who were doubtful of Hamer last season are clearly starting to come round, especially as a weak area - crosses - seems to have been addressed. But a new critiscm is creeping in and a totally amazing one at that concerning his distribution.
Hamer has the best distribution of any Charlton keeper I have seen and I have seen a few. IF he holds on to the ball, it is because of how the team is approaching the match. Against Leicester for instance the ball was coming straight back at us- the common sense approach was to slow things down - I think he showed an excellent awareness of the game in the way he played.
Crosses I could understand -I made that critique when he first joined us - but it was clear he improved as the season went on which some people seem to be able to see and others seem incapable off - but distribution - don't make me laugh.
The small number of people who were doubtful of Hamer last season are clearly starting to come round, especially as a weak area - crosses - seems to have been addressed. But a new critiscm is creeping in and a totally amazing one at that concerning his distribution.
Hamer has the best distribution of any Charlton keeper I have seen and I have seen a few. IF he holds on to the ball, it is because of how the team is approaching the match. Against Leicester for instance the ball was coming straight back at us- the common sense approach was to slow things down - I think he showed an excellent awareness of the game in the way he played.
Crosses I could understand -I made that critique when he first joined us - but it was clear he improved as the season went on which some people seem to be able to see and others seem incapable off - but distribution - don't make me laugh.
Couldn't have put it better myself.
His distribution is the best of any Charlton keeper I have seen in 35 years without question.
Hamer - 7.5 Growing into a very good keeper Solly - 5.5 Often out of position and looked nervy going forward Morrison - 7.5 Tank Cort - 7 Becoming a key attacking resource. Some dodgy control, but we didn't buy him as a winger Wiggins - 7 Strong defensively, good going forward, although often isolated on the left Pritchard - 5 Missing in action Hollands - 8 Best game for a while, the left side of central mid suits him. Stephens - 5 Game passed him by Jackson - 5 Never seemd to be where he was needed. Kermorgant - 8 I love watching Yann rinse out defenders. Helps out at the back, great flicks. Wright Phillips - 7.5 Hard working and tricky
Comments
Solly 8
Morrison 8
Cort 7
Wiggins 7
Pritchard 7
Hollands 7
Stephens 7
Jackson 7
Kermorgant 8
BWP 7
Solly 7
Morrison 7.5
Cort 6.5
Wiggins 6
Pritchard 7
Hollands 7.5
Stephens 6.5
Jackson 6
Kermorgant 7
Wright Phillips 7.5
Solly 7.5
Morrison 7.5
Cort 7.5
Wiggins 7
Pritchard 7.5
Hollands 7.5
Stephens 7
Jackson 7
Kermorgant 7.5
Wright Phillips 7.5
Solly-7
Morrison-7
Cort-6.5
Wiggins-6.5
Jackson-6
Hollands-7
Stephens-6.5
Pritchard-6.5
Bwp-8
Kermorgant-7
Solly - 6
Morrison - 7
Cort - 7
Wiggins - 6
Pritchard - 6
Hollands -
Stephens - 7
Jackson - 5.5
Kermorgant - 7.5
Wright Phillips - 8
Solly 7
Morrison 7.5
Cort 7
Wiggins 6
Pritchard 7
Hollands 7.5
Stephens 6
Jackson 6.5
Kermorgant 8
Wright Phillips 7.5
I will concede though that 6.5 mark may have been a bit harsh.
Solly- 7 - Solid as ever. Has played better
Morrison- 8 - Very Solid. MOTM
Cort - 6 - Few slips and errors today. Dominated in the air but CB's CANNOT get caught in possession.
Wiggins - 7 - Similar to Solly, good but not his best, didn't sparkle today
Pritchard - 7 - Lots of running but seemed a little slow to react towards the end. Don't know whether it was tiredness or struggling with the conditions.
Hollands- 7 - Solid but just doesn't dominate games in the way you want him to.
Stephens- 7 - Similar to Hollands, good, but not dictating our attacking play in the way I would like him to
Jackson- 6 - Unusually anonymous today, also out of position a lot.
Kermorgant - 7 - Worked hard won allot in the air - they marshaled him well and he just won't be able to dominate as much as last year.
Wright Phillips - 7 - Worked really hard and played for the team.
Solly 6 solid but as @legaladdick said got dragged in too much and gave his winger too much space at times
Morrison 7 solid
Cort 5.5 looked very suspect at times when ball at his feet
Wiggins 5.5 poor distribution
Pritchard 6 Lots of energy but too often a poor first touch.
Hollands 7 Does so much good work
Stephens 6 some good stuff but gives it away cheaply too often
Jackson 4.5 good corners but little else
Kermorgant 8 MOM His energy and effort is immense
Wright Phillips 7 much improved - has definitely stepped it up
Solly 6
Morrison 7
Cort 7
Wiggins 5
Pritchard 7
Hollands 8
Stephens 8
Jackson 5
Kermorgant 8
Wright Phillips 8
Solly 6.5 Defensively good, offensively not his best - we need our full backs to become wing backs with our formation.
Morrison 8 Can't fault him
Cort 6.5 Conditions didn't suit and he looked a bit clumsy but fought his way through the game admirably
Wiggins 6.5 ditto Solly
Pritchard 6 Not his best game- put in the work but some of the qulaity he has shown wasn't evident today
Hollands 7 Has a simple but important role in the side and did it well
Stephens 8 my pick of the midfiled -looks good on the ball
Jackson 6 In the team for his goals and delivery - no goals and deklivery was good rather than his usual excellent but conditions didn't help
Kermorgant 8 Won the headers, unlucky first half and scored a good goal that should have counted.
Wright Phillips 8 Worked very hard with little service - made the goal we were cheated out of.
Solly 7
Morrison 7.5
Cort 7.5
Wiggins 7
Pritchard 7
Hollands 7
Stephens 6.5
Jackson 6
Kermorgant 8
Wright Phillips 8
Solly 6.5
Morrison 6.5
Cort 6
Wiggins 6.5
Pritchard 6
Hollands 6.5
Stephens 6
Jackson 6
Kermorgant 6.5
Wright Phillips 7
Beds I am not questioning your mark or saying it's wrong, but why only a 6.5? Others are marking him 8.5/9. How do you think he performed?? I wasn't there so I can't say you're right or wrong but I am just interested.
I think his distribution once he has the ball is really poor.He tries that Dean Kiely curled long kick to the right winger ( which we dont play/have ) and it loses momentum when he should be giving it to Wiggins who is more often than not on his own on the left.
I will concede though that 6.5 mark may have been a bit harsh.
Sorry, I don't think it' right to comment on someones opinion, but this is ridiculous. You cannot mark Hamer down as he was bloody superb.
Solly 7
Morrison 7
Cort 6
Wiggins 7
Pritchard 6
Hollands 7
Stephens 6
Jackson 6
Kermorgant 7
Wright Phillips 7
Solly 7
Morrison 7
Cort 6 - some dodgy play with the ball at his feet. Just get it out.
Wiggins 7
Pritchard 5.5 some bad first touches and crosses. felt like he was always drifting into the middle and giving us almost no width.
Hollands 7
Stephens 6.5
Jackson 5.5 not a left winger in this league
Kermorgant 7
Wright Phillips 8 chased down everything and worked hard
Hamer has the best distribution of any Charlton keeper I have seen and I have seen a few. IF he holds on to the ball, it is because of how the team is approaching the match. Against Leicester for instance the ball was coming straight back at us- the common sense approach was to slow things down - I think he showed an excellent awareness of the game in the way he played.
Crosses I could understand -I made that critique when he first joined us - but it was clear he improved as the season went on which some people seem to be able to see and others seem incapable off - but distribution - don't make me laugh.
Totally agree.
His distribution is the best of any Charlton keeper I have seen in 35 years without question.
Solly - 5.5 Often out of position and looked nervy going forward
Morrison - 7.5 Tank
Cort - 7 Becoming a key attacking resource. Some dodgy control, but we didn't buy him as a winger
Wiggins - 7 Strong defensively, good going forward, although often isolated on the left
Pritchard - 5 Missing in action
Hollands - 8 Best game for a while, the left side of central mid suits him.
Stephens - 5 Game passed him by
Jackson - 5 Never seemd to be where he was needed.
Kermorgant - 8 I love watching Yann rinse out defenders. Helps out at the back, great flicks.
Wright Phillips - 7.5 Hard working and tricky
Your right about width but the hammering we took at the lane under uncle les we were the narrowest I have ever seen
Solly - 5.5
Morrison - 7.5
Cort - 7
Wiggins - 6.5
Pritchard - 6
Hollands - 7
Stephens - 6
Jackson - 5
Kermorgant - 8
Wright Phillips - 7.5
Solly 6
Morrison 7
Cort 6
Wiggins 5
Pritchard 5
Hollands 6
Stephens 6
Jackson 5
Kermorgant 7
Wright Phillips 7
Solly 7
Morrison 7.5
Cort 5 Donkey
Wiggins 6
Pritchard 7
Hollands 7.5
Stephens 6
Jackson 6.5
Kermorgant 7
Wright Phillips 7.5